Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The NHS in comparison to Spain is unfit for purpose . . .

265 replies

Lineofconcepcion · 03/04/2022 18:33

My partner was taken ill a couple of weeks ago, we're on an extended holiday to Spain and Portugal. We went to the nearest public hospital in Oveido. Within 5 minutes he was triaged, examined within half an hour, given iv painkillers within 40 minutes, seen by an a & e doctor within the hour. Diagnosed, put on an iv drip for antibiotics within another half hour. Completed this, had the cannula removed, discharged with a prescription all within 2 hours. I was allowed with him during the whole of the treatment/examination. Treated amazingly well, faultless, lovely staff, who uploaded Google translate, to communicate better. All this on a GHIC card.

If it had been the NHS we would have waited 12 hours to be seen, denied my entry to be with him and generally be pissed off by the lack of care.

Where has it all gone so wrong?

OP posts:
Iflyaway · 03/04/2022 23:26

People are still in the past thinking NHS are beyond compare to anywhere in the world....

I was horrified at the hospital my aging dementia mum was placed in in UK, compared to my personal health experience in Europe.

NHS staff deserve a medal for their dedication.

SucculentChalice · 03/04/2022 23:19

As well as my good experience with healthcare in Spain, DP was taken ill on holiday in Norway once. It seemed exactly like the NHS. A bit chaotic albeit not nearly so long to wait, a slightly couldn't care less attitude, not much treatment or interest in treating him (fortunately he recovered) but they couldn't be bothered processing the charging either, presumably because we were foreigners. So we were never invoiced or asked to leave our details! Just waved away. I was a bit shocked when I saw all the Norwegians paying for their treatment there and then and some withdrawing money from the cash machine adjacent to the invoices desk.

listsandbudgets · 03/04/2022 23:11

I had to gonti A & E in Italy once having accidentally set myself on fire ( yes really). Arrived 10pm, seen, given basic treatment and out by midnight with a dermatology appointment for 10.30m. Seen, prescribed further treatment and follow up appointment in one week.

Trying to find the Italian to explain id caught my short in gas flame, doused myself with unfortunately filthy washing up water and had a huge burn in my boob qas entertaining.. they let me go for an excruciating minute or two before switching to fluent English Blush

ShaneTwane · 03/04/2022 23:08

The NHS is a disgrace. It's not underfunded at all no matter how much people whinge that it is. It's badly managed to the hilt. So many staff need sacking and starting again. The execs and managers need gone as does the ridiculous waste. The system is ridiculous. Where I am from health care is incredibly good and although it's paid for the insurance system helps. Thing is people are so shit scared of having to pay for healthcare they will pretend the NHS is not a huge failure. Sure they can lament about the great care they received but they simultaneously shut down when people talk about the rampant neglect and abuse they have suffered at the hands of NHS staff. The NHS at this point probably costs as many lives as it saves.

SierpinskiSquare · 03/04/2022 23:07

We've had a few run in with the NHS with older relatives over the last few years and we've been amazed at what great care our relatives have had. One of my relatives died of cancer and the fact that they and we believe their care couldn't have been better is a huge comfort.

I have experienced delays for some things with my own health so I'm under no illusion that the NHS is perfect but there is a lot that it does well.

Luredbyapomegranate · 03/04/2022 23:03

@Anycrispsleft

It's the same in Germany. The healthcare is so, so much better. It frustrates me so much when ppl in the UK resist change to the NHS because "you wouldn't want a system like the US" - well no, but a system like France, Germany, Switzerland or Belguim would be just fine.
Well this is true, but you have to contribute a lot in Germany. Mind you, as a PP said the Irish system is fucking woeful and you have to pay into that too.

I dunno about Spain. But the NHS needs more cash and better management.

notimagain · 03/04/2022 22:52

[quote Lineofconcepcion]@notimagain you just need a GHIC which is sufficient for most needs. www.nhs.uk/using-the-nhs/healthcare-abroad/apply-for-a-free-uk-global-health-insurance-card-ghic/[/quote]
I'd be careful assuming that..from the GHIC link you posted:

"You can use your card to access medically necessary state-provided healthcare when you're visiting an EU country or Switzerland."

(my emphasis).

It shouldn't be used to provide cover if you are resident overseas, that's exactly where the S1 comes into play....though I'm aware of the reality.

TruffleShuffles · 03/04/2022 22:48

@Wrongkindofovercoat

So 5k for the both of them for 15 months cover ? When they complete their residency application will they be entitled to free cover or will they have to continue paying at the same rate ?
Yep 5k for two, they will have to continue after gaining residency until retirement age as they will not be working on Spain. Luckily they both reach it next year when they will be able to apply for their S1 forms, they were too impatient to wait another year before applying for residency.
Wrongkindofovercoat · 03/04/2022 22:44

So 5k for the both of them for 15 months cover ? When they complete their residency application will they be entitled to free cover or will they have to continue paying at the same rate ?

EthelsAuntie · 03/04/2022 22:43

I love the NHS and all it stands for but there are not enough staff, those that do stay are overworked. It is being strangled and it is failing.
It is just another part of the country and with the transport system and energy prices that are being handled better in other European countries.
Our government are completely at fault about all these failing and dont appear to care about the impact these issues have on ordinary people.
It isn't the NHS I want rid of - it is the Tory government.

notimagain · 03/04/2022 22:43

@LaMagdalena

Okay, I am corrected. I didn’t really mingle with many post-work but pre-retirement people!
No no, you and TruffleShuffles may well be right as far as Spain goes but the S1 reciprocal arrangement certainly continues to work in France post Brexit and I thought the theory was it should still work EU wide for those who qualify.

Be interested to know the reality.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 03/04/2022 22:41

@TruffleShuffles on average if you know, obviously the older someone is the more likely they are to have pre-exisitng conditions, such as diabetes, hypertension, arthritis etc which I imagine would bump up premiums.

TruffleShuffles · 03/04/2022 22:41

@Wrongkindofovercoat

Sorry just seen your update, how much is health insurance for a post retirement aged person in Spain, do you know ?
It’s varies due to your health but my parents are currently going though the residency process and they are paying around 2.5k each for 15 months cover.
Lineofconcepcion · 03/04/2022 22:39

@notimagain you just need a GHIC which is sufficient for most needs. www.nhs.uk/using-the-nhs/healthcare-abroad/apply-for-a-free-uk-global-health-insurance-card-ghic/

OP posts:
Sarahcoggles · 03/04/2022 22:39

Out of curiosity, if you were a Spanish National living in Spain, would you get free treatment?

TruffleShuffles · 03/04/2022 22:39

[quote Wrongkindofovercoat]@TruffleShuffles so if you are a UK pensioner who moved to Spain once you retired you are still entitled to full free healthcare in Spain ?[/quote]
Yes you are, you request an S1 form and then hand this over in Spain which allows you access. They was a worry after brexit that this wouldn’t continue but Spain and the U.K. have agreed to carry it on.

LaMagdalena · 03/04/2022 22:35

Okay, I am corrected. I didn’t really mingle with many post-work but pre-retirement people!

notimagain · 03/04/2022 22:34

@LaMagdalena

Actually I'm wrong, UK citizens might need to pay privately now (someone can correct me)...
It may be much the same set up as exists for other Brits resident in EU countries: how much, if anything, you pay into the local system may depend on whether the individual is a holder of a UK form S1 - issued if you still pay UK National Insurance (that is possible even if not resident in the UK) or are in receipt of a UK state pension...
Wrongkindofovercoat · 03/04/2022 22:34

Sorry just seen your update, how much is health insurance for a post retirement aged person in Spain, do you know ?

LndnGrl · 03/04/2022 22:34

@Lineofconcepcion

My partner was taken ill a couple of weeks ago, we're on an extended holiday to Spain and Portugal. We went to the nearest public hospital in Oveido. Within 5 minutes he was triaged, examined within half an hour, given iv painkillers within 40 minutes, seen by an a & e doctor within the hour. Diagnosed, put on an iv drip for antibiotics within another half hour. Completed this, had the cannula removed, discharged with a prescription all within 2 hours. I was allowed with him during the whole of the treatment/examination. Treated amazingly well, faultless, lovely staff, who uploaded Google translate, to communicate better. All this on a GHIC card.

If it had been the NHS we would have waited 12 hours to be seen, denied my entry to be with him and generally be pissed off by the lack of care.

Where has it all gone so wrong?

Spain doesn't let all and sundry use their healthcare. You have to pay in for a certain amount of time first, otherwise you have to have private cover. Plus they dont have umpteen useless managers, red-tape and bureaucracy. They are allowed and encouraged to use common sense.
hopeso · 03/04/2022 22:34

If you think privatising the NHS is the way forward, then you have not been paying attention. The government is driving the NHS into the ground by underfunding while outsourcing more services to private companies. The NHS Bill will allow an an increasing role for these companies. Do you really want the likes of Richard Branson to decide where our money should be spent and on what? The NHS spends a lot of time mopping up the mistakes of the private sector - remember, their bottom line is profit and shareholder dividends, while the NHS's is to treat people and save lives.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 03/04/2022 22:32

@TruffleShuffles so if you are a UK pensioner who moved to Spain once you retired you are still entitled to full free healthcare in Spain ?

TruffleShuffles · 03/04/2022 22:30

@LaMagdalena

Actually I'm wrong, UK citizens might need to pay privately now (someone can correct me)...
It’s never been the case that residency entitles you to access the Spanish health system. If you moved out there pre retirement and didn’t plan to work you always had to have private healthcare in place to apply for residency.
TruffleShuffles · 03/04/2022 22:28

[quote Wrongkindofovercoat]**@TruffleShuffles* The ones who work or are retired and are entitled to use Spanish healthcare always use it when needed*

Since Brexit do they need to be citizens or can they be UK citizens and still access Spanish healthcare free of charge ?[/quote]
They need residency to reside in Spain but this still doesn’t entitle you to Spanish healthcare. You need to be working and paying into the system, some areas do allow you to pay a monthly fee to access basic healthcare and if you are a pensioner you can also access the health system.

Pre brexit a lot of Brits didn’t bother applying for residency and rented properties privately to live there. Brexit has meant a lot of these Brits have moved back home as they can’t now move freely between the two countries.

thegreylady · 03/04/2022 22:21

The problem is that when the NHS started the costs of drugs, treatments etc were manageable funded by NI. There have been amazing advances in all areas of medicine but these come at a cost and NHS funding isn’t always feasible.We will only improve the service if we pay more. About 17 years ago we had some private health insurance included with our house insurance for a relatively low cost. Dh was too old but I was accepted. Six months later I was dx with an aggressive breast cancer. The insurance paid for two drugs not then available on the NHS. One cost £1000 per injection and the other £800. Both have now been approved by NICE. I believe I am probably alive today because of that £20 a month policy.