Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The NHS in comparison to Spain is unfit for purpose . . .

265 replies

Lineofconcepcion · 03/04/2022 18:33

My partner was taken ill a couple of weeks ago, we're on an extended holiday to Spain and Portugal. We went to the nearest public hospital in Oveido. Within 5 minutes he was triaged, examined within half an hour, given iv painkillers within 40 minutes, seen by an a & e doctor within the hour. Diagnosed, put on an iv drip for antibiotics within another half hour. Completed this, had the cannula removed, discharged with a prescription all within 2 hours. I was allowed with him during the whole of the treatment/examination. Treated amazingly well, faultless, lovely staff, who uploaded Google translate, to communicate better. All this on a GHIC card.

If it had been the NHS we would have waited 12 hours to be seen, denied my entry to be with him and generally be pissed off by the lack of care.

Where has it all gone so wrong?

OP posts:
Anycrispsleft · 04/04/2022 05:41

@gogohm

Have you lived in any of these countries? I don't know about Spain but dp has staff in Germany and they have to pay a lot of money for health and social insurance, around 3x the cost of U.K. employees
I live in Germany and all I can tell you is that it is a fair chunk (300 euros a month for me) if you have a good job but when I was a SAHM it was for free. So people with a bit of money pay a lot more than in the UK but everyone else gets the same excellent service without necessarily paying that much. Food for thought maybe for British middle class socialists so proud of contributing to the NHS - if you lived in European country with private healthcare, you might actually be paying more to support your low income fellow residents.
NumberTheory · 04/04/2022 05:11

The argument that the UK is either brilliant or terrible, overfunded and wasteful or resource starved and overworked doesn't really hold up against the evidence. The NHS is a middle ranking healthcare system amoung OECD nations in both investment and performance. There's plenty of room for performance if more money is spent (it's a trailer amoung G7 countries, but Spain isn't a member of the G7), but it's not really doing badly.

Spain is also fairly middle ranking, but it is considered one of the most efficient health care systems in the world. They spend less per person than the UK (£2,989 per person compared to Spain's £2,444 per person (PPP)) and get slightly better outcomes.

One of the ways they do this is by paying their doctors and nurses less (Drs make, on average, about half the income UK doctors make). They have more doctors per person than the UK and fewer nurses.

They also, in general, make more rational decisions about what drugs and treatment should be prescribed. Something the UK keeps trying to do with NICE, but then capitulating to pressure to favour groups with more political clout.

Zotter · 04/04/2022 04:37

@Anycrispsleft

It's the same in Germany. The healthcare is so, so much better. It frustrates me so much when ppl in the UK resist change to the NHS because "you wouldn't want a system like the US" - well no, but a system like France, Germany, Switzerland or Belguim would be just fine.
The problem is the US system is what a Conservative govt would choose. There is a lot of money to be made for their mates and some of them!
GreenNewDealNow · 04/04/2022 04:29

Look, there's no mystery, the Tories are deliberately running it down in order to privatise it.

sashh · 04/04/2022 04:08

@Umbellypico

The reason the NHS is failing, is fucking monumental waste. My mil was discharged with a new zimmer frame every time she left hospital - she collected 14!!! And they wouldn't accept them back. She was over-prescribed, despite having a dosset box and she used to save up the extra meds to hand out to extended family. She was a thief too and would pinch blankets/cutlery and anything else she could get hold of whilst on the ward. She fell over at home at least once a week, sometimes 2 or 3 times, and had to be lifted by paramedics & taken to hospital in an ambulance & checked-over. When my ds & his friends have needed crutches they won't accept them back. Massive massive wastage & no one taking accountability for it.
The reason they won't accept crutches / zimmer frames back is cost.

They would need to be disinfected, they would then need to be inspected for damage and they would need to be stored.

Even someone on minimum wage of £9.50 and whatever the hospital pays in tax/NI for that employee costs more than buying crutches / frames.

If you just issue new ones you know the quality and that they are safe to use.

When you only have a set amount of storage you order enough to fill that storage no more.

OP

You cannot compare one experience at one hospital and extrapolate that it is the same for everyone in that country and compare it with your assumption about what would happen in the UK.

A few years ago I had what turned out to be an ovarian cyst that would wrap round my fallopean tube and burst. I was seen in A and E at three different NHS hospitals (working out of area when it happened on 2 occasions) my local hospital I attended twice, once was a terrible experience, the other I came pout of an ambulance, was triaged to the surgical team who told me I was being admitted but they wanted to give me some drugs first, painkillers and an antiemetic.

Changeee1546789 · 04/04/2022 03:19

9 quid a month for insurance. Utter bollocks.

Changeee1546789 · 04/04/2022 03:18

Threads moaning about the NHS drive me insane. I live in a country where we have to pay every single time we go to the GP. I need some gynae treatment and I will have to fork out for it because we don't have insurance.

Stop voting Tory FFS

Grumpasaurusrex · 04/04/2022 03:17

@RagingRagingAndMoreRaging

Grumpasaurusrex

And if you develop a chronic condition or need an expensive operation? Fertility treatment? What if you have to see specialists regularly? £28 a pop, alone, is beyond what lots of people can afford. This you get more inequality.

I have a chronic condition. £9 a month health insurance covers all.
Changeee1546789 · 04/04/2022 03:16

FUNDING

Umbellypico · 04/04/2022 02:52

The reason the NHS is failing, is fucking monumental waste. My mil was discharged with a new zimmer frame every time she left hospital - she collected 14!!! And they wouldn't accept them back. She was over-prescribed, despite having a dosset box and she used to save up the extra meds to hand out to extended family. She was a thief too and would pinch blankets/cutlery and anything else she could get hold of whilst on the ward. She fell over at home at least once a week, sometimes 2 or 3 times, and had to be lifted by paramedics & taken to hospital in an ambulance & checked-over. When my ds & his friends have needed crutches they won't accept them back. Massive massive wastage & no one taking accountability for it.

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 04/04/2022 02:46

Grumpasaurusrex

And if you develop a chronic condition or need an expensive operation? Fertility treatment? What if you have to see specialists regularly? £28 a pop, alone, is beyond what lots of people can afford. This you get more inequality.

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 04/04/2022 02:42

BTW

To Anycrispsleft. Resistance to change is not something any NHS worker can be. Changed and reforms happen ALL the time. What doesn’t happen is enough time without change, decent budgets and staffing to allow, us, the workers, to build year on year on the strengths of the service. We do manage to mostly, but constant change, for changes sake, is not necessarily helpful.

Grumpasaurusrex · 04/04/2022 02:37

@RagingRagingAndMoreRaging

I work for the NHS and have used it many times.

In most of the departments I’ve worked in, they have been run well, the staff work way above and beyond what you’d expect and I’ve been proud to be part of the service. The feedback has been that well over 90% of people are satisfied with the service provided.

With one exception (England) I’ve always been very satisfied with, and grateful for, the care (Wales) that I’ve received. It’s been average to excellent.

The NHS is free for ALL at the point of access. Total equality. Few, if any, other countries have that. Just as well, as our government have set it up so that we are all so much worse off now.

The NHS is underfunded.

Without it, if you can’t afford care - you don’t get it. Or you get less of it. Watch ‘Sicko’ the Michael Moore film to get a taste of the situation we would have.

I will, however, agree about the IT systems. Most Health Boards I’ve worked in are not great here. Outsourcing doesn’t work well and in-house seems slow and outdated.

Be careful what you wish for. Unless you are very well off, a country without the NHS isn’t a place I’d want to live.

Very well off? All my scans and blood tests and seeing the doctor and solving the problem cost £28. A good health insurance that covers everything costs me £9 a month. Yes America's healthcare system is expensive and crazy but it's not usually like that, not in any other country I've come across.
Grumpasaurusrex · 04/04/2022 02:34

I live abroad and went to hospital recently. Within one day I'd seen the doctor, had an ultrasound, had a blood test, seen another doctor, got a diagnosis.

Since living abroad and realising what other healthcare systems are like, I've realised that the NHS is, quite frankly, a disgrace. And one that costs lives.

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 04/04/2022 02:34

I work for the NHS and have used it many times.

In most of the departments I’ve worked in, they have been run well, the staff work way above and beyond what you’d expect and I’ve been proud to be part of the service. The feedback has been that well over 90% of people are satisfied with the service provided.

With one exception (England) I’ve always been very satisfied with, and grateful for, the care (Wales) that I’ve received. It’s been average to excellent.

The NHS is free for ALL at the point of access. Total equality. Few, if any, other countries have that. Just as well, as our government have set it up so that we are all so much worse off now.

The NHS is underfunded.

Without it, if you can’t afford care - you don’t get it. Or you get less of it. Watch ‘Sicko’ the Michael Moore film to get a taste of the situation we would have.

I will, however, agree about the IT systems. Most Health Boards I’ve worked in are not great here. Outsourcing doesn’t work well and in-house seems slow and outdated.

Be careful what you wish for. Unless you are very well off, a country without the NHS isn’t a place I’d want to live.

StrangerYears · 04/04/2022 02:32

I have always thought the Australian hybrid system works well, but I realise this is only if you can afford private insurance/are never ill/are rich enough to pay for private yourself.

My child has been diagnosed with something and needs to see a specialist about 'what next'. If we want to see him on social medicine (ie paid by the government) it is about a 6 month wait. If I can afford 300quid, we can see the same person privately in 3 weeks,

My mate broke her foot- free xrays, but paying for crutches (not a bad thing I guess) a moonboot, physio and consultant appointments.

So be careful what you wish for.
BTw I used to work for NHS- it is way too managerial heavy and needs fewer meetings and more hands on staff.

straighttalker · 04/04/2022 01:44

Haven't read the thread but I will say when we get critically ill patients repatriated to UK from Spain, they come with the most horrific healthcare-associated infections, far beyond what we have in NHS.

The physio and basic nursing care has also been severely lacking based on the contractures/sores.

GiraffesInScarfs · 04/04/2022 01:32

@Anycrispsleft

It's the same in Germany. The healthcare is so, so much better. It frustrates me so much when ppl in the UK resist change to the NHS because "you wouldn't want a system like the US" - well no, but a system like France, Germany, Switzerland or Belguim would be just fine.
Exactly this.

The patient outcomes, survival rates and patient care by the NHS are shocking for a developed country and have been for a very, very long time when you look at the international data comparisons.

I am baffled why some people in the UK think it's so good. Confused

Onetwothree456 · 04/04/2022 00:42

I can't speak for the Spanish healthcare system but in the UK I recently had an eye injury. 111 told me to go to A&E within the hour. I waited for 2 days to be seen by a doctor (I had to go back the next day). I now have permanent vision damage.
It's very scarey to think the help just isn't there when you need it. I'd rather pay a small amount more every month for a functioning system.

Soringhaze · 04/04/2022 00:37

The NHS is shocking. Precious little is investigated when things go wrong. The standard of care is pathetic and it's complete pot luck if you live to see a consultant and even then you best hope for one who cares and is competent. Most Brits are completely shocked when they experience healthcare pretty much anywhere else. 200 babies died in Shrewsbury...will anything really change? Is the same not happening all over the U.K.? Years to be seen for autism referral. The U.K. doesn't do early intervention like the rest of the western world because children aren't seen for years! It's a disgrace.

It needs tearing down and starting again. It needs proper funding and if not then find privatise it because the level of care is so low now.

MardyOldGoth · 04/04/2022 00:37

@bringmelaughter

The NHS in comparison to Spain is underfunded for it’s purpose . . .

There we go, I fixed the title.

This!
Blossomtoes · 04/04/2022 00:03

Well done for sitting on your sofas offering your expert opinions

We’re not all doing it. I know all too well that the NHS runs on staff commitment and goodwill against all odds.

JaceLancs · 04/04/2022 00:00

I was taken ill on holiday in Tenerife about a month ago - very impressed with care I received - needed a follow up appointment with my GP on return home - I’m not able to book anything - keep ringing but constantly told no emergency appointments left (it’s not an emergency) and no pre bookable appointments
I’ve got a diagnosis and have had tests etc abroad - what I would like is ongoing treatment and medication

ladybuggoldfinch · 04/04/2022 00:00

For all the inefficient staff people are taking about there are hundreds more who work their arses off to give their best to people! I work hard as a nurse in critical care, my colleagues are amazing and we do our best. I agree we are not angels or superhero's but we certainly do deserve respect for the job we do. It's hard, it's sad and it's heartbreaking at times. Well done for sitting on your sofas offering your expert opinions 👌

Andouillette · 03/04/2022 23:54

@Blossomtoes

Spain spends a higher percentage of its GDP on healthcare. It’s obviously going to be better. You get what you pay for.
It doesn't. This suggests to me that their system is highly efficient. www.statista.com/statistics/268826/health-expenditure-as-gdp-percentage-in-oecd-countries/