Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think marriage is a thing of the past?

232 replies

StaceyP92 · 01/04/2022 12:28

So, I have 2 children, work part time - although could return full time in a heartbeat, own my
House. If we split I would then work full time and be able to afford to live by myself with the kids?

Why is going part time after babies seen as being financially dependant?

Also, my partner doesn’t have any other assets so I really don’t understand what this ‘no children before marriage’ statement is?

OP posts:
Swayingpalmtrees · 01/04/2022 13:28

I agree having children is the bigger commitment out of the two.

Champsandbubbles · 01/04/2022 13:28

I have a good career and worked hard to be where I am. Together in our marriage it has allowed us to buy a bigger home in a nice area one that I can't afford on my own. As we've had children ive worked less hours, my husbands career soared. He works late and he depends on my to sort all evening childcare, (after 3/5pm) all bills, household tasks,shopping,
cooking cleaning.

If we were to split despite my good role I would be priced out purely from the area that we live. Our children are settled as am I and it would be upsetting to leave.

So could I support myself on my own, yes but would it be near to the only place my children know and I like, no

Legoisthebest · 01/04/2022 13:27

Next of kin?
Who would you prefer to make the decision to switch off your life support if the worst happened?
The person who is the father of your children and is also the person you are most likely to have had deep and meaningful conversations about life?
Or your (possibly elderly) parents?
Who would be your next of kin if your parents are gone? A random aunt? One of your children once they reach 18? Can you imagine a just turned 18 year old having to make that decision?

LadyHenryofRawlinsonEnd · 01/04/2022 13:27

I have never been married, although I have not had children either. I've lived a fairly arty lifestyle and very much valued my freedom and autonomy, although thankfully not at the cost of losing out on love and loyal commitments.
My own partner and I have lived both together and apart for over 30 years, and have separate finances, which we tend to share regardless. We also have wills!

However I do think women are still encouraged to 'marry well' whether this is said aloud or not. I see it quite often on this website. I shudder when I read such threads....

We are all different, and our differences, if well intentioned, deserve respect, so I should think people ought to marry if it has meaning for them.
Perhaps also to teach our daughters to become self sufficient and dependent upon no man. No matter how wealthy or sound he may seem, to rely upon another's generosity (and yes, even within a marriage) reduces a woman's personal power and ability to leave as a result of abuse.
Marriage for money/security rather hobbles women the world over, however lucky some may seem.

Ladies, find your own security, then marry, if you must :)

Swayingpalmtrees · 01/04/2022 13:26

You need to ask your family to stop talking about it if it upsets you. It looks like you are all set up, should things fail, and you have your head screwed on. You don't need to justify yourself and your life to anyone else including Granny. Just laugh and say Marriage is so last century Granny if she persists.

From your update you seem like you are not adverse to getting married? So why not have that conversation with dp if you want to? Or if you are happy, continue as you are. No one really cares these days, as long as both parties are protected properly financially.

maxineputyourredshoeson · 01/04/2022 13:26

I married DH because it was important to me. Honestly until I met him I was adamant I would never marry or have DC. When I met him that changed, I don’t know why just something did - cliché I know. We married when DD1 was 18mths, we didn’t know on the day, I was pregnant with DD2. I don’t know who was more surprised me or my parents that I totally changed my mind on marriage or kids.

If we were to divorce, or worse, DH was to die I would never remarry. I’m not at all religious but I married once and for life.

Awakened22 · 01/04/2022 13:24

I understand where your coming from - marriage seems like more of a choice now that’s dependent on personal circumstances/preference rather than a requirement. I grew up assuming that I would get married but not so sure now. I’m financially independent, own my home and whilst I would have to cut back on luxuries, I could afford to work full time with kids in nursery if/when I have them.

To me, having kids is a bigger commitment to a relationship then marriage but can also understand the need to have the correct legal protections in place whether through marriage, civil partnership, wills or some other means.

Thejoyfulstar · 01/04/2022 13:24

I have never seen any women advising others not to have children unless married on any parenting forum. Don't have kids with deadbeats/abusers/narcissists etc, yes, but the marriage things doesn't ring a bell and I've been on these forums for a good decade now.

Swayingpalmtrees · 01/04/2022 13:23

Well then marry him because he means the world to you?

Thats why I married my dh, he was and is the most wonderful human I have ever met.

Why don't you want to marry op?

Santaslittlemelter · 01/04/2022 13:22

@Swayingpalmtrees

Rather romantically dh and I got married to be one, to be a family, we share names, our home and our children and our dreams. It bonds us altogether.

For us it was a marriage of devotion, and I can not imagine a single day without him even twenty years later. If he died tomorrow, I would never remarry. I would never find someone like him. Marriage is not always just a legal contract, it is very often done to consolidate a deep love between two people.

Marriage is for life for many people, and brings great security, comfort and a deep sense of contentment.

And this is the real reason for marriage. Love, trust, devotion. Why would you have kids without that. And is not marrying a sign you don’t? In many cases it unfortunately is.
StaceyP92 · 01/04/2022 13:21

No, I am not married because it hasn’t come up yet, I would though, I just don’t see the absolute need!

OP posts:
Santaslittlemelter · 01/04/2022 13:20

@StaceyP92

I want to Marry for the right reasons though? Not with the intention that he might screw me over?
This is ironic because you are not marrying for the exact same reasons.
StaceyP92 · 01/04/2022 13:20

I would marry absolutely but I don’t want it to be based on the fact of if he screws me over 😢

OP posts:
StaceyP92 · 01/04/2022 13:19

@Swayingpalmtrees I actually love this!

OP posts:
StaceyP92 · 01/04/2022 13:18

I’m not privileged, we got a mortgage i new I could afford the repayments on if anything happened (nothing spectacular just a 3 bed semi) I also don’t have an amazing job, just enough to get me by if needed. How is that privileged? I’m not here for an argument at all! I just see a lot of threads of women who want children and then other women are posting saying you would be daft if not married, but it’s not always the case

OP posts:
Aroundtheworldin80moves · 01/04/2022 13:17

Our elder DD has citizenship rights through DH due to the circumstances of her birth which she wouldn't have been entitled to if we weren't married.

Swayingpalmtrees · 01/04/2022 13:16

I did mean every word of my post though

Swayingpalmtrees · 01/04/2022 13:16

Rather romantically dh and I got married to be one, to be a family, we share names, our home and our children and our dreams. It bonds us altogether.

For us it was a marriage of devotion, and I can not imagine a single day without him even twenty years later. If he died tomorrow, I would never remarry. I would never find someone like him. Marriage is not always just a legal contract, it is very often done to consolidate a deep love between two people.

Marriage is for life for many people, and brings great security, comfort and a deep sense of contentment.

Specter123 · 01/04/2022 13:15

You're part time. So your pension has taken a hit and will continue to do so. I assume you're doing more of the childcare because you're part time? This enables him to earn more than you through your contribution.

Marriage equalises that out. It means his money is your money and visa versa. It means if things go wrong, you get compensated for the hit on your pension and the extra hours childcare you've put in, for example.

That's before we get to the different rights granted by Marriage. If he died tomorrow, you wouldn't automatically keep your house or any of the possessions he bought (car, fridge etc)

Marrying for love is a very recent development. Marriage is a contract and provides legal protections for both parties. Without a Marriage, you don't have that.

Shurl · 01/04/2022 13:11

Tax implications, pension implications, legal implications, financial implications, romantic implications, and so on

Every couple looks at their situation assesses the risks associated and their wants and acts accordingly. You have just decided that in your circumstances you don't want to, that's ok. Other people come to different conclusions.

midsomermurderess · 01/04/2022 13:10

You seem to have started this thread just to have an argument and can't understand that not everyone is you. And why do you make almost every statement a question? Have the courage of your argumentative convictions and make a statement a statement. Christ, I hate up-speak.

Swayingpalmtrees · 01/04/2022 13:10

I will be advising my children to never marry and ensure they can always support themselves

Please don't let your bad experience influence their choices. I don't blame you for feeling bitter, but don't pass on the negativity. Encourage independence and let them make their own decisions.

merryhouse · 01/04/2022 13:09

@StaceyP92

I think it was when my Gran said..still Not married…I always walk away thinking is that what we need to do to Prove we are committed/love each other?
Well, in a sense... yes?

I mean it's entirely possible that your Gran is unaware of your particular situation and is thinking of your security from the viewpoint of someone who grew up in the 50s and 60s

but also, she probably does wonder why you haven't made the commitment.

(I'm presuming you haven't told her that you don't want to (a) because you think it won't last and you're protecting your assets or (b) because you think it would be giving in to patriarchal heteronormativity)

Swayingpalmtrees · 01/04/2022 13:08

Marriage seems a raw nerve for you op, if you are being asked when you are getting married and you are feeling so stressed about defending your own choices.

You don't have to get married. You can do what you like!

But it is worth noting for some women, marriage protects them from losing everything! Financially they are able to focus on having babies and working maybe part time for a number of years without being penalised when their husband walks out. It gives you legal rights to the house, to advocate for a husband in an accident/serious illness. You are legally bound together. There is a lot to be said for it! Without it your dh can walk anytime and take the house with him, and many women do not have access to good careers or financial advice.

So marriage before children is very suitable for many women.

IceVolcanoes · 01/04/2022 13:08

Tbh, in my position, I would have been much better off not marrying. Despite my husband earning over £100k (far more than I do), the courts consider him the financially weaker party because I made sensible decisions so I had assets and a good pension when I met him. Whereas he did not, and then gave it all to his ex in his first divorce. Apparently I’m supposed to compensate him for that.

I should not have married him. More fool me.

I will be advising my children to never marry and ensure they can always support themselves.

Swipe left for the next trending thread