Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to find 11 yr DS really demanding...and frustrated how he can't entertain himself?

38 replies

Pantonecolour · 02/04/2022 09:10

Namechanged for this.

Love DS (Yr 6, 11yrs) to bits. Light of our lives. Brilliant personality, caring and kind.

But my god, he has a strong sense of injustice. Often misplaced, too. He complains and demands sooooo much.

His main thing is that we don't let him have unlimited gaming or screen time and we also don't let him go to the shop every day for sweets - this, it would seem, puts us part from almost every other parent.

It feels like a constant battle, every day, whatever approach we take. we try to listen and accommodate. We apologise if we're wrong. We take it all in if he thinks we're unfair and I think he does well - but the moment he has whatever it he wants - more screen, more sweets - he's back on the old complaining horse.

And then, in between the above, when we say go and do something - he literally doesn't know what to do. It's such an effort to get him to go and draw or play with something - the many things - in his room. He just wants screen. And I really think the screen and Minecraft makes him disinterested in anything else.

I don't even know what I expect from posting. Just need to vent, I guess. But if anyone has any advice on how to approach this successfully, I'm all ears

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WhereYouLeftIt · 02/04/2022 22:04

"It feels like a constant battle, every day, whatever approach we take. we try to listen and accommodate. We apologise if we're wrong. We take it all in if he thinks we're unfair and I think he does well - but the moment he has whatever it he wants - more screen, more sweets - he's back on the old complaining horse."
On the basis of 'if you do what you've always done, you'll get what you've always got' - I think you should reconsider your 'listen and accommodate' approach. You're the adult, he's the child. Try a straight no, maybe 'I've told you no already' at a push - and stop presenting it to him as a negotiation. The decision has been made. The answer is no. He's 11, he's always going to think you're unfair. The answer's still no, now go to your room and give me peace.

"And then, in between the above, when we say go and do something - he literally doesn't know what to do. It's such an effort to get him to go and draw or play with something - the many things - in his room."
Then he'll get bored. And he'll learn to draw, read, play because there's nothing else to do. Or stare out the window. Whatever. Boredom is not fatal, it's actually quite a good prompt. Just don't expect it to work first time, it might take months of boredom before he finds some initiative. But he'll never find it until you allow him to get bored.

Sunlightonthewater · 02/04/2022 21:51

I think this depends so much on the personality of the child - some are just born negotiators and are relentless, I totally get it OP!! My eldest has always been like this, he is now 14 and I have got to the stage where I have said as long as he does his lessons, homework, exercise and other chores/necessities then he can have as much screen time as he wants. I guess he probably has “too much”, but he doesn’t just sit playing games, he designs things, creates and edits videos, watches news etc. Giving his this freedom has transformed our lives - the constant moans and fights and tantrums were horrendous (he has ASD and screens are his main coping mechanism). We had many years of taking screens away for bad behaviour, sometimes for months at a time. But now this works for us. My middle two have strict screen time which is enforced daily and although they would like more they stick to the rules and don’t moan. My youngest doesn’t have any restrictions as he will play for a bit on his iPad then run off to play football, so he self-regulates. It’s not a “one size fits all” thing with screens. I often wish we didn’t have them at all for many reasons, but as others have said it’s the way the world is going…

MrsPepperpot79 · 02/04/2022 21:50

Can't help re the complaining, but we have rule in our house - if you use the word "bored" you get given a bin to wash out. Only had to do it once, all three quite now quite good at not complaining about nothing to do!

StrawberrySquash · 02/04/2022 21:05

Congratulations on having a Kevin the Teenager

Pantonecolour · 02/04/2022 20:56

Yes, I'm sure there's truth in I listen too much. I should just cut it off

OP posts:
AskingforaBaskin · 02/04/2022 20:33

Why does he need to be 'heard' not everything is a problem he needs to learn some things are just a him problem and he needs to shut up about it.

arethereanyleftatall · 02/04/2022 20:29

I 'think' your parenting might be like my friends. She does everything right technically, tries really hard to follow all the 'rules'. Has read all the books. But...she's (they are) too involved. Its too much attention. It's so difficult to articulate why, it just doesn't work. You don't need to listen to him so he feels heard when you've already told him the deal. 'No'.

Pantonecolour · 02/04/2022 20:22

@Ellmau

the moment he has whatever it he wants - more screen, more sweets - he's back on the old complaining horse.

Well, yes: he can see it works.

No, it doesn't work. We don't give in. We might try to have a conversation about it, so he feels heard, but we haven't changed our rules
OP posts:
Ellmau · 02/04/2022 19:40

the moment he has whatever it he wants - more screen, more sweets - he's back on the old complaining horse.

Well, yes: he can see it works.

itsgettingweird · 02/04/2022 18:30

If he's doing that sport etc I'd not worry.

I have simple rules such as no screen time until you're ready. If ds uses his iPad etc before getting ready and forgets something I don't bail him out and tell him straight if he had time for screens he had time to organise himself (his usual excuse is lack of time Hmm).

I also have a rule when we come to mealtimes that there is 30 minutes away from screens minimum. So he doesn't scoff to run back and helps tidy away afterwards.

Pantonecolour · 02/04/2022 18:27

Thanks for all the replies. Good to know I'm not alone!

For the person who said I'm a 'permissive soft touch,' - I'm really not. I'm harsh. We stick to the rules but it's just he's a major campaigner.

He is very sporty and does one particular sport several times a week, plus another sport and a music lesson - but there are still a lot of hours in the day. And if he could, he'd fill it with screen.

What is hard is knowing if you are making it the forbidden fruit or whether you are doing him a massive favour.

OP posts:
Borris · 02/04/2022 12:25

My dd is same age and similar. She has an hour max a day. She has to join in dog walking and we go on lots of trips out. Also she is in guides and horse rides. But at home she just wants to lie on the sofa watching mindless rubbish on YouTube. When the hour is up there’s no more.

I wish she was better at self stimulating as she’ll then want to do stuff together like baking, learning a dance, karaoke but I figure that’s partly being an only child so no siblings to play with.

Lougle · 02/04/2022 11:07

My children are pretty screen obsessed. It's inevitable. DD3 (12) does Army Cadets twice per week, plus drama club after school once or twice per week. She needs time to just decompress. So I'm not overly bothered as long as her attitude is good.

I judge most things on attitude. If she's grumpy and moany, I pull bed time back a bit. If she's co-operative and 'herself' then I'm a bit more relaxed about it.

Sweets are never guaranteed, but we have a limit of 60g. They can choose any sweets from their tubs, but they have to stick to the limit. That way, there are no arguments about one chew being worth two chocolates, etc.

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/04/2022 10:58

It’s good for kids to be bored, with my two if they’re moaning about being bored I’ll tell them to find something to do amidst the many toys, games, craft supplies, books etc or I’ll find something to do for them - I have an endless supply of small chores that need done. They’ll still complain about being bored (meaning they want a screen) but will also go and do something else after a few minutes. I don’t tend to negotiate too much with them, they know the deal with screen time so they know once it’s done they need to find something else. They also know that I’m not really bothered that they’re bored, so I’m not going to rush around finding ways to fill their time for them.

romdowa · 02/04/2022 10:53

@Porcupineintherough

Very easy to solve if you are evil. Each time he complains he doesnt know what to do, give him a chore to do. My ds2 was similar but became remarkably creative about what to do with himself if the alternative was emptying the dishwasher. Try it. Every time he complains tell him you're glad he's free because you need X doing. Then explain why it's only fair that everyone shared the work of running a household equally and how unjust it is that you have to do so much of it. Smile
This was my mothers tactic 🤣🤣 we never complained we were bored because there would be hoovering , polishing, washing up etc to be done!
Leah2005 · 02/04/2022 10:45

I hate to say this but my ds was pretty screen obsessed from about age 12. Before then he read voraciously but that stopped once he started gaming. He did plenty of extra curricular activities so I satisfied myself with that (choir, scouts, swimming). Now age 22 and seems to be permanently on a screen if not at work or uni. So disheartening but if all their friends socialise like that, what can you do? He goes out out probably twice a week.

AskingforaBaskin · 02/04/2022 10:35

@Porcupineintherough

Very easy to solve if you are evil. Each time he complains he doesnt know what to do, give him a chore to do. My ds2 was similar but became remarkably creative about what to do with himself if the alternative was emptying the dishwasher. Try it. Every time he complains tell him you're glad he's free because you need X doing. Then explain why it's only fair that everyone shared the work of running a household equally and how unjust it is that you have to do so much of it. Smile
I have done this and also walked DS into his room and asked if he wants me to gut it all and take it to the charity shop for him.

After his distressed response I acted bewildered and asked how he could have nothing to do with so many toys and games? And if he didn't find them worth his time why he wanted to keep them.

Lovemyheathershimmer · 02/04/2022 10:32

arethereanyleftatall
That’s the thing I was born in 1972 and we had to find our own entertainment. All through the summer holidays, we were hardly ever taken to days out. Maybe the odd beach trip. We were expected to go out to play and come back at lunch and dinner lol. None of this I’m bored. Lol we were told to get out and play and that was it.

arethereanyleftatall · 02/04/2022 10:27

Don't entertain your dc saying they're bored to you @Lovemyheathershimmer
How dare they? It's not your job to entertain them.
I think my dc's said it once, can't remember when, say around 5. They received a full on rant from me with all the usual stuff 'not my job to entertain you. You can do chores if you're bored. Only boring people get bored' etc etc and have never said it again.

Lovemyheathershimmer · 02/04/2022 10:19

It’s a crap age, my sons 11, 12 in June. My god he’s draining sometimes. He moans about sweets, fizzy juice, being hungry all the time. I’m looking at clubs for him, something active. He goes to a band twice weekly, but needs something else. If I hear I’m bored again, I’ll scream! I’m trying to get him to keep in touch with his friends also, start organising to meet up. Being a bit more sociable and thinking for himself.

Thirkettle · 02/04/2022 10:15

@DenholmElliot

we try to listen and accommodate. We apologise if we're wrong. We take it all in if he thinks we're unfair and I think he does well - but the moment he has whatever it he wants

Try a different approach. Tell him to shut up and stop moaning all the time or you'll give him something to moan about.

Worked for me Grin

This! You sound like a permissive soft touch. No wonder he's a tantrumming brat. Where are his consequences?

My kids know the times they can play games. Outside these times they do other things. Nobody complains or whinges, and if there is bad behaviour the privileges are taken away. With clear boundaries and obvious consequences, behaviour is really good.

Punish his whinging to teach him better manners, before he grows up and gets his arse kicked in a pub or loses a job for being rude. Book him into a sport class. Try and remember your job isn't too be his friend and make him happy at all costs, but to prepare him for a world that won't tolerate pathetic tantrums or his claims that life isn't fair.

HestersSamplerofCarrots · 02/04/2022 10:03

Stop all the listening and allowing him to mke his point and all that gubbins.

You’re the parents.

No. That’s it.

And if he moans then he doesn’t get his sweets, screen time or whatever tomorrow. And then follow it through.

Tell him you’ll play with him at x time and do y thing, but until then he needs to entertain himself. And send him off to do it. No. I’m not playing with you now. No. If you won’t go and find something to do I won’t play with you later.

Etc etc etc.

Set the boundaries.
Maintain them.

CHIRIBAYA · 02/04/2022 10:01

You are doing a great job and you are not alone in bearing these frustrations. Tech and screen time has specific impacts on brain development and on emotional regulation and your 'holding' of his frustration is a) helping him to learn that frustration is human b) it will pass c) his tolerance for frustration has now improved. He is also now practing self-control and delayed gratification which is important for effective development of his pre-frontal cortex (that's the bit of the brain that went off-line for Will Smith at the Oscars) He won't as an adult be using maladaptive ways to displace frustration b/c he is unable to contain it. We have this with our 14 year old when boundaries are enforced but I appreciate, it is not easy and very tiring. All very well to day do other hobbies and of course, developing interests is important but the problem arises when any time spent away from these activities is spent engaging with screens; there is no down time for the brain. The down time is where creativity (to draw, to imagine , to create) resides. His pushing against the boundary is his confirmation that he is safe, even though on a superficial level that's not how he will present it to you. It's all about finding the right balance and sometimes this can take time.

arethereanyleftatall · 02/04/2022 10:00

I also totally agree with extra curricular. I know this is finance dependent, so if you can. With school, walk home, plus at least one hour of extra curricular sport per day, plus dinner, bedtime at 8-9 (reading) for my 11yo, there's only about 2 hours left per day. I'm happy for her to spend that on a screen if she wishes. This way i don't need to set limits.

PermanentTemporary · 02/04/2022 09:54

I agree with the pp who said set the rules and then just say you know what the rules are. Takes a lot of the agonising out of it.

Ds who is lovely was at his least lovely between 11 and 13. It's not an easy stage imo. They are tackling much more demanding things at school and becoming aware of external threats. However, they are still incredibly immature so react by behaving like arseholes Grin

I do think though that they really seem to need a lot of interaction with adults at this time. For those of us with onlies, that's just how it is. Cooking/baking was something I could do harmoniously with ds at this stage - he responded quite well to supported success. My mother always has children chopping wood supervised from 8 and would probably have sent ds out to chop a load of firewood unsupervised at 11. I was not so brave.

I became a Woodcraft Folk leader when ds was 10 and did it for 3 years. It's a good age for that sort of group - Scouts obviously good too, depends on the leader though and really you should be prepared to get stuck in too if you can - at least a couple of sessions a term maybe. I can't honestly say I enjoyed it but it was satisfying and I saw another side to ds during those sessions.