Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have had enough of DHs moaning and to think we're actually pretty fortunate

140 replies

JustANC3 · 03/04/2022 09:38

My husband likes to moan sometimes. He's quite often hard done to.

Anyway, we were due to move to a bigger house after our last DC but things got in the way namely Covid and now with this cost of living crisis we've just abandoned the idea for the time being and are having to stay put.

We are moving out of our room so all DC have space of their own for now (until we can move) and have spent a decent amount making our dining area into a makeshift bedroom with a hidden bed so it can be used as normal in the day.

It's not perfect by any means but the bed is very comfortable and out of us all we agreed that we needed a separate room the least (kids have so much stuff!.

Anyway, this doesn't really bother me. You wouldn't even know if you came into our house during the day because everything is away but my husband has been making so many comments about how terrible it is, how embarrassing and so on that we can't "afford a bedroom", almost like he thinks it's a failure in life.

Meanwhile I have friends talking to me about how stressed they are about affording their rent, bills, food etc..

AIBU to want to scream at him to stop his whining? Yes we have to sleep downstairs for a time but at least it's in our own home! I'm sick of it. We're fortunate that although it'll be a bit tighter we can still afford what we need, who fucking cares if we need to sleep downstairs for a bit?

I know a few people will probably ask the set up but honestly without going into the whole layout it was just the easiest and best way to arrange everyone.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Goldfishmountainclimber · 03/04/2022 15:23

We live in central London where space, whether owned or rented, is very expensive. Plenty of parents sleep on a sofa bed in the living room during the teenage years so that the children can have bedrooms. Your post wouldn’t cause any reaction at all around here. More surprising that you actually have a separate dining room! It seems very sensible to use it as a bedroom. Certainly much better than moving in these uncertain times.

PersephonePomegranate · 03/04/2022 13:45

than

Bloody phone!

PersephonePomegranate · 03/04/2022 13:43

I would find it annoying too, OP, but you're fundamentally very different people in terms of how you cope with things not going your way and set backs in life.

People with your outlook will always be happier then people with your husband's. I don't think there's anything that can be done except wear ear plugs as this seem to be your husband's factory settings!

BlackeyedSusan · 03/04/2022 13:26

Found the answer now. Yanbu. You have a downstairs bedroom that can be turned into a dining room. That he agreed to.

Blimecory · 03/04/2022 13:24

@BlackeyedSusan

Why can't your kids share?
They do share.
BlackeyedSusan · 03/04/2022 13:21

Why can't your kids share?

Goldbar · 03/04/2022 13:21

YANBU. It's quite rare to have a separate dining room these days. Lots of people have to make do with a table in the kitchen or living-room. It's not really something to moan about. We have a table in our kitchen... works fine. Most people round here have the same, even if quite well-off (small houses, expensive property prices).

Like you said, you had various options, including converting the dining-room into a proper bedroom. You decided on one together and now you've got to make the best of it.

InFiveMins · 03/04/2022 13:04

YANBU. It wouldn't bother me to sleep in the dining room either. It's not ideal but he's behaving like a spoilt child. You literally just need a bed to sleep in - I can't see what his problem is.

Flatbrokefornow · 03/04/2022 13:02

I mean, it depends. I’m completely broke and could sell my car if I wanted to. I only do the shopping in it, can’t afford to go anywhere else. I don’t, because I’m not expecting it to be forever and because it’s so convenient for me not to take a bus. But I’m still very, very skint and can still moan to friends about it (all of whom are better off than me. It’s really important to dump outwards) without them telling me to stfu and sell the car.

OTOH, I don’t moan constantly and unreasonably to friends, who I would expect to tell me put a sock in it after a while. It’s a matter of intensity. We a need support, but there are limits to what we can expect unpaid people to give us.

WomanStanleyWoman · 03/04/2022 13:00

Yes this is it for me. Yes I get it it's not perfect but what do you want me to do? He's not suggesting we do anything other than we are, just moaning for the sake of it. Like okay I get it now can we just make the most of what we have and get on with it?He's not saying 'look I've tried it but I can't do it so I think we should look at X or Y again'. He agrees it's the best thing for now but then doesn't shut up about it "can't believe our life has come to this" and on and on.

This is what would drive me mad too. Of course it isn’t ideal, but it’s happening. He agreed to it happening. He’s doing nothing to change it.

It’s simple really. There are three options here:

  1. Reassess making the children share.
  2. Move somewhere that isn’t really suitable and risk paying out more to move again later - but with the bonus that you get the space you need now.
  3. Stick with sleeping downstairs, in the knowledge that it’s not great, but it’s temporary - and stop moaning about it.

Unfortunately, your husband seems to have chosen option 4 - “pick the least unpalatable of three less than ideal options, but then endlessly moan about the fact that it’s less than ideal, making everyone feel worse in the process”. If I had to put up with that, option 5 - he moves out - would be on the table fairly quickly.

As much as you could reassess 1 and 2, I honestly don’t think it would solve the main problem - his attitude. If the kids were sharing, he’d complain there was stuff everywhere because their room was too small for two. If you moved, he’d moan the house was in the wrong area, was run down, wasn’t spacious enough even with the extra bedroom…

It’s not your sleeping arrangements that need to change - it’s him.

NdefH81 · 03/04/2022 12:56

@Daisyonthelawn

A lot of the horror on here is just a way of boasting that they don’t have to live like that.
Such an odd post
Topseyt · 03/04/2022 12:49

@Daisyonthelawn

A lot of the horror on here is just a way of boasting that they don’t have to live like that.
I've lived like that before. I still stand by what I have said.
Andouillette · 03/04/2022 12:46

Argh OP, I feel for you! I have a moany git as well, just as well I love him! From what I can tell from your posts you live in a 3 bedroom house, have young twins and 3 DSC who visit often and need their own rooms. As you are not in a position to move for a year or two and extending is cost and garden space prohibitive you have made the eminently sensible decision to utilise your dining room as a part time bedroom. Is it ideal? No. Is it workable? Yes. Well done to you and DH for making a sensible decision. If he keeps on moaning change the subject, every bloody time. Usually works for me. In fairness he does the same to me if I am having a whinge-fest.

Daisyonthelawn · 03/04/2022 12:27

A lot of the horror on here is just a way of boasting that they don’t have to live like that.

Blurp · 03/04/2022 12:26

@Derbee

I would feel exactly the same as your husband. I’d be miserable and feel shit about sleeping in a dining room. I think he’s well within his rights to feel the way he does
It sounds as though OP isn't loving the setup either, but she(?) isn't moaning and huffing to everyone else. Of course very few of us would love it, and of course the DH is allowed to dislike it, but unless he has a better plan then why moan continually about it?

Some people on the thread are talking as if OP has brow-beaten DH into this arrangement and she's perfectly happy with it. My reading of it is that they agreed it together, neither of them thinks it's great, but not do they appear to have any better options for now. OP has chosen to get on with it; DH has chosen to moan but hasn't come up with any better ideas.

Booboobibles · 03/04/2022 12:12

I sleep on a sofa bed in the living room (although it’s rare that anyone else is in the room during the day) and my 17 year old son has the bedroom.

At the moment, it’s the least stressful option but I moan about it constantly - some days more than others. If I had young kids I’d be tearing my hair out.

Nanny0gg · 03/04/2022 12:07

@JustANC3

But the fact is that you’re getting your way and your husband isn’t getting his

This is totally incorrect. We agreed this was the best thing for now as I said in my OP. It wasn't just me demanding this is what we do. It was a mutual decision. We spent ages talking and going through things looking into conversions, how to make more space, would it be worth moving (even garden rooms!) etc... And we BOTH agreed at present this was the easiest way for a year or two until we can come to something more permanent.

He's not moaning because he's not getting his own way and I am.

So, is it a murphy bed? So you don't need to see it at all? Do you still have a table you can use in there or in the kitchen?

Was it used much before or did it just 'look' like a dining room?

I think if he agreed then there's not much point going on about it

LondonWolf · 03/04/2022 12:06

All these "I couldn't live with it!" Grin

Yes you could if you had to and plenty of people have no choice.but to.

Reminds me of a thread where people were expressing complete horror that OP had no where to store bikes for her kids so they didn't have any. People simply couldn't comprehend that others were living in straitened circumstances unlike their own.

Derbee · 03/04/2022 12:06

I would feel exactly the same as your husband. I’d be miserable and feel shit about sleeping in a dining room. I think he’s well within his rights to feel the way he does

shssandhr · 03/04/2022 11:54

If he's unhappy then he needs to find a new solution.
Yes he does. And keep saying that too him.
It's a pain in the arse having someone constantly moaning on about something without coming up with a better idea.

The only thing I wondered is why it's still a dining room. Just rename it the bedroom and have it properly set up, with the bed out permanently and not folding up and down.
And have some kind of fold up table instead which can be used for family meals if you don't have the space for a large enough table set up permanently.
You haven't answered questions about whether you have a table in the lounge or kitchen and you have told us many times you don't want advice on the set up... but I'm not really understanding why this "dining room" can't be a permanent bedroom and you sacrifice the "dining room" to ensure everyone has their own room.

Bewilderbeest · 03/04/2022 11:36

I wonder if he sees it as humiliating? Like “I can’t afford to keep my family in the manner I want to, and I feel like I’ve failed as a provider”? I know it’s not very 21st century to feel like that about it and he needs to get over himself if he does, but in my experience a lot of men still see their role as being a provider and feel embarrassed if they perceive that as being undermined somehow. Maybe his moaning is actually a cack-handed way of asking for reassurance?

Belladonna12 · 03/04/2022 11:31

Was this your idea? He may have agreed because he thought it's what you wanted and that there are no other options or he may have thought it sounded ok but has now changed his mind. There are other options though e.g. the living room could be used as a dining room too and you could make the current dining room a permanent bedroom. You need to make sure that he really thinks your current situation is the best option.

Whatsmyname100 · 03/04/2022 11:30

Why can't the kids move into your space and swap to a bedroom? Maybe change the living room to include a dining table, those ones with benches to save space? I'm with your dh on this. I feel for you as well. We lived in a place paying a huge rental and I was just utterly depressed. I moaned to poor dh every single day until we could move. As this is your own home, you both need to rework things so both are happy.

TheNameOfTheRoses · 03/04/2022 11:29

@NeedleNoodle3

Just because he agreed to it doesn’t mean he likes it. The reality for him is probably a lot worse that he imagined it would be. Could you work together and come up with another plan?
Or could HE work out another plan and work with the app to see if that would be workable/a better arrangement?

Why is it up to the OP to find a new solution when she has no issue with the current one?
Amd why would it be enough for her DH to just moan and provide no solution, Wo even trying to propose an alternative? He isnt a child that go and see mummy to moan and see their problem solved.

RedskyThisNight · 03/04/2022 11:28

@TheNameOfTheRoses

I would just say ‘Yes I can see that you are uncomfortable about the set up. What do YOU want to do about it?’ And then wait for him to come up with a solution.

Moaning is fine and understandable.
Moaning again and again about the same thing Wo ding anything about it isn’t.
Nor is it ok for him to moan about a solution HE agreed on.

Yes agree. The conversation goes: "none of our solutions are ideal - what would you prefer to do? And then we just need to both get on with it."

I don't think it's helpful to say that at least you're not worrying about the heating/food - maybe the people that are worrying about these things made a different choice to you and moved to a property they are now struggling to afford?

Swipe left for the next trending thread