Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 2 hours travelling time is too much for work?

92 replies

GraEll · 03/04/2022 07:29

Hi, I have just secured one of my dream positions and of course I am very happy, but I don't know if I understand the extent of the journey every day, there and back. I can get a direct bus for an hour and 50 mins or a bus and a train that's expected to take an hour and 20, but by the time I've swapped and wanted time in between to make sure I don't miss it, I've decided the direct bus is better (what do you think on this as well? Is it worth adding 30 mins there and back for a much easier way of getting there?)

How likely is it to be out the house 6:30am-7pm Monday-Friday and still have an active life filled with more things than work... especially children and stuff. Also, does anyone do a similar journey and think it's absolutely fine?

OP posts:
mistermagpie · 03/04/2022 08:24

One of the women in my team has a nearly 2hr commute. She did it for years to be fair but said she would cry in the shower at 5:30 in the morning and missed her sons bedtime most nights.

We have wfh mostly since the pandemic began and she says her life has been completely transformed. It was a miserable experience and she pretty much hated Monday-Friday and felt she was basically giving up being a parent for the week. The cost of the travel was also around £200 a month for her.

Based on literally this one example and the fact that I have three young children, there is no way I would take a job, any job, that involved that much travel. It just wouldn't be an option.

LittleRedRidingHood187 · 03/04/2022 08:23

It may start off okay but it will soon become a problem. After a shit day it will be the last thing you want esp in the Winter months

I've just gone from seven years commuting ten minutes by car to twenty five minutes by car and what with finishing at 5:30pm it's the absolute maximum I would ever want to do

saleorbouy · 03/04/2022 08:23

You're going to waste 20hts a week on the bus, I'd move closer to get a better work/ life balance.

ApolloandDaphne · 03/04/2022 08:20

My DD1 did a commute that long (Brighton to London train then bus across London to work) and it almost broke her. That was with a partner and no DC. She and her DP split up and she moved to London and reduced her commute to 30 minutes. She was like a different person. I would not consider that commute with small DC.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 03/04/2022 08:20

I allow 1 hour 15 mins to drive to work, which is only 11 miles, away due to traffic. I work compressed hours so the drive home is not during rush hour and it only takes 20-25 mins. It would take much longer than 1 hour 15 on public transport though. I guess it depends on how long it will take you to get to any place of work, is it unusually long or fairly typical if you live in a more remote area?

Nothappyatwork · 03/04/2022 08:18

Would you have to do that every single day I mean most of us in our office travel at least an hour each way but we only do it two days a week. and that’s entirely optional.

icklekid · 03/04/2022 08:16

As a teenager my mum used to do same length commute into London every day. But my dads job was much closer to home and therefore he would be around if needed. My mum loved the job and the social side of London working. She read on the train and wasn’t bothered by the length of time. Would you be stressed about what your missing or enjoy the time to read on the commute? Have you a partner who can pick up some of the slack? I think younger children come with more complicated wrap around care expectations of taking to clubs etc where as teenagers can sort lifts themselves or be more independent?

ChoiceMummy · 03/04/2022 08:15

@GraEll

Hi, I have just secured one of my dream positions and of course I am very happy, but I don't know if I understand the extent of the journey every day, there and back. I can get a direct bus for an hour and 50 mins or a bus and a train that's expected to take an hour and 20, but by the time I've swapped and wanted time in between to make sure I don't miss it, I've decided the direct bus is better (what do you think on this as well? Is it worth adding 30 mins there and back for a much easier way of getting there?)

How likely is it to be out the house 6:30am-7pm Monday-Friday and still have an active life filled with more things than work... especially children and stuff. Also, does anyone do a similar journey and think it's absolutely fine?

I'm not sure if you have children or are considering in relation to if you had children. Personally, the job is totally incompatible with a family life imo. You'd be reliant on a partner doing all the drop offs and pick ups etc.

I used to commute, by car though, so imo more relaxing and direct, and some days it was lovely, the radio on, sun shining etc, no traffic, sometimes that journey would take 3 times as long.

And don't forget that relying on public transport totally restricts you if you wanted to be there earlier or later etc. Let alone the cost factor.

Either move closer or find something closer or drive.

00100001 · 03/04/2022 08:13

If there were kids involved, not a fucking chance. You'd basically would only see them for 2 days a week and be shattered.

Footgoose · 03/04/2022 08:12

I spent 5 years commuting 4 hours a day ( sometimes longer if traffic was bad ) , 5 days a week. In the car so at least a smooth commute. Reasons included, it paid phenomenally well compared to similar positions locally. Local positions in the same field came up rarely and were often not great. It suited my children's routine but I hated it. I was often late due to traffic ( major route often shut due to accidents) , already stressed when I reached work , exhausted by the time I got home but Depending how you look at it I was either trapped or motivated to keep going . I didn’t do it because I loved the job and if that’s your only motivation , you may struggle to keep it up if other parts of your life suffer. I’m also wondering what kind of bus journey. Around all the houses ?
My other thought is the bus / train option as well as being a bit quicker gives you a bit of a break from being tossed about on a bus while getting a bit of a walk in / smoother journey on the train .
All bus winter ? Bus and train summer maybe ?
Good luck.

NoSquirrels · 03/04/2022 08:09

Do you have DC yet, OP? It’s not clear from your post.

Personally I’d probably do the direct bus for a week, then the train /bus combo and see what worked best.

If you can work on the coach as easily as a train then that would probably sway me.

It is a long commute but if it’s your dream job then you’ll find a way to make it work. That could mean moving though!

incompetentcervix · 03/04/2022 08:06

I do a similar commute but I don't see my kids much on the days I work which long hours, plus I have no other life and most importantly thats the minimum travel time - often it's longer due to cancelled transport or hold ups on the motorway. Once or more a week it's 2 hours one way. In summer everyday is longer

Sapphirejane · 03/04/2022 08:06

Sorry that should say a few times a year my commutes would be 2hrs each way for a few weeks at a time. I could cope with a few one offs throughout the year.

lechatnoir · 03/04/2022 08:05

An hour & half commute is fairly standard London / Home Counties commute and I did it for years pre kids and PT for another 4 years post kids- drive to station & park 20 mins, train55mins, tube or bus 15/20 mins.

It's knackering but you get used to it, I'd take the quickest option no question and wouldn't want to do it ft with family unless there is an OH around and hands on. Is there an option to wfh one day ?

Sapphirejane · 03/04/2022 08:05

I used to have a job where I would travel to different sites and a few times a year I had commutes of 2hrs each way and the put such a strain on me. I definitely couldn’t do it everyday. I have a young child and WFH through the pandemic has shown me how wonderful a better work life balance can be. I wouldn’t even consider jobs more than a 45 min commute now. I think 1hr 50 with a family at home is madness sorry.

LankylegsFromOz · 03/04/2022 08:05

I do 1.5 hours each way for coming up to 7 years. I hate it! It's severely impacted my quality of life in every corner. Each year it gets harder rather than easier. I am currently applying for jobs a step backwards or sideways, just to get out of it. If you take the job, be prepared your commute will impact near every decision you make (ie can DD take on a week day activity, where your DH can work etc).

My advice.. don't do it 🙂

hattie43 · 03/04/2022 08:04

I lasted a 2.5 hr commute each way 9 months then moved closer . It totally effected my life onside and outside work and that's without children .

Work was difficult being the only one commuting meaning I missed out on after work socialising and not being able to stay later if needed .
Outside work was difficult with partner ready to go out to dinner etc and me only ready for bed / sleep .

Short term yes longer term no imo

pictish · 03/04/2022 08:02

No. I wouldn’t do that commute. I’d be wrung out like a dishrag.

65honeybee · 03/04/2022 07:59

And to reiterate: a lot depends on whether this job is an essential stepping stone or a job you'd want to remain in forever.

It's one mindset doing a tough commute for a year or two maximum to progress your career so you have better opportunities closer to home. Quite different if you're going to want to do it long term

Scarecrowrowboat · 03/04/2022 07:59

Pre kids I did a couple of hours each way, ironically I lived in pretty central london and commuted out. That did mean quiet train though which made it bearable. Now I do about 1 1/2 hours and its ok, would be nice not to but I'm part time so it's ok. Full time I'm not sure.

PurplePansy05 · 03/04/2022 07:58

I did similar for nearly 5 years when I was single and tbh it was awful. Public transport is notoriously unreliable and delayed/cancelled. Long commute has its benefits in a sense I used to deal with all life admin then, but it's also tiring in a sense of neverending early starts and late finishes not by choice. It's possible to have a good social life, gym etc. but it was really tiring.

If you have no children, move closer. If you have children and can't move, I can't quite see this working out childcare wise and time wise unless you request hybrid working part wfh.

GeneLovesJezebel · 03/04/2022 07:57

No. I’d move closer.

Wnkingawalrus · 03/04/2022 07:55

That commute wouldn’t bother me if I didn’t have children, especially if the hours were very set and very limited chance I’d ever having to stay late. Still time to meet friends in the evening or go to the gym. And think of all the reading you could do on that journey!

But I don’t think it would work with kids. You would need a super supportive partner that took care of all the childcare, drops off/pick ups etc and was much closer to home in case of emergencies. I also personally wouldn’t want to go all week without seeing young children.

That said plenty if men do it.

RhubarbFairy · 03/04/2022 07:54

I think that you'll find you are exhausted and your work life balance will be tipped the wrong way.

Pre children, I was happy to commute an hour plus. I took on a role a few years ago that was an hours drive on a clear runn, bit could go up to 1hr 30 if I was unlucky. I have two DC who were under 9 then.

I did it 4 days a week and was out of the house from 7.20 to 3.20 on those days. The DC went to breakfast club. I would drop them off on the way to work and pick them up on the way home. I had no time to decompress and it felt like I never had time to do anything else.

That was being out of the house less hours than you will be. You also need to factor delays out of your control (roadworks, traffic jams, late bus, cancelled trains, maintenance works, diversions). All could add significant time to an already long journey.

To answer your question about having an active filled life, you won't have. Life will revolve around work.

Would moving closer be an option if it really is a dream position?

Darbs76 · 03/04/2022 07:50

People in my team travel quite a distance too, 1hr 20, most people in my team take around that to get into work with trains, traffic etc.