Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this was totally inappropriate parenting?

490 replies

eggstremereaction · 03/04/2022 15:55

Couldn't resist the username opportunity whilst name changing but genuinely upset about what happened

2 year old had a kinder egg as a treat, had spent hours going on about it, was very excited, literally shaking and stamping his feet when the lady in the shop passed it to him at the tills (yes over reaction but he is little) anyway I don't let him open until we get gone and he's very good doesn't try and open it the car, keeps saying "I excited" and giggling, was very cute and dh and me were both laughing finding it cute

Got home, I went and got a bowl to put it in, gave it to toddler, he was happy and took it into the lounge and broke it up in the bowl. Came running in with the toy asking me to open it which I did but doing so left dog unattended around egg which he'd left on the sofa so he went running back in to eat it and it was gone and he was hysterical, so upset. I thought it was fair enough, he's two! He was excited. Yes it's only a chocolate egg but he's tiny and isn't going to react like an adult would. Dh said it was ridiculous, huge overeaction, started saying his excitement in the first place was too intense for chocolate, unhealthy reaction blah blah blah. I went to go back in the car and get him another one, shops only 5 mins and it was like 60p it doesn't matter and it'll make him happy and dh said if I dare go get him an egg I am completely undermining his parenting. So toddler just kept crying. He was saying he was sad and wanted an egg, in the end I said to dh I'm just going to get one and I jumped in the car.

Got back and could hear screaming from the driveway. Toddler was in his room (behind closed stair gate) dh saying you can come out when you stop crying. Pathetic it's an egg. I went and got toddler and took him downstairs and gave him his egg and said it is completely ok to be upset, he's not in any trouble and to just be very careful to not leave food around the dog so this doesn't happen again as I won't always be able to go get a replacement. Dh really annoyed that I undermined him and said I'm too soft and he's going to be a spoilt entitled boy. He just wanted a bloody kinder egg.

Was I unreasonable or was this really inappropriate on his part?

OP posts:
Mouldyfeet · 03/04/2022 19:21

Your husband is an absolute dick! Your poor son.

This would really change my view of my partner. Horrible way to behave.

stuntbubbles · 03/04/2022 19:20

@mydogisthebest The dad literally shut the toddler in his room for crying. Crying is what toddlers do. It’s outrageous behaviour and the dog ate a Kinder egg which is barely chocolate and is going to be fine: I’m horrified by the posters who’ve only posted about the dog, and not about the borderline abusive parenting. The post isn’t even about the dog, the dog is irrelevant other than as the cause of the post – but it’s not the point of the post.

mydogisthebest · 03/04/2022 19:17

@stuntbubbles

Don’t care about the dog, can’t believe how much of the thread is about the bloody dog when the husband is this awful to a TWO YEAR OLD.

OP, my DD would have the same levels of hand-clapping excitement and joy at such a treat, and the same devastation at it being eaten. Totally normal. And FWIW I’m 40 and get excited by treats and gutted if they’re ruined. I can control the extreme reaction of it, obviously, but as Mary Oliver says, joy is not meant to be a crumb: your kid sounds happy and normal and is gaining pleasure at all the tiny pleasures of the world, like a little bit of chocolate. Don’t let your penis of a husband take that joy away.

Dogs can DIE eating chocolate, even a small amount or be seriously ill.

Of course the dad was awful to the son but the son was not at risk of dying was he?

Autumn42 · 03/04/2022 19:14

@eggstremereaction

Couldn't resist the username opportunity whilst name changing but genuinely upset about what happened

2 year old had a kinder egg as a treat, had spent hours going on about it, was very excited, literally shaking and stamping his feet when the lady in the shop passed it to him at the tills (yes over reaction but he is little) anyway I don't let him open until we get gone and he's very good doesn't try and open it the car, keeps saying "I excited" and giggling, was very cute and dh and me were both laughing finding it cute

Got home, I went and got a bowl to put it in, gave it to toddler, he was happy and took it into the lounge and broke it up in the bowl. Came running in with the toy asking me to open it which I did but doing so left dog unattended around egg which he'd left on the sofa so he went running back in to eat it and it was gone and he was hysterical, so upset. I thought it was fair enough, he's two! He was excited. Yes it's only a chocolate egg but he's tiny and isn't going to react like an adult would. Dh said it was ridiculous, huge overeaction, started saying his excitement in the first place was too intense for chocolate, unhealthy reaction blah blah blah. I went to go back in the car and get him another one, shops only 5 mins and it was like 60p it doesn't matter and it'll make him happy and dh said if I dare go get him an egg I am completely undermining his parenting. So toddler just kept crying. He was saying he was sad and wanted an egg, in the end I said to dh I'm just going to get one and I jumped in the car.

Got back and could hear screaming from the driveway. Toddler was in his room (behind closed stair gate) dh saying you can come out when you stop crying. Pathetic it's an egg. I went and got toddler and took him downstairs and gave him his egg and said it is completely ok to be upset, he's not in any trouble and to just be very careful to not leave food around the dog so this doesn't happen again as I won't always be able to go get a replacement. Dh really annoyed that I undermined him and said I'm too soft and he's going to be a spoilt entitled boy. He just wanted a bloody kinder egg.

Was I unreasonable or was this really inappropriate on his part?

I would say I’m a firm parent but your Dh being a complete twat, did he always have such a complete lack of empathy? I really feel sorry for both you and your DS :(
Mangogogogo · 03/04/2022 19:13

Our dog broke into my teenage sons room and ate his entire Easter egg. (Dog is a rescue don’t talk to me about training until you’ve adopted a starving dog off the streets. She will eat anything as she never knew when her next meal would be, and I don’t blame her) anyway said teenager threw the biggest strop, texted me about 50 times after stomping upstairs, slamming doors, just ranting and raving on and ended up in tears… so I mean it could be worse!

Your husband was nasty and that makes me sad :( poor little boy!

KnowingMeKnowingYouAhaaaa · 03/04/2022 19:12

I think your husband needs shutting in a room behind a toddler gate until he's calmed down. Has he completely forgot this is a 2 year old you are dealing with? I'd have done the same as you and got another with a child so young, an older child 7+ who you've said don't leave it out not at all unreasonable to say it's gone, but so little no.

Friendofdennis · 03/04/2022 19:10

Your husband is a bully. Don’t let him undermine your parenting

Thinkbiglittleone · 03/04/2022 19:09

You did absolutely the right thing.
Your son needs to know it's perfectly normal to cry when you are upset. Acknowledge that is a valid feeling, He needs to learn that showing your emotions is not a wrong or weak thing and he needs to learn how to manage them in a healthy way and not bottling them up resulting in them being expressed in anger or aggression.

Your DH needs to be educated on how to teach his boy about emotions and also that we don't lock people away for crying.
He sounds like he got this massively wrong, is he always this harsh ?

bellocchild · 03/04/2022 19:08

This is where you respond to DH by telling him he is cruel and unloving. Something rude anyway.

DigsDilemma · 03/04/2022 19:05

Your husband is a nasty twat, who doesn't understand empathy. To a 2 year old, a kinder egg is the equivalent of a Michelin meal or a ferrari or a wordl cup final (or other extremely expensive treat). I bet he was so confused and sad after being so happy and excited. Glad you've got his back OP. It's fine to undermine parenting when the parenting is shit.

stuntbubbles · 03/04/2022 19:04

@VeganGod

Don’t care about the dog, can’t believe how much of the thread is about the bloody dog when the husband is this awful to a TWO YEAR OLD.

It possible to care about children and animals. Imagine that.

There are multiple posts that ONLY express concern about the dog and ignore the humans altogether!
Shehasadiamondinthesky · 03/04/2022 19:03

Sorry but I hate men like this who think any indulgence is going to turn their son into a faggot (not my words).
My ex husband did this and had already planned a career in the military for DS.
I divorced him and DS is now a professional artist. Totally not suited for the military. Still get letters from him even though DS is now 40 saying looked what I turned DS into.

Squiff70 · 03/04/2022 19:03

Your husband reacted completely inappropriately in the context of the situation. Of course your toddler was excited about his eqgg, but he shouldn't have been left unsupervised - with a dog and potential small parts of a toy which are a choking hazard should he have been able to open it himself. You (or your husband) should have prepared the chocolate and the toy and stayed with your child until he'd eaten the chocolate and had had a chance to look at the toy. When he loses interest in either, you take them both away until he can be supervised with them again later.

I am not sure about driving to the shop to replace the egg but that's not really the main issue here. Your husband confined a tiny child, who is not old enough to be able to regulate his emotions, in his bedroom to punish him for a totally normal reaction for a two year old. That needs addressing, as does your husband's general attitude towards parenting.

Also, you're negating to mention your poor dog. Chocolate is toxic to dogs. You should both know this and be conscious of your dog's safety as well as your child's. I hope your dog doesn't suffer any ill effects.

Suzi888 · 03/04/2022 19:03

@Pyri

You husband sounds awful, no way to treat a toddler

Is your dog ok? Chocolate is toxic to dogs and might really harm him

^ This Your DH is a dick.

Hope DDog will be ok- our JRT could eat anything but our lab not so much.

Hope your DS enjoyed his choc.

AlternativePerspective · 03/04/2022 19:03

train your dog better? there’s always one.

Dogs are opportunists, and when it comes to food they will take an opportunity if it’s presented to them. And that is all dogs, even the most well trained ones.

My dog is impeckibly trained - he’s a guide dog. That seemingly didn’t stop him taking about a quarter of a tub of butter off the side last week and eating it. I’d stepped out for 5 minutes to walk my other dog, he’s never done it before so complacently I left the kitchen door open.

The state of my carpet the next day was something else, and the only one who has learned from that is me. Grin.

And I don’t know a single guide dog owner who hasn’t at some point had their dog eat something they shouldn’t have. From a whole turkey in one instance to chocolate to a chocolate cake to muffins and the list goes on, all of which were left within reach.

They’redogs animals. And they’re not perfect. Not even the best trained ones.

RedBeetroot12 · 03/04/2022 19:01

Aw I feel sorry for your poor boy and also you both as parents as it’s a stressful situation to be in all round. The meltdown your son had over the egg being gobbled up by your dog was understandable and the typical reaction from a 2 year old. They can’t understand the situation properly, don’t know other means to express their disappointment and don’t have the means to replace the egg. Christ I’d be having a mini-meltdown myself if someone else ate something I was intensely looking forward to eating! I imagine your DH saw that you were pandering to your toddler and that it’s setting precedence for future tantrums as a means to getting what he wants… but he should have tried to understand that in this situation your toddler wasn’t having a tantrum but had genuine grounds for his upset.
The level the crying gets to can be super stressful and on top of it all, you were both bickering and heightening the stress levels. Your DH should be more considerate not to add to the stressful situation and in reality it’s not the end of the world. I feel that your DH took it out on your son a little by putting him in his room whilst he cried about the egg. A better situation would have been for your DH to pop out and get another egg whilst you stayed with your toddler or a distraction for your son would have been another exciting adventure in the car to get another egg. Just be kind to each other, you both have different parenting styles and need to work to each other’s strengths. I bet your DH is more often than not the hard cop and may resent how soft you are but you need to be united as much as possible for smoother parenting in the future. When these things happen, just remember it will be a story to tell your son in the future and create a little humour in the retelling. We don’t get any training as parents, all learning on the job as we go along, hope you can both have a decent chat about things when everything’s cooled down a little… why not play a little prank on your DH and buy some nice dessert he will be looking forward to, leave it out and pretend your dog ate it and see how he reacts 🤣🤣🤣

DarkShade · 03/04/2022 19:00

That's horrible OP, your poor little boy. Of course he was excited about his egg, and devastated when it got eaten. It's awful of your husband to try and bully DS and make him feel worse. DS needed comfort, validation and reassurance. It wasn't DS's fault he lost his egg, it's not like he threw it in the bin and then had a tantrum about it being gone, so there was no lesson to be learned.

On a broader and more worrying note, I'd think carefully about how you want your DS to handle his emotions as he gets older. Being told that being upset and crying when something you were excited for gets ruined is a damaging lesson to grow up with. You want to teach him that his emotions are valid, along with some age appropriate ways of expressing and dealing with them.

phoneybaloney · 03/04/2022 18:58

Poor kid. Your husband sounds horrid. Putting in his room because he was upset like that. What a twat!!

CurlyPurpleHair · 03/04/2022 18:57

I'm so happy you went back and got him one!! Btw your husband is a prick.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 03/04/2022 18:53

Toddler was in his room (behind closed stair gate) dh saying you can come out when you stop crying. Pathetic it's an egg.

He called a toddler pathetic for crying about missing out on something they were really excited about.

He's a prick. And a bully.

And seems to be operating under the assumption that he is the parent with the deciding vote.

This can't be a one off, he's not a very nice bloke.

Dinoasaurme · 03/04/2022 18:53

This is extremely concerning to me. I'd be worried your son is going to end up on the Stately Homes thread or in years of therapy, unless your husband learns how toddlers and young children work. You sound like a great mum. Is this the first time he's reacted like this? I'd be having a very very serious conversation with him tonight where you point out he has bullied his own child. He needs to educate himself. Was he raised by a bully?

Thinking2041 · 03/04/2022 18:51

It isn’t a 2 year olds fault that the dog ate their chocolate - as if it’s fair to put the burden of policing a dog on a two year old.
He wasn’t teasing the dog with it and been warned multiple times.
I bought my son an ice cream today and he just dropped it 2 mins after I gave it to him. It was annoying as it cost £3.75! But it wasn’t his fault. If he had been mucking around and I had warned him then I might not have replaced it but given it wasn’t his fault it didn’t occur to me to not offer him a new one: What would the lesson be if I deprived him?! ‘Don’t be a child’?

Your DH sounds resentful and out of touch with child development. I wouldn’t want a man like that nurturing my child

Nanny0gg · 03/04/2022 18:50

@WonderfulYou

You both are BU.

Dogs, toddlers and food are not a good mix - he ran into you to open it meaning there was no one supervising him whilst eating it and no matter how friendly your dog is that is not a good mix.

I also think it’s ridiculous that you went to get into the car to drive and get him another kinder egg!!

He needs to learn that you can’t just get in the car and drive to the shop just to buy one small thing like that - if you carry on like that he is going to turn out very spoilt and you’ll end up making a rod for your own back.

He still had the toy and you could have said we’ll get you another one next time we go or even had a nice stroll there later on.
But jumping in the car straight away is very OTT.

Your DHs reaction was by far the worst!
I too would be upset if my dog ate something I was looking forward to so much.

I completely understand his reaction to you wanting to buy him another and his parenting is probably a reflection of your parenting - he knows what your son will turn out like if there is no discipline so he needs to be the one to do that if you’re not going to.
But he is still very young and there’s a way to discipline without being cruel.

You both could do with some reflection on your parenting and try and get on the same page else you’re going to have these problems for the next 18+ years.

He's 2, not 12!!!
PatientlyWaiting21 · 03/04/2022 18:47

Your two year old behaved better than your husband. Your husband should know better, your husband is the adult who should be able to process emotions, your two year cannot. I’d be livid if my husband treated our child this way! What a way to ruin a good day.

THisbackwithavengeance · 03/04/2022 18:45

@SnackSizeRaisin

However I wouldn't have bought a new egg as it was sadly gone.

Imagine you were out in a pub having a drink with a friend (which you very rarely do and were really looking forward to) and accidentally knocked over your drink before you had drunk any. Would you have said "I won't have another drink as sadly it's gone" or would you cut yourself some slack and buy another drink?

I know right? You and your DH really bigged the whole thing up as a Big Treat, revving your DS up in the car on the way home, really gearing up the anticipation. And then the bloody dog eats the egg! Your poor DS. And then the whole thing is made doubly worse by your DH being a mean, miserable twat and punishing your little boy for understandably being upset.