Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think marriage is a thing of the past?

232 replies

StaceyP92 · 01/04/2022 12:28

So, I have 2 children, work part time - although could return full time in a heartbeat, own my
House. If we split I would then work full time and be able to afford to live by myself with the kids?

Why is going part time after babies seen as being financially dependant?

Also, my partner doesn’t have any other assets so I really don’t understand what this ‘no children before marriage’ statement is?

OP posts:
GnomeDePlume · 01/04/2022 14:51

Of course you can be committed and not be married. The problem is that without marriage/civil partnership your relationship doesn't legally exist. Day to day this doesn't matter.

Marriage/civil partnership matters when you need to prove that a relationship exists. Oftentimes this will be because there is a problem. One of you gets seriously ill or dies, the romantic relationship ends and you need to prove that the legal relationship existed.

Do you ever travel abroad? A poster on another thread had the awful experience of her DH suddenly dying while on holiday. She said the whole experience was awful enough but would have been many times worse if they hadn't been married.

Alaimo · 01/04/2022 14:50

DH and I got married for immigration reasons. We'd been together for almost a decade when we got married, so it's not like it was a scam marriage, but it was a change in migration/visa rules that provided the impetus for us to finally get married. Since then we've moved overseas for my job and it does make the whole visa/moving process a lot easier if you can just show a marriage certificate rather than a pile of paper work to prove that the relationship is serious. We don't have kids, but it's also comforting to know that if something were to happen to either of us the other would inherit any savings, property, etc.

HardyBuckette · 01/04/2022 14:49

@StaceyP92

No I just don’t want to be classed as some sort of idiot for not marrying before children.
Well, calling you an idiot because of it is rude and unhelpful.

However, if you would actually like to get married, and it sounds like you do, when people say it's better not to have DC first then yours is the sort of scenario people are talking about. Because if a man wants children, which I accept they don't all, and if they want to give them their surname, which nearly all of them seem to feel entitled to and odds are is what's happened in your case because it usually is, the woman agreeing to have DC before marriage is taking away one of the reasons to do it.

Blossom64265 · 01/04/2022 14:45

You can be committed without being married, but you won’t be legal and economic partners without a whole bunch of paperwork and legal wrangling and even then it will be a pale imitation of the easy partnership created by the government with one marriage form.

If something happens to my DH, I might have another romantic relationship, but I will never remarry or commingle finances because my economic commitment will be to my child, even if she is an adult. I won’t be looking for a partner again because that partner can’t possibly have the same shared goals.

You have to separate the romantic and the pragmatic for a moment. Marriage works when it’s based on love, but it is really a legal contract that spreads the risk of raising children. Mostly it protects women, but it can protect men too and that is good. It lets two people make decisions together knowing that their interests are somewhat shared. It’s also important to remember that their interests aren’t identical and a good marriage will make sure the decisions made within the marriage don’t put either party at a significant disadvantage should the marriage fail or one party become impaired.

HardyBuckette · 01/04/2022 14:45

@Anyfeckinusername

I feel like I hail from another planet because when people talk about marriage and husbands it’s like a foreign concept to me.

I’ve a great life, really good salary and two great kids. I would feel very weird about someone being in here with me for life… married, tied…. Just don’t get it!

I have never daydreamed about a white dress, marriage of any part of it. I have romantic love and all that, but marriage to me is just what??? I simply don’t get it.

And I’m pushed to do so because of stuff like tax etc.

Those laws need to go!

Then the push for this expensive club to join/ expensive club to leave will go away

Why should other people not be able to enter into a particular form of legal contract because you feel conflicted about it?
Neongoddess · 01/04/2022 14:45

@StaceyP92

No I just don’t want to be classed as some sort of idiot for not marrying before children.
So your problem isnt that marriage is a thing of the past.

Its not that you want to marry and he doesnt.

Its, actually, that some people know that having kids and going part time or being a sahp, without being married is often a bad idea and risky for women?

You just don't want them to have that opinion?

Whatalovelydaffodil · 01/04/2022 14:44

@StaceyP92

No I just don’t want to be classed as some sort of idiot for not marrying before children.
That's not nice if someone has said that to you. But, on the other hand, why would you marry after you have had children?
StaceyP92 · 01/04/2022 14:42

No I just don’t want to be classed as some sort of idiot for not marrying before children.

OP posts:
ZoeCM · 01/04/2022 14:40

And I’m pushed to do so because of stuff like tax etc.

Those laws need to go!

Then the push for this expensive club to join/ expensive club to leave will go away

The whole point of marriage is that it's a legal contract. If you remove the laws around it, it becomes meaningless.

Kingharoldshairstyle · 01/04/2022 14:38

You seem really angry and agitated. Why start a thread saying marriage is a thing of the past then declaring you’d love to be married but basically he’s not asked you (so doesn’t wish to ).

Whatalovelydaffodil · 01/04/2022 14:37

@StaceyP92

Can you be committed without being married? Because I know I am?
Yes Of course you can . But getting married makes it more official and you become legally tied to eachother.
Strokethefurrywall · 01/04/2022 14:34

I chose marriage as I wanted the foundation of stability before we had children.
But romance is bullshit and intertwining it with marriage is where society goes wrong - marriage is not, and should not be something dangled in front of a woman's face as a carrot, like they're the ones that win the prize if a man wants to marry them.
It is a merger contract, signifying the intention to intertwine finances and convey that financial protection over both parties (and children by default).

Women are constantly told they can have everything and yet continue to put their trust in men who don't deliver, and tie themselves to these dickheads by having children with them. Children that they're inevitably left in sole care of women when these men fuck off elsewhere.
At least if you marry the dickhead, it's harder for them to leave you with nothing.

I'm very lucky that I was a high earner before I got married and had no option to work anything other than full time so have never had to sacrifice my career or growth.
But childcare in UK is so expensive that it doesn't allow for women to retain their independence and therefore men continue to "win" when it comes to having a family.

But honestly OP, if you don't realise that everyone's situation is different then there's no educating you is there...

HardyBuckette · 01/04/2022 14:32

The OP is sort of right in the sense that if you two earning partners with their own assets marriage is completely pointless.

Not in the slightest. At different ends of the spectrum, couples might find access to the full range of bereavement benefits or IHT exemptions when one dies to be very useful and desirable.

HikingforScenery · 01/04/2022 14:22

I’m married because that’s what we both wanted to do before children. I wouldn’t be with someone who didn’t want that. Neither would DH.
You sound like you’re not happy with your situation tbh. Speak to your partner, if that’s the case.

Fundays12 · 01/04/2022 14:19

I am married because we both wanted to be. Our 3 kids were born after we were married as that’s what we both wanted. It was the right decision for me and dh and being married is important to us. However I would never judge anyone who has kids and isn’t married. That’s there business not mine.

Swayingpalmtrees · 01/04/2022 14:17

The question isn't really your commitment op, is he committed to you?

Have you covered all the bases in terms of death, wills, estate, incapacitation.

Is he going to stay with you if you lost your legs one day in a car accident? He may not if you were married, but at least you have guaranteed half the assets and pensions etc.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 01/04/2022 14:15

There are good reasons for people in @burnoutbabe's situation for example. And that's a considered decision. It's women who drift into a weaker financial position in a relationship without really being aware of it that are at risk. I know someone whose dp threw her and the dc out when she objected to his affair. She was a SAHM and the house was in his name. She has now moved in with another man (his house) and works in his company. He seems decent but she's still vulnerable. If he dumps her or dies she's got nothing again.

EmpressCixi · 01/04/2022 14:13

@StaceyP92

I also didn’t have children until I knew I could provide for them by myself if the shit hit the fan?

What would I gain from
Being married? And why are people so pushy about it?

And how will your partner provide for them if the shit hits the fan and you die? And he inherits fuck all of your estate, loses his home because you own it and he has no rights to it and he gets no bereavement allowance because you never bothered to put a ring on his finger?
StaceyP92 · 01/04/2022 14:11

Can you be committed without being married? Because I know I am?

OP posts:
Whatalovelydaffodil · 01/04/2022 14:10

[quote StaceyP92]@MurmuratingStarling you are assuming I have a well paid career, why would I have to be earning a really high amount of money to afford mortgage, bills etc by myself? What I don’t understand is the big no no to kids before marriage?????[/quote]
Because marriage normally means you have committed to that person. It make sense to have a committed relationship before you have children.

Swayingpalmtrees · 01/04/2022 14:04

I would second what others have said. I became seriously ill a few years ago, out of the blue. I could not work (or do anything) for two years. I would have felt very frightened to be in that position and unmarried. It could just walk out on me...not that he would, but I could not pay a mortgage or a bill or anything. I have not been able to work again properly since.

We don't know what is around the corner, so any extra security even for the remote chance you will need it, is a really good idea. A plan B if you are incapacitated etc. We will always think we are loved, and healthy and bad things won't happen but that is an illusion of the young.

You have been together for a long time, a very long time, if you want to be married ask him! Perhaps with some chats in the run up so he is expecting it.

Scottishskifun · 01/04/2022 13:58

There are many reasons why people marry some advantages are marriage tax, cheaper bills especially things like life insurance, automatic rights for the father, automatic next of kin, no issues travelling with children with separate surnames etc etc etc.
For women it can provide security especially if a house is in husbands name.

Marriage ultimately is personal choice for many women it offers greater protection. I personally married because I wanted to show that ultimate commitment to a life with my husband. That's my feelings on marriage though and everyone is different.

burnoutbabe · 01/04/2022 13:58

i won't benefit from being married (no kids, i have house mortgage free)

Therefore I won't marry

Showing other people our commitment is not enough upside to the LOSE 50% of my assets downside.

Cameliah · 01/04/2022 13:57

I have never daydreamed about a white dress, marriage of any part of it
Me neither. I went to the register office in a blue suit and they drew up a legal contract to protect my financial investment in this relationship. The marriage contract protects me from being financially disadvantaged because I’ve birthed his child and provided him with domestic support. It ensures that in the event of separation or death I get my fair share of assets. It also ensures that we can legally make decisions for each other in the event that one of us is incapacitated. Romance has nothing to do with it.

RewildingAmbridge · 01/04/2022 13:53

I got married despite being the higher earner bringing more assets to the marriage. It is an indication of commitment for most people, whilst divorce is possible I do believe people are more likely to work on a marriage before walking away, which is much easier to do with no legal ties. I made it clear that I wouldn't consider children without being married both DH and my other previous long term partner respected that, that's not too say I'm very traditional or conservative I had plenty of wild times in my youth, it was just a hard line for me, a signal that we're in this forever and that's what I needed before thinking about babies . I like being married. It wasn't an insurance policy for me, I could support DS alone and so could DH although life wouldn't be as comfortable for either of us.

I would always advocate it for anyone who intends to put themselves in a financially precarious position following children, but that wasn't my motivation.