Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so sad neighbours cut down a Pear Tree

187 replies

danny735 · 02/04/2022 13:33

Just that really.

There was a beautiful pear tree right on the border of our garden. I returned from a trip and the neighbours had chopped it down.

It was on neighbours side of the fence but half of the foliage was in our garden. I love nature and adore tree silhouette.

We've only lived in this house for 2 years and the pears were blooming when we moved in. There are usually beautiful blossoms in spring time. I'm so devastated that it's gone - I can't work out if I'm being silly I not 🥺

OP posts:
Dillydollydingdong · 02/04/2022 16:29

Plant one in your garden. I planted a Comice pear tree in mine about 3 years ago and we had about a hundred fat, fragrant pears off it last year.

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 02/04/2022 16:24

@rwalker

We have a pear tree at the bottom of our garden . Pears always rock hard and inedible . Pain in the arse to prune all the windfalls that no one want rot on floor and kills grass .Puts a lot of shade and grass all mossy and nothing grows .

They could be in the same position

I think your pears may be Conference Pears,. They start off like cobble stones but if you pick them and put them in a bowl for a week or so you'll find that they become soft and juicy. 🍐
heldinadream · 02/04/2022 16:22

Have you got a photo that includes it OP? Being able to still 'see' it might be a comfort. (I'd like to see it if you can find a pic - I love trees.) Smile (I know you might not want to post it if it's too outing.)

FlyingPandas · 02/04/2022 16:21

I'm another one who has had to have trees felled for safety reasons. We had the most beautiful silver birch tree, from the main road it was stunning, you'd never have thought it might have been diseased But when an arborculturalist examined it he condemned it immediately as over 2/3 of the trunk was rotten at the base. We had it taken down shortly afterwards. It was far too dangerous to leave it.

We also have fruit trees (apple and pear) which are lovely and produce delicious edible fruit BUT I also spend hours and hours in autumn sweeping up dead leaves and manky half rotten fruit that the birds have pecked to death. They are a lot of work. I can see why people don't want them.

At the end of the day, as sad as it is (a) there could be a safety reason why the tree had to go and/or (b) if there is no TPO on the tree there is no reason why they shouldn't take it down.

But I can understand why you feel sad. There is something about a beautiful tree that is good for the soul.

Kanaloa · 02/04/2022 16:17

@balalake

I think you should ask them why, and if it was not for reasons of disease express your view.
And do you do that often with other people’s property? Ask why they’ve had drive laid and express your view when told why? Ask why they have a paved garden and if you don’t like the reasons denounce them as idiots?

Just makes you look stupid and a bit weird. It’s their garden, they’re entitled to do whatever they want in it regardless of whether or not it spoils the neighbours’ enjoyment of looking at someone else’s trees.

WomanStanleyWoman · 02/04/2022 16:15

@Lagarthatheviking

Have you spoken to the neighbours? It’s a bit suspicious that they did this while you were away, however it could have been diseased? I’ve come to realise that you can’t rely on others to give you what you want. Why don’t you just plant another pear tree on your side?
Why is this suspicious? It’s not like they waited until OP was away and cut down HER tree.
Kanaloa · 02/04/2022 16:13

@nightfairy

I despise people who cut down trees for no good reason.
Such an odd thing to despise people for. I despise people who are racist or sexist or bullies.

And also you have absolutely no clue what someone’s reasons are. It’s not op’s tree. She can feel sad about it but unless she was offering to share in all the care and cost of the tree and it’s possible issues it’s really none of her business and all she can do is plant a new one in her own space.

Easy to love a tree when you’re not the one collecting and disposing of the fruit, watching for pests, having it treated and pruned, watching out for root issues etc.

WomanStanleyWoman · 02/04/2022 16:12

@balalake

I think you should ask them why, and if it was not for reasons of disease express your view.
I’m sure it was a lovely tree, but go around demanding answers from the neighbours is a bit unhinged.
SockFluffInTheBath · 02/04/2022 15:53

When you have your own OP at least it’ll be under your control Smile

We took down a huge cherry tree a couple months ago (hi if any of you are my neighbour Grin ), we had a few reasons for doing it- safety being one- and have planted half a dozen shrubs, a maple and a rowan in the space it covered. The lawn was completely trashed all round it so we’ve gone for a deep border which be great in a couple of years and the birds are already busy in the new branches.

At the end of the day it’s our garden, and we’re not responsible for providing a view to the neighbours. If a plant is precious to you then get your own so it’s ‘safe’.

TheHoptimist · 02/04/2022 15:43

@HoveringDonkeyofKnock

That’s a disgrace and you’re not being silly. They’re philistines. You can’t easily replace mature trees like that. They take decades.

I know someone who chopped down a mature cherry blossom. Heartbreaking.

Cherry blossom has a limited life though and when they fall they cause a lot of damage
MrsClatterbuck · 02/04/2022 15:32

We had 2 Victoria plum trees. Lots of delicious plums in the Autumn but had to cut one down as it was diseasd.

etulosba · 02/04/2022 15:26

Disease was my first thought. We had to cut ours down after a heavy crop split it.

starfishmummy · 02/04/2022 15:26

Tbh, much as I like trees, I wish our neighbours would cut theirs down. They don't pick the pears- which is understandable as they are not nice at all, they become wasp infested, rotten and loads fall into our garden so we have to deal with the mess.

OfstedOffred · 02/04/2022 15:19

My neighbour was fuming when we felled the gorgeous cherry tree in our garden.

They couldn't see that it was diseased. The tree surgeon said we were risking our other trees leaving it there.

It's been 5 years and I'm still sad :(

RandomNumb3rs · 02/04/2022 15:04

I’m on the other side of the argument at the moment.

25 years ago I planted trees on a plot of land that we weren’t otherwise using.

Now I want to use the land for something else but neighbours are trying to have a preservative order put on the trees.

I planted them - I should bloody well be able to take them down.

lhjjhdjsdhkshdbc · 02/04/2022 14:59

I feel your pain. I live in a lovely rural area that has become popular with ex-London suburbanites. They move here because it is beautiful, and green, and promptly cut down every tree in their garden and tarmac or crazy path the entire frontage of their house, thus replicating the look of the place they have just left 'because it was too urban'. Seems like they like to look at other people's lovely gardens, but not the hassle of maintaining their own. Annoys me! The biggest irony is someone with a senior position in the RHS moved here, and did exactly the same! Removed every single tree. If that's the mentality of the people who are supposed to care.... Hmm

danny735 · 02/04/2022 14:55

@JodieFoster1

We planted a half dozen pear trees ten years ago, they grow fast and produce a lot of fruit pretty quickly. Ours were dwarf specimens but some are 8 ft tall now (we are a bit neglectful and don’t prune them etc). They don’t need decades to look good. They’ve done much much better than our apple trees planted at the same time. Plant your own. Smile
Thanks for the info. I'll definitely plant one - so glad to hear they grow quite quickly!
OP posts:
comealongponds · 02/04/2022 14:53

You don’t know that there wasn’t a good reason (disease, damaging foundations or drains etc)

If you want a pear tree, you’re free to plant one in your own garden.

CanIbeRio · 02/04/2022 14:40

Not silly at all. Trees are beautiful and it's such a shame when a mature tree is felled ...they are so majestic....it almost feels like murder!!
My mum's house backs onto a pretty major road in our city. Ever since she moved in 50 odd years ago there's been an ornamental cherry in the grass verge directly outside her back gate. Over the years it had started to lean and its branches partially brushed her top fence. This blocked the presence of this busy road out nicely....she swears also fumes and noise. Sadly it blew down in the storms last month and it is no more Sad. She's so upset.. no pretty tree to look at any more....all she can see now are the pedestrian lights which the tree hid beautifully. It's so sad....it was like an old friend to her Sad

Sceptre86 · 02/04/2022 14:39

You should move next to my parents they have a pear tree and a plum tree with no plans to ever cut them down.

Plant some trees in your own garden. I'd ask why they cut them down.

godmum56 · 02/04/2022 14:38

I am a tree owner and surrounded by tree owners. Its usually sad when a tree gets removed but if you don't own the tree then yabu a bit. Fruit trees are difficult. I had a victoria plum and the wasp problem was horrific. At the time all the trees in my garden (8) had preservation orders on so I got a man from the council out to advise. He immediately agreed that the plum should be removed for safety, but also said that a massive mature oak that I wanted to have pruned had outgrown its spot and needed to be removed as the roots were putting my foundations at risk, and identified that the wild cherry was actually diseased and rotting from the inside and again was a danger. It must have looked like wholesale carnage but wasn't. Anyway my point is that that its up to the tree owner to manage the tree. If you want a pear tree then buy one and plant it.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 02/04/2022 14:38

We removed an apples tree from our garden (left the cherry blossom!) as we needed the space and the apples were inedible. I'd be a bit annoyed if a neighbour questioned us about it! But YANBU to be sad about it.

RosesAndHellebores · 02/04/2022 14:36

We have had an avenue of trained and fanned apple trees (4), pear and plums removed this year. They were planted in 1927 and were rotting away despite still producing quite a lot of fruit but which was not particularly disease resistant. The stakes and wires on which they were trained were also rotten and breaking.

We will be replacing with miniature varieties next year once the ground has recovered.

They may have had valid reasons to remove the tree and if it didn't have a tpo they can do as they wish. We had to have a rotten silver birch with tpo taken down and had too replace with an acer. The beautiful cedar on the other side of the garden had no tpo but had to go despite its beauty because the roots were causing havoc with the drive that had to be partially relaid.

jytdtysrht · 02/04/2022 14:31

If you want one, buy one. You can get them cheaply if young or you can buy something more mature from a nursery.

Nanny0gg · 02/04/2022 14:31

@HoveringDonkeyofKnock

That’s a disgrace and you’re not being silly. They’re philistines. You can’t easily replace mature trees like that. They take decades.

I know someone who chopped down a mature cherry blossom. Heartbreaking.

My neighbours at the back of me did that.

The only upside is that I no longer get pink pigeon poo on my washing!

Swipe left for the next trending thread