Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

… to wonder why people continue having more children if they cannot cope with the ones that they already have?

495 replies

NetflixMom21 · 01/04/2022 08:50

… or am I just being extremely judgemental?

A couple of recent interactions and conversations with people that I know has got me thinking about this. In one situation; the person in question already has a couple of children plus a couple of stepchildren which they have 50% of the time, they are always complaining of having no money, they have openly said that they max out their credit cards to survive and pay their bills every month and are in a lot of debt because of it… now they have just announced that they are having another child.

In the second situation; the person in question has 5 children. The first child was born with a severe disability and they were told that it could possibly be genetic and that if they had anymore children, those children could have a disability too. The second child was also born with a disability, but not as severe as the first. The person then went onto having 3 more children, of which, another child has a similar disability to the first 2. So 3 out of 5 children are disabled. This person now admits that they are unable to cope and it massively impacts on the care that they are able to give their children.

In the third situation; someone that I know was born with cystic fibrosis (they are the first born child of the family). They nearly died as a young child and was only just about saved by a lung transplant which they were incredibly lucky to get. The parents have gone on to have more and more children, even though they know that they have the gene for cystic fibrosis and any child that they have may be born with it too and after watching how badly their first child has suffered. Well another child has been born with it, and suffers horrendously already (they are reception/year 1 age) and unless they receive a lung transplant, they might not even make it to a teenager.

My own situation; I have a progressive disability myself and also a child that has a disability. I know that I will never have anymore children (I am looking into surgical procedures to ensure this) because I know that firstly, I will not be able to cope with my own illness and that is not fair on the child especially as I know that there is a possibility of me having another child with a disability, and secondly; I do not know how much independence my child will go onto have as a teenager and adult, and if I had another child, it would impact on the level of care that I am able provide for my child and that isn’t fair on them.

AIBU to wonder why people in these situations continue having more and more children rather than focusing on the ones that they have, and then constantly complain of being unable to cope?!

OP posts:
WhatNoRaisins · 03/04/2022 11:45

I agree with PP, as a society we are still uncomfortable with childless women. Most of us are raised by our mother's along with grandparents and other family members with children. Unless you've had say a very influential childless aunt or family friend you probably haven't had much exposure to women in this situation.

Also add in that many women from difficult backgrounds won't have done well in education and their ability to find careers that give status and satisfaction will be limited. That can make childbearing seem even more like the only life option available to them.

PlayingGrownUp · 03/04/2022 11:07

As a child carer - I was very adamant I’d never have children. I still am though it’s cost me relationships in the past until I met my husband.

I watched my parents bury two children, the other three of us having to be pulled in and out of kinship care for years depending on my mum’s mental health. Which wasn’t her fault but it was very difficult for us.

When I turned thirty my mother became obsessed with becoming a grandmother. It was all she’d talk about and it really damaged an already precarious relationship. When all my friends began to have babies it almost came a bone of contention - look how well they are doing with their kids and husbands etc

I’ve also lost friends because we also don’t have anything in common even though I went to soft play for a coffee or attended their kids parties so that became incredibly frustrating and I can see why some people might have kids just to feel normal.

Ironically - the closest I ever came to wanting kids was in my early twenties (when my mum would have been furious) living in another country with a man who is an incredible husband and father. With him and at that time I’d have probably had one but we broke up ironically because I wanted to settle down and he wanted to travel.

Limer · 03/04/2022 10:52

Another all too common situation is where people want "one of each", so they keep trying until they get that. Such an old-fashioned attitude.

CounsellorTroi · 03/04/2022 10:35

[quote godmum56]@Joy247
Not quite the same circs as you but when DH and I discussed whether to start the fertility treatment route (many years ago, harder route, less choices) The intermal voice that said "you don't have to do this to be successful" came from my parents. At the time they had one grandchild from a sibling and they adored him but had been clear since we were all children (I am the youngest and born in the 50's) that marriage and children were not the only, or even the best, choice.
As I said upthread, the adults of the future won't "get" this until they are told this in their homes and see it modelled in their parents behaviour and in society.
You mothers and mothers in law (men too but I don't think they seem to be so vocal about it).....I am not saying don't rejoice when the grandchildren come IF they come.....but think about the baby-centric behaviour...boast about your family's achievements other than the children.
I do agree about un maternity leave...I would have loved it.[/quote]
I agree. DH and I were in this position in the 90s. My mother was certainly not desperate to be a grandmother (was never very maternal) and actually said we could have a great life without children. My DB did eventually oblige but she was 85 by then and not in the best of health.

Zombiemum1946 · 03/04/2022 10:32

Interesting question from a number of angles. The non disabled children becoming carers at a very young age, the pressure placed on them to put their own lives on hold to care for siblings and/ or parents. My own situation, where after finding there was a possibility of a genetic pre disposition to cancer (was told there wasn't despite strong family history),I went on to have another child. My sil accused me of being selfish and I should have been sterilised. Did she have the right to say that? Is it different because my kids can be tested for the gene, checked, and any problem found quickly? I do think that if you're not coping with the current circumstances then don't have more kids, but you can't really police that. Mental health support would be a big part of the answer but without funding where does that come from ? Maybe not so much judgemental as expressing serious concerns.

PaperTyger · 03/04/2022 10:23

Some people do not have the Critical thinking skills nor access to support or education about these matters.

It's Just taken for granted. This is what everyone does,they have children. Lot's of them.

Joy247 · 03/04/2022 10:10

oh sorry, you had the reassurance from your parents that you did not need to do it for them! Wine to them for getting it.
And doh to me for skim reading!

Joy247 · 03/04/2022 10:08

[quote godmum56]@Joy247
Not quite the same circs as you but when DH and I discussed whether to start the fertility treatment route (many years ago, harder route, less choices) The intermal voice that said "you don't have to do this to be successful" came from my parents. At the time they had one grandchild from a sibling and they adored him but had been clear since we were all children (I am the youngest and born in the 50's) that marriage and children were not the only, or even the best, choice.
As I said upthread, the adults of the future won't "get" this until they are told this in their homes and see it modelled in their parents behaviour and in society.
You mothers and mothers in law (men too but I don't think they seem to be so vocal about it).....I am not saying don't rejoice when the grandchildren come IF they come.....but think about the baby-centric behaviour...boast about your family's achievements other than the children.
I do agree about un maternity leave...I would have loved it.[/quote]
Absoloutely. sorry you went through the extra hurdle of fertility treatments.

Jokes like ''I'll have to knit my own grandchildren'' take their toll.
My mother and father had a good life before grandchildren, they didn't need me to do the wrong thing for me just to had a bit more to their lives. But they did put that pressure on me, knowing i wasn't in a relationship.

godmum56 · 03/04/2022 09:57

@fanjosaysi

I think a lot of the desire for babies is rooted in low self-esteem of the women. I admire women who remain childless by choice; I'm in my mid-50s and know a few. All are wonderfully successful, well-off, supremely content with their lives.

The desire for an excessive number of babies may be rooted in low self esteem. Never being happy and enjoying the newness of it all. Saying the desire for anyone to have a baby is a massive generalisation.

Also, people are absolutely capable of being successful with a child, or multiple children, regardless of age. As much as I admire women who are childfree, I hate the narrative that having children (young, or even at all) makes you less successful. Ironically, that's also rooted in low self esteem of a different kind- fear of missing out, so consoling oneself they're doing better anyway.

Anyway, even back to excessive babies... it's not great but I do empathise.

But even ONE baby can be excessive if you know you can't support it and care for it or are putting it at risk of genetic illness and you still deliberately TTC or pretend that you aren't TTC but don't use contraception sensibly.

Yes people are capable of having a child or children and being successful, but II don't think that anybody would deny that its harder....takes more planning...takes more resource...takes more determination.

godmum56 · 03/04/2022 09:43

@Joy247
Not quite the same circs as you but when DH and I discussed whether to start the fertility treatment route (many years ago, harder route, less choices) The intermal voice that said "you don't have to do this to be successful" came from my parents. At the time they had one grandchild from a sibling and they adored him but had been clear since we were all children (I am the youngest and born in the 50's) that marriage and children were not the only, or even the best, choice.
As I said upthread, the adults of the future won't "get" this until they are told this in their homes and see it modelled in their parents behaviour and in society.
You mothers and mothers in law (men too but I don't think they seem to be so vocal about it).....I am not saying don't rejoice when the grandchildren come IF they come.....but think about the baby-centric behaviour...boast about your family's achievements other than the children.
I do agree about un maternity leave...I would have loved it.

Joy247 · 03/04/2022 09:24

yes @WanderingFruitWonderer absolutely, it's more than ''just'' the fear of not having children. It's the fear of being on the margins of a society that kind of mocks and pities you.

Limer · 03/04/2022 09:23

In countries where women are educated and have access to contraception, fertility rates decline rapidly.

That is encouraging. But we also need to address the myth that this country needs more and more babies to support the ageing population. That's a Ponzi scheme that will end in disaster. Climate change, spiralling costs of living, dwindling resources all mean that we need to reduce population, not increase it.

fanjosaysi · 03/04/2022 09:20

I think a lot of the desire for babies is rooted in low self-esteem of the women. I admire women who remain childless by choice; I'm in my mid-50s and know a few. All are wonderfully successful, well-off, supremely content with their lives.

The desire for an excessive number of babies may be rooted in low self esteem. Never being happy and enjoying the newness of it all. Saying the desire for anyone to have a baby is a massive generalisation.

Also, people are absolutely capable of being successful with a child, or multiple children, regardless of age. As much as I admire women who are childfree, I hate the narrative that having children (young, or even at all) makes you less successful. Ironically, that's also rooted in low self esteem of a different kind- fear of missing out, so consoling oneself they're doing better anyway.

Anyway, even back to excessive babies... it's not great but I do empathise.

SnackSizeRaisin · 03/04/2022 09:07

Hate to be "that person" but this is a very simplistic and western view of developing countries

Yes ...hope and something to love sounds more like a middle class western reason to have children.

Having children is a basic biological process. To restrict the number is the unnatural thing. It is generally not up to women in poor countries to make that choice, but reasons for having lots of children include status, to look after you when you are old, because some are likely to die, because you want a son and only have several daughters, rape within marriage, lack of contraception, religious expectation, or because it's just what is expected. In countries where women are educated and have access to contraception, fertility rates decline rapidly.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 03/04/2022 08:52

@Limer

Joy247 you make some excellent points. Why is marriage and motherhood seen as the top prize for a woman? The patriarchy have us exactly where they want us!

I remember Teresa May being rubbished because she had no children, therefore had no idea about what issues "hard-working families" were facing. Ridiculous and sexist.

I think a lot of the desire for babies is rooted in low self-esteem of the women. I admire women who remain childless by choice; I'm in my mid-50s and know a few. All are wonderfully successful, well-off, supremely content with their lives.

I think unfortunately there are still vestiges of medieval thinking, regarding childless and/or unmarried women. Echoes of ancient wrongs still heard today. The 17th century witch hunts for example - much more deadly for single childless older women on the margins of society Sad Older unmarried women were ridiculed for centuries, in literature and on the stage. I think those ideas have got into many people's subconscious, and meanwhile mothers and motherhood are endlessly celebrated, and it's still held up as the ideal by the media etc. As a result, I think many women are terrified of ending up childless. I think a concerted effort needs to be made to celebrate women who haven't given birth. They need to be seen as the heroines they often are. Not having children, when you know life could be challenging for them (due to a medical condition or whatever) is selfless, compassionate, brave, and yes, very motherly...
Joy247 · 03/04/2022 08:48

Thanks! all I can do as an older woman (well, life left in me yet but definitely past the window of fertility) is to just be really really honest.

I won't dress up the decisions I made as a younger woman, because on one level, I knew they felt wrong. But the bit I couldn't OVERRIDE was that desire to win approval, my mother's, society's, strangers' approval.

If only we were all told to tune all of that. We're not told that though. We're told ''oh don't give up hope!''. ''love might be around the corner'' and ''don't give up hope'' and it's all sold to us as the only happy ending.

The happy ending might be that we realise we're being sold this patriarchal narrative. Have DC if you want to of course. If you're H is meeting you half way.

SuperheroBirds · 03/04/2022 08:43

I’ll be honest, I judge too. Partly because I have a friend who was the younger sibling of a severely disabled brother and the impact it had on her life. All of her parents’ time and energy went on looking after him, so she said they were too exhausted to ever do anything with her. He was physically big and strong, but also non verbal and violent so she would have to hide from him when he was having violent outbursts. He was also really sensitive to noise, so she couldn’t play much in her own house. As she got older she was expected to help care for him.
In the end, she had had enough and moved away, going low contact with her family. She never understood why they had had her, and didn’t feel loved or prioritised.

Limer · 03/04/2022 08:30

Joy247 you make some excellent points. Why is marriage and motherhood seen as the top prize for a woman? The patriarchy have us exactly where they want us!

I remember Teresa May being rubbished because she had no children, therefore had no idea about what issues "hard-working families" were facing. Ridiculous and sexist.

I think a lot of the desire for babies is rooted in low self-esteem of the women. I admire women who remain childless by choice; I'm in my mid-50s and know a few. All are wonderfully successful, well-off, supremely content with their lives.

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 03/04/2022 08:25

@Joy247, amazing posts. You're absolutely right.

Indoctro · 03/04/2022 08:15

Lack of education I always thought.

I don't think personally anyone needs more than 2 kids, we have a responsibility for the future of the planet and over population is a major issue.

Joy247 · 03/04/2022 08:14

Yes, I would like to hear the stories of women who were on that now or never precipice and then didn't take the leap, carried on with their life and then how they found fulfilment elsewhere and how their life is now.
I guess the media doesn't like the story of forty something woman without a husband or children happier than she's ever been since she created/discovered/produced/researched..........x,y&z

habibihabibi · 03/04/2022 08:11

Media could do more to promote successful women who are able to combine parenting and professional roles AND as childless women who are very successful.
All we seem to see are the likes of Katie Price with her menagerie of different fathered kids and Kim Kardasian who rents wombs.

Joy247 · 03/04/2022 08:09

Yesterday actually, I said to my DD, I've no expectations that I be a grandmother! She said ''I know, I wouldn't do it for you!'' and she seemed taken aback that I spelled that out, but I very much did feel that it was something I owed my mother. My family helped me financially when I was a single parent (still am a single parent) but they also judged me and pitied me! I've never said this to my parents, that I had children so as not to disappoint them more. I don't think that would improve my relationship with them, they would deny that, but it is true. Rightly or wrongly, that was how I felt back then.

I don't think that's a unique feeling and now with smaller families being the norm (I only had one brother) I think that that '''obligation'' to give parents grandchildren is another weight on 30 something women's shoulders

Joy247 · 03/04/2022 08:04

@Malibuismysecrethome

Women need to rethink the ‘need a man/another baby to complete their life/family’ What do most of the losers out there bring to the table, certainly not food or money from many of the posts on here. People should stop being foolish in the choices they make. I know talk is cheap but honestly if you have your own home, business or job, a living child why risk it all for some muggy bloke.
I agree with this but I think this mindset often kicks in after the baby (babies) are born.

I'm 52 now, have my own job, house, savings, pension but I'm a single parent to two teenagers and that responsibility will be ongoing for another 6 -7 years minimum

I do wish that when I was 30 something and pondering motherhood and what my life would mean with it/without it that there'd been some wisdom from somewhere to let me know that I could have found fulfilment elsewhere, that although I may not have known how I would have found peace with it. I didn't know that you could have faith in yourself to construct a life that had meaning for you. I didn't know that you could tune out others' expectations. All I saw everywhere was 'winners' getting married and all I felt coming my way was PITY that I wasn't one of the winners. My brother is a bit anti-social so I had the extra pressure of knowing that if my parents were to become grandparents, it was all down to me. With all of that milling around in my head I went ahead and had two children with a controlling man who projected on to me that I wasn't good enough.

As soon as you have children you get it. As soon as you have all of that responsibility I think the scales fall from your eyes and you think, wow, I could have carved out a life that suited me, I could have tuned out other people's pity and expectations. All of these perfect families I see everywhere, that's just a phase in my life (age-related) and it will pass.

Now I can see the direction I could have taken my life, but when I was staring down the barrel of MOTHERHOOD NOW OR NEVER it didn't seem so clear to me.

You have to be really fucking smart and self-aware to hack biology. Having children is the one thing you can't sort out later. It was like a panic buy.

I love them of course. But just wondering how we can get young single or unmarried women who have 5 weddings to go to in one year to not feel that like a club they're excluded from.

Women are told they've a shelf life. Men your own age won't marry you after hmmm, not sure but married life remains an option for men for so much longer.

I think biology explains why women panic buy and end up with a shit man.

We could counter that but the information and the reassurance that everything will be OK either way just isn't really there. Not as a loud voice.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 03/04/2022 06:58

@marbleeyes

A friend on my fb who I know quite well has 4 kids as a single parent plus 2 dogs. She has now met her 3rd partner of 6 months and is pregnant again. She started her own business recently and was taking on new clients as I follow her business page and I was extremely happy for her for finally breaking the cycle. But then she announces her 5th pregnancy and is saying she is taking a break from her business due to a difficult pregnancy and how the 5th baby finally completes her family.

I don't understand why she wasn't ever complete with the first 4 and why whenever a new man comes along, you fall pregnant and somehow you have the urge to make a baby to complete your family every time you meet a new fella especially when the new fella has never been there for his other children!Then this 3rd man will piss off like the other 2 deadbeat ex partners she has had and then she will meet another man "to complete" her family and have the 6th child. It's a vicious cycle.

I really don't know but some people honestly don't know anything other than living in chaos and somehow think that's a normal way to live.

Also, does she not know about the climate change emergency, and the overpopulation problem? I say that without judgement. Just a genuine question. The climate emergency informs so much of many people's decisions now. There are people doing their best not to have too many baths, let alone too many new humans! That said, I obviously wish her, and especially her children, well. Let's hope she does indeed decide her family is complete! It must be frustrating for you to witness
Swipe left for the next trending thread