Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What's fair in this relationship?

84 replies

pinksunshine101 · 01/04/2022 08:05

Hi there

I wanted a bit of advice regarding my living situation with my partner. We have been seeing each other for 18 months and I love him very much. We are both early 30's, work in a similar field and have lots in common. I have one child, he has two who he sees every other weekend and half hols.

My issue is that he lives with his parents and I have my own rented place where I live with my son. He naturally comes over to mine to stay and spend time with me. He will normally be here between 3- 5 nights a week here (sometimes more), if it's a week he doesn't have his kids. The weeks where he does, he will spend approx 4 nights here. He lives home with parents.

I'm not doing the best financially..bills are already high but increasing even more now..my sons father has stopped paying CMA/isn't working/fiddle papers so I'm feeling the pressure even more.

I feel that my partner should be contributing more when he is here. When he comes, he does buy soft drinks and snacks. If we get a takeaway/lunch out, we either go halves, or take it in turns to cover it.

However, I think he should be paying a set about to cover the extra costs such as heating/gas/water/the little expenses like shower gel/toilet roll/toothpaste etc - or if he isn't happy to pay that, he should stay at his house for the majority of the week and stay at mine for just 2 nights and be treated as a guest and not have to pay a set amount. Even knowing I'd be getting £20 a week from him while he is here would help at that would cover a bulk of my fuel bill/broadband etc.

I brought this up with him last night and we've had a massive bust up that I think we are over. He doesn't think he should have to do that and I should cover it as it's my house. He believes that the snacks and times he covers the food are more than enough. He is adamant that he doesn't stay at mine that often (he does). He's made me feel like I'm asking too much and now I'm just not sure if I am indeed the one being too demanding and expecting too much from him.

So, what do you think in this situation? I want him to stay with me but only if he is going to contribute - it's hard because I love him but I hate constantly feeling like I'm supporting him - when he is very very well off, he just doesn't spend it!

Thanks

OP posts:
billy1966 · 01/04/2022 13:13

Well done OP for ending it.

Meanness goes to the core of a persons character.

I bet he was lovely while he was with you, he was living off you and so were his children.

He has used you and your home for his children.

Utterly shameful.

Do not be naive, he knew well he was using you.

This is NEVER accidental.

Mean people are NEVER accidentally mean.

It is absolutely calculated behaviour on their part.

Stay strong.Flowers

LadyJaneHall · 01/04/2022 13:04

I really can't believe all these posters saying that it only costs a few pence for an adult living at your house for over half the week.
Breakfast, dinner, lunch at weekends for an adult male costs a lot. Extra cooking and washing up cost more in fuel and water.
Showers and use of toilet cost in water as well as fuel. Charging phones/laptop, maybe TV on more, cost money. More washing for sheets and towels, maybe clothes as well, cost for fuel and cleaning products. Toiletries cost money.
All this adds a lot to household costs and would be quite a large percentage of income for someone on a low salary.

LimeSegment · 01/04/2022 12:56

Agree entirely. He's costing you 10p extra in toiletries maybe per visit.

Yep, sorry OP but yabu. He isn't the reason your living costs are high. He should be splitting the food bill but I'm guessing on the days he is there it's something like a piece of toast for breakfast, he buys his own lunch at his work, then for dinner it's a take away and snacks, which he buys. Where's the cost? A splash of milk and a tea bag? A few squares of loo roll?

Also I've previously been in a long term live apart relationship and I can tell you that being the one to always visit isn't easy - you never have anything you need and don't get to spend time in your own house.

Graphista · 01/04/2022 12:39

Cocklodger in waiting!

Throw this one back in the sea op

In addition he has you committing council tax fraud which if caught could cost you a fortune!

Plus it's really early days on emotional side for dc to be spending SO much time together

@Philisophigal no another occupant DOES increase costs of energy, groceries etc even the utility companies recognise this.

When my dd moved out a few years back my bills dropped considerably - more than even the 50% you might expect!

My ex when we were dating he was officially still in barracks but in reality was mostly at mine. He'd top up meter, get a full grocery shop, tidy up, do dishes, hang a laundry to fry etc if he stopped over and he covered the 25% inc in council tax too

That's what a decent person does in such a situation

His type NEVER want to pay for anything.

Agree with that

Also mean with money mean with love - this type also usually not there for you when you go through something tough emotionally they're all take take take

I'm a single mum and unfortunately you're a target for men like this.

Oh yes! They think we're "desperate" and will put up with all kinds of crap treatment cos "no other man would take on all that baggage" which is crap btw - also crap that we need a man perfectly fine to be single

I think you did right to end things op. 18 months in you can't know that he's "perfect" his behaviour on this matter strongly suggests he isn't

Freeloading is the same regardless of the income of the person you’re sponging off.

Yep

18 months is about when the limerence starts to end and you discover what the relationship is really about

Yea biochemically it's when the rose coloured glasses come off and you start to notice each other's faults - can be from about 12 months to 18 months in this happens, certain hormones die down.

Sometimes what happens is the opposite of rose coloured glasses and all you can see are faults then around 6 months later it balances out again.

Also in the first 12-18 months people are on best behaviour! If this was his best I dread to think what his worst would be

£20 is a joke in terms of costs…with the increase in energy, broadband bills etc.

I agree

Mean, tight, grasping people are like that in every aspect of their life, you just haven't seen it in him yet.

Absolutely

summersolstice43 · 01/04/2022 12:31

So I'm presuming he already pays board to his parents? So why not you go over there and stay a few nights and see how inconvenienced they are with you and your son using their electric, gas etc.

Money is a sensitive subject but its really hard being a single parent and running a house, especially rented as the monthly costs are really high.

Try to talk to him again and explain that you were not having a go you just feel you could do with a little bit to cover the extra heating and electric you are using while he is there.

FlowerArranger · 01/04/2022 12:25

I wish women who put up with cocklodgers would do the sums and work out the extent to which they are robbing themselves and their children.

Hollyontherampage · 01/04/2022 12:02

^bold fail

The first paragraph quotes @Grenlei

Hollyontherampage · 01/04/2022 12:01

He's costing you 10p extra in toiletries maybe per visit. Him staying is not the reason you have no money, but I guess getting money off him seems an easy way to increase your income. If it's such an issue tell him to bring his own shower gel and toothpaste.

Er....@Grenlei have you missed the fact that he'll be eating meals when he's living there?!? Dinner and breakfast?? I'd like to know how you eat tel meals, drink teas, coffees, milk, plus charging phone, hot water for showers, laundry etc all for 10p? Did the cost of living crisis escape you? FFS!

Hollyontherampage · 01/04/2022 11:55

Meanness is such an unattractive trait, it is so off-putting. Living with his parents would also really put me off. The fact he kicked off about it shows he wasn't purely ignorant of this, he was calculating. If it just hadn't occurred to him that you were paying for more then he'd have apologised and offered a contribution. The fact he kicked off was because he's been caught out and he knows it. He's been sponging off everyone it seems. What a knob.

You and your child are way way better off without him OP Thanks

Grenlei · 01/04/2022 11:27

@Philisophigal

Internet costs thr same ni manner how many people use it. 1 or twenty people can sit under a light bulb and it cost the same. I assume you'd heat your place regardless. If you are on water rates, it's not costing you anymore to have him there. I'd you don't want.to pay for shower gel and tooth paste, don't have him to stay.

Basically the problem is that you are skint and you wish he'd give you some money to help out because he isn't skint. And you've dressed it up in a way that seems more justifiable.

I would be upset if someone asked me to stay all the time and then expected me to pay. YABU.

Agree entirely. He's costing you 10p extra in toiletries maybe per visit. Him staying is not the reason you have no money, but I guess getting money off him seems an easy way to increase your income.

If it's such an issue tell him to bring his own shower gel and toothpaste.

lemongreentea · 01/04/2022 11:18

@CherryDocsInYrBalls

I'm a single mum and unfortunately you're a target for men like this. They know you have the qualities they're looking for, organised, capable, nice home, food and washing well planned and organised. And they want to benefit from your home, your money, your whole infrastructure and don't want to contribute in a financial way, or any way. Complete unattractive men children. Dump him and put your time, energy and money into your future and your child
This is spot on.
Cocomarine · 01/04/2022 11:15

You’ve done the right thing ending it, because you feel that in general he is financially mean - and that’s never a good thing in a partner. Careful yes, mean no.

However, I would be concerned at being seen as a cash cow if my boyfriend tried to charge me for stating over. As others have said - what is the actual impact? If I was being charged for toothpaste, I would think that person was the financially mean one.

Why I’m unsure about your charging, is that you mention “heating/gas/water/the little expenses like shower gel/toilet roll/toothpaste etc”

And yet not food. If he’s eating with you 3-5 nights a week, that’s where your main cost is (+ breakfast?). So it’s a bit odd not to mention it. You do say he buys soft drinks and snacks. Hard to see that those would balance the cost of actual meals - but, as you haven’t mentioned food consumption and cost, it does make me wonder.

Luckingfovely · 01/04/2022 11:04

I'm sorry you're feeling sad, but I'm sure you've done the right thing.

Daisydoesnt · 01/04/2022 11:00

I don't understand it as in every other way he is perfect but financially, he is mean

OP the truth is people aren't mean with money but generous of spirit in every other aspect of life. Mean, tight, grasping people are like that in every aspect of their life, you just haven't seen it in him yet. This is NOT someone you want to share your life with.

I still can't get over that a man earning well and living at home with his parents hasn't OFFERED you, a single mother, a bit of extra cash to go towards the basic expenses of running a home, that he apparently enjoys spending time at. What a total skinflint. Ugh.

Chloemol · 01/04/2022 10:37

At least you found out what he is really like

I would be ending the relationship

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 01/04/2022 10:23

Any man still living with his parents in his 30s would be very unattractive to me.

He's sponging off them and also sponging off you.

You've brought it up and tried to address it like and adult and he's reacted like this...

I think you've had a lucky escape. Finish things with him properly and move on.

Abaababa · 01/04/2022 10:15

@MerryMarigold

Let's take the things he should pay for that you wouldn't use if he wasn't there:
  • toothpaste, loo roll, shower gel
  • food
  • shower heating

I'm not sure that's 20.00 per week but it depends how much he continues to food. That can add up.

I don't think he should cover broadband, fuel bills etc. as you would need to pay them anyway. It's not 'fair' he should pay towards what you would need to pay if he wasn't there. The implication he has been 'cocklodging' so far probably got his back up.

However, as a loving partner he should want to help you out with money if you're struggling and he has fewer outgoings. Are you open about the finances with him? Sure he really understand how little you have and is still being difficult about it? Maybe he doesn't like that he feels you are 'charging' him to be your boyfriend when really you just need some financial support from your partner and to be treated to things eg. The takeaways etc on him.

The obsession with being 'fair' is what has caused this because there will be different perceptions of what is 'fair' and clearly you both have a different perception of this. However, saying 'I'm finding it difficult and I would appreciate some help' is different. If he still responded in the way he has, he doesn't care about you and doesn't see a future with you.

This!

I had a similar situation with a well off, older man who had moved into my flat. After nearly 8 months I asked if he would contribute to some of the food and utilities, I had just wanted to open up the conversation on cost sharing and understand if he wanted to move in long term as we’d not had that conversation. About a week later he literally did a Dear John on me and moved out whilst I was at a family lunch. I was devastated. I didn’t know the term cocklodger at the time but wish I had as I may have realised what a disgusting man child cocklodger he was then instead of spending months utterly devastated.

Best of luck!

worriedaboutmoney2022 · 01/04/2022 10:04

@AlternativelyWired

You've got yourself a cocklodger. If it is the end of the relationship then good riddance. He can go back to sponging off mummy and daddy full time.
Yes I agree get rid
DarkCorner · 01/04/2022 09:59

You've done the right thing OP Flowers. He was being completely unreasonable. So, he just paid a few soft drinks and snacks and you bought all the rest of the food for 3-5 nights per week?! And used your space, bills etc. No, just not OK. He could "live with" his parents (although he wasn't really was he? He was living with you more than 50%!) and enjoy all the comforts of a home with his partner the majority of the time but without contributing at all.

Sounds like he has got too used to living for free (I assume) at his parents and can't understand why you can't just subsidise him too. Entitled and unattractive.

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 01/04/2022 09:43

@mrsm43s

He should pay for the extra costs of him being there. But, if he's already paying his way with food, then that will literally be the odd squeeze of shower gel, the odd blob of toothpaste, a tiny fraction of the water/energy costs to cover his shower etc. It won't add up to anything close to £20 per week, not likely even £10 per month!

You can't expect him to subsidise your household costs. The big issue seems to be that your ex isn't paying his way in supporting his son. That is what you should be focusing on.

This is crap. Having an adult male and his two kids pulling into your home more than half the time is a huge increase in costs. They all use extra electricity and water and proper food and drinks not just snacks. Make demands on the heating and hot water, dish washer runs more often, sheets have to washed twice as often. Toiletries, loo paper etc all disappear twice as fast too. And since they are not paying for any of it they use up as much as they can in my experience. Its a complete and utter piss take.
Fireflygal · 01/04/2022 09:39

It won't add up to anything close to £20 per week, not likely even £10 per month!

Are you for real?? Where do you live that an adult can eat, wash twice a day, charge devices etc for £2.50 a week. If he stays 4 nights you are attributing his costs at 60p a day. If that's the case then benefits can be cut and there would be no need for food banks as an additional adult can live on £18.00 a month for food, heating etc.

MayMorris · 01/04/2022 09:36

@Philisophigal

Internet costs thr same ni manner how many people use it. 1 or twenty people can sit under a light bulb and it cost the same. I assume you'd heat your place regardless. If you are on water rates, it's not costing you anymore to have him there. I'd you don't want.to pay for shower gel and tooth paste, don't have him to stay.

Basically the problem is that you are skint and you wish he'd give you some money to help out because he isn't skint. And you've dressed it up in a way that seems more justifiable.

I would be upset if someone asked me to stay all the time and then expected me to pay. YABU.

Extra loads in washing machine, showers or baths daily, toilet flushes multiple times per day (one of bigger uses of water metered - mst people are now metered), extra charging for his devices, and any other electronics he uses. . Food-given a grown man will consume more food than her 1 kid that is an enormous increase. Add to that her effort in cleaning up for an extra person (unless he does that and takes on that in his thanks for staying) £20 is a joke in terms of costs…with the increase in energy, broadband bills etc. Note that this is not a case of give and take. The Op does not stay nights at his so it evens up …it is just him living with her more than he is living in his own “home” and that home he is also like Y to be getting housekeeping covered as well as roof over his head at a discount too.
mrsm43s · 01/04/2022 09:27

He should pay for the extra costs of him being there. But, if he's already paying his way with food, then that will literally be the odd squeeze of shower gel, the odd blob of toothpaste, a tiny fraction of the water/energy costs to cover his shower etc. It won't add up to anything close to £20 per week, not likely even £10 per month!

You can't expect him to subsidise your household costs. The big issue seems to be that your ex isn't paying his way in supporting his son. That is what you should be focusing on.

NoSquirrels · 01/04/2022 09:25

I think you’re a strong, independent woman who knows the value of her own worth, and of the cost of living, and isn’t prepared to be taken advantage of. And I think you’ve done the right thing. There’s no long-term future with a man like that, or not one that’s going to do you any good.

Flowers
konasana · 01/04/2022 09:25

I had one of these too, it makes me so angry when I think of all the money I spent covering his living expenses over the years. Would have had thousands more to spend on myself and my DC if I hadn't been hoodwinked into it. You've had a lucky escape.