Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to ask when and why it became the norm for schools not to allow juniors to make their own way home?

335 replies

RedHelenB · 02/04/2022 04:03

Seems they need parents to collect them from the class teacher up until y5 or 6 now, whereas a few years ago my dc orimary school.Just let them out at hometime and stonewalled home, somewhere collected by older siblings and some by oarents. Just one staff member by the junior entrance.

OP posts:
Stressedout65 · 02/04/2022 11:02

I starred school in 1970. I remember walking home from school with all the other kids from a very early age. I'm sure at the age of 8 I was responsible for walking home my 5 year old sibling. And from quite a young age we would have to look after ourselves for an hour & half while dad finished his day time sleep ready for his nightshift and mum finished her day at work. Between us we had to do the dusting & peel & chop the spuds ready for tea. Then my dad would get up & for work. My old school friend who lived 2 doors away can remember going to and from school at 6 years old too. There wasn't the traffic then & Road safety was drummed into us. We used to be out on our bikes all day without parental supervision and I remember at 12 years old I just decided while I was out playing to cycle to my grans house 12 miles away in a city. No one knew until I arrived at my grans, but I think they were very shocked at that one! Neither I or my parents would have been happy if my 12 year old to have cycled that far away on their own. Different times when I was a child, but we were a lot more independent at a younger age

TizerorFizz · 02/04/2022 11:01

When my DDs were at school (2000s) it was up to parents what they did. Class teachers just let them out of the classroom door. Infant school released them to parent or nominated carer. I think DC need resilience and walking home when a junior is good prep for secondary and avoids congestion with cars. Of course they should walk home with friends.

WhatICallMyUsername · 02/04/2022 11:00

The first day of Y6 school told them all they should be walking to and from school by themselves now to prepare for senior school. It annoyed me in the fact we moved house during DSs time there and now live a 45 minute walk away so it wouldn't be feasible.

Someone in his year has been leaving alone, walking home and letting himself in his house since Y2. No one can understand how the school allowed it but I guess the parents insisted Confused

RampantIvy · 02/04/2022 10:57

I remember walking home from school with my sister by the time I was in juniors at primary school. I had only one main road to cross and it had a lollipop man. I think if I had been on my own my mum would have wanted me to be a little bit older to walk home on my own - maybe year 5 or 6.

DD started primary school in 2005 and the school wouldn't let children go home on their own until year 6. One of the roads the children had to cross was a very busy main road through the village, and in spite of requesting crossing measures/lollipop person it never happened. I did say to DD that I would see her across the road and she could walk the rest on her own once she was in year 6, but she wanted me to take her to school every day, and collect her.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 02/04/2022 10:56

At our school, the kids can walk home from y6. It was the same when I was at primary in the late 1980s!

Sushi7 · 02/04/2022 10:55

I’m in my mid 20s. It was totally normal to walk home age 7 (year 3). I was taught some road sense and stranger danger from a very young age. I grew up in a village so that’s obviously different to a city.

GoldenOmber · 02/04/2022 10:53

@TabithaTittlemouse

I need a nap. I read the title as when it became normal for junior doctors to walk home.
tbf they do look awfully young sometimes.
Hankunamatata · 02/04/2022 10:51

Our school its year 5 and 6 to walk home alone. That's early enough imo. They are old enough to deal with unexpected scenarios like parents not being home if running late etc

WelshyMaud · 02/04/2022 10:50

Several years ago I had to have ructions with the dc's primary school for them to let ds2 (Y4) leave alone.

Their rule was Y5 and Y6 only can leave. I changed work hours and my dad had agreed to pick the dc up for me two days a week - except he was disabled and unable to walk the distance from the car to the junior pick up point which was right at the back of the school. I had literally no other option at that time.

I asked permission for Dc2 to leave with dc1 (Y6) and walk to the gates of the school and 30 seconds down the road to my dad's car (no crossing). Declined. I had a meeting with the head where I explained and asked to sign with my permission. Declined. I was told they would under no circumstances release Dc2 without an adult at the class door.

It got to the point where I said fine. My dad is outside waiting for him on Mondays and Tuesdays. Either release him or get a teacher to take him out but no one is coming to the door (I prepped ds2 for what would happen and he was fine and expecting it).

Day 1 and I was in work - cue call advising no one was there to collect. Reiterated my dad was parked on the road outside. Told he'd have to come in. Said he couldn't. Receptionist said they'd have to report to SS. I said fine and hung up. My dad called me 5 minutes later to say a teacher took him out.
Day 2 same but escalated, Head came on the phone and tried to give me a dressing down - I hung up on her in the end. Ds taken to car by the head who attempted to tell my dad off - he refused to engage and said she'd need to speak to me.
Day 3 ds was released and continued to be and I never heared another thing about it.

TabithaTittlemouse · 02/04/2022 10:50

I need a nap. I read the title as when it became normal for junior doctors to walk home.

overitall1 · 02/04/2022 10:48

I used to catch a bus with my 8 year old sister, I was 5. One day she 'forgot' me coming home and I caught another bus on my own. Mid 60s. My mother nearly had a heart attack when my sister got home without me!

TILFA · 02/04/2022 10:48

My children school in the 80s and all four of them started walking home without an adult in year 4. There was no restriction set by the school on the Age child could walk home Alone.

I can't recall anyone doing practice runs to secondary school before they started because they all had the experience of going on busses etc without an adult. Or is this just a mumsnet thing? They went to the park, town or to friends houses without an adult before secondary school age.

I don't understand this overprotective mollycoddling of children nowadays. They are just as safe now as they were in the 70s and 80s so why aren't we encouraging independence and learning essential life skills and ending up with teenagers scared to go somewhere alone?

Obviously not all families are like this, but they seem to be in MN land.

Snazzyjazzpants · 02/04/2022 10:48

My DC school they can leave however the parents want from grade one. DD6 would walk a few blocks to the park with her brothers aged 9 and 10, plus a bunch of other children of various ages. This is in Australia and most schools have issues with traffic so they don't want to push more parents into drop off zone. Roads are the only issue, so it depends on how many they have to cross how safe the trip is.

Icelandicsox · 02/04/2022 10:47

Of course its the catchment area thing, I hadn't thought if that.
Most of thd kids here in Scotland go to their local school so there are millions of them all walking a fairly short distance.together.

RaraRachael · 02/04/2022 10:43

Very few parents collect kids at our school unless they are in P1 or P2 or live a long way from school. Most walk to and from school on their own and have always done so.

Catlitterqueen · 02/04/2022 10:35

I was at primary school in the 1970’s and walked on my own from the age of about 5.
There were no busy roads to cross on our estate.
Nobody batted an eyelid.
I also remember (though I could be wrong!) school finishing at 4:30 and 4:00 in the winter when it was dark. Have I made this up?

Appleby11 · 02/04/2022 10:34

Year 6 kids should be given the trust and independence to get themselves to and from school. Especially when after the summer holidays they may be expected to get themselves to high school by walking or buses. They need to learn about the world don't they, easier to learn than be slung in.

ToCaden · 02/04/2022 10:34

I find it fascinating how much it varies. I started primary around mid 90s. Buses were at the top of a lane. We were just let out of the classroom around year one or two to either walk home, up to the bus, or to carpark (all diff directions). No supervision or checks. Not sure if there was a rule against younger kids walking home alone, but it did happen and no one seemed bothered after reception class.

School was in a village / small town though. Didn't hear of anyone being knocked over or kidnapped. Secondary school was in a busy town, and while kids were old enough to sort their own transport, due to area there were a lot of kids being hit by cars and even a few attempted kidnappings and assaults

Confrontayshunme · 02/04/2022 10:20

My DD did small parts of the school run independently at the beginning of Year 4 (all off road) then learned to safely cross the single road herself by the end of Year 4, and now halfway through Year 5, she is totally independent doing the 1.5 mile journey herself by bike. The school office just has you fill out a form saying she can be released herself, and no one ever suggested it wasn't allowed. It is my bugbear that parents allow children zero independence then expect them to be able to cope getting to and from secondary with no help. You have to work up to it, and it is more unsafe to let an 11 yo with no toad awareness out than a 9 yo who has had safe risks allowed.

SunonmyFace · 02/04/2022 10:15

3 tier system here. End of first school is year 4. Very normal that they are walking to school without adults by the end of year year 4. To go home without collection then the parent has to consent that the school can release them.
Year 5 is the first year of middle school, they all walk to and from school without adults. Granted in big friendship groups. It is very much the norm.

vdbfamily · 02/04/2022 10:14

From year 4 at my kids primary. ( youngest now about to sit GCSEs for context. When I was at primary school on 70's we walked home. I remember being met half way home by my 4 year old pre school brother who had come to meet us with my other brothers bicycle AND our German shepherd dog. My mother was both shocked and impressed when we all arrived home. she had another baby and had not noticed the 4 year old had disappeared!!

Thewolvesarerunningagain · 02/04/2022 10:13

I walked to primary school and back over a mile in the 80s. It was very normal, we lived in a quiet town in Devon, and I was only curb crawled a couple of times.
The 80s were a child abuse bonanza for a reason sadly.

AmyandPhilipfan · 02/04/2022 10:13

I do think that we infantilise perfectly capable children these days. My boys left primary in 2019 and 2020 and at their school you could go home alone from Year 5. But if you were being picked up by a parent you had to wait with the teacher until s/he had made eye contact with the parent and then marked you off on their clipboard and then you could go to your parent. Until 2019 we lived a 25 minute walk from school, with some busy roads, so I always collected my kids. But I was perfectly happy for them to come over to me without being checked off by the teacher, so I signed the form to say they could walk home alone and then usually met them at the first road. There was always a teacher at the gate too and on more than one occasion one certain teacher walked with one or both my boys along to the crossing, 100m from the school gate, where I was waiting at the other side, to make sure they got to me safely. I could literally see them as soon as they left the gate and was clearly going to watch them across the road so I’m not sure why she thought they weren’t safe? When I was in primary in late 80s/early 90s, the doors used to be opened and the children were told ‘if you’re going with a parent and they’re not here, come back to me’ and the kids were let out to find their own parent in the playground (or walk home alone) and trusted to return to the classroom if there was a problem. I think it should still be like that from Year 3 onwards, unless kids have SEN. We seem to be unable to allow kids any sense of responsibility these days.

It also used to really annoy me that if my child had left his coat or whatever in the classroom I couldn’t just say, ‘quickly go back and get it.’ No, he’d have to wait for the teacher to see off the rest of the class and then the teacher would have to escort him back in. I thought that showed a complete lack of trust in the children.

TheDogHasABone · 02/04/2022 10:12

I think it was 2007 I left primary. You certainly weren't allowed to walk home alone, even in year 6. It never crossed my mind some primary schools would allow this

britneyisfree · 02/04/2022 10:11

@RewildingAmbridge

I went to primary school in the eighties, it was a rite of passage that year six were allowed to walk home workout being collected by an adult, anyone younger wasn't. This was 25 years ago.
I went to school in the 90s. Started secondary in 98.

I was walking home alone with my brother (two years younger) from at least year 5 but I'm pretty sure it was year 4.

Swipe left for the next trending thread