Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think in the UK, in 2022...

244 replies

justonanote · 03/04/2022 01:46

The lowest incomes should be able to -

Have food in at all times and be able to do a shop without fear they haven't got enough

Adequately heat their homes and have as much hot water as they need

Have a enough left over for a few little treats. An ice cream, a coffee out once a week, enough to enjoy a cheap trip out every now and then?

The lowest of incomes.

I despair, I honestly do.

OP posts:
Waxonwaxoff0 · 03/04/2022 13:08

[quote shabbalabba]@justonanote

The lowest incomes should be able to -

Have food in at all times and be able to do a shop without fear they haven't got enough -YES

Adequately heat their homes and have as much hot water as they need-YES

Have a enough left over for a few little treats. An ice cream, a coffee out once a week, enough to enjoy a cheap trip out every now and then?*- NOT NECESSARILY NO...
[/quote]
Yes they should. Everyone deserves more than just paying bills and existing.

rugbunch · 03/04/2022 13:07

@mudgetastic but there are more older people (population dynamics) & you are more likely to be a have if you're older.

liliainterfrutices · 03/04/2022 13:06

I think it’s utter bollocks that current Labour leaders would have done worse. On what evidence? I don’t think for a moment that they’d have funnelled £37 billion to their mates, pretending it was for PPE.

rugbunch · 03/04/2022 13:05

@MrsSkylerWhite which was my point. What your parents have & how much they can help you will determine your path in life & what education you can access for most. I think uni fees are quite prohibitive now.

HRTQueen · 03/04/2022 13:04

We do have a problem of low wages, people stuck on benefits (universal credit of world correctly helps but that is an if) and those who choose to stay on benefits let’s not pretend this is a few people it isn’t but why they do needs to be looked at

I agree Labour has lost its way the party for those they decide are worthy of championing that is no longer the ordinary working person

Clavinova · 03/04/2022 13:02

There is ‘a lot’ of very good social housing (Danes only)

Danes only? That's the complete opposite of Labour's 2019 manifesto which pledged to 'level-up' access to benefits and social housing for asylum seekers and migrants.

Florenz · 03/04/2022 13:00

I think the onus needs to be on people that are working rather than people that are on benefits. As long as Labour can be branded as the party for people on benefits, a lot of working people will find it difficult to vote for them. The party was founded to represent workers, I don't know at what point it got away from that.

woodhill · 03/04/2022 12:59

[quote Clavinova]The Danes believe in society- that’s the big difference

So they do - September 2021;

Some migrants in Denmark will now be required to work 37 hours a week in order to receive welfare benefits.

It will be a requirement for those who have been on benefits for three to four years, and who have not reached a certain level of proficiency in Danish.

Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen said the rules were directly aimed at women from "non-Western backgrounds" living on benefits.

Denmark has repeatedly tightened its immigration policies in recent years.

It now has some of the toughest rules in Europe, and has set a target of zero asylum applications.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-58484953[/quote]
Sounds sensible tbh

roarfeckingroarr · 03/04/2022 12:57

Well yeah, that would be great. Can the lowest paid in other countries do that? Probably not. The answer is not becoming some sort of communist hell hole.

shabbalabba · 03/04/2022 12:55

@justonanote

The lowest incomes should be able to -

Have food in at all times and be able to do a shop without fear they haven't got enough -YES

Adequately heat their homes and have as much hot water as they need-YES

Have a enough left over for a few little treats. An ice cream, a coffee out once a week, enough to enjoy a cheap trip out every now and then?*- NOT NECESSARILY NO...

MrsSkylerWhite · 03/04/2022 12:52

rugbunch

“But social mobility has gone backwards, so why are you assuming it's the same now? “

Oh I don’t disagree with you. I do believe though that it’s no tougher for young, working class families now than it was in the 1960s/70s, in terms of educational opportunities.

Very different story in terms of housing, obviously, which of course impacts every other aspect of life.

vixeyann · 03/04/2022 12:52

I don't have faith in any of the current political parties to deal with the issues, we are just on the same carousel year after year and will be until we have political leaders who have worked hard for a living, our sleaze free and accountable and aren't propped up by rich spouses or wealthy family and actually give two shits about the common man/woman.

balalake · 03/04/2022 12:51

Express your opinion via the ballot box next month if you have elections in your area.

mudgetastic · 03/04/2022 12:50

It's not right / accurate to say that it's older people who would resent paying taxes to enable a fairer society ( it's another example of people falling into the divided society trap whereby false wars are created to obsfucate the real problems )

It's across the board - broadly the haves vs the have nots with a good dollop of "self made man/ I look after myself and my family " attitudes coupled with a crap voting system so that the country is ruled by a party only around 1/3 actually voted for , and with boundary changes it will take even smaller minorities to keep the tories in power

gogohm · 03/04/2022 12:49

Of course we agree but what is adequate? I have my heating on 2 hours per day, I feel that is adequate (newish house) I have plenty of healthy scratch cook food but no treats, not good for us, haven't bought coffee or ice cream in many weeks, have coffee at home (lidl French roast and cafetière). It's about priorities.

I would say I think people should be able ti buy healthy food to cook at home but treats like takeaways or coffees are not essential. Trips out don't have to cost anything but nobody should be worrying about the cost of heating their home to 18 degrees morning and night or the cost of cooking their food crucially (healthy food often takes more cooking).

I would like to see vouchers for gas/electric/heating oil for all households on benefits or incomes up to circa £30k through the winter months each year but means test the old peoples ones (my parents do not need the help!)

Iwonder08 · 03/04/2022 12:48

A lot of people vote tory because the alternative seems even worse. It is bad now, but current Labour leaders would have done even worse. There are many issues that need addressing, not a lot of them down to any government. The general sense of entertainment is causing a lot of troubles. Why encourage kids to work harder in school if parents truly believe there is no need. That is one of the reasons why second generation immigrants often do well here. Different work ethics they teach they kids..
People also often forget that if you just blindly raise the taxes both rich individuals and big companies will move elsewhere

Waxonwaxoff0 · 03/04/2022 12:48

[quote bigyellowTpot]@MoonminMummy9 I don't read the daily fail. if you read my post properly it clearly says I know many of these families personally that are on benefits or low incomes and can afford all these things quite easily. I live in a so called deprived area but I have honestly never witnessed any deprevation. The majority of families also seem to own atleast 2 cars which are definitely not old bangers.[/quote]
I don't believe posts like these. No one can afford 2 cars and designer clothes on an income of just benefits. Either you're lying to get people frothing, or they're lying to you about their incomes.

Clavinova · 03/04/2022 12:48

The Danes believe in society- that’s the big difference

So they do - September 2021;

Some migrants in Denmark will now be required to work 37 hours a week in order to receive welfare benefits.

It will be a requirement for those who have been on benefits for three to four years, and who have not reached a certain level of proficiency in Danish.

Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen said the rules were directly aimed at women from "non-Western backgrounds" living on benefits.

Denmark has repeatedly tightened its immigration policies in recent years.

It now has some of the toughest rules in Europe, and has set a target of zero asylum applications.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-58484953

rugbunch · 03/04/2022 12:47

@Spikeyball absolutely

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 03/04/2022 12:47

Spending £10 a month on Netflix is cheaper than a television licence. If you're watching on a device and don't have a television at all then that's an economy.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 03/04/2022 12:46

Your husband is a perfect example of a) why we're in the situation we are and b) why it will never change. Far, far too many people vote Tory because they either mistakenly believe they might one day be rich enough to benefit from tory leadership, are terrified people who "doesn't deserve it" might get help they didn't get (or just help in general), or think that creating a more equal society will somehow negatively effect them.

Oh and then of course you've now got the "I won't vote for Labour because the don't know what a women is but will vote for a party that have spent the last decade eroding women's rights and increasing inequality that disproportionately effects women" lot too. Which would be hilarious if we didn't have to live with the consequences.

rugbunch · 03/04/2022 12:46

@MrsSkylerWhite I assumed you were the same poster who had replied to me. I don't pay for the filtered thing.

If that was possible in Britain in the 1960s and 70s, it is certainly possible now.

But social mobility has gone backwards, so why are you assuming it's the same now?

I think differently because I'm a millennial. I had aspirations (as did my parents) & worked hard. However the reason I have the life I have now is because I could live at home to save a deposit & buy. In fact if I had stayed in my holiday job & not bothered with uni I would be wealthier by buying earlier.
I was lucky to go to good schools as a dc. My dc go to excellent schools too, the difference is the catchment is approx 300 metres & a house costs about 1.1m plus so not so easy to access those good schools now.

Spikeyball · 03/04/2022 12:45

Regardless of education changing lives for the better, people will always be needed to do the jobs that are currently poorly paid - eg caring ( poorly paid despite being a demanding and skilled role). Those people deserve to be paid a decent wage for those roles.

HRTQueen · 03/04/2022 12:44

It’s not a small thing that’s the issue

It was for a long time considered an argument on social media not really to be concerned about

But it is concerning changes are being made that we would have laughed at 10 years ago some are not foe the better for females women or girls

Labour are tying themselves in knots not to be offensive to a small minority of people but forgetting that many of they voters are now waking up to this and are not comfortable with women being erased or definitions being changed

stickygotstuck · 03/04/2022 12:43

@Neverendingdust

I tend to agree and think that in 2022 Great Britain, glorious exceptional world super power, a G7 chief willy swinger (ahem) which has long standing regal, noble ambitions of stupendous magnitude upon the elite global stage on which it proclaims civility, power, togetherness and progress would be able to guarantee its population food, warmth and a sense of belonging.

Yet scratch beneath the gilded surface and it quickly becomes apparent that this is absolutely not the case.

Instead we’re a small naf island with lofty ambitions and an ego not too dissimilar to those of a Coke’d up 5’1” Moncler wearing body builder squaring up to the 6’4” bouncer on a Wednesday afternoon outside a Wetherspoons.

Pathetic doesn’t even come close.

Excellent post.