Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The NHS in comparison to Spain is unfit for purpose . . .

265 replies

Lineofconcepcion · 03/04/2022 18:33

My partner was taken ill a couple of weeks ago, we're on an extended holiday to Spain and Portugal. We went to the nearest public hospital in Oveido. Within 5 minutes he was triaged, examined within half an hour, given iv painkillers within 40 minutes, seen by an a & e doctor within the hour. Diagnosed, put on an iv drip for antibiotics within another half hour. Completed this, had the cannula removed, discharged with a prescription all within 2 hours. I was allowed with him during the whole of the treatment/examination. Treated amazingly well, faultless, lovely staff, who uploaded Google translate, to communicate better. All this on a GHIC card.

If it had been the NHS we would have waited 12 hours to be seen, denied my entry to be with him and generally be pissed off by the lack of care.

Where has it all gone so wrong?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Opaljewel · 12/04/2022 21:37

We have big signs around A&E basically stating what I said. In other words, is it an emergency or an accident.

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 07/04/2022 18:52

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

SevenWaystoLeave · 07/04/2022 17:00

The US system delivers amazing healthcare and freedom of choice to the wealthy and insured and neglects everyone else

The thing is it doesn't though. Stories abound from the US of people who thought they had "good" insurance discovering when it comes to the crunch that insurance refuses to cover certain procedures because they disagree with your doctors about what's necessary, and you certainly don't get freedom of choice since insurancers won't cover treatment from doctors who are "out of network" (ie don't have a contract with them). Even with insurance you can find yourself with an unexpected medical bill running into the hundreds of thousands and no help to pay it. And even if they will cover you, you'll likely have to pay a big excess. The system is just fundamentally broken from the ground up, the poor obviously get screwed completely but it's not actually a good working system for anyone. Even if you're lucky enough to be able to afford to pay a huge bill upfront, you're still getting screwed because medical costs in the US are vastly inflated above what the procedure actually reasonably costs.

NumberTheory · 07/04/2022 16:13

[quote Sarahcoggles]@NumberTheory the stats I looked at show the UK has 3 doctors per 1000 people and Spain has 5.[/quote]
The WHO put us at 5.8 and Spain at 4:
data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.MED.PHYS.ZS

RedHelenB · 07/04/2022 13:22

[quote Badbadbunny]@Cuck00soup

unless they can stop GPs leaving

Or they could increase the numbers of training places, build additional medical schools, etc to increase the supply of new doctors coming through. We've had a shortage for decades, which used to be made up by immigrants, but even that's not enough now. It didn't help that the BMA used to be against increasing the number of training places and against the building of new medical schools![/quote]
How does that help when there were 700 medical graduates unable to get FS1 placements this year?

Patchbatch · 07/04/2022 12:19

[quote Badbadbunny]@Cuck00soup

unless they can stop GPs leaving

Or they could increase the numbers of training places, build additional medical schools, etc to increase the supply of new doctors coming through. We've had a shortage for decades, which used to be made up by immigrants, but even that's not enough now. It didn't help that the BMA used to be against increasing the number of training places and against the building of new medical schools![/quote]
As with all healthcare degrees though there needs to be enough placements, mentors and everything else in addition to the university part. That's why although the NHS is horrendously short of midwives loads of people don't get a place on the degree.

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 07/04/2022 12:16

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Sarahcoggles · 07/04/2022 10:46

@NumberTheory the stats I looked at show the UK has 3 doctors per 1000 people and Spain has 5.

LaMagdalena · 04/04/2022 19:01

@SVRT19674 Yes, when all this was happening I did some Googling and everything said the same regarding treatment of minors. I agree it was very strange.

NumberTheory · 04/04/2022 17:57

@Hotheadwheresthecoldbath

We have less GPs,Hospital Drs nurses and carers per patient than most other countries and then people wonder why there are waits. Outcomes, however inost area are comparable. If community care was better funded and staffed we could reduce many,many hospital visits. But without investment in this isn't going to happen. I've been a nurse now for 42 years and this is the worse it has ever been with moral at rock bottom And canjust ask all of you to not criticise staff and care unless you took the time to write an official letter of complaint which is all management will respond to.
We have more Drs. per capita than Spain does.
BattenbergdowntheHatches · 04/04/2022 16:47

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Badbadbunny · 04/04/2022 16:34

@Cuck00soup

unless they can stop GPs leaving

Or they could increase the numbers of training places, build additional medical schools, etc to increase the supply of new doctors coming through. We've had a shortage for decades, which used to be made up by immigrants, but even that's not enough now. It didn't help that the BMA used to be against increasing the number of training places and against the building of new medical schools!

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 04/04/2022 16:09

@Franklin12

We would not get a US system. Stop being ridiculous. We need to reform the NHS. It’s not fit for purpose.
We are getting a US style system. More and more people are taking out private health insurance or paying privately for one-off treatment. The government is not funding the NHS in line with health inflation, it's not tackling g the skills shortage, and it is most definitely not considering a Spanish-style healthcare system. Please wake up.
Puzzledandpissedoff · 04/04/2022 16:08

SucculentChalice considering that dentistry, chiropody and optical services have already been largely privatised, I see no reason why it shouldn't spread into other areas - even orthopaedics

And Cuck00soup I said 18 months ago that this could be used as "to introduce privatised GP care" and got roundly blasted for it, especially when I mentioned my own previous GP who was using NHS telephone appointments to tout for private trade ... funny old world isn't it?

SucculentChalice · 04/04/2022 15:53

Does anyone else think that NHS orthopeadics is becoming a bit like NHS dentistry? Its very hard to get anything done, even scans, unless you are very bad or an emergency and more and more people are having to pay to go private in order to resolve their ongoing pain and loss of quality of life.

Cuck00soup · 04/04/2022 15:52

The NHS is set up to have primary care as gatekeepers, but don't fund it properly so you can't even get down the path, never mind through the gate.

A&E isn't funded properly, because it isn't meant to be so busy. (According to a team of useless management consultants I had an argument with many years ago). However it is overrun with people not receiving enough support from the places they should.

Mental Health Services are underfunded because they are an even lower priority than the other bits of the health service.

Social Care isn't anywhere near the priority list.

And all politicians ever want to do is reorganise it and move the deckchairs.

I don't pretend to have the answers, but the issues in accessing primary care will only get worse unless they can stop GPs leaving. Cynically, I honestly see this becoming a lever to introduce privatised GP care.

thisplaceisweird · 04/04/2022 15:49

@BambinaJAS

Oviedo?

Thats pretty out there in Asturias so you won't have much congestion.

Very different situation in more urban areas with a higher % of sicker and older folks.

I live in a big densely populated city in Spain. When I broke my finger (not much pain, minor dislocation) I was in an out of A&E in the main hospital in 90 mins.
Hotheadwheresthecoldbath · 04/04/2022 15:48

We have less GPs,Hospital Drs nurses and carers per patient than most other countries and then people wonder why there are waits.
Outcomes, however inost area are comparable.
If community care was better funded and staffed we could reduce many,many hospital visits.
But without investment in this isn't going to happen.
I've been a nurse now for 42 years and this is the worse it has ever been with moral at rock bottom
And canjust ask all of you to not criticise staff and care unless you took the time to write an official letter of complaint which is all management will respond to.

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 04/04/2022 15:38

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Skinnydogz · 04/04/2022 15:37

I'm not trying to shut down a conversation I'm saying that it needs to be told to the only people that actually have power to change things. The NHS was run into the ground for years, then something like covid comes along and there was absolutely no capacity for it and whole thing crumbled. The clapping for the staff was offensive, and now that we are pretending covid doesn't exist anymore lots and lots of staff are ill and off sick, burned out, tired and there's no end in sight and instead of standing up for our health services and demanding better from the governments use of our money (PPE contracts, fraudulent bounce back loans, another mps pay rise, golden wallpaper, lunch and booze on expenses) we are blaming "waste" which as of yet I still haven't seen a definition. Lots of talk about managers and pointless staff but why would an organization that has 8 million employees not have a a lot of managers? NHS staff can't even park at their own place of work.

If you can afford to go private then go, but a lot of people cannot from some of the threads on here.
Genuinely, write to your MP, how many of them have shares in the private hospitals that are booming right now.

user1497207191 · 04/04/2022 15:34

@SucculentChalice

I too am very surprised by people working within the profession who choose to keep quiet about what is happening. In my profession, law, I am thoroughly ashamed by what this government has done to criminal legal aid and other social welfare legal aid, and the effect this has had on access to justice and resulting in the courts being not fit for purpose.

Another lawyer with similar concerns here. It brings into issue ethics. And permitting the practice of NHS employees to run a private practice, often using NHS facilities, one day per week, is such an obvious conflict of interest. I cannot imagine it being allowed in any other profession. You do have to question whether some consultants are inclined to refuse surgery required to maintain quality of life to some patients in the knowledge that they will pay to go private.

The other problem that the NHS causes is that it restricts the private sector in the UK, so that its less competitive and therefore offers less value to people and there are less treatments available. PP in the UK is also dependant on an NHS referral in the first place.

Not to mention how difficult it is to sue the NHS because its so difficult to prove that another doctor within the NHS wouldn't have offered similar negligent by any other measure treatment.

I agree with all that. Same with dentists who pick & choose which of their patients get NHS treatment. My sister works at a "private" practice who puts their pregnant "private" patients back on the NHS register so they can get the free treatment whilst they're eligible and then kicks them off back to private once the NHS treatment period expires. It's like having the best of both Worlds and really shouldn't be allowed.
Anycrispsleft · 04/04/2022 15:33

@Opaljewel

Because too many people go to A&E with colds and illnesses that they don't need to. Hence holding everybody else up. Try encouraging people arouns you not to go to A&E if it isn't an accident or emergency. Then you might see it improve. You also don't have to pay for it. Let's be grateful. Imagine paying for cancer care. It's not perfect but it's amazing in my eyes what it does do for us when we need it!
When my kids were little, their GP here in Germany told me that while he was quite impressed with how often I correctly called it as to whether the kids needed medical intervention or not, I should probably bring them in more often, as social services here might see it as a sign of neglect that I was only bringing then in when they were really sick. Their attitude is that medical professionals should be doing the triaging, not patients. So I think that "A&E time wasters" are unlikely to be the reason for the long waiting times in British A&Es compared to the continent.
SucculentChalice · 04/04/2022 15:15

I too am very surprised by people working within the profession who choose to keep quiet about what is happening. In my profession, law, I am thoroughly ashamed by what this government has done to criminal legal aid and other social welfare legal aid, and the effect this has had on access to justice and resulting in the courts being not fit for purpose.

Another lawyer with similar concerns here. It brings into issue ethics. And permitting the practice of NHS employees to run a private practice, often using NHS facilities, one day per week, is such an obvious conflict of interest. I cannot imagine it being allowed in any other profession. You do have to question whether some consultants are inclined to refuse surgery required to maintain quality of life to some patients in the knowledge that they will pay to go private.

The other problem that the NHS causes is that it restricts the private sector in the UK, so that its less competitive and therefore offers less value to people and there are less treatments available. PP in the UK is also dependant on an NHS referral in the first place.

Not to mention how difficult it is to sue the NHS because its so difficult to prove that another doctor within the NHS wouldn't have offered similar negligent by any other measure treatment.

Kione · 04/04/2022 15:07

I don't know about Filipinos but Spaniards historically needed visas and sponsorship for Australia and Canada, whilst it was a lot easier to work in the UK.
I am not sure how it is now post Brexit.

Kione · 04/04/2022 15:04

Also to build up experience, because they will only employ staff with experience, to even get one of those shitty contracts.

Swipe left for the next trending thread