Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think in the UK, in 2022...

244 replies

justonanote · 03/04/2022 01:46

The lowest incomes should be able to -

Have food in at all times and be able to do a shop without fear they haven't got enough

Adequately heat their homes and have as much hot water as they need

Have a enough left over for a few little treats. An ice cream, a coffee out once a week, enough to enjoy a cheap trip out every now and then?

The lowest of incomes.

I despair, I honestly do.

OP posts:
TimBoothseyes · 03/04/2022 14:04

[quote shabbalabba]@justonanote

The lowest incomes should be able to -

Have food in at all times and be able to do a shop without fear they haven't got enough -YES

Adequately heat their homes and have as much hot water as they need-YES

Have a enough left over for a few little treats. An ice cream, a coffee out once a week, enough to enjoy a cheap trip out every now and then?*- NOT NECESSARILY NO...
[/quote]
What do you mean by "NOT NECESSARILY NO"? It's either yes or no surely.

Leol · 03/04/2022 14:01

Voting Labour just puts more money in the hands of the state and that doesn’t seem like a good thing.

RobotValkyrie · 03/04/2022 14:00

Plus no one should be getting more in benefits than someone working full time on a low wage. That’s not fair, all wrong

Really? Have you really thought this through?

Some benefits are paid to disabled people, so that they can manage their disability. It can covers lots of needs, and lots of ways to meet these needs (special equipment, paid helper, etc.). These are needs able people don't have. But disabled people also need to meet all their other "normal" needs, like eating, housing, etc.
So it's only fair they should get (if they can't work) the equivalent of a small wage for their "normal", basic needs, and some money on top to manage their disability.

As it stands, as far as I understand, things are capped, and that is certainly not fair.

ToiletPoster · 03/04/2022 13:44

The majority of people claiming benefits are in work. I work Full Time and take home around 1300, but bills are just over 1150. I'm topped up by universal credit. I have a post graduate and work in HE...I can't believe I work FT, endure a lot of stress and shoulder heavy expectations...to exist and require top up.

The thing is, these issues are directly linked. If the government didn't top up wages, people would not work for companies that didn't either pay more or allow enough free time for additional income.
Those companies would be forced to pay workers more (which means hiring fewer people) or make their processes more efficient to keep labour costs down.
All of these things are trade-offs. You can have a situation with lower unemployment but lower wages or higher unemployment and higher wages but one will generally impact the other.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 03/04/2022 13:43

@mudgetastic

Rents increased because the housing market was privatised and wealth protection is the priority of the uK political classes , not a result of immigration

Countries with higher immigration have lower rents

Which countries with immigration have lower rents?

Perhaps countries with low population densities, but we are not.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 03/04/2022 13:42

@mudgetastic

Rents increased because the housing market was privatised and wealth protection is the priority of the uK political classes , not a result of immigration

Countries with higher immigration have lower rents

Of course, the 6 million EU immigrants had no effect at all!!!!
mudgetastic · 03/04/2022 13:40

Rents increased because the housing market was privatised and wealth protection is the priority of the uK political classes , not a result of immigration

Countries with higher immigration have lower rents

Goodbyetowinter · 03/04/2022 13:39

Try being a pensioner. If DH dies before me, I wouldn't be able to pay the next month's bills. I couldn't pay heating bills, buy food etc. we rely on our state pensions and his attendance allowance. He is in total denial that I wouldn't even be able to pay for a funeral.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 03/04/2022 13:35

@OnTheGoAlways

The majority of people claiming benefits are in work. I work Full Time and take home around 1300, but bills are just over 1150. I'm topped up by universal credit. I have a post graduate and work in HE...I can't believe I work FT, endure a lot of stress and shoulder heavy expectations...to exist and require top up.

I also don't understand why Father's are able to cheat, leave and pay next to nothing for their children.

Yes, one of the major reasons your bills are so high is because of rent and mortgage costs caused by the unlimited immigration of 6 million people from the EU who have all had to live somewhere and have caused rents and house prices to increase.
OnTheGoAlways · 03/04/2022 13:33

The majority of people claiming benefits are in work. I work Full Time and take home around 1300, but bills are just over 1150. I'm topped up by universal credit. I have a post graduate and work in HE...I can't believe I work FT, endure a lot of stress and shoulder heavy expectations...to exist and require top up.

I also don't understand why Father's are able to cheat, leave and pay next to nothing for their children.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 03/04/2022 13:28

@Thebestwaytoscareatory

Your husband is a perfect example of a) why we're in the situation we are and b) why it will never change. Far, far too many people vote Tory because they either mistakenly believe they might one day be rich enough to benefit from tory leadership, are terrified people who "doesn't deserve it" might get help they didn't get (or just help in general), or think that creating a more equal society will somehow negatively effect them.

Oh and then of course you've now got the "I won't vote for Labour because the don't know what a women is but will vote for a party that have spent the last decade eroding women's rights and increasing inequality that disproportionately effects women" lot too. Which would be hilarious if we didn't have to live with the consequences.

Yes, people vote Tory because they are terrified of Labour after seeing how Gordon Brown tried to make all working people dependent on benefits.

Employers should not be able to pay their employees a low wage knowing that it will be topped up by benefits.

Unfortunately, after 13 years of Labour, it is going to be difficult to reverse this.

Brexit has helped increase wages, but it will take a long time.

Spikeyball · 03/04/2022 13:20

"Anyone who works full time should be able to afford some luxuries. People who do not work or who only work p/t should not expect this."

Some people will never be able to work. Could have been you, could be you in the future, could be your child.

Flatbrokefornow · 03/04/2022 13:18

I completely agree. But costs vary. Heating costs are vastly different in different houses, ‘a shop’ looks hugely different for every family. So it’s hard to set a bar of what cash people should need. Whatever you see it at, people will abuse it by whacking the heating up and wearing t shirts, and people will freeze in 78 layers and say it’s too much and everyone should be happy freezing in 78 layers. (Or even worse, be nice and comfy now, but say it’s unreasonable to fund others to be comfy because they used to freeze in 78 layers when they were kids and it never did them any harm).

Which is not to say low incomes are adequate now. They are not, and the current Tory government has blood on its hands. It’s hard to get it right, which should not excuse the bastards from trying.

Lovemyheathershimmer · 03/04/2022 13:17

I’m not benefit bashing, I’m only on the min wage myself, my partner earns just above the benefit threshold. So we only get child benefit. We struggle every month

liliainterfrutices · 03/04/2022 13:17

I do wish that the UK got as exercised about taxing big businesses and the super wealthy properly as it does about those on benefits.

Florenz · 03/04/2022 13:16

Anyone who works full time should be able to afford some luxuries. People who do not work or who only work p/t should not expect this.

Lovemyheathershimmer · 03/04/2022 13:15

People should get help when needed, eg disabled and the vulnerable in society. But folk that use the welfare system as a lifestyle choice is wrong. Having more kids when they can’t afford it, knowing they will get money from the system. If you can work, you should be made to work. Employers should be paying decent wages, not relying on the government to top up wages. Plus no one should be getting more in benefits than someone working full time on a low wage. That’s not fair, all wrong

bigyellowTpot · 03/04/2022 13:14

@Waxonwaxoff0 No not at all this is honestly true as I often wonder myself how they afford it. I do know quite a few of the families are claiming to be single parents but actually have their partners living with them, nobody checks up so they get away with it for years. Also maybe some are using credit cards. When you live in these so called deprived areas you do see how well off people actually are. I actually think the people who are the worst off In society are single people with no children who are working in minimum wage or low paid jobs as they get very little help and support. Many cannot afford to live alone so have to stay living at home or house/flat share as could not manage the bills alone.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 03/04/2022 13:13

@gogohm

Of course we agree but what is adequate? I have my heating on 2 hours per day, I feel that is adequate (newish house) I have plenty of healthy scratch cook food but no treats, not good for us, haven't bought coffee or ice cream in many weeks, have coffee at home (lidl French roast and cafetière). It's about priorities.

I would say I think people should be able ti buy healthy food to cook at home but treats like takeaways or coffees are not essential. Trips out don't have to cost anything but nobody should be worrying about the cost of heating their home to 18 degrees morning and night or the cost of cooking their food crucially (healthy food often takes more cooking).

I would like to see vouchers for gas/electric/heating oil for all households on benefits or incomes up to circa £30k through the winter months each year but means test the old peoples ones (my parents do not need the help!)

But what kind of a life is that? Someone has to do the lowest paid in society. Why should they just exist and not live?
EveningOverRooftops · 03/04/2022 13:12

@the80sweregreat

You need tech these days to do anything , it is an essential ( just my opinion , but it's how we have been programmed and made to accept that everything is about having it because we can't line without it ) if your job hunting you need tech. No way around it. Netflix is cheaper a month than going to the pictures for one night out. I think some people would only be happy if everyone went back to living in caves. Even my parents had the odd take away fish and chips now and again and we were really poor , everyone needs a lift or a treat sometimes.
Indeed.

You need a smartphone or computer of some sort and an internet connection to access benefits even the jobseekers element of UC. If the govt require the internet to access its services then it’s an essential Item in my eyes.

Agree. A Netflix subscription is £7 a month. That’s access to not only Netflix own productions but a rotation of films and Tv shows you can struggle to find on terrestrial TV and pay to watch that too.

There’s online learning platforms too that are free. Openlearn has free course, futurelearn, even learning skills via a YouTube video. There’s many more than just these and I know a lot of people who have used them between jobs to keep busy. Myself included.

It’s a great leveller, the internet and internet access in the same way the BBC originally was with its documentaries, schools and education programmes, GCSE bite size etc and libraries still are. They provide free educational and entertainment resources.

We need to treat it as such.

But I’m a great believer that every human needs some ‘fun’ or ‘play’ alongside their work and adulting.

mudgetastic · 03/04/2022 13:11

There is more variability in wealth within any specific generation than there is between the generations

We will not defeat the current ideology if we don't come together - so don't alienate older people by stereotyping as you need them in our side as much as younger people

OfstedOffred · 03/04/2022 13:11

People who think we aren't a rich country have no fucking idea.

We have huge wealth disparity which is totally unacceptable.

But even our very poorest are not poorer than the poorest in countries like much of sub saharan Africa, Asia.

We have far more generous benefits available than in many countries.

chisanunian · 03/04/2022 13:11

@rolypolydoly

Shouldn't apply only to the UK
I agree, but you have to start somewhere and this thread is about poverty in the UK specifically.
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 03/04/2022 13:09

Well yeah, that would be great. Can the lowest paid in other countries do that? Probably not. The answer is not becoming some sort of communist hell hole.

Ah yes the good old communism trope. This is something I've noticed the right doing more and more recently, spouting off about communism when people are talking about socialism. I can only assume it's because they either don't know the difference or are deliberately trying to spread misinformation about it because they know they have no sound against it.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 03/04/2022 13:09

@Florenz

I think the onus needs to be on people that are working rather than people that are on benefits. As long as Labour can be branded as the party for people on benefits, a lot of working people will find it difficult to vote for them. The party was founded to represent workers, I don't know at what point it got away from that.
A lot of workers are on benefits too. It's not either/or.
Swipe left for the next trending thread