Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be finished with voting Tory

417 replies

Viviennemary · 03/04/2022 16:47

I've voted Tory in the last couple of elections. Didn't like Corbyn and thought Keir Stammer was a bit feeble. But after that smug performance by Sunak I am totally not going to vote Tory for a very long time. We are now in a position not to be affected too much by recent rises. Not always been that way of course. I wonder if others are feeling the same. But the lack of any sort of help for less well off people makes me absolutely sick. And all decided by a multi millionaire.

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 04/04/2022 13:38

Thank you @DrSbaitso

That's a polite response and I see your point. I just think it's a shame that every thread on voting intentions goes this way.

QuirkyTurtle · 04/04/2022 13:34

Flip side: imagine not caring about women so much that you're prepared to lose again to the fucking Tories over it...

I'm not sure I understand what you mean by this.

DrSbaitso · 04/04/2022 13:29

@ilovesooty

Is this another thread on voting intentions which is going to be forced into focus on self ID?
I'm sorry, truly.

But they ARE connected issues. It's a hot button topic and many people have indicated that it will affect their vote. Labour supporters will need a better strategy than "you're a transphobic idiot" if they want to swing this. Even if they're right in saying it, it doesn't win people over.

ilovesooty · 04/04/2022 13:28

@PancakePenelope

I voted Tory right up until the last election. I cannot even explain why, I never really investigated it for myself but I was sort of raised to believe that Conservative = work hard to better yourself and your position whereas Labour = expect free handouts. I feel sick to think that I voted based on this notion for so long. The scales have now fallen from my eyes. There is no reward for working hard for a large proportion of people in today's Britain. It's not something I feel I can tell my son. In so many cases both adults in a household work hard and can only just manage to make ends meet. With the cost of living increasing (under the Tories) many hard working people will be left in the gutter. I couldn't bring myself to vote at all at the last election, but next time I intend to do my research and vote for the party that most aligns with my beliefs now.
It takes guts to post that. Well said.
DrSbaitso · 04/04/2022 13:27

@QuirkyTurtle

Imagine hating trans people so much that you're ready to ruin your own life over it.
Flip side: imagine not caring about women so much that you're prepared to lose again to the fucking Tories over it...
ilovesooty · 04/04/2022 13:26

Is this another thread on voting intentions which is going to be forced into focus on self ID?

PancakePenelope · 04/04/2022 13:25

I voted Tory right up until the last election. I cannot even explain why, I never really investigated it for myself but I was sort of raised to believe that Conservative = work hard to better yourself and your position whereas Labour = expect free handouts. I feel sick to think that I voted based on this notion for so long.
The scales have now fallen from my eyes. There is no reward for working hard for a large proportion of people in today's Britain. It's not something I feel I can tell my son. In so many cases both adults in a household work hard and can only just manage to make ends meet. With the cost of living increasing (under the Tories) many hard working people will be left in the gutter.
I couldn't bring myself to vote at all at the last election, but next time I intend to do my research and vote for the party that most aligns with my beliefs now.

DrSbaitso · 04/04/2022 13:23

No.

Thought not.

Because (1) no one has provided any evidence that Labour would win significant numbers of votes by adopting a different stance

Well, the question is hypothetical, hence the "if". (It is clearly a hot button issue, so why exactly isn't anyone carrying out research to get an idea of what the population overall thinks?) And the fact that you're on here trying to persuade people to overlook it when they vote suggests that you do think it's significant.

and (2) what you actually describe is Labour's position - they have said they would keep the Equality Act Single Sex Exemption.

Then why are they being so wishy washy about it in the public discourse?

I'm trying to establish if you would make the same compromise/sacrifice you're berating other people for not making. It seems not. And that's entirely your choice. But surely if it's a sticking point for you, you can see why it's a sticking point for others?

As for the swipe about anyone wanting to be "validated", that's frigging hilarious given the context...

QuirkyTurtle · 04/04/2022 13:20

Imagine hating trans people so much that you're ready to ruin your own life over it.

AllOfUsAreDead · 04/04/2022 13:13

@DrSbaitso

What I'm saying, in a nutshell, is that Labour could win back a lot of female voters if it declared that a woman is an adult human female, and will protect single sex spaces, provisions, rights and so on on that basis.

Do you think that would be a reasonable position to take, if it meant winning enough votes to overthrow this current bunch of vampires and vultures?

They would and god I wish they would. Because people are happy to vote in tory again if it means not Labour and yet, tories are no better. None of the parties seem to care about women anymore, even the ones led by women! It's insane these days.

Ill be voting Labour though I think, or lib dem. It doesn't matter really, snp will win regardless, but I can't vote for them or tory so short of spoiling my vote it's all I've got.

TeaKlaxon · 04/04/2022 13:10

@DrSbaitso

What I'm saying, in a nutshell, is that Labour could win back a lot of female voters if it declared that a woman is an adult human female, and will protect single sex spaces, provisions, rights and so on on that basis.

Do you think that would be a reasonable position to take, if it meant winning enough votes to overthrow this current bunch of vampires and vultures?

No.

Because (1) no one has provided any evidence that Labour would win significant numbers of votes by adopting a different stance; and (2) what you actually describe is Labour's position - they have said they would keep the Equality Act Single Sex Exemption.

anniegun · 04/04/2022 13:10

The fact that people are just waking up to the state of the country after 12 years of Tory rule makes me weep. You are the people that enabled them to create this mess!

TeaKlaxon · 04/04/2022 13:08

@DrSbaitso

I have never argued that 'trans women are women but cis women are cis women'.

"If you're not trans then you're cis."

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4510989-Are-the-wife-and-children-really-fine?pg=15

"Trans women are women."

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4510989-Are-the-wife-and-children-really-fine?pg=16

You are choosing to demonise the people who consider this issue to be a voting point as not giving a shit about poverty or simply being "an idiot".

Yet you clearly do not give enough of a shit either to prioritise getting them back to Labour by accepting the validity of their concerns, even as you chastise them for not accepting the validity of your anti-woman logical absurdity. Like a PP said, 7 pages of criticism isn't a great marketing campaign. I'll never vote Tory, but I can see why you won't win more voters if "ignore this important issue the way I don't, or you're a hateful idiot" is your slogan.

Unfortunately, these issues are linked. Poverty affects anyone, but people whose situations are exacerbated by being single parents living with children, or having a lower income, are more likely to be women.

Your solution is to call people useful idiots who don't give a shit about poverty (even as many of them suffer it in the current crisis) if they are concerned enough about this for it to affect their vote. Do you want to bring female voters back to Labour, or do you want to dig your heels in over your doublethink and Newspeak?

Because it looks as though you think it's only other people who should have to make a compromise on this issue regarding COL and poverty and who otherwise might be selfish, uncaring and idiotic...

As to a previous poster, it's not my job to persuade anyone.

If you want someone to validate you and wrap you in cotton wool about your 'legitimate' concerns then go find a politician.

I'm just someone with views and I'm expressing them. Anyone voting Tory after the last twelve years needs their head wobbling (unless they're the very wealthy benefitting from Tory Government, in which case they need their morals wobbling). That is doubly the case after the last three years.

-Democracy suspended by unlawfully proroguing parliament.

-Violence back in a part of the UK that experienced a civil war during the lifetime of most people on here.

-2.5 million people using food banks.

-Housing massively unaffordable and home ownership out of reach for many more than previously.

It's not my job to convince people that these are bad things. And far worse things than a trans woman being in the women's toilet. If anyone things those are not bad things, or are outweighed by how awful it would be to treat trans people with dignity and respect and inclusion, then those people are beyond any persuasion I can offer.

But I can and will offer plenty of condemnation. And repeat my view that they have brought on whatever hardship they will suffer through Tory misrule themselves. Unfortunately of course the rest of us will have to live with the consequences of their warped values.

DrSbaitso · 04/04/2022 13:07

What I'm saying, in a nutshell, is that Labour could win back a lot of female voters if it declared that a woman is an adult human female, and will protect single sex spaces, provisions, rights and so on on that basis.

Do you think that would be a reasonable position to take, if it meant winning enough votes to overthrow this current bunch of vampires and vultures?

DrSbaitso · 04/04/2022 13:02

I have never argued that 'trans women are women but cis women are cis women'.

"If you're not trans then you're cis."

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4510989-Are-the-wife-and-children-really-fine?pg=15

"Trans women are women."

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4510989-Are-the-wife-and-children-really-fine?pg=16

You are choosing to demonise the people who consider this issue to be a voting point as not giving a shit about poverty or simply being "an idiot".

Yet you clearly do not give enough of a shit either to prioritise getting them back to Labour by accepting the validity of their concerns, even as you chastise them for not accepting the validity of your anti-woman logical absurdity. Like a PP said, 7 pages of criticism isn't a great marketing campaign. I'll never vote Tory, but I can see why you won't win more voters if "ignore this important issue the way I don't, or you're a hateful idiot" is your slogan.

Unfortunately, these issues are linked. Poverty affects anyone, but people whose situations are exacerbated by being single parents living with children, or having a lower income, are more likely to be women.

Your solution is to call people useful idiots who don't give a shit about poverty (even as many of them suffer it in the current crisis) if they are concerned enough about this for it to affect their vote. Do you want to bring female voters back to Labour, or do you want to dig your heels in over your doublethink and Newspeak?

Because it looks as though you think it's only other people who should have to make a compromise on this issue regarding COL and poverty and who otherwise might be selfish, uncaring and idiotic...

TeaKlaxon · 04/04/2022 13:01

@Xenia

Labour in an echo chamber of people with the same views does not listen to those with a different view point eg on the trans issue. I want English law left as it is as do the Tories. Labour wants to change it. That is one issue. For me trusting Labour with lowering taxes is something I will never do. They seem anti just about everything I want from free speech to a small state.
"Small state"

=

More people in poverty.

More people in precarious economy in an unregulated gig economy.

More people priced out of decent housing.

TeaKlaxon · 04/04/2022 12:59

@riotlady

Ffs, Labour voters don’t exactly make a good sale do we? “Come and join us, we’ll berate you for your previous choices for 7 pages, it’ll be great”
Why do you think its on anyone here to sell anything?

I'll be voting LibDem next time but only because they have the best chance of unseating the Tory where I am. I'd vote Labour if that were the case.

It's not my job to make people who are content to elect a cruel, incompetent and corrupt government back into office. Those voters are morally bankrupt in my view and will deserve everything coming to them in terms of living standards - but it's not my job to make idiots non-idiots.

On the other hand, it is Labour's job - and unlike me, they have more restraint and Starmer has been at pains to point out that his approach is not to tell people who voted Tory previously that they were wrong (though obviously they were IMO), but to persuade them.

Xenia · 04/04/2022 12:59

Labour in an echo chamber of people with the same views does not listen to those with a different view point eg on the trans issue. I want English law left as it is as do the Tories. Labour wants to change it. That is one issue. For me trusting Labour with lowering taxes is something I will never do. They seem anti just about everything I want from free speech to a small state.

TeaKlaxon · 04/04/2022 12:54

@babyjellyfish

I believe both trans women and cis women are women.

Why?

What do they have in common?

Not relevant to this thread.
TeaKlaxon · 04/04/2022 12:54

@babyjellyfish

"wants to eradicate women"

Oh bugger off with that absolute nonsense. Not only is it a lie, it is precisely the sort of self-serving culture war lie designed to allow a party that has made life worse for millions and millions of people with the support of useful idiots pleading 'but toilets'.

But Labour has got itself into this culture war by constantly banging the "trans women are women" drum and dismissing anyone concerned about single sex spaces as a transphobic bigot.

I was really looking forward to being able to vote Labour now Corbyn is gone but now I just can't.

And to be quite honest, I'm not sure that a party which chooses to focus on such a niche issue when there are far more important things to worry about, such as the fallout from Brexit, Covid, the war in Ukraine and the rising cost of living, is really competent to govern.

Don't get me wrong, I don't think the Tories are competent to govern either, and unfortunately one of the two will always be in charge.

But since I vote in a safe seat where my vote makes absolutely no difference anyway, I have the luxury of deciding that none of these fuckers deserve my vote, and spoiling my ballot paper.

The only thing that could possibly persuade me to vote Labour or Lib Dem now would be if they made an electoral pact to change the voting system to proportional representation and then hold another general election. And even then I would only be lending them my vote for one specific reason, in the hope that one day I might be able to cast a meaningful vote for a non batshit party.

It's simply wrong to claim Labour have focused on this issue.

Many of us who support trans people would have preferred they focus a LOT more on improving lives of trans people.

When they are asked about their priorities, when they're doing election launches or broadcasts, when they're making their pitch to voters, when they release their manifesto, when they make conference speeches...trans rights is never, ever high on that agenda.

It's simply not true to claim they are 'choos[ing] to focus on such a niche issue'.

The focus is entirely by media (and transphobes within the party like Rosie Duffield) who constantly ask stupid questions. Jeez, I wonder why a right wing media might be desperate to get Labour talking about culture war issues rather than the massive cock up the Tories have made of the country or their massive corruption.

And everyone who buys into it is a useful idiot and has only themselves to blame when they can't afford to heat their home.

Vanderpump · 04/04/2022 12:52

There is no such thing as cis women we are women

babyjellyfish · 04/04/2022 12:48

I believe both trans women and cis women are women.

Why?

What do they have in common?

sleepyhoglet · 04/04/2022 12:48

Democracy isn't ideal but we have free speech. I realised that when looking into life in Russia under Putin

TeaKlaxon · 04/04/2022 12:46

@DrSbaitso

Well you would say that, TeaKlaxon. Last time I saw you, you were arguing that trans women are women but cis women (as you like to call them) are cis women. Which leads to the question of what a woman is.

Of course you're going to deny that women are being eradicated because for some reason, you want to do this. And you'll also deny that it's an issue that women have any right to be concerned about, hence your attempt to oversimplify and reduce it down to nothing but bogs.

And you've got a right to argue all this; free speech, innit.

But many women are concerned about this. So if your priority really is winning them back to Labour, then it's probably better that you compromise on this issue rather than attempting to disprove everyone else with that heady mix of logical absurdity, Newspeak and doublethink.

You're accusing them of not caring enough about poverty to abandon themselves to your brave new world. But, for all your insistence that the issue is no more important than "toilets", you're not giving up on it for the greater good either, are you?

Umm, no. Your first sentence is not correct.

I have never argued that 'trans women are women but cis women are cis women'. I believe both trans women and cis women are women. And in most contexts, the adjectives trans and cis are unnecessary and its enough to just refer to both groups as women. In some cases, the adjectives might be needed.

But that is all a diversion from the main point here - which is that the Tories have spent 12 years making women's lives massively worse. Poverty among women is up. the 62-fold increase in people using food banks? Disproportionately more likely to be women. Gutting local authority budgets meaning social care cuts, cuts to support for kids with SEN etc - mainly hitting women.

And that's before the fact that they're literally presiding over the worse tension in a generation in a part of the UK that experienced a thirty year civil war.

Sorry, but anyone still voting for this because of trans issues is either actively supportive of their cruelty, corruption and incompetence - or is an idiot.

babyjellyfish · 04/04/2022 12:42

Perhaps, but do you really think that's why Tory MPs voted against it? To benefit women?

No. But the fact that some Tory MPs might have voted against it for different reasons doesn't mean it would have been a good law.

Swipe left for the next trending thread