Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so sad neighbours cut down a Pear Tree

187 replies

danny735 · 02/04/2022 13:33

Just that really.

There was a beautiful pear tree right on the border of our garden. I returned from a trip and the neighbours had chopped it down.

It was on neighbours side of the fence but half of the foliage was in our garden. I love nature and adore tree silhouette.

We've only lived in this house for 2 years and the pears were blooming when we moved in. There are usually beautiful blossoms in spring time. I'm so devastated that it's gone - I can't work out if I'm being silly I not 🥺

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
YawnAndTheyWillYawnToo · 04/04/2022 21:45

Being so devastated is OTT but I can remember my Nan having an apple tree I get garden when I was small and then as a teen I visited and she had it cut down could never work out why.

UnsuitableHat · 04/04/2022 06:17

I'd feel similarly about that - it doesn't matter whether the reaction's rational or not. A new housing estate has been built recently, backing onto my garden, and a tree which overhung the end of my garden, and was lovely, was cut down as part of that. It wasn't on my land, but still sad to see it had vanished.

wombat1a · 04/04/2022 05:25

Could be a simple as they are allergic to wasp stings,

Longdistance · 04/04/2022 04:31

My parents used to have an apple tree in their garden. It was Bramley cooking apples. The tree started ageing and had to be chopped down unfortunately. We think it was planted when the house was built after the war.
It had lots of memories for us, as neighbours used to come in the garden and collect the abundance of apples. So I can see why you’re upset.
I love a fruit tree, my only concern is the birds eating the fruit.

Kanaloa · 04/04/2022 03:54

Are you turning it into a hideout for Russian spies? If not, why bother keeping it secret? By talking to my neighbours about the work each of us are getting done we've each gained advice and recommendations, such as how to deal with difficult weeds and where we can get a reliable plumber.

It’s not ‘keeping it a secret’ Confused your neighbours will know you’re cutting down your tree when they see that you’re cutting down your tree. But it’s not necessary to go round to the neighbours and let them know you’re changing your garden. If anything it’s a bit odd unless they’re friends of yours.

runsoncaffeine4 · 04/04/2022 03:40

Oh no, I would be upset by this too! I love trees.

NigellaLawdaughter · 04/04/2022 03:06

@TwoLeftSocksWithHoles
. . . uh oh! Now I am too afraid to go look up what that might mean these days!
(Although I could take a pretty good guess at it, I think. Blush)

@Norgie 👏👏👏
= Glitterball Star 🏆 👍 Grin😂

DdraigGoch · 03/04/2022 23:59

@WomanStanleyWoman

Are you turning it into a hideout for Russian spies? If not, why bother keeping it secret? By talking to my neighbours about the work each of us are getting done we've each gained advice and recommendations, such as how to deal with difficult weeds and where we can get a reliable plumber.

This is bonkers. It wasn’t a secret’ when I redecorated a couple of years ago either - but I didn’t actively discuss it with the neighbours either. Why would I? As for recommendations, I could just ask if I wanted them.

It wouldn't have occurred to me to ask my neighbour for advice on planting an apple tree if she hadn't told me that she was getting a couple herself.
WomanStanleyWoman · 03/04/2022 23:27

Are you turning it into a hideout for Russian spies? If not, why bother keeping it secret? By talking to my neighbours about the work each of us are getting done we've each gained advice and recommendations, such as how to deal with difficult weeds and where we can get a reliable plumber.

This is bonkers. It wasn’t a secret’ when I redecorated a couple of years ago either - but I didn’t actively discuss it with the neighbours either. Why would I? As for recommendations, I could just ask if I wanted them.

DdraigGoch · 03/04/2022 23:18

@WomanStanleyWoman

Why not talk to your neighbours before you do so? I know that most of Mumsnet are pretty antisocial, but communication can avoid all of the grief.

Why on Earth would I tell my neighbours what I’m planning to do with my own garden?

Are you turning it into a hideout for Russian spies? If not, why bother keeping it secret? By talking to my neighbours about the work each of us are getting done we've each gained advice and recommendations, such as how to deal with difficult weeds and where we can get a reliable plumber.
DdraigGoch · 03/04/2022 23:08

[quote Dearmariacountmein]@DdraigGoch I’m actually on very good terms with most of my neighbours but I wouldn’t seek out to discuss my garden plans with them unless it would affect them I.e replacing a party hedge.

I find the suggestion really bizarre TBH. Shall I also seek their approval before we replace the shed, what about painting the garden walls?[/quote]
My neighbour told me that she was replacing the old shed. I helped demolish it. I showed her what shade of blue that I had got for painting my living room. My neighbour-but-one told me that he was going to start getting rid of the ivy on his wall. I offered the use of my garden waste bin.

We often talk about the work we're doing on our respective gardens, as well as the repairs we're doing to our houses. It's got nothing to do with "approval", it's just making conversation.

"Hi Doris, how are you?"
"Hi Brenda, not so bad. We got a tree surgeon around to look at the old pear tree last week. He says it's rotten, got to come down."
"Oh that's a shame. Never mind, can't be helped"
"How's Johnny getting on with his A Levels?"

BlooberryBiskits · 03/04/2022 22:25

@Norgie

Oh no, not a cutted up pear tree 😱
GrinGrinGrin
Plantsandpuddlesuits · 03/04/2022 21:58

@Norgie you win the thread Grin

RosesAndHellebores · 03/04/2022 21:53

@norgie Grin Good to see an old-timer. Whoever you might once have been.

Snoopsnoggysnog · 03/04/2022 21:45

@Norgie Grin

Norgie · 03/04/2022 20:43

Oh no, not a cutted up pear tree 😱

BlooberryBiskits · 03/04/2022 20:43

@danny735: good choice to plant your own tree- dig a massive hole (2x size of pot at least) & stick some fish blood & bone in the planting hole 🤞🏼

Of course trees are beautiful, but as @Ratonastick says, fruit trees especially have a life cycle! My place has 3 mature apples and a fig, I’ve just planted 2 plums and a cherry… but o would not hesitate to remove a fruit tree which was diseased/blocking my light or causing problems, and I think your neighbours also have every right to have their garden as they wish

godmum56 · 03/04/2022 20:25

[quote Dearmariacountmein]@godmum56 I did look at selling it but due to where it is we would struggle to get it out of the garden unfortunately. There are two smaller ones clustered with it that I may try and sell.[/quote]
buyer collects and removes. Its worth offering anyway?

godmum56 · 03/04/2022 20:24

@whymewhyme

Not unreasonable at all. On the way to school there was the most beautiful oak tree in someones rather lovely garden, i must of been 100 yrs old and every day for a week i had to watch it being cut down!! Not my tree not my business but i found it very sad
If it was that old it was probably either dangerous or had outgrown its spot or both. When old oaks drop branches they can trash cars and injure people.
Dearmariacountmein · 03/04/2022 20:23

@godmum56 I did look at selling it but due to where it is we would struggle to get it out of the garden unfortunately. There are two smaller ones clustered with it that I may try and sell.

godmum56 · 03/04/2022 20:10

@Dearmariacountmein

So much vitriol on this thread.

We’ll soon be chopping 3 trees from our garden along with a massive fern. One is an apple tree right by our only entrance which makes getting in and out of the house in summer somewhat perilous for those with sting allergies, one is diseased and the other is a fern that is too big for where it is. We will be removing and replanting the garden with far more trees and plants but for a time (depending on scheduling) we won’t have any greenery in the garden.

Here’s hoping none of our neighbours try to confront us for being tree murders Hmm

seriously a massive fern? tree fern? sell it, those things are worth moolah! www.toddsbotanics.co.uk/tree-ferns/tree-fern-dicksonia-antarctica-_3.htm
WomanStanleyWoman · 03/04/2022 19:37

Why not talk to your neighbours before you do so? I know that most of Mumsnet are pretty antisocial, but communication can avoid all of the grief.

Why on Earth would I tell my neighbours what I’m planning to do with my own garden?

LoveSpringDaffs · 03/04/2022 18:53

@balalake

I think you should ask them why, and if it was not for reasons of disease express your view.
To what point? They can hardly put it back!! It was their tree in their garden, they don't need the OP's blessing!

@danny735 yes, I'd be sad too. Friends of friends have just spent £859,000 on a house, with (to me) a beautiful garden. They have stripped it bare, had all the mature trees removed, taken lovely pots of trees/flowers/plants to the tip, astroturfed it at great expense because they cba mowing it. .... it's a crying shame. Mature beautiful garden to Astro fucking turf.

A friend has a lovely garden, huge oak tree (which thankfully is staying!) several other lovely mature trees which are going, little pagoda, couple of sheds/woodpiles/bits & pieces. I LOVE it! It's fabulous!! They're putting in an office (shame but understandable) and 'landscaping' the rest! Basically removing everything (except the oak) putting in 'areas' & poncufying it. I'm sad already!! Yep, their garden, their choice and all that, but I'm allowed to be sad!!

whymewhyme · 03/04/2022 18:46

Not unreasonable at all. On the way to school there was the most beautiful oak tree in someones rather lovely garden, i must of been 100 yrs old and every day for a week i had to watch it being cut down!! Not my tree not my business but i found it very sad

Dearmariacountmein · 03/04/2022 18:40

@DdraigGoch I’m actually on very good terms with most of my neighbours but I wouldn’t seek out to discuss my garden plans with them unless it would affect them I.e replacing a party hedge.

I find the suggestion really bizarre TBH. Shall I also seek their approval before we replace the shed, what about painting the garden walls?