Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have had enough of DHs moaning and to think we're actually pretty fortunate

140 replies

JustANC3 · 03/04/2022 09:38

My husband likes to moan sometimes. He's quite often hard done to.

Anyway, we were due to move to a bigger house after our last DC but things got in the way namely Covid and now with this cost of living crisis we've just abandoned the idea for the time being and are having to stay put.

We are moving out of our room so all DC have space of their own for now (until we can move) and have spent a decent amount making our dining area into a makeshift bedroom with a hidden bed so it can be used as normal in the day.

It's not perfect by any means but the bed is very comfortable and out of us all we agreed that we needed a separate room the least (kids have so much stuff!.

Anyway, this doesn't really bother me. You wouldn't even know if you came into our house during the day because everything is away but my husband has been making so many comments about how terrible it is, how embarrassing and so on that we can't "afford a bedroom", almost like he thinks it's a failure in life.

Meanwhile I have friends talking to me about how stressed they are about affording their rent, bills, food etc..

AIBU to want to scream at him to stop his whining? Yes we have to sleep downstairs for a time but at least it's in our own home! I'm sick of it. We're fortunate that although it'll be a bit tighter we can still afford what we need, who fucking cares if we need to sleep downstairs for a bit?

I know a few people will probably ask the set up but honestly without going into the whole layout it was just the easiest and best way to arrange everyone.

OP posts:
JustANC3 · 03/04/2022 11:04

@TatianaBis

I have. And I am. But he agrees this is the best thing for now so what? What am I supposed to do?

Give up on having a dining room, move kids in there and move back into a bedroom?

He. Doesn't. Want. To. Do. This.

How many times?

OP posts:
TatianaBis · 03/04/2022 11:02

I have. And I am. But he agrees this is the best thing for now so what? What am I supposed to do?

Give up on having a dining room, move kids in there and move back into a bedroom?

TheBigDilemma · 03/04/2022 11:02

We did something similar at my partner’s house. He has a 2 up 2 down house and two teens. The living room became the bedroom for the teen boy. It is a proper bedroom, we opted out of sofabed of Murphy bed solutions as he needed to feel this was HIS space and a place he could retreat to when he felt like it. I can see how your husband end up feeling he is living out of a bag in the situation you had.

My partner’s dinning room is next to the kitchen and has a fire. So with a three seater and a dinning table that slids into an alcove when not in use (but still looking nice in the place when at the alcove) we have sorted the problem.

As the kids have grown older, we have added TVs in their rooms so they are not tripping on each other’s feet or fighting for the reduced social space all the time.

It works well, everyone has the space they need, the house feels presentable and comfy and the dinning/living room is really nice and lovely to sit in. We were always sitting there when we were together or had visits so the living room was only used for TV watching which is now done in the dinning room or bedrooms.

tempester28 · 03/04/2022 11:01

Lots of people do it and better for kids to have their space in my opinion.

IvorCutler · 03/04/2022 10:59

YANBU. I think we will have to do the same eventually. We rent in a very expensive city with no chance of getting a mortgage (even though it would be less than rent 😩). We’re in a 2 bed apartment with a 6 & 8 year old, they’ll need their own rooms soon.

Purplecatshopaholic · 03/04/2022 10:58

@Iwonder08

YABU, your husband is perfectly entit3to his very reasonable aspirations. I would also think it is terrible not to have a bedroom. Just because there are people who struggle more it doesn't invalidate his personal experience. It would annoy me massively if my spouse would preach me about people struggling to find food when I was concerned about my own situation
I’m with your husband to be honest - I would hate it if I didn’t have a bedroom, and find it upsetting and stressful not to have ‘my’ space. Sleeping in the dining room would be very stressful. His view is as valid as yours. However, in the circs, and given this is a joint decision you have made to deal with the current situation, I agree he should stop moaning and get on with it - presumably there’s an end point to it that he/you can aim for.
JustANC3 · 03/04/2022 10:58

OP is an adult and is perfectly capable of saying if this isn’t working then they she will support an alternative solution

I have. And I am. But he agrees this is the best thing for now so what? What am I supposed to do?

I can't stress enough how long we spent and how many things we looked into.

We looked into converting the attic. We got someone round to take a look, it's a bitch to convert apparently due to the style, would cost ridiculous money. Same with extension, it would mean moving both the kitchen and the bathroom as both are at the back of the house which is the only place we could convert, both of which would add large additional costs onto an already expensive extension. An extension which would also eat largely into our garden space which we don't want to do as it's a good space and we all use it regularly.

Along with many other room splitting scenarios and so on and on...

The idea is still to hopefully move, it's just been delayed.

OP posts:
NeedleNoodle3 · 03/04/2022 10:57

I think I’d moan too, he’s probably feeling frustrated with the situation. I think if it was me I’d be fine with a permanent downstairs bedroom but the putting it away every day would get to me.

Oblomov22 · 03/04/2022 10:57

I would NOT be happy with this. And I'm staggered that you can't understand that both your husband and most normal people would not be happy with this. Making up a bed each night is an utter pain. I'd rather live in a small three bedroomed terrace in a very rough area to live with the circumstances that you have.

bumblingbovine49 · 03/04/2022 10:55

@JustANC3

I'm not expecting him to be joyous about it. But going on and on and on like it's the worst thing ever seems a bit tone-deaf right now.

We actually paid a lot of money to ensure the bed was the best we could get. It's very comfortable and thick. He has no gripes about the bed. Just that it's "scummy to sleep in the dining room".

Like bloody hell if that's the worst we have to sacrifice at the moment for a year or two surely we're alright?

I would find this very unacceptable too, particularly having to make the bedroom look like a dining room every day. A few days for, a set limited time maybe while renovating fine but just ' for now' with no set finish date. I'd loathe it. Where do you dress and keep your clothes.? I would would find the whole thing very stressful
Whatwouldscullydo · 03/04/2022 10:54

He's an adult and perfectly capable of saying "It might be better to do X, but I don't fancy the hassle of moving everyone again"

And if he won't consider moving or any other solutions that were available, and he won't leave, presumably cos he probably actually benefits quite alot from the assistance in looking after his kids amd won't want to give that up either, I mean all this would have been apparent when they moved in together in the first place surley ? Unless there was a gun involved at the wedding? Then tbh he hasn't lost the right to be annoyed/put out/feel inconvenienced by things but he's lost the right to make everyone miserable by moaning about ot all the time.

Comtesse · 03/04/2022 10:54

I would hate this. I would probably moan quite a lot as well.

TatianaBis · 03/04/2022 10:52

But OP hasn't said that he's offered a different solution. She said he claims to agree that the current set up is the best option. He's an adult and perfectly capable of saying "It might be better to do X, but I don't fancy the hassle of moving everyone again".

As I said there may be reasons why he’s reluctant to suggest a different solution and move everyone round again.

OP is an adult and is perfectly capable of saying if this isn’t working then they she will support an alternative solution.

crimsonlake · 03/04/2022 10:52

You still have not told us the children's ages I don't think... I would not have agreed to this in the first place, so I do not blame him.
There were four of us sharing a bedroom when I grew up, but I guess we had much fewer things then....certainly no one expected there own space.

MangosteenSoda · 03/04/2022 10:51

Is he a regular moaner, or is he usually ok and is specifically upset about this situation? If it’s the latter, then he’s showing you how genuinely upset he is (if the former, then surely you already knew his character).

He may have agreed it’s the best case scenario atm, but perhaps felt bulldozed into it. Or thought he wouldn’t mind, but found the reality different. Either way the feelings are valid and you should look into a solution because 2 years is a really long time to be unhappy.

Personally I would treat it as a full bedroom and not tidy it away (apart from Christmas Day etc when you might need a proper dining room. There’s nothing wrong with a downstairs bedroom.

You say you can close the door, but not if it’s a completely separate room (unless I’ve missed that). Do you need to pass through it to get to any other rooms eg. Kitchen? If so, I’d make that room the living area and put the bedroom in the sitting area unless that’s direct entry from the street.

DrManhattan · 03/04/2022 10:49

I hate pointless draining moaning. Tell him you don't want to hear it, he isn't saying anything he hasn't said before, it's boring and unattractive.

Blurp · 03/04/2022 10:49

[quote TatianaBis]@Blurp

But the DH is free to suggest and implement this, and he hasn't. OP isn't stopping him. They have collectively agreed that the current setup is the best option. Neither of them is thrilled by it, but it is what it is. I totally understand him having a quick moan every now and then, but what's the point of constantly whining? It achieves nothing and just drags everyone else down.

You’ve met him have you?

DH may feel bad moving everyone around again and that’s why he hasn’t pushed the point. They collectively agreed but DH is unhappy so something needs to change. I think OP needs to understand how much this is upsetting him and support a different solution.[/quote]
But OP hasn't said that he's offered a different solution. She said he claims to agree that the current set up is the best option. He's an adult and perfectly capable of saying "It might be better to do X, but I don't fancy the hassle of moving everyone again".

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 03/04/2022 10:49

I sympathize with you both. It's shit that you've not got a proper bedroom and it's crap you've to listen to him. The bedroom dining room is a symbol to him for failure I assume.
I also feel doubly sorry for you that everyone is wrecking your head on the thread about bedrooms- if it wasn't the bedroom it would be something else, you had lovely plans and they got postponed which is shit. There's no solution. I'm hoping he'll calm down as time goes on?
I do think it's ok that he complains though but can you maybe make a joke of it? Like 3 complaints a day or something? He mightn't realize how much he's doing it. (I am very tired- I do not have the will to correct the American spellings)

Cherryana · 03/04/2022 10:48

Moaning is a defence mechanism which tried to reflect the problem onto the situation and away from own feelings of fear and inadequacy etc

(which in itself keeps a person stuck and in a comfort zone).

What is his moaning really telling you?
You can’t do this but for him op - but some sort of action to combat what he is afraid of will help.

Eg afraid of seeing himself as a failure who can’t provide for his family - take action to look for new job.

Eg afraid of not having a space of his own to recharge- find an alternative eg a shed

(I know they sound a bit sexist assumptions of fears and solutions but they sort of work in a lot of situations and are just examples).

TatianaBis · 03/04/2022 10:43

@Blurp

But the DH is free to suggest and implement this, and he hasn't. OP isn't stopping him. They have collectively agreed that the current setup is the best option. Neither of them is thrilled by it, but it is what it is. I totally understand him having a quick moan every now and then, but what's the point of constantly whining? It achieves nothing and just drags everyone else down.

You’ve met him have you?

DH may feel bad moving everyone around again and that’s why he hasn’t pushed the point. They collectively agreed but DH is unhappy so something needs to change. I think OP needs to understand how much this is upsetting him and support a different solution.

JustANC3 · 03/04/2022 10:41

Why couldn’t your kids share for longer, or build a partition in their room?

Our youngest DC were sharing with us as I've already said.

Is there no option to build an extension/convert attic to get the extra room you need?

We did look into this extensively among many other things.

OP posts:
VioletCharlotte · 03/04/2022 10:38

I totally understand why you're frustrated OP. You've found a solution that works ok for the next couple of years. Not perfect, but better than struggling financially and getting into debt. As you say, he agreed to it and is now dragging you down with constant moaning.

I think more people should take a leaf out of your book actually, be grateful for what your have and count your blessings rather than always looking at the negatives and wanting something better.

Gonnagetgoing · 03/04/2022 10:38

I think I’d be pretty pissed off with this too and though I like to moan I’d probably want it to be a permanent bedroom and not a fold away bed.

Is there no option to build an extension/convert attic to get the extra room you need?

TabithaHazel · 03/04/2022 10:37

I actually don’t blame your husband. It’s pretty shit being a grown up and not having a bedroom! I use ours to escape to all the time, adults need a space for quiet time too. Why couldn’t your kids share for longer, or build a partition in their room?

DisforDarkChocolate · 03/04/2022 10:34

I'd be saying to him that he gets one more week to main about and then you expect him to shut up.

It sounds much better than sharing with a toddler.