Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The NHS in comparison to Spain is unfit for purpose . . .

265 replies

Lineofconcepcion · 03/04/2022 18:33

My partner was taken ill a couple of weeks ago, we're on an extended holiday to Spain and Portugal. We went to the nearest public hospital in Oveido. Within 5 minutes he was triaged, examined within half an hour, given iv painkillers within 40 minutes, seen by an a & e doctor within the hour. Diagnosed, put on an iv drip for antibiotics within another half hour. Completed this, had the cannula removed, discharged with a prescription all within 2 hours. I was allowed with him during the whole of the treatment/examination. Treated amazingly well, faultless, lovely staff, who uploaded Google translate, to communicate better. All this on a GHIC card.

If it had been the NHS we would have waited 12 hours to be seen, denied my entry to be with him and generally be pissed off by the lack of care.

Where has it all gone so wrong?

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 03/04/2022 20:31

The nhs is not under funded it’s badly managed and wasteful of its resources

It’s all three.

allthegoodusernameshavegone · 03/04/2022 20:29

@OverByYer

The nhs is not under funded it’s badly managed and wasteful of its resources.
Absolutely this
Capturetotalelotion · 03/04/2022 20:27

Private healthcare makes no difference in the UK. I have it through work, I have a chronic illness, it was diagnosed privately but the consultant refused to treat me privately “as the insurance companies don’t like it”. Also they can’t prescribe certain drugs privately, only on the NHS. It’s a joke. I was born abroad and have lived in loads of places and the NHS is definitely the worst. I had the money to give birth privately and chose not to, my DS and I nearly died. I didn’t clap for the NHS, it isn’t underfunded, it’s just badly managed and the punters take the piss constantly. I have a close relative who is a doctor and also has a DH role, they’re a massive socialist but admit things are bad. It needs reform. Those who can pay, should pay. My relative says the entitled boomers are the worst, constant demands and rudeness and most of them are sitting on enough cash to self fund. The political will just isn’t there. What can we do? Nothing.

ChloeHel · 03/04/2022 20:20

Sadly the NHS is not fit for purpose at the moment. What is even more sadder is the staff are trying so hard to help their patients but don’t have the resources to care for them!

I was in A&E a few weeks ago due to dehydration and being pregnant (hyperemesis) I was very ill, I could barely talk or walk, BP severely low and HR 162 BPM. I was left in the middle of A&E sat on a plastic chair on a drip of IV fluids and medication. The doctor was so upset for me and was constantly coming up to me and apologising. He said I’m so sorry I wish I could give you a bed but they’d kill me if I did. Not sure who he was referring to, but assuming they were reserved for patients even more critically ill. Every Dr walking past me looked so embarrassed that they couldn’t offer me a bed. After 7 hours they eventually transferred me to the maternity assessment unit and the Dr was so happy I could lie down and have a bed…but no I got to maternity and was left in a wheelchair on a drip for 2 hours in an empty room until they had a bed. I was finally given a bed and was just without a single midwife checking on me. However, I am still so grateful for the amazing doctors in A&E!!! Not so much some of the midwives who I could hear gossiping outside and not coming to check on me 🙄

NHS is simply falling apart. Tbh I think every aspect of healthcare is falling apart. Ambulance services, GP surgeries, Pharmacies. The lot of us.

Malala48 · 03/04/2022 20:16

spanish healthcare far better with diagnosis & primary care. our nhs is poorly managed with funds being either wasted and going to outsourced agencies. infact i have experienced far better care in a few countries abroad in comparison.

my caps lock not working lol

ajandjjmum · 03/04/2022 20:12

It's not money, it's management in many cases.

A friend in his 80's had major surgery for bowel cancer, and five days later (after two days in ICU), was put in a chair in the 'discharge lounge' at 11 am. The dischange lounge is a small ward with no beds, just chairs. When his wife arrived for her online scheduled visit at 2 pm, she knew nothing about it. They then sat there until 5 pm waiting for his prescription! They delay was because the doctor forgot to sign in, and no-one could find him to do so.

By this point, I arrived and they went home while I waited for the prescription. After an hour, a message came from the ward to say that he didn't need a prescription, he had the drugs at home.

When I asked one of the nursing staff if I was being unreasonable, and it was acceptable to leave an 80+ year old couple waiting for six hours - one of whom had just had major cancer surgery - for a prescription they didn't need, she told me it wasn't her fault.

But none of it matters, because the ward hit their 'Home for Lunch' target - although home was the 'Discharge Lounge' within the same building.

Before surgery and during the care was FANTASTIC - afterwards it was a total shit show.

LaMagdalena · 03/04/2022 20:12

@bluejelly

I also think the UK population is likely to be older, more obese and more prone to substance abuse than the Spanish
The UK population is more obese, however the ages of the populations are not so different (I believe Spain has the older population) and many more Spanish people smoke than British people.
OrangeBlossomsinthesun · 03/04/2022 20:09

My MIL doesn't pay 8 euros for prescriptions. It depends on the drug prescribed but it can be a few cents if it's something like paracetamol.

Blossomtoes · 03/04/2022 20:01

@cptartapp

Spanish pensioners pay between 8-18 euros towards their prescriptions. Ours get them all for free, regardless of financial circumstances.
I wish we did the same. We get free prescriptions and we could perfectly well afford to pay.
Pinkyxx · 03/04/2022 20:00

Having lived in 4 countries in Europe couldn't agree more. All state funded healthcare systems providing a standard of care well above that of the NHS. It's such a shame people are so frightened of changing the NHS, and this notion that the only alternative is a US style privatized system..

It's easy to say the NHS is underfunded and blame that but the data suggest otherwise. According to the OECD in 2019 the NHS was better funded.

Spain - 9.1% of GDP
UK - 10.19 % of GDP

www.statista.com/statistics/268826/health-expenditure-as-gdp-percentage-in-oecd-countries/

I find it incredibly arrogant of the NHS to consider itself above scrutiny as to efficiency particularly when the vast majority of people have to wait inordinate amounts of time to access basic care. I needed specialist care when I was pregnant, I never got it and have suffered as a result. I gave birth to a premature very unwell child, who admitted did get a referral to a specialist when she was 6 weeks old. She would have been 18 months old on the day of the appointment.. Luckily for me I had private insurance from my employment. She saw a consultant a week later. The consultant immediately admitted her to hospital. He was livid the NHS had allowed a premature low birth weight child to get to the point she had - despite me taking her almost daily to the GP at the behest of the midwife. What would have happened to her if I hadn't had private insurance? She had complex needs and spent the first 2 years of her seeing various specialists, I have no confidence the NHS would have helped. Even when she was admitted to an NHS hospital from an ambulance having stopped breathing at 14 weeks old, they discharged her the next day saying they weren't sure what was wrong!!! NO FOLLOW UP. Again, had to get that worked out privately. Absolute disgrace and not fit for purpose. Needs reform and the sooner it happens the better.

whiteroseredrose · 03/04/2022 19:56

YANBU.

PIL have been in Spain since early 2020.

MIL has had various conditions and has been treated really quickly.

She collapsed, an ambulance arrived within 10 minutes and she was taken to hospital.

Her appointment with a consultant was 10 days later and she has a series of appointments for investigations.

They are scared to come back to the UK because the NHS was so bad in their part of the UK. Weeks to get a GP appointment way before covid.

pinkstripeycat · 03/04/2022 19:54

NHS hasn’t been fit for purpose for many years.
Two of my relatives work in our town hospital (one in ICU and one as a theatre technician) The say it’s like the 3rd world in there. Also one of my student’s parents are both doctors at the hospital and they’ve said all departments are always arguing and blaming each other for failures.
They all agree no one knows what anyone else is doing and no one really cares and so many patients get neglected and ignored especially the elderly ones

cptartapp · 03/04/2022 19:51

Spanish pensioners pay between 8-18 euros towards their prescriptions. Ours get them all for free, regardless of financial circumstances.

DreamingofTimbuktu · 03/04/2022 19:50

The population as a whole keep voting for the tories. Therefore they keep voting to underfund the NHS. They either value low inheritance tax over their and others day to day well being or are seriously fucking stupid 🤷‍♀️

yellowblanketban · 03/04/2022 19:50

@Fluffycloudland77

I agree, I literally tell strangers to get private cover now.

Wednesday dh was told his breathing problems were anxiety, Thursday I took him to a+e because his goitre is occluding his airway causing stenosis and he’s still in there as it’s an emergency if you can’t breathe…

It’s like a fucking game show “you said Anxiety, our survey said….stenosis” 🙄 but there is no comeback to drs. The gmc isn’t going to reprimand anyone, it becomes a “learning experience”.

How is private insurance going to help you in a medical emergency? There's no private ED you can go to....
Fluffycloudland77 · 03/04/2022 19:49

I agree, I literally tell strangers to get private cover now.

Wednesday dh was told his breathing problems were anxiety, Thursday I took him to a+e because his goitre is occluding his airway causing stenosis and he’s still in there as it’s an emergency if you can’t breathe…

It’s like a fucking game show “you said Anxiety, our survey said….stenosis” 🙄 but there is no comeback to drs. The gmc isn’t going to reprimand anyone, it becomes a “learning experience”.

Southbucksldn · 03/04/2022 19:48

My impression of Spain is that there is a lot less middle management and bureaucratic paperwork there. When it comes to wastefulness the organisations that run the NHS feel slow and unwieldy - it isn’t the clinical staff but the structure and organisation that is inefficient.

Blossomtoes · 03/04/2022 19:46

@Canhearthemice

Brexit. The Tories. This is where it's all gone wrong.
It went wrong long before Brexit. Blame Cameron and his fucking austerity.
FrankLeeSpeaking · 03/04/2022 19:46

@Badbadbunny

My OH has been waiting since November to get a prescription for Vitamin D supplement. Just being passed between his GP, oncologist and orthopaedic consultant. All telling him that one of the others needs to raise the prescription. He's had different blood tests for each and different x-rays/scans for each. They simply refuse to communicate with each other so OH has to pass messages between them, not helped with it always being different GPs.

Latest was the GP phoning up with results of latest blood test to say he's Vit D deficient and to ask the oncologist to issue a prescription. My OH referred her to the patient records showing that both the Oncologist and Orthapaedic consultant have both referred him to the GP to do it - she eventually found the notes on the record but still refuses to issue the Vitamin D, but can't explain why. Previously the GP surgery excuses were that they needed their own blood test (which was done) and then they needed their own X-ray (which was done). Now they've run out of excuses but still passing OH from pillar to post.

So because of NHS stupidity, there's been multiple blood tests, multiple x-rays, and multiple GP/consultant appointments, but none of them will actually take the action to actually issue the sodding prescription that they all agree is needed.

Unless it's a very high dose, you can buy Vitamin D in supermarkets or online in the meantime.
BambinaJAS · 03/04/2022 19:45

@Franklin12

We would not get a US system. Stop being ridiculous. We need to reform the NHS. It’s not fit for purpose.
People who want a US system have no idea how terrible it is.

I twisted my ankle one time hiking (badly) in Colorado.

Ambulance got called out to pick me up.

First word out of their mouth: "do you have insurance"?

Not: "how are you feeling" or "here is a mild painkiller"

Want to make clear:

If I did not have insurance they would have 100% left me there or billed me an insane amount. They only have to take care of you by law if its an emergency.

Canhearthemice · 03/04/2022 19:44

Brexit. The Tories. This is where it's all gone wrong.

LaMagdalena · 03/04/2022 19:44

I lived in Spain for about 3 years and used its healthcare system quite a lot, including for pregnancy and childbirth. I've only been pregnant/given birth once, so I can't do a direct comparison with the UK. I think it can be difficult to judge these things objectively as a foreigner experiencing healthcare in another country (any country). If you live somewhere but aren't completely fluent in the language, for example, it can be difficult to navigate the system, and if you receive one-off treatment on holiday, you don't necessarily get a full picture either.

Overall I found the healthcare fine I guess, to be honest I didn't really find it massively different to the UK one way or another. There were certain details that I remember being different (vaccine schedules for babies, for example), but the boredom of sitting in A&E was pretty similar in both countries for me... The care wasn't always amazing in Spain though. I remember some particularly horrible comments from nurses after childbirth for one thing, and my daughter's father and I kept getting angry letters and phone calls because my daughter needed some medical care after birth and they wanted to charge us €1000s for it, which we didn’t have... (we were legal residents, paid taxes, etc). Confused Maybe I just did healthcare in Spain wrong?

Badbadbunny · 03/04/2022 19:43

[quote Blossomtoes]@Fairyliz, Spain spends 8.9% of GDP on health. The UK spends 7.2%.[/quote]
How much is spent "per patient" in both countries, not as a percentage of GDP?

MsFogi · 03/04/2022 19:41

Same in France, healthcare from GPs to hospitals to pharmacies to eldercare all a million times better.

HRTQueen · 03/04/2022 19:41

We won’t get a US system as we have a very different attitude towards healthcare.

We will have more and more private companies involved within the NHS unless it’s reformed