Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 2 hours travelling time is too much for work?

92 replies

GraEll · 03/04/2022 07:29

Hi, I have just secured one of my dream positions and of course I am very happy, but I don't know if I understand the extent of the journey every day, there and back. I can get a direct bus for an hour and 50 mins or a bus and a train that's expected to take an hour and 20, but by the time I've swapped and wanted time in between to make sure I don't miss it, I've decided the direct bus is better (what do you think on this as well? Is it worth adding 30 mins there and back for a much easier way of getting there?)

How likely is it to be out the house 6:30am-7pm Monday-Friday and still have an active life filled with more things than work... especially children and stuff. Also, does anyone do a similar journey and think it's absolutely fine?

OP posts:
kitcat15 · 03/04/2022 09:33

I would never ever contemplate this....I have a 15 minute commute ..... but 45 mins would have been my absolute maximum pre children

purpledagger · 03/04/2022 09:24

Given that you've worked in a 'shitty call centre for two years since graduating' (your words), I would go for it, if only for a few years, to get some experience. It sounds like you are quite young and don't have any dependents yet, so it should be manageable.

I've spent most of my working life commuting to central London, so a 2 hour commute is quite standard and I've known lots of people to have commutes of this length or longer, even with children.

Yes, it can be tiring, but use your time productively eg read a book, learn a language, play a game on your phone, listen to a podcast. I always take a travel mug and read the Metro and time flies by.

You could also explore other options to commuting eg renting a room locally, Mon-Thurs. You many find other ways to cut down your commute eg cycling part of the journey.

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 03/04/2022 09:17

My commute was 2-2.5hrs each way before I went on maternity leave. I found the worst part was the unreliability of public transport. Frequently the train would be late and I'd have to run across the train station like a mad woman hoping the bus was also late as the next one wasn't for 40mins and was always full. Make sure you do trial runs on both methods. Personally I prefer buses to trains.

As you have no kids I'd say it's doable - I did it for years, however I left at 5:20am so was home at a more reasonable time. There's no way I could do that commute if I had childcare to deal with. Luckily mine will half by the time I'm back at work as the office has relocated.
If it's only weekdays then it shouldn't affect your time with your stepson too much - is there a possibility of finishing earlier on Fridays?

As it's a dream job the travel might not get you down too much. I don't particularly like my job so the travel felt like it was grinding me down every time a train didn't turn up or broke down leaving me stranded.

Thesheerrelief · 03/04/2022 09:10

If it's your dream position and you don't have kids then go for it. It'll get you out of the call centre job and onto the right career path that could open more doors for you.

RosesAndHellebores · 03/04/2022 09:09

If it's a building block on a cv I'd do it for a couple of years. Will you be able to work/read on the bus? Can you nod off on the bus?

Totally unfeasible with dc though.

rookiemere · 03/04/2022 09:07

Can you stay over at a cheap PI or Travel lodge once a week ?
Or look at Mon-Fri boarding somewhere?

fuzzyduck1 · 03/04/2022 09:04

Is the job worth it?
You’ll be doing a 12-13 hour day. So price it on them times not just the 8 hours you’ll be at the job. It may sound daft but you could get a lower paid job closer where you get paid less but more per hour as you have no commute.

ThatPosterIsSoRight · 03/04/2022 09:04

I did 1 hour 30 mins (plus delays) each way for years. It was fine because DH stepped up and I didn’t bring work home (I did a more local job before but had to bring work home and it was awful). Used to do some life admin on the train, but mostly read and listened to music and came home ready for family life. I was out of the house 7:30 to 6:30, sometimes left at 8am, sometimes in at 7 or 7:30pm. Came home to kids in the bath and dinner cooking. Like many many dads. It’s good being a dad, more mums should try it.

I have at best a 2 hour commute now and it’s too much to do regularly, particularly as there’s big scope for it to go wrong as it’s far. If it was exactly 2 hours with no train changes would be just about ok.

RantyAunty · 03/04/2022 09:04

I'd take it and move closer to the job.

If you were married and had DC of your own, it might be different.
It seems you have a boyfriend and his son.

TonkaTruckduck · 03/04/2022 09:03

It sounds beyond miserable. Surely there must be something else you can apply for?

When would you exercise, cook, do life admin, see friends see dp without his child being there?

So many roles are wfh now, I'd keep looking.

HomeprideSaucy · 03/04/2022 09:03

DP did this for many years, typically c.80-90 minutes on two crowded buses depending on timetables and traffic. He also worked long stressful days so would leave at 7am and not be home until 7pm. It nearly broke him (and us) by the end, just the tiredness. If you don't get home til 7pm, you still want to spend time with your kids and you still need to eat, but that left no time for our relationship as he was too tired to spend any time with me. He was asleep on the sofa by 9pm. I work part time but I did everything relating to house and children and all the "life admin".

The pandemic was a saviour as it tipped the balance into working half the week at home which looks like it's going to be ongoing now, thank god.

An hour's commute in London is pretty normal for many people, but for me, any longer than that would have to be an exceptional job or have a good capacity to work from home at least a couple of day a week.

TokyoTen · 03/04/2022 09:01

It's doable. I've left the house at 6.30am to get a 6.50am train and then get back home by 7.30pm for several years (I have kids). But it depends if the money makes it worthwhile.

Royalbloo · 03/04/2022 09:00

It's tiring but I did it pre-children. You sort of get used to it. Wouldn't do it now I have DC's.

cheninblanc · 03/04/2022 08:57

I had to do this as work changed my site. I was miserable, tearful and left. Sorry I can't be more positive

Anyfeckinusername · 03/04/2022 08:56

Do you also have a walk or a drive at either end? I did a xx 2.5 hour commute once a week and it had me so tired for the next day… any more frequency and I couldn’t have maintained it (but my kids were nursery age so it also involved an additional drive each way to drop off and pick up).

The killer was when the connecting train was held up. I think your bus/train combo will ruin you… go the longer way but stay on the one train, and do something useful on the journey. It might not be so bad if you’ve no kids to also deal with.

I used to actually like the train part. I forced break from the otherwise go-go-go life.

DistrictCommissioner · 03/04/2022 08:54

If childcare isn’t a factor & it’s a progression in your career, then I would take it.

I commuted 1h 45 mins each way, it was ultimately impossible to find childcare that worked with a shift working DH & that commute, so I left. The commute itself wasn’t a massive problem really, read lots of books!

WelshyMaud · 03/04/2022 08:52

A lot of people will say it's standard and normal and they or their DH do it but it sounds utterly miserable to me.

I have a 20 minute drive and 10 minute walk to get to work (free car park a block away) and I'm glad I only have to do that twice a week!

badspella · 03/04/2022 08:48

I commuted 2.5 hours or 3 hours each way for about seven years, If I could drive, the commute would be just over an hour each way. I had two teenage sons with additional needs.

I had a part time online job that I did on the way to and from work (if I could get a seat on the bus/train). This meant I worked up to 14 hours each day, and then had the boys to look after.

My husband looked after our sons on his own for six hours each day (when they attended school) and for 14 hours a day when they began to refuse school.

If I was single, I could have done it, although I would be more likely to move closer to work. With all the additional commitments, it was impossible, and I remember the seven years as being a period of permanent stress and fatigue.

As others have said, public transport can be very unreliable. I had to catch a bus, then a train, then a connection, then (if I was going to the other site) another bus. Despite travelling for three hours, I was often a little late if I worked on the other site, so I would work through my lunch to catch up. The national trains were fine, but the local trains were horrendous and crowded. The copper wire for the railway lines was frequently stolen, and this meant another half hour or more added to my journey..

When I got home, my sons would become over-excited and I would spend ages trying to calm them down enough to settle down for the evening. My husband would clear off, exhausted.

Sorry about the rant, but I work from home now and it is bliss compared to those years and that monstrous commute.

GraEll · 03/04/2022 08:47

I have a step son who comes Friday evenings until Monday mornings where dad drops at school. Obviously it doesn't really affect the working week but it's still a family weekend.

No biological kids of my own right now.

I've been doing a shitty call centre job for 2 years since graduating and obviously can't wait to get into an actual career at last!! Great progression as well...

But obviously don't want to feel completely dreadful... but not sure it's possible to feel worse than the job I'm in now lol! Even with the commute... but not sure, hence I'm really grateful to read all the replies.

My worry about the train and bus combo is things not running properly, seems more likely something to go wrong than the direct bus and ofc the train will take 2.4K a year more, again, is that worth for the extra 30 mins?

No option to work from home. It's not really possible to move even closer due to there already being an hour (by car) between DS and his dad/mum, then he wouldn't be able to stay until the Monday morning etc.

OP posts:
Blankscreen · 03/04/2022 08:40

My DH has just changed jobs and his commute is 2!hrs a day. The office is thankfully moving so it will be i.5 hrs.

We live in Surrey and he commutes into London and 1.5 hrs is pretty average and what he has done for the last 14 years.

BUT he is the main earner and I work reduced hours so i pick up ALL of the slack at home with the children dogs and house admin.

He get in about 8+8:30 every night and is knackered.

He can only do it because I facilitate it.

RiaG91 · 03/04/2022 08:33

Speaking from experience, it makes a long day when you're commuting 4 hours each day. Throw in any traffic delays or on days where you might not be feeling too great and it's even harder.

I used to commute 2 hours each way, sometimes this would be 3. I had to be out of the house by 5:30 to make sure I missed the traffic otherwise I'd never get to the office in time. This meant I was actually working an extra 2 hours per day too, and home between 7-8pm.

The only spare time I had was at the weekend.

Personally I'd never do it again - dream job or not, because I understand how the commute can weigh you down even if you love the job.

I hope it all works out for you.

PaddlingLikeADuck · 03/04/2022 08:32

I used to have a job where I would leave the house at 7am and not get back until 8.30pm and it was exhausting.

I did it three times a week and that was frequent enough. My commute wasn’t even that bad, so the thought of being out the house that long and 4 hours of it was just getting to work and back sounds awful.

If I did two long days in a row I was then absolutely wiped out for a good few days and was having frequent headaches etc because I just wasn’t getting any down time.

There is just no way I could do it 5 days a week.

When I had my first child and returned to work I managed to keep up with that shift pattern for about a year but then I just couldn’t manage it anymore, I was just too tired to enjoy my time with my son and on the days I worked I wouldn’t even see him and I found that really hard.

After that year of trying to prove I could manage it, I had to drop my hours so even though I was still out the house for those long hours it was only two days a week which gave me my equal life/work balance back.

I understand that it’s your dream job but you need to seriously consider whether you can maintain that commute and time away from home, day after day, week after week, month after month etc. Don’t underestimate how draining it will be.

You don’t specifically mention you have children but there’s an implication you may, so I would seriously consider how much time you would be able to spend with them if you took on this new job.

LndnGrl · 03/04/2022 08:30

How likely is it to be out the house 6:30am-7pm Monday-Friday and still have an active life filled with more things than work

Very unlikely. I used to commute 2.5hrs each way, so 5hrs a day.

I used to knave the house at 5.30 to get the 5.50 train and get off in the evening at 7.20, all being well with no delays.

It was a nightmare. I was exhausted and had no life. By the time I went to the shop and sorted dinner, I then had a bath and went to bed.

Didn't do a lot on the weekends either.

lightnesspixie · 03/04/2022 08:29

Sorry I couldn't do that

over2021 · 03/04/2022 08:24

I have a commute by car of between an hour and an hour and a half (it's 47 minutes without traffic...!). For me it's worth it because the salary is very good. I work in London but live outside of London so don't have the humongous mortgage I'd have if I moved closer.

I work 5 days in the office so youngest DD is in breakfast and after school club which makes for a long day for her - 7.30am-5.30pm.

DH works more locally though so is home earlier for pickups/get dinner on etc. I couldn't do it without that support.