Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What's fair in this relationship?

84 replies

pinksunshine101 · 01/04/2022 08:05

Hi there

I wanted a bit of advice regarding my living situation with my partner. We have been seeing each other for 18 months and I love him very much. We are both early 30's, work in a similar field and have lots in common. I have one child, he has two who he sees every other weekend and half hols.

My issue is that he lives with his parents and I have my own rented place where I live with my son. He naturally comes over to mine to stay and spend time with me. He will normally be here between 3- 5 nights a week here (sometimes more), if it's a week he doesn't have his kids. The weeks where he does, he will spend approx 4 nights here. He lives home with parents.

I'm not doing the best financially..bills are already high but increasing even more now..my sons father has stopped paying CMA/isn't working/fiddle papers so I'm feeling the pressure even more.

I feel that my partner should be contributing more when he is here. When he comes, he does buy soft drinks and snacks. If we get a takeaway/lunch out, we either go halves, or take it in turns to cover it.

However, I think he should be paying a set about to cover the extra costs such as heating/gas/water/the little expenses like shower gel/toilet roll/toothpaste etc - or if he isn't happy to pay that, he should stay at his house for the majority of the week and stay at mine for just 2 nights and be treated as a guest and not have to pay a set amount. Even knowing I'd be getting £20 a week from him while he is here would help at that would cover a bulk of my fuel bill/broadband etc.

I brought this up with him last night and we've had a massive bust up that I think we are over. He doesn't think he should have to do that and I should cover it as it's my house. He believes that the snacks and times he covers the food are more than enough. He is adamant that he doesn't stay at mine that often (he does). He's made me feel like I'm asking too much and now I'm just not sure if I am indeed the one being too demanding and expecting too much from him.

So, what do you think in this situation? I want him to stay with me but only if he is going to contribute - it's hard because I love him but I hate constantly feeling like I'm supporting him - when he is very very well off, he just doesn't spend it!

Thanks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Graphista · 03/04/2022 21:10

@Sugarplumfairy65 as far as the authorities are concerned if he's spending more time at ops than elsewhere it IS his main residence it's not actually up to op or him to determine that and that's where people like op can get caught out and stung for fraud

Sugarplumfairy65 · 02/04/2022 21:04

@BritInUS1

Presumably your council tax is more too if he is there that much as you wouldn't be able to claim the single person discount
Not unless its his main residence
FloralsForSpring · 02/04/2022 14:06

Lose him. He won't pay his own pay.

RonSwansonsChair · 02/04/2022 13:52

Well if this thread shows anything, it's that there is the whole breadth of thoughts on this... everything from he costs 10p a day to stay with you to £20 a week isn't enough.
Anyway, Well Done for bringing up the subject. It has obviously been playing on your mind.

However the biggest thing here for me is his reaction to you bringing it up. Instead of discussing it like an adult and proposing a solution, he causes an argument about it. On this basis YANBU to dump his sorry arse!

Newestname002 · 02/04/2022 13:22

@pinksunshine101

I know you're hurting right now but you've absolutely done the right thing. Please don't doubt yourself - you are absolutely in the right. Stay strong! 🌹

lemongreentea · 02/04/2022 11:27

How are you doing OP? Hope you are okay Flowers

Any plans for Easter Holidays?

Totalwasteofpaper · 02/04/2022 09:00

@Mummytobe93

He’s an immature man child & a cocklodger *@pinksunshine101*

you're better off without

Yep you've done yourself a favour.

Not sure why but men like this seem to seek out single mothers (maybe as a replacement for their own?)

Scbchl · 02/04/2022 00:29

Id get him to fuck quite frankly.

TweenTrauma · 02/04/2022 00:23

Just by contrast OP, my bf and I don’t live together but because I have DC and he doesn’t, he stays at mine a lot more than I stay at his. We have been together 19 months.

He pays for all meals when we eat out (even for my DC), which we do pretty often, even when I try to pay. I tend to drive more than he does when he’s here so when I fill up at the pump he’ll jump out of the car and go and pay. We live quite a distance away so if he’s stayed for a week or so, I’ll randomly often find he’s just bunged £100 in my account, so I’m not out of pocket (even though he’ll have paid for pretty much everything while he’s here). We just went on holiday and he paid for literally everything while we were away, except for the flights which I had a voucher for from a couple of years ago.

Set your sights higher.

Nsky · 02/04/2022 00:11

I live alone, use coffee machine, so kettle on twice a day max, water metre, extra showers and washing.
Extra cooking too, if he paid towards food that would be something, other things do add up.
Glad you are rid

RantyAunty · 01/04/2022 23:58

Well done on getting rid.
There's no reason a man in his 30s should be living with his parents.

HollowTalk · 01/04/2022 23:49

This is the second guy in just a few days on here who is living both with his mother and his girlfriend and not paying either of them anything. The other one had a shitload of savings as well. You did the right thing dumping this one. 💐

Junipercrumble · 01/04/2022 23:43

OP, He doesnt want to stay only 2 nights a week for free! He wants to stay as often as he likes. . . For free, because as he said, it's your house, so he doesnt see why he should contribute, based on the fact that it's your house.

But it's your house!
What would you do if I wasnt here?

And upon moving in,
I'm happy to pay for the extra I cost, but I'm not happy to pay for anything that you would pay for if I weren't here.
I'll pay the extra 25% council tax, because you'd pay the rest even if I wasnt here!

ALL THINGS COCKLODGERS SAY!!

They try to make you feel like you abu when you're being more than reasonable.

You are happy to have him over with no expectation of a contribution for 2 nights a week.
You cannot afford to have him over more than 2 nights a week without a contribution.

I see nothing wrong with your proposal.

His response to you bringing it up would tell me everything I needed to know.
I'd be interested in what he contributes to his parents.

BadNomad · 01/04/2022 18:38

I suppose he sees it as you being grabby because you want him to give you money because your bills are getting too much because of your ex and the general rise in the cost of living. From his point of view he doesn't live with you and is only staying over to see you.

MadMadMadamMim · 01/04/2022 18:34

Blimey. I can't believe how ridiculous some of these answers are. He's costing you £10 a month. Grow up!

He's getting to stay somewhere, rent free, for more than half the week. Pays no council tax, pays no bills, pays no food. Makes no contribution to the stuff he's using.

I'm guessing he pays little (if anything?) to his parents as he's only staying there a couple of nights a week!

I'd love to be cruising through life on someone else's money like this.

He's a cocklodger.

timestheyarechanging · 01/04/2022 18:27

My BF stays here 3/4 nights a week. He doesn't pay me rent but we go out to eat at least two of those nights and he pays. He also takes me food shopping before he goes back to his rented place, and pays for it. So I feel that is more than covers his bed and board when he is here. I wouldn't charge him rent but I know he pays his way. He also pays when we go away for the weekend (frequently)

Hollyontherampage · 01/04/2022 14:21

He should pay for the extra costs of him being there. But, if he's already paying his way with food

She said he brings soft drinks and snacks. That hardly helps with meals.

MuggleMadness · 01/04/2022 14:15

@mrsm43s

He should pay for the extra costs of him being there. But, if he's already paying his way with food, then that will literally be the odd squeeze of shower gel, the odd blob of toothpaste, a tiny fraction of the water/energy costs to cover his shower etc. It won't add up to anything close to £20 per week, not likely even £10 per month!

You can't expect him to subsidise your household costs. The big issue seems to be that your ex isn't paying his way in supporting his son. That is what you should be focusing on.

^^ that!
MuggleMadness · 01/04/2022 14:12

@Blossomtoes

It’s not about whether she’s struggling financially *@MerryMarigold*. If she was earning £200k he should still make a financial contribution. Freeloading is the same regardless of the income of the person you’re sponging off.
Well, that's your definition of 'freeloading' it's not merits or mine. A boyfriend/partner staying because you want to be together isn't the same as living together. Very few costs change having a partner stay.

If the resident person is finding things tight and the non resident has more money, then helping out would be nice. But it's not about 'being fair'. It's about caring about each other.

GeminiTwin · 01/04/2022 14:11

@mrsm43s

He should pay for the extra costs of him being there. But, if he's already paying his way with food, then that will literally be the odd squeeze of shower gel, the odd blob of toothpaste, a tiny fraction of the water/energy costs to cover his shower etc. It won't add up to anything close to £20 per week, not likely even £10 per month!

You can't expect him to subsidise your household costs. The big issue seems to be that your ex isn't paying his way in supporting his son. That is what you should be focusing on.

I agree
Fireflygal · 01/04/2022 14:09

@limeSegment, you should apply to those tv shows about cost of living. If you know you can provide for an additional adult at 10p per visit, £3.00 per month you should tell us how. What toilet paper do you use? What does your tea or coffee cost? How regular do you shower? Is the water warm or do you choose not to heat it?

MuggleMadness · 01/04/2022 14:07

@MerryMarigold

Let's take the things he should pay for that you wouldn't use if he wasn't there:
  • toothpaste, loo roll, shower gel
  • food
  • shower heating

I'm not sure that's 20.00 per week but it depends how much he continues to food. That can add up.

I don't think he should cover broadband, fuel bills etc. as you would need to pay them anyway. It's not 'fair' he should pay towards what you would need to pay if he wasn't there. The implication he has been 'cocklodging' so far probably got his back up.

However, as a loving partner he should want to help you out with money if you're struggling and he has fewer outgoings. Are you open about the finances with him? Sure he really understand how little you have and is still being difficult about it? Maybe he doesn't like that he feels you are 'charging' him to be your boyfriend when really you just need some financial support from your partner and to be treated to things eg. The takeaways etc on him.

The obsession with being 'fair' is what has caused this because there will be different perceptions of what is 'fair' and clearly you both have a different perception of this. However, saying 'I'm finding it difficult and I would appreciate some help' is different. If he still responded in the way he has, he doesn't care about you and doesn't see a future with you.

^^ that's how I feel too.
MuggleMadness · 01/04/2022 14:01

@Ragwort

And what message does it give your DC if this waste of space is sleeping over so frequently?
That Mummy has a boyfriend she loves?!
Goldbar · 01/04/2022 13:56

Of course it costs a lot more to have an additional adult around.

My DH is at work most of the time during the week but on weekends and holidays when he is home we spend a lot more. Food, for example...DC and I will have scrambled eggs, fish fingers or baked beans on toast for dinner a few times a week. DH usually wants a 'proper' meal with meat or fish (or a fancy veggie option with lots of ingredients). Or we'll order takeaway - the cost of one takeaway is often the same as my food budget for DC and I the rest of the week. If I make a chilli, spag bol or pasta bake, it will cover 4-5 meals if it's just DC and I eating it. If DH is sharing, it will do 2 meals at most. Milk/coffee/ketchup doesn't last as long if there's another adult using it. Heating too...if DH is home, we'll often stay up late and keep the heating on longer. If not, I'll often go up with DS, read in bed and turn it off.

OP, I think you've done the right thing and good riddance. He sounds like someone who has never had to deal with the financial realities of life.

D0lphine · 01/04/2022 13:50

Gosh £20 a week is nothing to stay in someone's house 4/5 nights a week!