Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To he appalled at this experience today

361 replies

User199999 · 01/04/2022 18:23

Hi.

I understand this sounds quite unbelievable but it is a genuine experience from today.

Myself, my mum and my DD went to a local charity shop which we have visited many times. My DD sometimes can have tantrums whilst out in shops, just normal toddler tantrums. Whilst in there my DD got a bit upset and kicked off a bit and was crying/throwing herself around. I knelt down and tried to calm her down. Next minute the shop keeper came storming over and tapped her a few times on the shoulder from behind saying ‘I think someone’s in a bad mood arnt they’ and got right in her face. I was in shock. She then pointed her finger right in DDs face like she was telling her off. I walked off with DD so I didn’t see this but my mum said the shop keeper pulled a really angry face and did a ‘strangling motion’ behind mine and DDs back. DD then got upset again and I picked her up to try and calm her but she got more upset. The Shop keeper said ‘I think she wants to be put down, doesn’t she’ in a really stern manner, like she was trying too belittle me.

My mum wanted to purchase something so we went to the que and when was getting served o said to DD ‘you’re tired arnt you’re and the shop keeper said ‘yes, I understand she wasn’t doing anything wrong but I’m very old fashioned’. I think this was very inappropriate. What are peoples opinions please.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 02/04/2022 15:02

OP has repeatedly said she would take DD out next time. Its easy to say with hindsight when she thought initially she could easily calm her DD. The shop assistant sounds bonkers and my DC never liked strangers getting up in their face or worst of all poking them, speaking harshly to the child and basically interfering in what the OP was trying to do to calm her. If she startled the OP she almost certainly startled the child and so its not surprising that the situation escalated.
All the while the OP's DM continued her browsing and didn't bother to lift a finger to help, even when the child was calling for her.
The OP agrees she needs to remove the DD more quickly in future, that's the end of it. But for all the comments saying that the child irritated the shop assistant - Its not normal to mime child strangling and if the rest of her behaviour was in line with that, she shouldn't be in a customer facing role.

S4M3 · 02/04/2022 13:17

@caringcarer

As your dd was being so badly behaved I would have removed her to outside. She will learn if she wants to be with Nanny she behaves in a shop or public area. I don't see why shop keeper should be subjected to your dd tantrums especially as you were not disciplining her.
This is a very interesting point that no one (in the previous 300+ replies) has thought to point out to the OP. 🙄

This post (like so many others before it for time infinity) needs a good burping - it is repeating on itself.

caringcarer · 02/04/2022 13:08

As your dd was being so badly behaved I would have removed her to outside. She will learn if she wants to be with Nanny she behaves in a shop or public area. I don't see why shop keeper should be subjected to your dd tantrums especially as you were not disciplining her.

londonrach · 02/04/2022 13:02

I'd have taken her out as soon as she started.

Youvebeengonesolong · 02/04/2022 12:55

@Walkaround

Except the OP had already accepted umpteen pages ago that she should have taken her toddler out of the shop. Not that she would have had the time before the volunteer initially interfered and exacerbated the situation. Nobody covered themselves in glory with their reactions, but the fact remains the volunteer’s intervention was inappropriate and unhelpful.
Er, I was agreeing with you in a way Walkaround. The fact that a sensible solution was agreed upon ages ago, means there is no need for endless discussion and drama about the op apparently not "standing up" for her dd or the volunteer having a potential brain injury.
Walkaround · 02/04/2022 12:44

Except the OP had already accepted umpteen pages ago that she should have taken her toddler out of the shop. Not that she would have had the time before the volunteer initially interfered and exacerbated the situation. Nobody covered themselves in glory with their reactions, but the fact remains the volunteer’s intervention was inappropriate and unhelpful.

Youvebeengonesolong · 02/04/2022 12:32

@Attictroll

I would have picked dd up and taken out of the shop for tantrum and weirdness doesn’t matter if your mum was buying something. Your mum could have quickly paid or helped dd calm down outside and returned to pay. Just forget about it but the best thing about toddlers is you can still pick them up and move them and every parent can remember there’s having tantrums
^^ Exactly this but I suspect this post is far too sensible a post for Mumsnet Grin
User199999 · 02/04/2022 12:27

Also yes it was definitely a prod on her shoulder as she used just one finger to do it, not her hand

OP posts:
User199999 · 02/04/2022 12:18

@chiefwiggumsboy I understand how it may seem that way to some people but she came over very quickly and I am not exaggerating when I say that she stormed over and came between myself and my DD. I know I say tapped in my original post but I think it was done more than just to get her attention as she did prod several times and quite hard. Enough to startle my DD and it definitely didn’t help to stop her crying. Also her tone of voice and the way she spoke to myself or DD wasn’t helpful either

OP posts:
Walkaround · 02/04/2022 12:15

@ChiefWiggumsBoy - do you like strangers tapping you repeatedly on the shoulder and telling you you’re in a bad mood? Would that make you feel more calm? It’s the action of someone who appears to think your behaviour is entirely controllable and can be instantly switched off - ironic if the person doing the shoulder tapping has reacted in this way because they cannot control their own reactions to sensory overload.

claretblue79 · 02/04/2022 12:01

@ThePlantsitter. Great post. I volunteer in a charity shop and these incidents do crop up, same as in any environment. In my opinion a bit of understanding and compassion goes a long way. We are trying to do our best at the shop and a kind word and a bit of patience goes a long way. Not impressed with the poster who put volunteers working in a charity shop in inverted commas though. There is a lot to do there and not everyone realises how much effort it takes to keep it running.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 02/04/2022 11:56

@Walkaround ok

I mean I kind of think that the most obvious answer is not that this woman was so filled with outright rage that she assaulted a toddler and made a threatening gesture, but that she tapped a child on the shoulder to try and distract them and then made a ‘bloody kids!’ gesture - but neither of us were there so we’ll have to agree to disagree.

Walkaround · 02/04/2022 11:52

@Porcupineintherough

the toddler didn’t choose to be in the charity shop

And so?

Self-evidently because they had the least agency over the situation. They were the most vulnerable and had the least power. The reaction of all concerned was understandable, but to say the toddler’s behaviour should have been controlled and they should be made to understand their behaviour was not appropriate and should be forcibly removed from the situation, but that the adults concerned might have disabilities that not only explain but also condone their behaviour, so that nothing should be said or done about it, is no more rational or reasonable than claiming the volunteer should not be allowed out in public.
RockinHorseShit · 02/04/2022 11:46

I'm appalled that you didn't stand up for your DD & tell the woman to back the fuck off out of her face whilst you were trying to deal with the situation.

Otherwise put it behind you, learn from it & next time speak up & call people out for interfering

Porcupineintherough · 02/04/2022 11:31

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn as it quotes a deleted post.

lollipoprainbow · 02/04/2022 11:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Attictroll · 02/04/2022 11:18

I would have picked dd up and taken out of the shop for tantrum and weirdness doesn’t matter if your mum was buying something. Your mum could have quickly paid or helped dd calm down outside and returned to pay. Just forget about it but the best thing about toddlers is you can still pick them up and move them and every parent can remember there’s having tantrums

Porcupineintherough · 02/04/2022 11:13

the toddler didn’t choose to be in the charity shop

And so?

Walkaround · 02/04/2022 10:54

Also, the toddler didn’t choose to be in the charity shop volunteering or shopping - they were forced to be there.

Walkaround · 02/04/2022 10:51

There is no mismatch whatsoever in pointing out the volunteer shop assistant was not acting in solidarity or being supportive, and was not being helpful. Yes, of course the volunteer could have disabilities that result in them being exceptionally self-centred in their responses to stress, and having particular sensory sensitivities. That would merely help explain their unhelpful, nasty reaction, but would certainly not condone it. The human least to blame in this scenario is the toddler, as at 2-years old, they have not yet had enough life to have learnt effective strategies to deal with sensory overload - they are pretty self-centred more or less by definition at that age.

swallowedAfly · 02/04/2022 10:45

I used to work with brain injured clients btw - one of whom I accompanied to her charity shop volunteer role once a week and who I'd accompany shopping, going for a drink etc. She could come across as rude, inappropriate (massively so with men as her inhibitions were shot), a 'weirdo' as people have delightfully called this woman.

You have no idea. She might have been too terrified to speak to anyone a year ago and is now clumsily managing to face the public in a charity shop and occasionally gets it wrong. She might have no idea that what she did was mis-pitched and caused offence.

Someone actually said on here that sen, mh etc was no excuse for inappropriate behaviour Confused ffs.

If you want consideration and the benefit of the doubt for you the cost is having the same for others. Otherwise you're just self centred and entitled and raising your children to be the same. Part of raising small people is teaching them to be considerate of others. If people did that more I wouldn't have got earache in the chemist yesterday listening to a young person shouting at someone on the phone and airing all of her intimate and uncomfortable business in a small quiet enclosed space. People are blatantly not being trained in basic stuff anymore because people think they and their needs should be tolerated without having to extend that courtesy to anyone else or obey all the little social rules that make life more bearable for everyone whatever their specific needs.

swallowedAfly · 02/04/2022 10:36

Toddler screaming must be tolerated and mother given compassion. An adult volunteer who for whatever reason, potentially sen, brain injury, mh etc, can't possibly be tolerated or shown compassion. No, she shouldn't be allowed to be public facing.

Does no one see the mismatch?

Everyone could do with being more understanding of the fact that some people can't easily conform to the standards you've decided they should be able to whether that's because they're 2 or because they sen or other traumatic or organic deficits.

Btw, and I know I'll be berated, not every child does have tantrums and not everyone has been there. Yes lots of toddlers do have tantrums and lots of parents struggle to deal with them however that doesn't mean everyone whose children didn't behave like this or who managed to avert behaviour escalating towards this is a liar or sanctimonious.

Walkaround · 02/04/2022 10:23

@ChiefWiggumsBoy

I honestly don't think any of this is something I would have been arsed about. A tantrumming toddler isn't fun, anyone who hasn't flicked the Vs or similar at their annoying kid is lying Wink. I would have read the reaction as more of a solidarity thing.

Put it this way - and you're absolutely free to have your own opinion of course - but is it more likely that this woman was aggressive and threatening towards a 2 year old, or that you were a little stressed and maybe embarrassed about her behaviour and that has coloured your thinking?

So no, I wouldn't complain, and I wouldn't have reacted the way you have at all. I would likely have rolled my eyes and done a 'kids!' type exclamation before manhandling the child outside.

I fail to see how making a strangling motion behind the parent’s and child’s backs is a gesture of solidarity - unless you mean solidarity towards the grandmother who saw the gesture. Supposed solidarity for the one is obvious hostility towards the others. I also don’t see how a hard poke of the child can be interpreted as being made with helpful intent when followed up with an aggressive gesture! The intention was clearly to make as public as possible the shop assistant’s negative opinion of the toddler and parent and was not even the tiniest bit helpful or supportive - it was in fact guaranteed to exacerbate the situation. No toddler in history has ever stopped a full in tantrum because a complete stranger poked them.
ThePlantsitter · 02/04/2022 09:23

Wow there are a lot of people being hard on other people in this thread. Every player in the story- the mum, the toddler, the grandma, the shopkeeper- has been criticized and slagged off.

In my opinion the shopkeeper was utterly inappropriate but so much so that there must be some other reason for her behaviour. She wasn't being paid either. The mum was doing her best to contain the tantrum and whatever you think after the fact it's not especially helpful to go on about it because when your kid tantrums in a shop it's bloody stressful and you do what you can! Carrying a flailing 2 year old through a load of clothes rails and bric-a-brac and onto the street where there may be cars and pedestrians would not be my first instinct either. The toddler was just doing the toddler thing and combat l couldn't help it. The grandma just made the common mistake of thinking you could do a nice little potter around the shops when you have a two year old with you - we've all done it (and how do children get life experience of you never take them anywhere in case they misbehave?)

Definitely one of those times to chalk up to experience but not necessary to examine the minutae of everyone's actions! Just humans being humans!

Brefugee · 02/04/2022 09:10

Just putting it out there - trying to have a calm chat with anyone, in fact any species - when they're over-threshold and having a melt-down is a big fat waste of everyones time.

agree. And yes, aybe the shop lady shouldn't have "tapped" the toddler on the shoulder, the "throttling" action - meh misguided but I agree it's not world-shaking. But the thing to do when you have children and people do that - tell them to stop. And then remove the child.

Sorry you lost your DP, OP, that must be very hard.

Swipe left for the next trending thread