Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government to ban LGB conversion therapy but not T.

38 replies

BowtieBling · 01/04/2022 08:51

Aibu to think this sounds right?
My understanding, which despite me reading a lot of the media around this today could be all wrong.
I take it to be that actions such as 'praying away the gay' and other harmful abhorrent practices are to be legally banned but the government are holding off on this being LGBT conversion therapy just now.

My understanding is that when it comes to Trans they are holding off.
Does that mean that talking therapy for those questioning their gender remains an accepted practice?
Would talking therapy come under conversion therapy?
Surely considering changing gender, facing operations, taking medication in order to change gender is helpful in the same way that therapy for other body dysmorphia exists and is accepted/encouraged for example in the case of eating disorders?

I have enabled voting

YANBU - Of course LGB conversion should be banned. The T needs more careful consideration.

YABU - Conversion therapy should be banned for all under the LGBT umbrella

OP posts:
EishetChayil · 01/04/2022 12:18

The trans-rights lobby have tried to push their insidious laws through by hitching their wagon to the LBG movement. Thank fuck it hasn't worked on this occasion.

Mumsnut · 01/04/2022 12:17

I think it's right that there should be a disctinction between the LGB and the T.

When my son was at school, several of the boys in his form announced that they were gay, or bi. None is so now. And so what? They tried a little exploration , with no consequences.

With my daughter's cohort, the flirtation is with gender. A significant number are clamouring for binders, puberty-blockers, and 'top surgery'.

If they follow the boys' path, some if not all will change their minds later. But will they have damaged their bodies irretrievably in the mean time?

BowtieBling · 01/04/2022 12:12

If you've fully read and understand the proposed legislation, I haven't as yet only the news articles @AuntieMorag is it right that a student exploring these issues with a teacher may lead to the Teacher being at risk of disciplinary?

OP posts:
BowtieBling · 01/04/2022 12:06

OK @ChristinaXYZ so talking withing a trusted adult is classed as conversion therapy but talking with a therapist isn't?

OP posts:
AuntieMorag · 01/04/2022 12:05

I did read the proposed legislation. I also work with therapists, including CAMHS therapists, who have such conversations with their clients. All were appalled that the legislation was being shelved, and now also appalled that it's been un-shelved, but removing the Trans parts.

Again there is a big difference between conversations between someone with questions, and conversion therapy. Having a conversation, whether a therapist or friend or relative, that explores all the options, is NOT conversion therapy. Conversion therapy is 'therapy' that CURES you of your desires, and as such, would not include any form of looking at all options. It's basis is that LGBT is wrong, an illness, and thus can be cured and the desires removed. There's no open conversation. If a therapist stated that the person questioning their gender was wrong with no discussion, and suggested they could cure of them of these feelings, then THAT would be conversion therapy. And frankly, any therapist that does that deserves to be struck off anyway.

ChristinaXYZ · 01/04/2022 11:46

*mentoring conversation - para 2 typo

ChristinaXYZ · 01/04/2022 11:44

@AuntieMorag

No, talk therapy with a qualified therapist is not covered under conversion therapy and is vital for anyone questioning, or considering, transitioning. So again, it is not considered conversion therapy.

Talk therapy is also very useful for those who struggle with any aspect of their lives.

You are confusing two very, very different things.

But people, especially children, will want to and should have the right to discuss gender issues with other adults not just qualified therapists - their parents and other adult relations, their teachers, other adults they might come into regular contact with.

Example: girl, a bit of tomboy, plays football and whose right-on mates at school are trying to 'affirm' her into thinking she's a boy because she also does not like pink, sparkles, etc. She might raise it with her tomboyish woman football coach. Who might say, 'Slow down, perhaps you're going to be a woman who likes football, perhaps you might work out that you're a lesbian, perhaps not. No rush. Girls can like football. Don't let people tell you what you are.' A reasonable reaction and the kind of menroing conversation many adults might have with a young person.

But with threat of non-professionals being prosecuted - what would the woman coach say: 'I can't talk about that with you.' Teen reaches out and is pushed away, into the arms of the no-debate mates who without even fully realise what they are doing are potentially transing away the gay.

Bad enough to push the kid away if you're a football coach or teacher - but if you're the kid's parent of elder sibling or aunt??

Awful law, badly thought through. And problems caused by lumping the T with the LGB - sex and sexuality are not the same, they need different laws, different protections, different discussions. They need to be treated seriously not as 'identities to worn on a lanyard or pro-nouned at the end of an email.

VestaTilley · 01/04/2022 11:44

Sounds a very sensible move.

purpleboy · 01/04/2022 11:42

The impression I got was that talking therapy would also be banned, which sounds dangerous considering the 4000% increase in young girls being referred to the gender identity clinics.

If someone has evidence to show I'm wrong I'd love to see it, as I have seen talking therapy included in the ban.

BowtieBling · 01/04/2022 11:11

The articles I've read mention talking therapies as being conversion therapy @AuntieMorag
So I wouldn't be the only one confused.
It's one of the reasons I'm asking the question.

What is considered conversion therapy towards the trans community?
Difficult to know if you support the stance or not if the therapy being discussed isn't clear

OP posts:
nothingcomestonothing · 01/04/2022 09:35

The proposed law was an absolute dog's dinner, and would have resulted in therapists being too scared to explore gender with clients at all, or even under threat of being struck off for doing anything other than 100% agreeing that the client is trans. Therapy should help clients question, explore, and reach their own best answers, the proposed ban would have squashed that for gender questioning young people.

LGB conversion therapy is of course wrong (and I think from memory was found to be very rare in this country?) but mandating therapists to just affirm gender would have been wrong too.

AuntieMorag · 01/04/2022 09:33

No, talk therapy with a qualified therapist is not covered under conversion therapy and is vital for anyone questioning, or considering, transitioning. So again, it is not considered conversion therapy.

Talk therapy is also very useful for those who struggle with any aspect of their lives.

You are confusing two very, very different things.

Gowithme · 01/04/2022 09:20

When I saw the headline I thought they were holding off on banning any conversion therapy including LGB. But if it's just the T they're holding off on then I think that's very good news. We know without a shadow of a doubt that conversion therapy for the LGB community is very damaging and doesn't work. When it comes to the T things are a lot more complicated, particularly with the number of autistic children that come to feel they are T and the number of young girls and old men that think they are T ( in contrast to the numbers of young men and older women).

I think the term 'conversion therapy' is very damaging though. It suggests that you're trying to change a person into someone they're not. I think 'gender exploration therapy' or something along those lines would be better. Gender has become a very dangerous and toxic concept IMO, where people who don't fit into the terrible male/female stereotypes think there must be something wrong with them and as a result, that they must be non binary (which is meaningless) or trans (which can have very serious long term implications). Gender is a social construct ie made up by people, it should not be something we're all so concerned about just because we don't fit into the stereotypes.