Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think marriage is a thing of the past?

232 replies

StaceyP92 · 01/04/2022 12:28

So, I have 2 children, work part time - although could return full time in a heartbeat, own my
House. If we split I would then work full time and be able to afford to live by myself with the kids?

Why is going part time after babies seen as being financially dependant?

Also, my partner doesn’t have any other assets so I really don’t understand what this ‘no children before marriage’ statement is?

OP posts:
HighOnPie · 01/04/2022 16:14

On MN, marriage is often discussed as solely a financial transaction between two people. When DH proposed to me, he did so because of plain old love and devotion. We married for purely romantic reasons!

What we get out of being married cannot be measured, it has huge benefits to our health and mental well-being, the sense of stability being married provides is very reassuring; we are a solid team and being married only serves to reinforce this. It may only be ‘a piece of paper’, but marriage is very different to simply living together as a couple.

Marriage makes a lot of people very happy and content, although it may often seem the polar opposite case on MN. Marriage isn’t going anywhere, well not for a long time, anyway

IncompleteSenten · 01/04/2022 16:13

If every woman was in your situation or better then it possibly would be a thing of the past.

But many women have children with men, unmarried and give up their jobs to raise his children, in his house, paying into no pension scheme, getting no career advancement, gaining no employment skills and if the relationship breaks down she's left with minimal child support or none if he chooses to be a twat, no right to half the house, no claim on his pension, no up to date job skills and often fuck all savings.

She's royally fucked. So my advice is never give up your job and your financial independence to be a sahm for a man you aren't married to (and ideally not even then!)

Mia85 · 01/04/2022 16:12

@StaceyP92

My point wasn’t that I didn’t want to, just that people say you ‘should’ before children
People say this because:
  1. Having children is often the point at which one parent takes a step back to become SAHP/part-time/less pressured role at work and it is not fair for that person to take all the financial risk of that decision. Marriage gives some protection from that risk.
  1. Once you have dependent children you should have plans for what happens if things go wrong e.g. one of you dies. Part of that is making sure the surviving parent is in as good a finanicial position as possible You don't need marriage for that but it makes things easier.
  1. Money and time tend to be in short supply with young children so planning the wedding first is often more sensible if you know you want to eventually.

Of course that doesn't mean everyone thinks you 'should' or that it's right for everyone but they are good reasons to think about.

Figgygal · 01/04/2022 16:11

You're talking absolute nonsense op
And seemingly you do actually want to get married after all

MurmuratingStarling · 01/04/2022 16:10

@AChocolateOrangeaday

Who are you trying to kid OP?

Yourself or us?

This. ^
AChocolateOrangeaday · 01/04/2022 16:07

Who are you trying to kid OP?

Yourself or us?

thepeopleversuswork · 01/04/2022 16:04

@Swayingpalmtrees

Marriage is not always just a legal contract. It is very often done to consolidate a deep love between two people

That’s the ideal and the template that a lot of (mainly women) have in their heads.

But while loving the person you’re married to is a great thing to aspire to I actually think this attitude is responsible for a lot of damage in society.

It makes women idealise marriage and see it as a solution and endgame in itself and disincentivises them from becoming economically independent which is the only true way to protect yourself.

I think women would do themselves a great favour by decoupling a lot of the romantic nonsense around marriage and become more hard nosed about it.

JustLyra · 01/04/2022 16:02

@StaceyP92

I’m not privileged, we got a mortgage i new I could afford the repayments on if anything happened (nothing spectacular just a 3 bed semi) I also don’t have an amazing job, just enough to get me by if needed. How is that privileged? I’m not here for an argument at all! I just see a lot of threads of women who want children and then other women are posting saying you would be daft if not married, but it’s not always the case
Is it a joint mortgage?

If so can you afford to buy him out?
Can you afford the deposit and fees on a new place if he forced a sale?

While you’ve been working part time have you (joint you) been paying into a pension as you would have if you worked full time or has your pension taken a hit?

Calennig · 01/04/2022 16:02

@StaceyP92

My point wasn’t that I didn’t want to, just that people say you ‘should’ before children
Having children can adversally impact on women's careers - doesn't always and sometimes men become SAHD.

Previous generations had greater stigma attacked to children out of wedlock and fewer work opportunities and less legal protection.

I do think it's much more normal than in prior decades to have kids first however many people can and do marry before children or marry never wanting children.

piglet81 · 01/04/2022 16:01

It sounds like you would like to be married, @StaceyP92, so why don’t you propose to him?

Do you own your house as joint tenants or tenants in common? Do you have wills, and are you the beneficiaries for each other’s pensions/life insurance etc? Marriage is a simple and cost-effective way of dealing with what could be lots of paperwork in one go.

Ponoka7 · 01/04/2022 16:00

@StaceyP92

"My DP has put my as his next of kin for life insurance etc but I’m not too sure why haha?"

Because with out that you aren't his next of kin and can't necessarily carry out all the bits needed to close bank accounts, collect his body, arrange a funeral, collect any money and inherit from him. Who is his legal next of kin?

My DH had a twat of a family, when he got cancerous brain tumors and had to be detained under the MH Act, as his wife I was his next of kin and got a say. His family don't believe in MH/medical conditions are big anti treatment/Vax and if I was battling them it would have been a bigger nightmare.

He's put you on now and you can make wills, but he can also change that without you knowing. As his wife you'd have rights. Men are notorious for getting a new family and bio kids being fucked over.

Calennig · 01/04/2022 15:58

@Hercisback

As you've just proved, marriage being a benefit or a potential cost, depends on the circumstances of the couple.
This.

It's also these days just as normal to get married post having children as before - change in PR rights possibly helped that along but was already a trend.

It's a legal state - not just a social thing - and that frequently gets overlooked.

Citizens advise Living together and marriage: legal differences.

Lulu1919 · 01/04/2022 15:48

No my daughter who is 27 is getting married this summer and her sister 29 got married 18 months ago ...so I don't agree !!

MurmuratingStarling · 01/04/2022 15:46

@StaceyP92

My point wasn’t that I didn’t want to, just that people say you ‘should’ before children
Confused
MurmuratingStarling · 01/04/2022 15:45

@Minatrina

And, quite frankly, the rhetoric of 'marriage is a thing of the past/just a piece of paper etc' has actively harmed so many women that have gone along with it. The ones who find after spending years as sahm or in low paid part times jobs, their partner kicks them out and they have a struggle financially.

Agree with this. I have a friend with a delightful (read: awful) partner who's convinced her that marriage is a pointless piece of paper. She's now pregnant and is planning on giving up her job to become a SAHM and live in her boyfriend's house. I have gently tried to make her realise how much marriage could protect her but she won't have it because he's convinced her that it's uncool to get married Hmm

Also OP, a lot of people just think getting married is a romantic and frankly obvious thing to do idk what to tell you 🤷‍♀️

That's sad. I can't believe anyone would give advice to any woman to have babies with a man and NOT get married.

As a previous poster said, interestingly, it's well-educated, professional women who are more likely to get married. Because they know it's the sensible thing to do.

StaceyP92 · 01/04/2022 15:43

My point wasn’t that I didn’t want to, just that people say you ‘should’ before children

OP posts:
MurmuratingStarling · 01/04/2022 15:37

@StaceyP92

My DP has put my as his next of kin for life insurance etc but I’m not too sure why haha?

I love him more than anything in the world I really do. Would love to get married if would say yes if he asked of course, it just hasn’t come up yet. I’ve had my fair share of mental health issues since the kids came along so probably made him feel he was taking a risk hahah!

Wait what? So NOW you say you want to get married? Make your mind up. Hmm
MurmuratingStarling · 01/04/2022 15:25

@Swayingpalmtrees

Rather romantically dh and I got married to be one, to be a family, we share names, our home and our children and our dreams. It bonds us altogether.

For us it was a marriage of devotion, and I can not imagine a single day without him even twenty years later. If he died tomorrow, I would never remarry. I would never find someone like him. Marriage is not always just a legal contract, it is very often done to consolidate a deep love between two people.

Marriage is for life for many people, and brings great security, comfort and a deep sense of contentment.

@Swayingpalmtrees

Don't need a sick bowl. This is actually lovely. Smile

Minatrina · 01/04/2022 15:17

Another thing for me is that I love my husband and he loves me - if we were to split up, which many couples do, we don't want either of us to be shafted by financially. That's why we got married, to protect ourselves and each other. I'm sure most people feel the same about their partner (of course, by the time you're at the divorce stage you may feel differently 🤣 but the point is you don't feel like that at the time when you marry)

BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 01/04/2022 15:06

Statistically, you aren’t wrong OP. According to most recent figures for England and Wales, marriage rates have been decreasing for a while (www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsdeathsandmarriages/marriagecohabitationandcivilpartnerships).

That said, marriage is still a popular option that is beneficial to most women (thanks to inequalities in wages, career progression and biological realities of pregnancy & childbirth). A friend who works in the wedding industry is absolutely rushed off her feet and certainly hasn’t noticed a lack of customers.

NowEvenBetter · 01/04/2022 15:01

@Anyfeckinusername
Nah, those laws do not ‘need to go!’
It’s important that people opt in to getting legal status and protections, not just organically evolve them after shagging for a certain amount of time. Rightly so that boyfriends/girlfriends have zero protections, that’s their choice.

Toomuch2019 · 01/04/2022 15:00

I love my husband but didn't marry because of it.

We got married primarily to ensure that we got equal rights to death in service pensions (our organisation had different rules for married couples at the time). And for next of kin reasons too. It just made things much simpler

For anyone working part time I would encourage marriage, if you don't marry you can maybe go full time again and live month by month fine but you will have missed all those years of pension contributions for your old age.

MintJulia · 01/04/2022 14:56

I think there is such a variety of circumstance now.

I had a dc in my 40s by which time I owned my house outright. DP had two adult children by a previous marriage who were still living at home in his house.

So while we were delighted with news of pregnancy, his dcs weren't. Under those circumstances I chose not to marry or co-habit. It was better to remain separate.

StCharlotte · 01/04/2022 14:52

DH and I are on a fairly even keel financially and both owned our own properties before we got together. We'd both cope financially if we split up.

Emotionally however, I bloody love being married and that's what it's about for me.

A family member has five children and has been engaged for longer than I've been married (over 20 years). If her DP left her, she'd be utterly screwed.

Whatever works for you may not work for others. Doesn't make you right. Or necessarily wrong.

It's horses for courses OP.