Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so sad neighbours cut down a Pear Tree

187 replies

danny735 · 02/04/2022 13:33

Just that really.

There was a beautiful pear tree right on the border of our garden. I returned from a trip and the neighbours had chopped it down.

It was on neighbours side of the fence but half of the foliage was in our garden. I love nature and adore tree silhouette.

We've only lived in this house for 2 years and the pears were blooming when we moved in. There are usually beautiful blossoms in spring time. I'm so devastated that it's gone - I can't work out if I'm being silly I not 🥺

OP posts:
ItIsntFair · 03/04/2022 08:52

Their tree, their choice!

Plant your own tree in your own garden if you miss it OP. Bit rich IMO, asking someone why they chopped a tree down in their own garden!!

I had an orchard in a previous house. When I downsized I planted two fruit trees that I am training on a wall, but, they get aphids every year, then there's the wasps. I often wish I hadn't planted them when I am dealing with the bugs and the wasps in the height of summer.

PersephonePomegranate · 03/04/2022 08:51

Trees in gardens, whilst looking lovely, can be a bloody nuisance and are not aways suitable for the space. They can wreak havoc with fences etc. and as they become more mature and their roots spread out.

I agree, it's sad, but there might be a good reason behind it.

thecatsthecats · 03/04/2022 08:45

I sympathise.

The landlord next door has ripped out the ten foot privet hedge on the far side boundary. So many birds nested there and I loved the scent of the blossom.

But more practically, another few houses down there's a busyish road and it was a great sound and view buffer. Now our house and garden feel a lot less private.

wh00pi · 03/04/2022 08:41

It’s insane. Honestly if you have this much time to worry about what other people are doing with their own garden you need to make yourself a bit busier.

So much cooler and busier than Op, you don't even have time to look out your front window in the morning, sounds fun

wh00pi · 03/04/2022 08:39

@SockFluffInTheBath

Good grief, some of the hyperbolic nonsense on this thread 🙄 did we know trees are good for wildlife, some of us want to concrete everything, nature needs a home… my garden is in many ways a wildlife haven but I had the brass neck to take down a massive cherry at the end of last year- so I suppose that renders it all null and void. Some of you really need to stop looking so hard at what other people do on their patch and green up your own.
Lol we're allowed to talk on a chat forum you know. If your garden is as nice as you say, why do you care what others think?
Bunnycat101 · 03/04/2022 08:17

“Lots of defensive and/or proud tree murderers here.”

I think this perfectly encapsulates a previous poster that referenced hyperbolic nonsense.

Kanaloa · 03/04/2022 03:57

I was referring to another poster, who suggests that op should go over to question the neighbours, and ‘give her views’ if their reasoning isn’t good enough.

So possibly it is you that needs to reread the thread. Goodness me.

milkyaqua · 03/04/2022 03:30

If you have this much time to angrily chastise a poster for making a observation, then you also have time to read the thread...

The OP is sad. Not once has she suggested she's about to storm over. She said she is sad. "Just that really."

Kanaloa · 03/04/2022 03:19

So who are the defensive ‘tree murderers?’

It’s just ridiculous to assume you can judge people as defensive because someone says op has no right to storm over and demand an explanation from the neighbours and give them her ‘views’ if the reason isn’t good enough.

It’s insane. Honestly if you have this much time to worry about what other people are doing with their own garden you need to make yourself a bit busier.

milkyaqua · 03/04/2022 03:06

I’ve never cut down a tree.

Then I wasn't talking about you.

Kanaloa · 03/04/2022 02:19

@milkyaqua

Lots of defensive and/or proud tree murderers here.
Confused

I’ve never cut down a tree. My neighbours can cut down trees that belong to them if they like.

If op is so so invested in nature and trees she can balance things by throwing all her time and energy into making her own garden a miniature national park. Then she’ll be able to enjoy trees even closer to the thing. And her neighbours will also benefit because they can do what they like with their own garden and enjoy the view of someone else’s tree without any of the maintenance efforts.

milkyaqua · 03/04/2022 00:45

Lots of defensive and/or proud tree murderers here.

godmum56 · 02/04/2022 23:01

@tearinghairout

I would be very sad too. People don't value trees enough. My neighbour has butchered a fabulous weeping willow because it dropped stuff on his car. He could've parked away from it but that would've meant walking another ten feet. Now it looks like a palm tree and it's lost that swishy sound. I don't think people realise how much wildlife need trees. The little bugs in the bark, for example, are at the bottom of the food chain and ultimately, everything depends on them. Also shelter for birds, etc. Scalping hedges doesn't help either - no berries, not enough thickness to shelter birds. It's so short-sighted.
"Fabulous weeping willows" are not trees for private gardens. Their roots grow massively fast towards water and if there is even the smallest leak, the roots will find a way in and grow like crazy...and "scalping" hedges actually thickens them.

www.ashridgetrees.co.uk/blog/why-willows-and-drains-do-not-mix

TheWildRumpyPumpus · 02/04/2022 22:53

Nothing riles up a MNer like a neighbour cutting down a tree.

God forbid they should actually have to plant one of their own!

SockFluffInTheBath · 02/04/2022 22:28

Good grief, some of the hyperbolic nonsense on this thread 🙄 did we know trees are good for wildlife, some of us want to concrete everything, nature needs a home… my garden is in many ways a wildlife haven but I had the brass neck to take down a massive cherry at the end of last year- so I suppose that renders it all null and void. Some of you really need to stop looking so hard at what other people do on their patch and green up your own.

Rosewaterblossom · 02/04/2022 21:42

Quote

Rosewaterblossom · 02/04/2022 21:41

The birds lived in it every spring and it was beautiful. They are very Hardy so not sure why you think they die? I will be planting one yes!

Questiontellme · 02/04/2022 21:31

Oh OP I get you one million percent, I'm too tired to write down all the sacrilegious behaviour which went on on our old street full of lovely mature and period houses in the past five years. Similar to what @CoastalWave was talking about but on an industrial scale!

Of course the neighbours can do what they want and of course it cpuld have been effecting things structuraly (and I say this knowing it is purely anecdotal but I've bought two houses now with lots of mature trees in the gardens and nothing has ever come up on the surveys so find it hard to believe they would know that now having lived in the house not just moved in) she can be sad if she wants and we should be planting more trees not cutting them down!!!

Pear blossom is so 😍 too.

wh00pi · 02/04/2022 21:17

@Lucy304

A few years ago my neighbours chopped down a beautiful magnolia tree that was in the middle of our shared front garden. I was so upset when I drove in and saw it gone that I nearly crashed the car into the house! When I saw them next, I politely asked why. Because they were going to tarmac their half of the garden. I said I felt sad to see it go, and she actually laughed at me.

A couple of months later, the same neighbour let slip that it was actually MY tree, planted by the previous owner of my house. It'd been there since I moved in, and was right on the boundary, so I was never sure. Once they chopped it, I assumed it was theirs after all, but apparently not. And they obviously knew this, but did it anyway.

I know this isn't the same, as it wasn't OP's tree. But I really do get how people can feel so strongly about them. Still makes me sad now, and we don't even live there anymore!

Oh wow, that's terrible. All they had to do was leave a little 40cm radius around the base!

I hate this new trend of paving over the first sign of nature; making lovely semis look like Lego blocks etc.

tearinghairout · 02/04/2022 21:13

I would be very sad too. People don't value trees enough. My neighbour has butchered a fabulous weeping willow because it dropped stuff on his car. He could've parked away from it but that would've meant walking another ten feet. Now it looks like a palm tree and it's lost that swishy sound. I don't think people realise how much wildlife need trees. The little bugs in the bark, for example, are at the bottom of the food chain and ultimately, everything depends on them. Also shelter for birds, etc. Scalping hedges doesn't help either - no berries, not enough thickness to shelter birds. It's so short-sighted.

Lucy304 · 02/04/2022 21:07

A few years ago my neighbours chopped down a beautiful magnolia tree that was in the middle of our shared front garden. I was so upset when I drove in and saw it gone that I nearly crashed the car into the house! When I saw them next, I politely asked why. Because they were going to tarmac their half of the garden. I said I felt sad to see it go, and she actually laughed at me.

A couple of months later, the same neighbour let slip that it was actually MY tree, planted by the previous owner of my house. It'd been there since I moved in, and was right on the boundary, so I was never sure. Once they chopped it, I assumed it was theirs after all, but apparently not. And they obviously knew this, but did it anyway.

I know this isn't the same, as it wasn't OP's tree. But I really do get how people can feel so strongly about them. Still makes me sad now, and we don't even live there anymore!

tigger1001 · 02/04/2022 21:02

@balalake

I think you should ask them why, and if it was not for reasons of disease express your view.
Really? You would ask why someone cut something down in their own garden and if the reason wasn't to your liking you would "express your view"??

Why on earth would you think a neighbour would want your views on their garden?

Sheilaroundthefountain · 02/04/2022 20:46

You’re not being silly. I’d be heartbroken. We have a few trees and bushes overhanding and I love them

FOJN · 02/04/2022 20:36

My neighbour has a beautiful magnolia which I adore. I’d be a bit sad if they got rid but it’s now massive and dominating so I wouldn’t wish them ill if they eventually have to reduce or remove it.

My neighbour has a beautiful magnolia too. I get more benefit than the neighbour because the side I see is south facing. It's gorgeous in flower and offers additional privacy in my garden but it's not my tree so I have not say (and don't think I deserve one) in what my neighbours do with it.

godmum56 · 02/04/2022 20:34

@modgepodge
"’m debating cutting down a big tree because of bird poo. I like the tree and the shade it provides. I don’t like that the whole patio has to be pressure washed at least weekly otherwise it’s covered in poo, or that I can’t sit on my patio without fear of being pooed on. If anyone knows how to deter pigeons from sitting in a tree which is the height of the house I’d love to hear them!!"

If its that close to your house think too about where the roots are and what damage they might be doing to your foundations. As I said upthread, I asked for permission to prune a protected oak because it was aphid dew I had a problem with. The patio and windows were black and sticky with it. Nice council man said it was way too near the house and suggested removal. My neghbour was allowed to have an oak removed because it had actually cracked and warped his garage floor, Fortunately it was covered under hs buldings insurance but what a nightmare getting it all fixed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread