Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so sad neighbours cut down a Pear Tree

187 replies

danny735 · 02/04/2022 13:33

Just that really.

There was a beautiful pear tree right on the border of our garden. I returned from a trip and the neighbours had chopped it down.

It was on neighbours side of the fence but half of the foliage was in our garden. I love nature and adore tree silhouette.

We've only lived in this house for 2 years and the pears were blooming when we moved in. There are usually beautiful blossoms in spring time. I'm so devastated that it's gone - I can't work out if I'm being silly I not 🥺

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 03/04/2022 18:28

@Dearmariacountmein

So much vitriol on this thread.

We’ll soon be chopping 3 trees from our garden along with a massive fern. One is an apple tree right by our only entrance which makes getting in and out of the house in summer somewhat perilous for those with sting allergies, one is diseased and the other is a fern that is too big for where it is. We will be removing and replanting the garden with far more trees and plants but for a time (depending on scheduling) we won’t have any greenery in the garden.

Here’s hoping none of our neighbours try to confront us for being tree murders Hmm

Why not talk to your neighbours before you do so? I know that most of Mumsnet are pretty antisocial, but communication can avoid all of the grief.
Blossomtoes · 03/04/2022 18:12

Glad you’ve bought a new tree @danny735. Hope you can find some way of making it grow super fast!

Dearmariacountmein · 03/04/2022 17:56

So much vitriol on this thread.

We’ll soon be chopping 3 trees from our garden along with a massive fern. One is an apple tree right by our only entrance which makes getting in and out of the house in summer somewhat perilous for those with sting allergies, one is diseased and the other is a fern that is too big for where it is. We will be removing and replanting the garden with far more trees and plants but for a time (depending on scheduling) we won’t have any greenery in the garden.

Here’s hoping none of our neighbours try to confront us for being tree murders Hmm

DdraigGoch · 03/04/2022 17:49

@NoSquirrels

Of course you’re not being silly. My neighbours 2 doors down also chopped down a mature pear tree when they moved in, that produced masses of fruit every year, to put a hot tub deck with pergola in its place. They’re perfectly nice people but I can’t help but judge them, I’m afraid. But it was their tree, after all.

Plant a new tree in your garden!

Given that their sex pond has suddenly become even more expensive to run, it's even more of a waste.
Kanaloa · 03/04/2022 17:47

@wh00pi

my garden is pretty great thanks. Personally I couldn’t give a hoot if some random online disapproves of what I do in it but I do think some of you need to get a grip- maybe on a spade and plant some trees to replace all those poor murdered souls…

Are you the one complaining people don't like your concrete garden? And we shouldn't talk about it? Sounds like you don't care a lot. Plant lovers are allowed to talk about their tastes, and opinions. Cope.

You sound insane. Honestly nuts.

Definitely you can talk about your tastes and how much you love plants - but this bizarre hyperbole whereby people cutting down their own tree is akin to them storming into your garden and punching your baby in the face is just ridiculous.

Kanaloa · 03/04/2022 17:45

[quote wh00pi]@Kanaloa

It's sarcasm babe. If you're sooo busy up any look out a window and have no interests besides being busy, it doesn't sound fun. I'd rather be like op who has time to enjoy her home and garden but each to their own🥰[/quote]
Not only time to enjoy her own home and garden but other people’s as well apparently.

It’s ridiculous babes x it’s someone else’s tree hun x it’s not a crime to remodel your own garden sweetie pie xxx

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 03/04/2022 17:23

@nigellaLawdaughter
I'd've been super bummed, too

I say, what you do at the weekends is your own private matter and we really do not need to hear about it. Thank you very much. Shock

NigellaLawdaughter · 03/04/2022 17:06

I'd've been super bummed, too @danny735.
So glad you're going to plant your own! 👍
But not too close to the fence, or the neighbours will
lob off all of the branches that grow over on their side.

wh00pi · 03/04/2022 16:16

my garden is pretty great thanks. Personally I couldn’t give a hoot if some random online disapproves of what I do in it but I do think some of you need to get a grip- maybe on a spade and plant some trees to replace all those poor murdered souls…

Are you the one complaining people don't like your concrete garden? And we shouldn't talk about it? Sounds like you don't care a lot. Plant lovers are allowed to talk about their tastes, and opinions. Cope.

wh00pi · 03/04/2022 16:14

@Kanaloa

It's sarcasm babe. If you're sooo busy up any look out a window and have no interests besides being busy, it doesn't sound fun. I'd rather be like op who has time to enjoy her home and garden but each to their own🥰

Kanaloa · 03/04/2022 15:44

@wh00pi

It’s insane. Honestly if you have this much time to worry about what other people are doing with their own garden you need to make yourself a bit busier.

So much cooler and busier than Op, you don't even have time to look out your front window in the morning, sounds fun

What are you, half tree? If having time to look out my window will turn me into someone wailing over a tree that doesn’t even belong to me and referring to people who don’t mind cutting down trees as ‘murderers’ then thank god I’m too busy.
SockFluffInTheBath · 03/04/2022 15:27

@Bunnycat101

“Lots of defensive and/or proud tree murderers here.”

I think this perfectly encapsulates a previous poster that referenced hyperbolic nonsense.

Ooh that will be me Grin

I had mine down because it was seriously weakened in a gale, and had it fallen it would taken taken down the electricity supply to half the village. So yes, I’m proud to have saved my neighbours considerable inconvenience and a pita job for the linesmen who would have been sent out. If you’d rtft you’d see what’s gone in it’s place.

@wh00pi my garden is pretty great thanks. Personally I couldn’t give a hoot if some random online disapproves of what I do in it but I do think some of you need to get a grip- maybe on a spade and plant some trees to replace all those poor murdered souls…

danny735 · 03/04/2022 14:57

@TheWildRumpyPumpus

Nothing riles up a MNer like a neighbour cutting down a tree.

God forbid they should actually have to plant one of their own!

I've already purchased a pear tree to replace the one that was chopped down.

Most of the leaves from the pear that was chopped down fell into my garden and were taken care of by me.

The tree was not rotten - they just preferred a bare garden. That's their right - but I'll be planting my new pear almost exactly where the old one stood - but on my side of the fence.

To be so sad neighbours cut down a Pear Tree
OP posts:
KloppsTeeth · 03/04/2022 14:53

YANBU to be sad about the lost of a lovely tree.

We had to have a mature cherry tree because it was very diseased. We spoke to all the neighbours to explain that the reason it was going was because it was highly likely to fall over in strong winds. They appreciated the notice and explanation.

CruCru · 03/04/2022 12:30

A couple of weeks ago, someone came into Next Door to post about how upset they were with a neighbour who’d chopped down a magnolia tree. Cue hundreds of posts about how evil it is to remove trees and what appalling people they were to do this.

Presumably it was diseased but even if it wasn’t, it was their (small) garden that was being dominated by the tree.

Blossomtoes · 03/04/2022 12:02

@Youcansaythatagainandagain

For all the posters who lament the loss of other people’s trees, pop along to a tree nursery and pay hundreds and hundreds for a semi mature tree and plant it in your own gardens? Wait… you don’t have the space or money or inclination to budget to do this. Oh well…..
It’s not actually that expensive. If I were @danny735 I’d be doing exactly that.

www.paramountplants.co.uk/plant/pptw/pleached-pear-tree-williams.html

SexiestDogWalker · 03/04/2022 11:50

YANBU but some people just don't like trees. We have a weeping willow tree in the corner of our back garden, it's fucking massive and spills over into three other gardens. The bloke directly behind me hates it, whinges like mad about it and has even tried to book tree surgeons to lop the entire top off when we were on holiday one year: they refused because it's not his tree and left us a note asking if we wanted it done could we get in touch. He's complained to the council about the tree, and they've asked if we will cut it back, we said no and they said fine.

If we cut that back, we are immediately overlooked and overlooking two properties, bedroom window to bedroom window. And since the bloke behind me has a pervy adult son who used to climb a ladder to try and watch me in my own garden, I'm not keen on removing the giant screen of leaves we have.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 03/04/2022 11:22

There’s a village near my work that’s very footballers wives territory, it features in books of prettiest villages in England etc and yes the high street is lovely but people constantly buy a mansion, demolish it, rip out the garden and put a modern glass monstrous house in with a pool and fake grass and grey decking. The amount of trees that must go is horrible. Can’t buy class!

Youcansaythatagainandagain · 03/04/2022 11:18

For all the posters who lament the loss of other people’s trees, pop along to a tree nursery and pay hundreds and hundreds for a semi mature tree and plant it in your own gardens?
Wait… you don’t have the space or money or inclination to budget to do this. Oh well…..

Ratonastick · 03/04/2022 10:07

Trees aren’t permanent, they have a life cycle. I murdered 3 trees when I moved into my house. All were unstable, 2 were rotten through the core and one was rocking badly and couldn’t be stabilised. My neighbour raged at me for destroying nature, but he would have been more pissed off if I’d left them as two would have fallen on his garage. I’ve planted new trees and have managed to save two others, but sometimes you have to get the tree surgeon in.

HomeprideSaucy · 03/04/2022 09:23

YANBU to be sad; trees are lovely things.

YABU to think you have any right to think what they do with their garden. Their garden, their tree, their right to remove it if they want.

DingleyDel · 03/04/2022 09:15

I’d feel the same too if it were a healthy tree. However reading some of the replies is making me paranoid that our neighbours think we’ve done this to the beautiful old cherry blossom that was in our front garden. It looked healthy and still blossomed but was completely rotten inside. The storm toppled it into the hedge so although it didn’t look like it had blown down, it was just balanced there so we had to get rid of it. Sad

Rubyupbeat · 03/04/2022 09:13

This is sad, trees are beautiful. Although I know in my parents old house, they had a lovely, very old pear tree, it was all crooked and all the grandchildren had climbed it. The only problem was wasps, they loved those pears, the birds would peck them on the branches, then the wasps would move in.
Could you maybe put a tree on your side, to watch grow? Some nurseries do semi mature trees and will come and 'plant' them for you.

Toocooltoboogie · 03/04/2022 09:06

I've seen it happen so many times. New people move into a house with a beautiful mature garden and they rip the whole lot out to be replaced with something soulless and rubbish for wildlife. We had a beautiful garden in our last house with many trees. I'm so happy the people that bought it appreciate nature and have continued to preserve it.

Keladrythesaviour · 03/04/2022 08:55

We've got a mature apple and mature pear tree in our garden. They're lovely and I love harvesting from them but the reality I need to face up to is both of them are becoming a massive liability. They're rotten in part and whilst we've got the apple propped up they're near our fence and the last thing I want is them going down and causing damage to our and our neighbors garden so at some point they will have to come down. I'm just delaying the inevitable.
We also had to take out an immature cherry recently because we are redesigning the garden and it was in the middle of my vegetable garden. For some that wouldn't be a good enough reason, but we have lots of trees, lots of bee friendly flowers etc - we can sacrifice a tree for growing more vegetables.

On the other side we had an elderly neighbour who loved trees and refused to have anything cut down. As a result we've got a big ash growing right on the boundary, causing problems with our foundations. We were about to make a compliant when she sadly died. So now we are waiting for the house to be sold etc and just hope they are reasonable people.

I love nature, care deeply for my garden and protect wildlife etc where I can but the reality is sometimes trees are just no longer suited to the environment they're in. I can't say if that's why your pear came down but it's often a decision that has to be made on a multitude of factors.