Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the Covid situation will ever deteriorate again so badly that we need another lockdown?

215 replies

goaskmum · 01/04/2022 07:15

Posting here for traffic.

I’m in no way suggesting the situation will ever deteriorate and I’m in no way advocating another lockdown.

I’m genuinely curious though, do you think the situation will get worse again, perhaps in the winter, were the hospitals can’t cope and we end up back in lockdown again?

Or do you think because most people are immune to covid either through having it or being vaccinated that it will keep on getting better from here on and there will never ever be a single restriction imposed again?

YABU - there will never ever be anymore restrictions. It’s over
YANBU - there could very well be another lockdown in the future if it gets out of hand

OP posts:
thebellagio · 01/04/2022 09:44

My perspective is that lockdowns helped kick the can down the road to allow the scientists to develop vaccines.

But the real issue was that the NHS wasn't able to cope. And let's be honest, over the last 5-10 years, this has ALWAYS been an issue of the NHS running at breaking point.

Back in 2020, clearly we couldn't magic up trained nurses/doctors. But we are now in year 3 of this pandemic. It takes 3 years to train a nurse. A doctor could be halfway through their training by now...So my view is that I wouldn't comply with a lockdown, because this government has had ample time to actually fix the issues that led to the lockdown in the first place. The type of virus is almost a mute point.

If they hadn't wasted so much money on test and trace, we could have the best health system in the world by now.

what they need to do is focus on sick pay, and ensuring that no one is financially disadvantaged by staying home when they are ill. In the long run, it would be much cheaper with better health benefits!

Mummyoflittledragon · 01/04/2022 09:42

@HardyBuckette
Totally agree with you. Society would collapse. I’m not worrying about it, which is what I meant about the not thinking about it. No point. Live for the now.

HardyBuckette · 01/04/2022 09:38

@Mummyoflittledragon

Seven day average deaths stayed below 300 death per day over the winter. I think we would have to get a very deadly strain with pretty much zero resistance before another lockdown. I wouldn’t think this to be likely to happen in the short term with the current covid strains as it appears to be sweeping through the population right now. We must be getting toward herd immunity with antibodies produced from covid plus the vaccination, surely?

I would imagine the population therefore to be somewhat immunised from becoming gravely ill from any new variant coming along right now but what about the future? Chris Whitty has warned another more deadly strain could come along within the next two years. Sage have stated there could even be a MERS like variant, which kills one in 3 people. Presuming we are approaching herd immunity and that covid had abated, antibodies will somewhat wane in the next two years if we don’t continue with vaccinations so I can see what he’s saying and in this scenario. Obviously then, restrictions would come back.

Hopefully, however, if a variant emerged causing 1 in 3 deaths, if would not spread as fast as BA.2 as the sufferers would die before infecting too many. I’ve seen too many films, where this isn’t the case though and I’d rather not think about it tbh.

Part of living as humans now do is the risk of something coming along that wipes out a significant chunk of us. That's happened before, and the possibility always exists, so SAGE aren't saying anything much by pointing that out. It was true before covid arrived and it's still true now. But very few pandemics get anywhere near that level. And tbh, if anything that killed as many as the Black Death ever came along again now we have the level of connectivity we do, I think there's a fair chance civilisation would collapse as we all turned on each other.
Mummyoflittledragon · 01/04/2022 09:34

Seven day average deaths stayed below 300 death per day over the winter. I think we would have to get a very deadly strain with pretty much zero resistance before another lockdown. I wouldn’t think this to be likely to happen in the short term with the current covid strains as it appears to be sweeping through the population right now. We must be getting toward herd immunity with antibodies produced from covid plus the vaccination, surely?

I would imagine the population therefore to be somewhat immunised from becoming gravely ill from any new variant coming along right now but what about the future? Chris Whitty has warned another more deadly strain could come along within the next two years. Sage have stated there could even be a MERS like variant, which kills one in 3 people. Presuming we are approaching herd immunity and that covid had abated, antibodies will somewhat wane in the next two years if we don’t continue with vaccinations so I can see what he’s saying and in this scenario. Obviously then, restrictions would come back.

Hopefully, however, if a variant emerged causing 1 in 3 deaths, if would not spread as fast as BA.2 as the sufferers would die before infecting too many. I’ve seen too many films, where this isn’t the case though and I’d rather not think about it tbh.

Popcornriver · 01/04/2022 09:32

I don't think there will be. Pretty much zero chance unless a really dangerous varient emerged with much higher fatality and the vaccines were rendered pretty much useless against it. Luckily the new varient seems to be less severe and I think that trend will continue.

HardyBuckette · 01/04/2022 09:32

I'm not sure it even boils down to the number of people dying of covid in the public perception either tbh. There could be a significant increase in the numbers of elderly people who die of it without that causing general desire for lockdown.

TheRealityCheque · 01/04/2022 09:31

After the unnecessary shit-show of the past couple of years, it should be written into law that never again can our freedoms be removed in this way.

Lockdowns achieved nothing
Masks achieve nothing

WFH where possible is sensible, as is self isolating.

Cornettoninja · 01/04/2022 09:28

It will all boil down to the number of people dying in the end

From the publics pov maybe but in all (gruesome) honestly possibly not from the NHS/governments pov.

One of the biggest issues with covid is the disease progression means that those that succumb on average take a relatively long time to do so which is a factor in overwhelming hospitals which then forces treatments for other survivable issues to decline in quality/availability.

If disease progression speeds up with mutations we could tolerate higher levels of fatalities. Of course treatments feed into this and lives are prolonged whilst treatment attempts to save people but in a society where the expectation is to be at the very least made comfortable which usually requires treatment, it would have to be as maniac to suggest that we stop treating people while we have the means to do so.

EthelTheAardvark · 01/04/2022 09:26

@Enzbear

Never. It barely had any positive effects and loads of negative ones.
You only have to look at the statistical curve to see that it did have a very positive effect.
GoldenOmber · 01/04/2022 09:23

true, agree with that. There is definitely more public appetite for “government needs to look like it’s doing something in a way which won’t inconvenience me personally very much” than there would be for full lockdowns.

HardyBuckette · 01/04/2022 09:20

Thing is though that any variant which could dissolve omicron would have to be more infectious than omicron, and in that case restrictions short of lockdown are unlikely to do very much.

WRT restrictions there are two separate questions however: whether they're going to do anything useful and whether it's politically expedient to be seen to have them anyway. Obviously some restrictions are far too costly to be able to use purely as a sop, like lockdown or the return of isolation laws, but they're not all.

This is why I don't rule out masks coming back even in the face of an Omicron like strain where there's no reason to think they'd do much. I think anything that doesn't have an obviously significant cost to the state or economy might still be on the table in a Something Must Be Done situation.

Dinoteeth · 01/04/2022 09:05

@LaurieFairyCake
Where is that 200,000 deaths figure coming from?

I didn't think the estimate was anything like that in the UK, and there were very few of the normal annual flu deaths, which are accepted every winter as part of the normal ageing process.

Enzbear · 01/04/2022 08:51

Never. It barely had any positive effects and loads of negative ones.

Polyanthus2 · 01/04/2022 08:51

It will be what it will be

I am utterly sick of people discussing Covid - this person tested + but they were - at their earlier test, so and so has a cold but they thought it was covid, So and so is isolating, numbers are high at the nursery/school/hospital etc etc etc etc etc etc

I DO NOT CARE - let's just get on with life and make the best of it

EthelTheAardvark · 01/04/2022 08:48

Lockdown is not being babied. You only have to look at the statistics pre-vaccine to see that it clearly had an effect on the infection rate, and at that time that was all we had to keep it under some sort of control.

Wiredforsound · 01/04/2022 08:47

I only think there would be a lockdown if a highly virulent, super deadly, variant emerged that was immune to the vaccines, and a high proportion of the population started needing hospitalisation or died. That’s the worst case scenario.

EthelTheAardvark · 01/04/2022 08:45

There's a potential scenario where a highly life-threatening strain mutates that is resistant to the vaccine: in that situation lockdown would be the only possibility both to save lives and to keep the strain off the NHS. No idea how likely that is, though.

GoldenOmber · 01/04/2022 08:44

displace omicron, I meant, not dissolve… would be cool if it could dissolve it though Grin

elliejjtiny · 01/04/2022 08:43

I don't think there will be another lockdown. I do sometimes worry that the problems currently with schools and hospitals are going to be permanent though. I haven't been allowed to go into my dc's primary school for 2 years now and for selfish reasons I am really hoping that my 3rd dc will be allowed to have his year 6 class photo, leavers service, school concert and leavers barbeque like his brothers did. None of that has been happening since 2019 in our primary school. Secondary school has been a bit better. We have been allowed to attend dc3's open evening, dc2's options evening, dc1 and dc2's award ceremony and dc2's SEN review this year. Still no plays or concerts though. Dc1 gets to have his leavers assembly and prom though, really pleased about that.

GoldenOmber · 01/04/2022 08:42

@comealongponds

YABU for using those options! Far more likely is a middle ground of some restrictions being reintroduced but short of a full lockdown
Thing is though that any variant which could dissolve omicron would have to be more infectious than omicron, and in that case restrictions short of lockdown are unlikely to do very much.

(hello from Scotland, where with omicron we still have mandatory masks and available testing and a lot of guidelines restricting use of public space to limit transmission and WFH-sometimes advice from the government, and… the highest rates in the UK by a hefty margin.)

SoupDragon · 01/04/2022 08:41

I think the government will do everything to try to avoid more lockdowns but I don't think they can be totally ruled out.

I can see restrictions and testing being reintroduced as necessary to avoid lockdown.

comealongponds · 01/04/2022 08:37

YABU for using those options! Far more likely is a middle ground of some restrictions being reintroduced but short of a full lockdown

HardyBuckette · 01/04/2022 08:34

I'm seeing increasing awareness of the massive number of infections at the moment. Everyone seems to have close friends, family, co-workers with it, and that's impacting, i.e. cancelling social events, workplace staff shortages, product/delivery delays etc. I certainly know people who've started wearing masks again, cutting down close contacts, avoiding crowded places. The "feel good" factor of the lifting of restrictions seems to have been very short lived and people are starting to become wary again.

This is very, very different to appetite for lockdown though. Also the social stuff doesn't remotely match what I'm seeing around me, where people are more than over it and want to make up for lost time. I accept that considerable variation on this point exists in the population, but that's the point really. For lockdown to ever be a realistic possibility, you need a critical mass of the population to buy into it. We do not have that. It's not something that can be sustained long term.

I don't rule out the possibility that masks might return at some point though, it's a relatively minimal intervention and ticks a 'doing something' box for those who want one.

beautifullymad · 01/04/2022 08:32

It could. Mutations can go either way but it unlikely to be omicron it will be another strain.

Globally when omicron takes over completely could be a good thing as we will have levels of immunity to this strain.

But if another variant proves to be lethal then I expect masks and distancing might be brought in to curb the spread for a while. Slow the hospitalisation rate. But that's all.

We have vaccines and treatments that weren't available for original strains.

It will all boil down to the number of people dying in the end.

GoldenOmber · 01/04/2022 08:32

I'm seeing increasing awareness of the massive number of infections at the moment.

That’s not the same thing as appetite for a lockdown, though.

There are of course some people who will go right from “I see lots of covid around” to “we should lock down now!” but to get public support for a lockdown you need to get most people thinking that, and they just don’t.

Swipe left for the next trending thread