Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The NHS in comparison to Spain is unfit for purpose . . .

265 replies

Lineofconcepcion · 03/04/2022 18:33

My partner was taken ill a couple of weeks ago, we're on an extended holiday to Spain and Portugal. We went to the nearest public hospital in Oveido. Within 5 minutes he was triaged, examined within half an hour, given iv painkillers within 40 minutes, seen by an a & e doctor within the hour. Diagnosed, put on an iv drip for antibiotics within another half hour. Completed this, had the cannula removed, discharged with a prescription all within 2 hours. I was allowed with him during the whole of the treatment/examination. Treated amazingly well, faultless, lovely staff, who uploaded Google translate, to communicate better. All this on a GHIC card.

If it had been the NHS we would have waited 12 hours to be seen, denied my entry to be with him and generally be pissed off by the lack of care.

Where has it all gone so wrong?

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 04/04/2022 15:04

@OrangeBlossomsinthesun

Yes, the contracts for doctors and nurses in Spain are totally shit. Nurses sometimes have contracts for just a couple of days. It's mad. So a lot of them went to the uk as the employment conditions were much better.
There seems to be a staff merry go round. The NHS brings in foreign workers to replace the NHS workers who've left to move abroad. So why don't, say, the Spanish nurses/doctors go to work where the NHS nurses/doctors have left to go to? Are there different standards/qualifications in different countries which mean, say, a Spanish (or say Philipino) nurse can come and work for the UK NHS but wouldn't be able to get a job in say Canada or Australia?
OrangeBlossomsinthesun · 04/04/2022 14:35

Yes, the contracts for doctors and nurses in Spain are totally shit. Nurses sometimes have contracts for just a couple of days. It's mad. So a lot of them went to the uk as the employment conditions were much better.

SVRT19674 · 04/04/2022 14:29

@LaMagdalena How strange. Especially because minors in Spain have a right to health care whatever their immigration status. An illegal immigrant from Afghanistan, if a minor, has a right to be seen and treated and not just for emergency care, either.
I do know someone who swore blind she went to hospital in Spain and had to pay for her treatment and nobody would accept her EHIC card. Turns out she went to a private hospital, so no, the cards they accept there are VISA and Mastercard mate. (Not saying this is your case at all, by the way).
Someone wondered why so many Spanish nurses had had to move to Britain for work. Mainly because they are on short term contracts if they don´t have a public space earned through examination. So they have one short term contract after another for years. Starting a family and getting a mortgage is pretty tough like this.
Also someone wondered why do UK pensioners return to Britain for treatment if the Spanish system is ok. I can answer that one. Because many were not legal residents of Spain. My mom´s British partner was officially registered resident in Britain so as not to lose the extras on his pensions and stuff, so he was only entitled to emergency care in Spain, as officially a tourist. He had an inkling something was wrong non emergency but required longer treatment and has had to return to England. I know many in this situation. My mum´s best British friend is officially registered in Spain and gets all healthcare in Spain.

user1497207191 · 04/04/2022 14:23

[quote Blossomtoes]@Fairyliz, Spain spends 8.9% of GDP on health. The UK spends 7.2%.[/quote]
But Spain's "per capita" GDP is a lot less than the UK's. I.e. Spain's financial productivity per person is less than the UK. In actual "pound note" terms, Spain spends less per person than the UK.

It's one of those statistically anomalies, where if the average UK person become less financially productive, we'd spend a bigger proportion of GDP on healthcare, even if we spent the same amount in pound note terms, so GDP isn't really a good indicator of spending.

Getoff · 04/04/2022 14:07

[quote Blossomtoes]@Fairyliz, Spain spends 8.9% of GDP on health. The UK spends 7.2%.[/quote]
According to wikipedia, in 2019, spending per person in Spain was $3,616 USD compared to $4,653 in the UK.

LaMagdalena · 04/04/2022 13:20

@Kione

LaMagdalena maybe someone was trying to scam you or you got referred to a private hospital?
It definitely wasn't a private hospital, and I still have one of the letters somewhere, I don't believe it was a scam. I don't know, I think the red tape got mixed up somewhere.
user1497207191 · 04/04/2022 13:08

The thing with A&E though is that it's also used for admissions when there's no alternative admission pathway. I was once referred by my GP for an urgent abdominal ultrasound scan to the maternity unit (I wasn't pregnant and it was abdominal rather than gynae but GP said it was the only way to get a scan as only the maternity unit had a spare scan appointment!). GP told me I had to present at A&E and they'd know what I was there for and direct me to the maternity dept. In fact, I waited 4 hours in A&E as they insisted on normal triage, triage nurse couldn't see anything on file to confirm why I was there, and they claimed they had to do all the normal "opps", i.e. BP, heart scan, blood tests, etc., which all took time, only for the consultant to appear, query why I was there, and after again telling them what the GP said (must have been 4 or 5 times by then to different people), they finally told me to go to maternity. When I got to maternity, I was down as an admission rather than a scan only, so a maternity doctor had to take all my medical history, examined me, etc etc, even showed me to my "bed" and did a formal admission. Only after all that had been done, could I go for the actual scan itself which took about 10 minutes, and then I had to go back to the ward to be formally "discharged" which took another couple of hours after waiting for the doctor to sign off the discharge paperwork. So I was there best part of a full day, took up the time of several different nurses and doctors who filled in a lot of paperwork, all for a simple ultrasound scan. Then they wonder why they spend so much money and the staff are always too busy. They need to find quicker/more efficient ways of doing the simple stuff!

Kione · 04/04/2022 12:59

LaMagdalena maybe someone was trying to scam you or you got referred to a private hospital?

Peaseblossum22 · 04/04/2022 12:29

@Opaljewel

Because too many people go to A&E with colds and illnesses that they don't need to. Hence holding everybody else up. Try encouraging people arouns you not to go to A&E if it isn't an accident or emergency. Then you might see it improve. You also don't have to pay for it. Let's be grateful. Imagine paying for cancer care. It's not perfect but it's amazing in my eyes what it does do for us when we need it!
This is hard though. We have had a situation this weekend with something which didn’t need A&E but did need prompt treatment. After waiting 8 hours for a call back on Saturday from 111 they told us to try painkillers or ‘go to A&E if worried’ , by Sunday morning he had high temperature , pain and was vomiting but honestly not A&E type emergency. Called 111 again, 50 minutes to answer , then call back from nurse an hour later ( who was lovely but said needed Doctor call back) then waited another hour to speak to Dr who prescribed antibiotics , he still hasn’t actually been seen by anyone, his advice ‘go to A&E if you are worried’. Wait time in A&E currently 6 hours Confused. No walk in clinics in this area so it’s phone or A&E at the weekends. Anecdotally weekends the paeds A&E is heaving with things that only need a GP or nurse practitioner but there is nothing but .
Hoppinggreen · 04/04/2022 12:19

@Opaljewel

Because too many people go to A&E with colds and illnesses that they don't need to. Hence holding everybody else up. Try encouraging people arouns you not to go to A&E if it isn't an accident or emergency. Then you might see it improve. You also don't have to pay for it. Let's be grateful. Imagine paying for cancer care. It's not perfect but it's amazing in my eyes what it does do for us when we need it!
It’s true I used to have a high level voluntary position at our local NHS trust We commissioned a study on how many people who attended A&E over a weekend genuinely needed to be there - it was around 20% So not based on anyone’s opinion of who looked ill etc but based on clinical assessment In many cases they were there because they had been let down by other services such as GPs, MH support etc. A lot were entitled arseholes, although we didn’t actually have a category on the study for that
Opaljewel · 04/04/2022 12:11

@user1497207191

For anyone who wishes to understand what happens in the NHS and the way whistle blowers are treated, they need to read "Whistle in the Wind" by respected surgeon Peter Duffy who was hounded out by the management of the Lancaster infirmary! They'd rather get rid of him rather than tackling his colleagues who were responsible for patient harm and in some cases, their deaths.
This is not the case in the trust I work at. They encourage people to alert when things are going wrong and they use it as an opportunity to learn.
Opaljewel · 04/04/2022 12:10

Around*

Opaljewel · 04/04/2022 12:10

Because too many people go to A&E with colds and illnesses that they don't need to. Hence holding everybody else up. Try encouraging people arouns you not to go to A&E if it isn't an accident or emergency. Then you might see it improve. You also don't have to pay for it. Let's be grateful. Imagine paying for cancer care. It's not perfect but it's amazing in my eyes what it does do for us when we need it!

LaMagdalena · 04/04/2022 12:06

@Kione

"my daughter's father and I kept getting angry letters and phone calls because my daughter needed some medical care after birth and they wanted to charge us €1000s for it, which we didn’t have... (we were legal residents, paid taxes, etc). Maybe I just did healthcare in Spain wrong?"

I think you might have, I don't know how it works for non nationals, but nationals don't have to spend a penny. Never, ever, get a medical bill.

Even some medication is fully covered.

Frankly I don't know why we got a medical bill. I had a Tarjeta Sanitaria, I had never had a problem getting medical treatment for myself. But the treatment for my newborn daughter caused so many problems. My ex told me he got a phone call saying that if she came to the hospital they would refuse to treat her because she didn't have the right documents, and yet whenever I actually took her to appointments people seemed fine accepting the documents we had for her?? Confused
user1497207191 · 04/04/2022 11:36

For anyone who wishes to understand what happens in the NHS and the way whistle blowers are treated, they need to read "Whistle in the Wind" by respected surgeon Peter Duffy who was hounded out by the management of the Lancaster infirmary! They'd rather get rid of him rather than tackling his colleagues who were responsible for patient harm and in some cases, their deaths.

Brainwave89 · 04/04/2022 10:55

My sisters are nurses and my son a Doctor. All would say that the NHS has some serious issues from the perspective of staff. Management can be poor. Whistleblowers are often hounded. In one case as an example Doctors were asked to provide fingerprints so that a whistleblower could be identified. Mistakes are not recognised quickly enough and rectified. Resource planning can be quite poor. Notably for bank holidays (when higher pay kicks in), Managers and their friends are often rostered. Most staff are dedicated, but some are not and often play the system. My sisters have colleagues who have been off for months on full pay, openly stating they just fancied a break on full pay. There is a limited appetite to focus on bad practice and absence rates are very high. Add into this mix patients who are increasingly angry and litigious and it is a potent mix. It is very difficult currently to persuade medical students to specialise in obs and gynae given the likelihood of being regularly in court and the stress this involves. The US is no benchmark at all, but health systems in Ireland, Germany and France are better on almost all measured outcomes. This require more expenditure for some via an insurance plan, but I would happily fund this if it guaranteed appropriate treatment.

Kione · 04/04/2022 10:53

@Sarahcoggles

Out of curiosity, if you were a Spanish National living in Spain, would you get free treatment?
Yes
Kione · 04/04/2022 10:46

@cptartapp

Spanish pensioners pay between 8-18 euros towards their prescriptions. Ours get them all for free, regardless of financial circumstances.
This is not correct. It might depend on the county, my relatives don't pay anything.
Kione · 04/04/2022 10:42

"my daughter's father and I kept getting angry letters and phone calls because my daughter needed some medical care after birth and they wanted to charge us €1000s for it, which we didn’t have... (we were legal residents, paid taxes, etc). Maybe I just did healthcare in Spain wrong?"

I think you might have, I don't know how it works for non nationals, but nationals don't have to spend a penny. Never, ever, get a medical bill.

Even some medication is fully covered.

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 04/04/2022 10:02

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 04/04/2022 09:58

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Lineofconcepcion · 04/04/2022 09:56

@Skinnydogz

All these posts stating "you're not allowed to criticize the NHS", on a thread that is 99% criticizing the NHS. People criticize the NHS non stop. If you're so desperate for private treatment then go private, the only thing stopping you is your wallet, anyone can go private.

It's probably nothing to do with our ageing population or critical understaffing level's of the service, due to lack of recruitment, nurses having to pay to be trained, poor pay and conditions, Brexit encouraging thousands of qualified staff overseas, people wanting to be seen for dry nostrils or backache in A&E or their health conditions caused by years of smoking or over eating or lack of exercise. If it's that bad either write to your MP or go private.

There should be absolutely no problem with people discussing serious issues that effect them, which is what we are doing. The level of some care within the NHS is nothing short of scandalous and in 2022 is an absolute disgrace. Very few people on here are having a go at doctors and nurses, it's the whole culture that needs to change, and that means change from the top down and from the bottom up. If we don't have these discussions how will change ever be effected.

I too am very surprised by people working within the profession who choose to keep quiet about what is happening. In my profession, law, I am thoroughly ashamed by what this government has done to criminal legal aid and other social welfare legal aid, and the effect this has had on access to justice and resulting in the courts being not fit for purpose.

As can be seen from Shropshire maternity care, keeping quiet costs lives, it was mothers and babies who died, and quite often poor care affects women so much more than men. So to those people trying to shut down this discussion, go away. We'll have it whether you are here or not . . .

OP posts:
Peaseblossum22 · 04/04/2022 09:48

The solution for the NHS is not for everyone who can afford to to go private. Do you think the solution for the problems in state education is for everyone who can afford to to go private .? Of course not.

The solution is for the NHS to be radically reformed, not privatised, we need to put the patient at the centre of care at the systemic level. I have sat in too many meetings where it is clear that the most important person in any decision made is ‘the NHS’ . Instead of arrogantly assuming that because our system is the most universal we have nothing to learn from other countries for example Germany and France and the Netherlands the USA is irrelevant , there are plenty of publicly funded systems which we can learn from.

Stabbitystabstab · 04/04/2022 09:47

@Puzzledandpissedoff

Doctors are humans too! They aren’t going to get it right every single time!

Spot on

However they also have a great deal of trust placed in them, and it really doesn't help when they lie, fob off and close ranks at the slighest suggestion of a problem - even when it turns out one of their number has just killed someone

This. Like my beloved late partner. They closed ranks at the inquest and tried to pin the blame on a lovely attentive SA doctor who did more than the rest of them put together. Systems were changed to "ensure it never happened again" "lessons were learnt" Like fuck.
mellongoose · 04/04/2022 09:44

People are happy to criticise the NHS on an anonymous forum. Political parties cannot rip the plaster off for fear of screeches of "privatisation!!"

Actually, radical reform by someone brace enough is exactly what is needed. I would love to see that, despite the hysteria!