Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we taking bets yet on when mass civil unrest will begin re. Cost of living?

409 replies

UsernameInTheTown · 02/04/2022 18:34

Having frozen my backside off these past two days as I'm terrified to have the heating on longer than an hour a day, I'm thinking that this will be utterly intolerable come next Winter. Will there be mass civil unrest and the guillotine rolled out while the affluent are targeted by the desperate and those with nothing left to loose?

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 03/04/2022 07:51

The Tories haven't kept the triple lock for pensioners.

Usou · 03/04/2022 07:44

I think the current situation has been coming for years - it's taken covid and a war to make it finally happen. There are basically too many people using too much energy, so the price goes up affecting everything.

The human race will have to adapt, and the good news is that the energy industry is now far more attractive to new entrants such as renewables and nuclear, more of which will appear in the coming years. It will hurt in the short-term though. I would also expect more localisation as it just won't be worth shipping stuff on oil powered ships from the other side of the world - again not a bad thing.

I expect farming will need to revert to lower-input, higher-labour models with less dependence on oil and chemicals. We have the capacity to do this, and indeed used to do this, but the modern industry is predicated on high inputs, so adaption will be painful.

Riot wise, the excessive profiteering of utility companies needs to be punished, and some re-nationalisation is worth considering. Not sure which of our current parties have the bottle for that.

This is the word of the Lord..

rugbunch · 03/04/2022 07:38

A lot of people have done very well with house prices rises & BTLs &/or inheritance. They won't want things to change. I can't see how things will change because even building wealth is much harder these days so the gap will just widen.

RoseyLentil · 03/04/2022 07:38

@PearlclutchersInc

And what exactly will rioting achieve. It's not achieved anything in the past.

Not least because the current government couldnt care less.

Poll Tax Riots put a stop to the Poll Tax. I was in my early 20s at the time. The riots and mass demonstrations against the Poll Tax were effective but the Tories won the next election with Major because such a large proportion of the population couldn't vote as they were effectively disenfranchised by the Poll Tax. However, the next time around they lost as people had got themselves registered to vote again. The Poll Tax bill for my BF and I living in our 1 bed flat in Stokes Croft in Bristol was just over £2,000 per year. Our household income, both working, was just over £14,000. By parents, who lived in a 4 bed 2 bath detached house with an acre and a half of garden in the Cheshire countryside paid just under £1,000. My dad's income would have ben about £60,000. This is why I hate the Tories and will never ever vote for them.
clarazabel · 03/04/2022 07:37

I was at the poll tax riots. I was in my 20s, not juggling 3 kids, struggling to pay for food and could afford the bus fare to London. Those of us who need to protest don't always have the privilege of being able to.

ivykaty44 · 03/04/2022 07:27

You can’t really compare 1997 to now as we hadn’t just had a global pandemic and before that a recession and forced austerity measures, and Tony Blair led us into wars which depleted our monetary reserves, so he was hardly a great example.

It’s was all down to the fact Murdoch wanted Blair in power, and he gets what he wants

ivykaty44 · 03/04/2022 07:24

@Watermelon44 Reader the post above yours

Suzi888 · 03/04/2022 07:19

@Fedupbuyer

I think crime will go through the roof I know that much!
^ I think this too. What people don’t have they’ll steal.
lightisnotwhite · 03/04/2022 07:18

@XDownwiththissortofthingX

It’s going to get a lot worse and the overall standard of living for a huge chunk of the working class is going to fall through the floor, the question is > how long will it be before something gives?

What's also pretty frightening is what you end up with when the public eventually decides enough is enough.

30 years of industrial decline and abuse of the working classes gave us Thatcher (spit). Thatcherism and runaway free-market capitalism has given us a debt crisis coupled with a cost of living crisis.

I think we are going to see the ultimate end-goal of Brexit arrive much more quickly than anticipated, i.e. the 'race to the bottom' with working class Brits reduced to wage-slaves, tolerating appalling conditions in order to be able to eat, and the unemployed used as physical labour in return for inadequate welfare payments. Anyone who thinks that isn't what was driving Brexit hasn't been paying attention.

You can’t have high living standards though without some borrowing. Whether that’s individuals or governments. In the same way people need mortgages to buy a house governments need to pay for very expensive infrastructure.

The problem is the massive divide between rich and poor thats getting worse. Full time workers at the bottom need tax credits to make their wage liveable. We’re back to Victorian times with the workers in slums watching every penny and the people in the big houses having lovely lives and thinking being charitable will solve the problem.

And it’s no good blaming the Conservatives if no other party isn’t inspiring enough. Or people feel they can’t trust a party that can’t use science to define a woman.

notwhatineednow · 03/04/2022 07:18

@prettyLittlefool

People don't riot over £700 quid a year extra. Get real. It's not that bad.
You haven't got a fucking clue, have you.
Krabapple · 03/04/2022 07:15

I don’t think there’s will be. People voted for this and will continue to do so. The gap between the elite in society just seems to be widening and people keep voting for Boris and his buffoons. I honestly despair!

UsernameInTheTown · 03/04/2022 07:08

@Cyw2018 I didn't know that re. Protesting effecting certain jobs/DBS checks.

The next elections being 2 years away make the voting thing (if there were a party to vote for!) unviable. The effects will have already well and truly have been felt by then.

OP posts:
the80sweregreat · 03/04/2022 06:55

@Libertaire

This is Britain. We don’t do ‘mass civil unrest’. We leave that sort of thing to the French, who are actually prepared to stand up to their rulers, rather than just complaining about them. We just moan about how badly the country is run, then go out and re-elect the Tories.
Best post ever ! And true
Watermelon44 · 03/04/2022 06:45

@notwhatineednow

With respect you haven’t answered what labour would do to change things today if they were put in power, which would make a significant difference to the average person.

And based on the state of the economy, where they would get the funds to pay for it?

It’s easy to promise people more money and a better quality of life and to blame the government when you are the opposition but another thing to actually change things in reality. I just can’t take labour seriously, as they make out that they will stop poverty for example and other outrageous promises which would be great in reality, but don’t back that up with practical ways of funding it. The windfall tax would be a drop in the ocean for example and not a good idea in the long term if we want those companies to invest in renewables.

I feel that all parties should not be able to make promises and policies that they cannot keep and should be legally bound to stick to their manifesto. That may make them more realistic, not pie in the sky. That would enable the electorate to make a more informed choice without being hoodwinked with false promises. Then I would have more respect and interest in politics.

You can’t really compare 1997 to now as we hadn’t just had a global pandemic and before that a recession and forced austerity measures, and Tony Blair led us into wars which depleted our monetary reserves, so he was hardly a great example.

You must live in cloud cuckoo land if you think labour would be any different to the tories without bankrupting us in the process or opening the doors for cheap labour from the rest of the world which is very much a short term solution.

It needs long term planning which neither party is capable of or interested in it seems......

empireemmy · 03/04/2022 06:43

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the request of the poster.

sst1234 · 03/04/2022 05:01

Well there was so much public support for lockdowns, wasn’t there? Looks like Covid will kill fewer people that that the inflationary pressures brought about by the crazy restrictions.

1forAll74 · 03/04/2022 04:35

There is no point in rioting. When masses of people go out on the streets to demonstrate about all the issues, you will always get certain types of angry people, who will really Riot in the true sense of the word, and who set fire to cars, smash windows in shops, set fire to things all over the place, fight with the police, and chain themselves to things.. and superglue themselves to NO.10 Downing Street.

Adarajames · 03/04/2022 02:51

@Livelovebehappy you are, to put it politely, delusional!

There is NO safety net any more, you can owe the DWP money before you’ve even received a penny due to punitive sanctions, and it’s perfectly acceptable in this torie ‘only the rich matter’ world for people to starve / freeze to death. And it already is happening, and the government don’t give a damn, they just make matter worse! Angry

Nat6999 · 03/04/2022 02:39

We need some civil disobedience, walk outs, strikes, riots won't work. Rolling mass walkouts of essential services, public transport, civil service, bring the country to a standstill, it is the only way, unions need to find their balls & call members out. It needs to be coordinated to have the biggest impact.

TooBigForMyBoots · 03/04/2022 02:36

When people don't have bread, circuses Netflix and internet won't be enough.

reesewithoutaspoon · 03/04/2022 02:27

We are stuck with the Tories for the foreseeable future. People have short memories.
The tories will cut tax in the General election year and throw in a few monetary sweeteners and they will get re-elected.
The right-wing papers will make Labour seem even more unelectable through smear campaigns. TBH though Labour doesn't need much help in that which is frustrating as hell
Labour can't win votes in Scotland, without those votes it's difficult to get enough seats because the south bar London usually votes Tory, Wales is watered down by Plaid Cymru and unless Labour can swing a load of Tory seats in the south then I doubt it will happen.
Until their core voters start to suffer then they will still vote for a donkey wearing a blue rosette.
The tories know this, it's why they never target pensioners. They kept the triple lock and the national insurance hike won't affect their pensions.

Hawkins001 · 03/04/2022 02:06

@Nancydrawn

Intriguing points to consider, much appreciated

Nancydrawn · 03/04/2022 02:03

[quote Hawkins001]@Nancydrawn

These days, those events are history, especially with the internet and tv to keep the population distracted etc, you may get some groups, but could a whole or almost whole country wide protest be ever achieved ?[/quote]
I think that's a fair point. I would also note that most of those riots and rebellions I listed were counter-productive, insofar as they tended to alienate the middle, who then aligned with the authorities in a reaction against violence. There are relatively few long-lived rebellions in history, and even fewer that truly subverted the social order; when they succeed, it's often because they align with the interests of some section of those in authority, who encourage them.

That doesn't mean they're pointless, or that no rebellions ever work. Interestingly, those that enforce social norms tend to work better than those that subvert them. And those that can capture the support of the middle, often in peaceful terms, tend to do best.

I was just reacting to the idea that "In all of history the British have never opted for mass civil unrest."

(In terms of the idea of mass, I'll say that even things we tend to think about as "mass" unrest are usually a voluble minority, or a majority in a limited area.)

(My father is very fond of history and I had to listen to his discussions on this quite a bit when I was young.)

Smokeahontas · 03/04/2022 01:47

I can guarantee that half the people on this thread advocating riots and / or civil disobedience won’t be anywhere remotely near it if it does happen. The closest they’ll get is voting YANBU in an ‘AIBU to support the riots?’ thread.

ilovesooty · 03/04/2022 01:37

[quote Narwhalelife]@newyearnewwname2022 same!! And the price of bread thing goes wayyyyy back!

I dunno though, the tories seem to be making themselves unpopular on purpose (surely) and people are getting desperate. In my job I have a lot of conversations with jo public and the tides are turning even for people that defended the tories before[/quote]
I remember Edward Heath campaigning in 1970 by telling the people that if they voted Labour they would see the 3 shilling loaf.

Swipe left for the next trending thread