Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government to ban LGB conversion therapy but not T.

38 replies

BowtieBling · 01/04/2022 08:51

Aibu to think this sounds right?
My understanding, which despite me reading a lot of the media around this today could be all wrong.
I take it to be that actions such as 'praying away the gay' and other harmful abhorrent practices are to be legally banned but the government are holding off on this being LGBT conversion therapy just now.

My understanding is that when it comes to Trans they are holding off.
Does that mean that talking therapy for those questioning their gender remains an accepted practice?
Would talking therapy come under conversion therapy?
Surely considering changing gender, facing operations, taking medication in order to change gender is helpful in the same way that therapy for other body dysmorphia exists and is accepted/encouraged for example in the case of eating disorders?

I have enabled voting

YANBU - Of course LGB conversion should be banned. The T needs more careful consideration.

YABU - Conversion therapy should be banned for all under the LGBT umbrella

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ChristinaXYZ · 02/04/2022 14:58

I think this thread by a transwoman on twitter on the importance of talk is important:

"If I could have found a way, through therapy, of avoiding it [surgery] I'd have gladly accepted it ..."

twitter.com/Strobe_Lightly/status/1510179485034897409

wasibat · 02/04/2022 10:37

@blameitonthecaffeine

wasibat people are wrong about their sexuality all the time, surely? Especially when growing up. Lots of people change their minds about their sexuality at all times of life. Not saying there's anything wrong with that and certainly not that conversion therapy has any place in society but I don't think it's as simple as a decision on sexuality is correct and a decision on gender identity may or may not be.

I don't think there should be legislation on talking and advice on any issue. Sometimes adults give young people bad advice. But I don't think it's fair to make that a prosecutable or sackable offence. Conversion therapy is a whole lot more than advice though, it's sinister, proactive and abusive. I didn't know it was still legal tbh.

Thanks, blameitonthecaffeine . You may be right, in a way. But 'being wrong about one's sexuality' is very different from being wrong about whether one is trans, I think.

Yes, a child may think she is gay because she is sexually attracted to another girl, then later find she is sexually attracted to boys. That happens, sure. But the point I wanted to make was that the attraction felt is self-validating in the sense that if I feel I am attracted to someone then I am attracted to that person. So, in this sense, one cannot be mistaken about who one is attracted to.

One can, by contrast, be mistaken about being trans. The distinction, then, blends into what we might describe as overall self-description. Based on this self-validatory aspect of attraction, If someone (child or adult) tells us "I am gay", and they are sincere, it makes no sense to tell them they are just wrong. By contrast, if someone (a daughter, say) tells us "I am a boy", then their sincerity will not validate their claim, especially in the light of contemporary discourse around 'trans'. What they say might be true, but it need not be, no matter the sincerity of its utterance.

I can be mistaken about whether I am trans in a whole other sense, in other words, from any way in which I could be mistaken about being gay.

This is especially important, it seems to me, with children. We should treat a child claiming to be gay differently from a child claiming to be trans with regard to their self-description. Thus, in other words, T should be separated from LGB with regard to possible so-called 'conversion'. You might agree with this conclusion even while allowing for confusion in a child's mind about who she is attracted to as her sexuality develops.

[In a sense, of course, this point applies a fortiori to adults whose adolescent confusion about developing sexuality has settled down. It would make no sense to call a mature person's sincere avowal of her own sexuality into question: the self-description "I am gay" cannot be false if sincerely avowed, whereas many other sincere self-descriptions could accurately be described as delusive ("I am smart", "I am Elvis reincarnated" ...).

It does seem, prima facie , that sincere avowals such as "I am a man" or "I am a woman" are likely to fall into the latter category of non-self-validating self-descriptions in our contemporary discourse. That is a slightly different argument, perhaps. The very fact of this being arguable, however, bolsters the case for splitting T from LGB, given the unarguable fact that, although I may lie about my sexuality, I cannot be mistaken about it in any ordinary sense of the word.]

blameitonthecaffeine · 01/04/2022 23:43

wasibat people are wrong about their sexuality all the time, surely? Especially when growing up. Lots of people change their minds about their sexuality at all times of life. Not saying there's anything wrong with that and certainly not that conversion therapy has any place in society but I don't think it's as simple as a decision on sexuality is correct and a decision on gender identity may or may not be.

I don't think there should be legislation on talking and advice on any issue. Sometimes adults give young people bad advice. But I don't think it's fair to make that a prosecutable or sackable offence. Conversion therapy is a whole lot more than advice though, it's sinister, proactive and abusive. I didn't know it was still legal tbh.

nolongersurprised · 01/04/2022 23:35

It’s very telling I’m these threads as well. As soon as people start to question or discuss children transitioning posters always say - you don’t want us to exist! You want to take away our rights!

Almost as though they are trying to shut the conversation down

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 01/04/2022 23:19

Transing gay kids is conversion therapy

This. In a nutshell.

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 01/04/2022 23:18

I agree with the move. LGB people, do not need or want hormones and drugs to validate what they are.

But the scary amount of children being affirmed that they are born in the wrong body, need to take puberty blockers and such, is fucking scary. You don't need to affirm a 10 year old child.

Watchful waiting is the sensible approach.

At the moment, gay kids are being taught if they don't conform to gender norms, they might be trans.

They're not. They're just gay. They need time to discover and explore these feelings before being affirmed and medicalised.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 01/04/2022 23:18

The issue is we were meant to have an investigation into why teenage girls are suddenly claiming to be boys at 13/14. When they are at their most awkward and discovering their sexual orientation.

The reasons are not the same as the grown men, many who have spent their entire adult lives as straight men and even fathered children before claiming they were women, but we must pretend they are the same despite being two very different demographics.

Suddenly hitting puberty and being uncomfortable with your body and the change in the way society, especially men, sees you is perfectly normal. Girls being coerced into believing puberty needs medicating or that their discomfort means they must be men is ridiculous.

A large portion of these girls are same sex attracted. Transing gay kids is conversion therapy.

As has also been pointed out, how come the adult males get to say they are trans with no dysphoria or even without making any changes at all, but the teenage girls are pushed to drugs and surgery on their perfectly healthy bodies, in order to be their true selves?

nolongersurprised · 01/04/2022 22:58

It’s a sensible move, especially for doctors who work with young people and not at all comparable to the LGB.

It doesn’t matter what the fine print says if the effect is to deter the people who can refer to gender clinics from actually asking questions. No GP or paed wants their already busy day-to-day working life being mixed up with legal mess, even if that will eventually be thrown out.

Scenario one : 14 year old girl presents with parents.
Parents : our daughter says she is attracted to girls.
Doctor: Ok. So why are you actually here to see me today? What is the problem?

Scenario two:
Parents: Our 14 year old girls says she is trans. This seemed to come out of nowhere after spending hours online during lockdown and now she’s back at school 5 of her friends say the same.
Daughter: I want puberty blockers then T then top surgery.
And if you don’t refer me I will report you.

Transition regret exists, the r/detrans site has nearly 28 thousand members and is awash with young women who were affirmed as teens and have reached their mid 20s saying, “Why did everyone go along with it so easily? I was a child”.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 01/04/2022 22:56

Its an outright lie

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 01/04/2022 22:55

This
But according to Mumsnet trans people shouldn't get any legal or social protection because they don't exist 🙄🙄🙄

This hasn’t happened

wasibat · 01/04/2022 22:47

toconclude :
But according to Mumsnet trans people shouldn't get any legal or social protection because they don't exist.

This is a good example of how the debate about anything to do with trans issues gets derailed and reduced. Of course Mumsnet does not say anything like what this poster claims. 'Trans people shouldn't get any legal or social protection' ; 'Trans people don't exist' ... What nonsense. Obvious nonsense.

So obvious, and such nonsense, we have to wonder what it is for. Why would anyone post such obvious nonsense?

... It happens so often, this sort of wild exaggeration, we need to ask what purpose it serves. I think it is mostly an attempt to close down reasoned discussion and debate: if you have no sensible things to say, but you still want to get your way say in getting children taking drugs to postpone puberty in an attempt to bolster claims about adult trans status it seems 'make an outrageous claim' about people standing up for children is the order of the day, in order to cover for the lack of reasoned sensible argument. Shout down the opposition?

Let us see. toconclude : do you have anything sensible to say, any arguments to make, examples to give, factual stories to tell, anything, on the subject of this thread (the split of T from LGB, we recall, in terms of proposed bans on 'conversion practices').

Anything reasoned, sensible, to conclude? Anything at all? Or do we expect from you no more than foolish nonsensical claims about those with whom you disagree?

JaninaDuszejko · 01/04/2022 22:17

But according to Mumsnet trans people shouldn't get any legal or social protection because they don't exist

I haven't seen anyone say trans people shouldn't be covered by the equality act, as indeed they already are in this country. That doesn't mean there aren't clashes between trans and womens rights just like there are clashes sometimes between gay and religious rights. These clashes need to be decided on by public debate and legal cases. Unfortunately the TRAs believe in 'no debate'.

Bloodybridget · 01/04/2022 22:08

@toconclude you're talking absolute nonsense there! Show me all the posts saying trans people shouldn't have any protection, or that they don't exist?

twelly · 01/04/2022 22:04

I think this is good decision and pleased that the bill has been changed - at the moment there appears to be few breaks applied in preventing young people and vulnerable people changing sex.

toconclude · 01/04/2022 22:01

@AuntieMorag

No, talk therapy with a qualified therapist is not covered under conversion therapy and is vital for anyone questioning, or considering, transitioning. So again, it is not considered conversion therapy.

Talk therapy is also very useful for those who struggle with any aspect of their lives.

You are confusing two very, very different things.

This. But according to Mumsnet trans people shouldn't get any legal or social protection because they don't exist 🙄🙄🙄
wasibat · 01/04/2022 19:39

@ChristinaXYZ

Spot on *@wasibat* spot on!
Thanks ChristinaXYZ. Much appreciated.
HotPenguin · 01/04/2022 16:56

I dont understand what practices the law is meant to be stopping. If a heterosexual person, say married with kids, suddenly developed feelings towards someone of the same sex they might want to see a counsellor to talk it through and decide what to do next. Would the counsellor have to affirm the person and say yes you are definitely gay? Would it be conversion therapy if they suggested that there could be another cause (stress of work, manic episode?).

ChristinaXYZ · 01/04/2022 16:46

Spot on @wasibat spot on!

wasibat · 01/04/2022 16:01

It seems to me there is too big a difference between trans and LGB for it ever to be practical to have a 'one size fits all' approach. I am glad to see this split.

Why? ...

To be gay is just to feel attracted to people of the same sex. And to feel attracted is to be attracted. So if I feel I am gay, I must be gay. It would be invidious, then, to think of asking someone a child, say, who sincerely feels she is gay whether she is really gay. The question cannot arise because to feel attracted is to be attracted, so to think one is gay is just to be gay.

It is different with trans, as detransitioners illustrate. If I feel I am trans, it might be that I am trans ... but I might be making a mistake. (Keira Bell, for those of you who know the case, illustrates this possibility with utmost clarity -- someone who wrongly thought she was trans and regretted the choices made following this mistake about herself.)

So, particularly for children, it is really important to understand that feeling one is trans is not the same as being trans (unlike, to reiterate, the way in which feeling one is gay is, precisely and exactly, the same as being gay).

It follows from this that there needs to be caution, in particular, about children. Asking questions and discussing feelings around the subject and veracity of a child's self-description as 'trans' will always be called for and is to be encouraged, in a way that discussing the veracity of a child's self-description as 'gay' would be out of the question (and, in the extreme, to be banned as a 'conversion practice').

Of course a lot of people trans people included have not understood this, which is one of the reasons the 'T' got to be linked with 'LGB' in the first place. People say things like, 'Take me as I am' ... 'Surely I know my own identity' and so on. Some things, indeed, we know for sure about ourselves; however some things we think we know about ourselves and this is particularly true of children turn out to be mistaken.

There definitely is a difference between a self-description as gay, which must be true, and a self-description as trans, which might not be true.

[To see this distinction with the heat taken out, so to speak, think of someone self-describing as 'hungry', and compare with someone self-describing as 'wonderful': 'I am hungry' must be true if said sincerely (because, again, to feel one is hungry is to be hungry). However, 'I am wonderful' may not be true, however sincerely claimed, because to feel one is wonderful is not necessarily to be wonderful. In this respect, 'gay' is like 'hungry', but 'trans' is like 'wonderful'.]

In short, then, T is sufficiently unlike LGB as to require a distinction about 'conversion' practices.

[Oh, and just for the record. There is nothing transphobic about this. None of this derogates in any way from the rights trans people have to live their best and fullest lives however they see fit, which I support to the fullest extent possible. (Thought I better say that, just in case!)]

ChristinaXYZ · 01/04/2022 14:02

The problem is the no debate culture. The trusted adult would feel afraid that any advice would be misconstrued and therefore would back off. We have many cases of vexation reporting of people to their employers, professional bodies, and even the police. Even if found to have done nothing wrong the process is the punishment and parents and other concerned adults would have been penalised (by the process at the very least).

Again, it is the lumping of LGB and T together. Banning conversion therapy for the LGB is a no-brainer. It is not something that that is something that comes with possible de-transitioner regret nor something that is potentially permanent and irreversible or causing life long medical needs. Being homosexual does not require medical intervention.

Kids and young adults need to talk about their gender issues. There must be no doubt in adults' minds that they can talk to kids about it. The bill would have sown serious doubt.

It is that - process is the punishment and possibility (probability) of vexatious claims - that teachers will run a mile from. It does not matter @AuntieMorag what the fine print says - it is the fear caused by this bill hitting the no debate mob. And teachers are not going to read the fine print - most teachers are only in a teaching union because they know they're only one misconstrued comment (on anything - religion, politics, even educational things) away from a career ending newspaper headline.

The T part of this bill would have a tremendous chilling effect and anyone who thinks otherwise is naïve.

Foilball · 01/04/2022 12:51

@AuntieMorag

I did read the proposed legislation. I also work with therapists, including CAMHS therapists, who have such conversations with their clients. All were appalled that the legislation was being shelved, and now also appalled that it's been un-shelved, but removing the Trans parts.

Again there is a big difference between conversations between someone with questions, and conversion therapy. Having a conversation, whether a therapist or friend or relative, that explores all the options, is NOT conversion therapy. Conversion therapy is 'therapy' that CURES you of your desires, and as such, would not include any form of looking at all options. It's basis is that LGBT is wrong, an illness, and thus can be cured and the desires removed. There's no open conversation. If a therapist stated that the person questioning their gender was wrong with no discussion, and suggested they could cure of them of these feelings, then THAT would be conversion therapy. And frankly, any therapist that does that deserves to be struck off anyway.

I have also read the proposed legislation and completely agree with everything here.
comealongponds · 01/04/2022 12:42

Counselling absolutely should be required before people are allowed to do irreversible things that can cause future issues, like hormone therapy or surgery.

If someone thinks they’re gay, has sex with someone of the same sex, decides actually they’re straight, that’s fine, there’s no lasting repercussions of changing their mind. If someone thinks they’re trans, starts to physically transition, decides actually they’re not trans, while they can stop taking hormones, the damage to their body and fertility may already be done.

DisappearingGirl · 01/04/2022 12:38

What is, and isn't, conversion therapy was quite clearly laid out

I don't think it was clearly laid out though, especially for trans people, and that was the major problem.

AuntieMorag · 01/04/2022 12:30

@BowtieBling

No, no where does it say that someone exploring these issues with someone such as a teacher may lead to the teacher being sacked under conversion therapy legislation, and it's not even hinted at.
What is, and isn't, conversion therapy was quite clearly laid out. Someone who is a teacher COULD be prosecuted if they were providing conversion therapy, but a discussion on feelings and options is not conversion therapy. Using the situation laid out above about a 'tom boy' girl who likes football, the teacher would say that it doesn't mean they are trans, and that many people feel many different things. If the child wanted more information, it would be sensible of the teacher to suggest seeing a therapist to discuss it further and get more information.
IF the teacher said "no you cannot be trans, trans isn't real, you just need to x, y and z and these feelings will go away", they, frankly, should be sacked

JaninaDuszejko · 01/04/2022 12:29

Transitioning is seen by many as a form of gay conversion therapy. Countries with strict homophobic laws have high numbers of trans individuals. GIDS's own documents suggest many of the patients' parents are homophobic.

Swipe left for the next trending thread