Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think marriage is a thing of the past?

232 replies

StaceyP92 · 01/04/2022 12:28

So, I have 2 children, work part time - although could return full time in a heartbeat, own my
House. If we split I would then work full time and be able to afford to live by myself with the kids?

Why is going part time after babies seen as being financially dependant?

Also, my partner doesn’t have any other assets so I really don’t understand what this ‘no children before marriage’ statement is?

OP posts:
villamariavintrapp · 01/04/2022 13:07

Has your boyfriend/partner also gone part time since having the children? Did you split maternity leave? Do you share all the kids appointments/school runs/sick days equally between you? Have you been topping up your pension while your income has reduced? In most couples one person does more of the childcare and their finances are impacted more by having children than the other. In a marriage there is a legal framework that considers assets joint, so that if the marriage ended then assets would be split fairly. If you are not married then you are financially independent and there's no way to ensure any kind of fairness in retrospect.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 01/04/2022 13:07

Marriage is basically a legal contract with advantages and disadvantages

For some the disadvantages outweigh the advantages so that chose to remain unmarried
Some people marry to give protection to the weaker party (male or female)
Some people think the whole thing is pointless and don't marry despite the protection it gives (or they don't realise why).

Examples of the last being a woman having children, living in the mans house, giving up her job as he earns loads... them him moving on to a different woman leaving her with no home, job etc and children to care for. Thats the sort of people who need marriage.

It should be a carefully considered position.

There is also those who need marriage for Visa reasons, working abroad etc.

Blossom64265 · 01/04/2022 13:07

Even if women are higher earners who return to work full time, having children still impacts them negatively financially. There is also inherent risk involved to physically being pregnant and the unknown needs children might have that will demand career changes by at least one parent. Marriage mitigates these risks.

If you look at the demographics of who still chooses to marry, it is quite illuminating. Highly educated, high earners still overwhelmingly choose marriage before children. While other groups may be eschewing marriage, the people who probably need it the least still cling to it. It’s not because of tradition or morality, these groups also have very low rates of religious attendance and belief. Marriage remains a rational choice so it is still practiced.

Dropping marriage in other social groups seems linked to a couple of causes. One is entirely rational. Women no longer marry men that seem unworthy. Some of the others seem irrational. As I mentioned above, there appears to be a lack of acknowledgment in the inherent imbalance and risk surrounding pregnancy, childbirth, and parenting.

AllOfUsAreDead · 01/04/2022 13:04

Very typical narrow minded view of someone privileged. Shame.

MermaidEyes · 01/04/2022 13:03

@PastMyBestBeforeDate

As well as the obvious rights around property, there are other legal implications of being married or in a civil partnership particularly if one of you dies.

This. People always bang on about what happens if a couple get divorced, house, assets etc. Its not always about divorce. They seem to forget if one of you dies, unless you've made a will, the surviving partner could be up shit creek. I've seen it happen and it's awful to have to deal with when your partner dies unexpectedly.

Neongoddess · 01/04/2022 12:58

I am not getting married again.

I live with dp and my 2 older children. Was married to the kids dad.

I think yabu. I have the gold fortune to live in a cheapish area but earn alot. I moved here when I first divorced as I earned 25k and it was the nearest to my parents I could afford.

If you need someone else wage to pay part of your bills then you are financially dependent on them. If your parents pay your bills you would be financially dependent on them.

You seem to think that just going full time is an option for everyone. It's not working fulltime and having to use childcare or breakfast clubs and after school clubs is a struggle. When you are doing it alone it's harder.

Lots of people, even working fulltime as a single parent would struggle. Especially, if they all of a sudden find themselves homeless because their oartner has asked them to leave and the partner owns the house. Also if the partner earns more and has savings etc in their own name which you have no access to, there's no money ro move.

Marriage isnr the right thing for everyone. Its situation dependent. Some sahp are independently wealthy. Lots are not. Some people can go full time easy enough, some can not. Some people's kids have complex needs some do not. Some relationships are set up so they share money and property, with equal amounts in the both names and some are not.

Some people can afford to live off a part time wage. Some don't. Some people have lots in assets or kids with other people, some do not. Its about look at your own circumstances and trying to plan for a future where it doesn't go tits up.

If I went part time, I could pick up full time easy enough. I have quite a bit in assets. Dp is an adult with own money and we aren't having kids, so neither will be compromising our careers. So marriage isn't for us.

That doesn't make it pointless. And, quite frankly, the rhetoric of 'marriage is a thing of the past/just a piece of paper etc' has actively hated so many women that have gone along with it. The ones who find after spending years as sahm or in low paid part times jobs, their partner kicks them out and they have a struggle financially.

Marriage doesn't solve all problems and it doesnt guarantee you will be fine and never have to plan for the future. But for lots of people it's more sensible to marry.

Besides which, some people just really want to be married.thata fine too.

HardyBuckette · 01/04/2022 12:58

What do you think the 'right' reasons are OP? I'm of the view that those vary a lot depending on the people involved.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 01/04/2022 12:57

As well as the obvious rights around property, there are other legal implications of being married or in a civil partnership particularly if one of you dies.

youlightupmyday · 01/04/2022 12:57

Your circumstances are great for you but, newsflash, not everyone is you

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 01/04/2022 12:55

For many women, having children puts them in a financially dependent position on their male partner. Childcare is expensive and it is often women who step back from full time work with income and pension implications.

If you are not married then the partner making the childcare sacrifices may be left in the lurch if the other partner leaves.

In my case, it is DH who benefits from us being married as I was the asset owning high earner and he was the SAHP. I already owned a property before we married and earn multiples of his salary. Should I have left him unprotected?

StaceyP92 · 01/04/2022 12:54

I am not saying that I earn a crazy amount
Of money either, I am
Just saying I would have the option to go full
Time if I needed to and would afford to provide..granted we wouldn’t have the luxuries we have now but I’d still
Manage?

Sorry if you think I am being unreasonable maybe I am not putting this across well at all

OP posts:
Thejoyfulstar · 01/04/2022 12:54

Marriage is important for me. Its an institution and a commitment that has joined me to my husband in a way that nothing else can, including our children. It enables me to live out my Christian faith in a day to day way. It's more than just a piece of paper to me, or even some kind of legal çontract. It has a deep spiritual meaning that has changed my outlook and how I treat my husband. I totally get that many people don't share my views though!

InDubiousBattle · 01/04/2022 12:54

X post with you op. So it's your gran that's said something. If you feel that you want to explain why you're not married you can just say what you have in your op.

MurmuratingStarling · 01/04/2022 12:52

@StaceyP92 You are breathtakingly naïve and clueless.

ScarlettSunset · 01/04/2022 12:52

People who are not married have no financial obligations to each other. This can potentially impact on either partner, but after children, it is usually the women who ends up taking a hit to their finances.
In some families, it works out cheaper for one partner to stay at home with the children rather than send them to childcare. In the vast majority of cases, it is the woman who gives up her job to do this.
She is then not earning any income of her own and may not be building up any credits to her pension either. If the house is in the name of her partner, she also has no claim to that either.
If after a number of years, the couple split up, she is left with no rights to the house and often no money of her own, with her career prospects drastically reduced which may impact her for the rest of her life.
If the couple had been married, she would have been entitled to at least some of the assets that her husband had been able to build up (due to the fact he was working and earning throughout) which at the very least, could help her get back on her feet after their split.

MurmuratingStarling · 01/04/2022 12:52

What @CurlyToStraight said, is a much more common scenario for women with children than the scenario the OP claims to have.

StaceyP92 · 01/04/2022 12:52

I think it was when my Gran said..still
Not married…I always walk away thinking is that what we need to do to
Prove we are committed/love each other?

OP posts:
InDubiousBattle · 01/04/2022 12:50

Well in your case there may not be any benefit to getting married, you might not gain from it. Others do. Who's being pushy about it? I think it's fairly socially acceptable to not get married now, certainly compared to when my parents were young.

BoodleBug51 · 01/04/2022 12:50

I think it depends on which partner has the assets, tbh.

In your situation, no I wouldn't marry.

StaceyP92 · 01/04/2022 12:49

@HardyBuckette yes…maybe I could have worded it better,

My gran Said to me the other day, still
Not married the ? Why?!?

OP posts:
CurlyToStraight · 01/04/2022 12:48

@StaceyP92

So, I have 2 children, work part time - although could return full time in a heartbeat, own my House. If we split I would then work full time and be able to afford to live by myself with the kids?

Why is going part time after babies seen as being financially dependant?

Also, my partner doesn’t have any other assets so I really don’t understand what this ‘no children before marriage’ statement is?

Let me help you out by turning your post into mine:

So, I have one child, work part time. No option to go full time.
Don't own my own home. If we split I would struggle to find full-time work that would enable me to live by myself and my child as I am not highly educated. We agreed before we decided to have children that I would give up my full-time job (but not well paid) and become a SAHM and therefore I became financially dependant on my husband. I have no assets of my own so I don't understand what this "children before marriage" statement is.

That's why I am married. Well, apart from the probably more important fact that I love my husband and WANTED to be married to him!

Does that help? Can you really not see the pluses & minuses to different scenarios?

StaceyP92 · 01/04/2022 12:48

I want to
Marry for the right reasons though? Not with the intention that he might screw me over?

OP posts:
InDubiousBattle · 01/04/2022 12:46

Going pt is seen as being financially dependent because it usually is, at least to some degree. Your have to be on a pretty high salary for half (or whatever pt you're on)to be enough to pay for everything. Not everyone can return to ft in a heart beat.

stormswiftlysweetafton · 01/04/2022 12:46

Might not be for you, but it's premature to say it's a thing of the past. For many, it's still important, regardless of whether one has children or is financially self-sufficient.

StaceyP92 · 01/04/2022 12:46

I also didn’t have children until I knew I could provide for them by myself if the shit hit the fan?

What would I gain from
Being married? And why are people so pushy about it?

OP posts: