Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the Covid situation will ever deteriorate again so badly that we need another lockdown?

215 replies

goaskmum · 01/04/2022 07:15

Posting here for traffic.

I’m in no way suggesting the situation will ever deteriorate and I’m in no way advocating another lockdown.

I’m genuinely curious though, do you think the situation will get worse again, perhaps in the winter, were the hospitals can’t cope and we end up back in lockdown again?

Or do you think because most people are immune to covid either through having it or being vaccinated that it will keep on getting better from here on and there will never ever be a single restriction imposed again?

YABU - there will never ever be anymore restrictions. It’s over
YANBU - there could very well be another lockdown in the future if it gets out of hand

OP posts:
HardyBuckette · 02/04/2022 11:43

@GoldenOmber

If the past two years have taught us anything, it’s that no amount of lockdown is ever going to count as a ‘proper lockdown’ by some people’s criteria.
That much we do know.
GoldenOmber · 02/04/2022 11:40

If the past two years have taught us anything, it’s that no amount of lockdown is ever going to count as a ‘proper lockdown’ by some people’s criteria.

TheKeatingFive · 02/04/2022 11:34

A proper one this time

Wtf is a 'proper' lockdown?

And what would it achieve?

Have you cast your eye over what's happening in China these days for example?

PurpleDaisies · 02/04/2022 11:26

Tests now cost individuals so most people will not test. This will reduce the reported numbers.
The ONS prevalence survey will tell us how many have covid. The daily case numbers are basically irrelevant now.

PurpleDaisies · 02/04/2022 11:25

I think we need one. A proper one this time. But it wont happen

Based on what information?

user1471538283 · 02/04/2022 11:23

I think we need one. A proper one this time. But it wont happen.

Tests now cost individuals so most people will not test. This will reduce the reported numbers.

HardyBuckette · 02/04/2022 11:19

@Belladonna12

We know there are no guarantees and nobody thinks there are. It isn't about certainty. The question was whether people think a Covid 19 variant that's resistant to all of of our existing vaccines and treatments, not merely less effective but ineffective because that's what you said, and that also reverses the existing age profile for vulnerability, is as likely or more likely than a variant that doesn't do these things.

Of course the virus could change so that current vaccines and treatments weren't effective at all. We have been lucky in that so far they have just been less effective rather than completely ineffective. They would probably would be able to tweak them to be effective but there would be a delay and restrictions could be necessary in the meantime.

Once again, nobody thinks it's impossible. The question is why the focus on this rather less likely scenario when people respond based on what is most likely. And also why, even in your focus on that point as you argue that further lockdowns could happen during this pandemic, you don't address the impact of lower risk on the behaviour of many who are higher risk now.
Belladonna12 · 02/04/2022 09:40

We know there are no guarantees and nobody thinks there are. It isn't about certainty. The question was whether people think a Covid 19 variant that's resistant to all of of our existing vaccines and treatments, not merely less effective but ineffective because that's what you said, and that also reverses the existing age profile for vulnerability, is as likely or more likely than a variant that doesn't do these things.

Of course the virus could change so that current vaccines and treatments weren't effective at all. We have been lucky in that so far they have just been less effective rather than completely ineffective. They would probably would be able to tweak them to be effective but there would be a delay and restrictions could be necessary in the meantime.

HardyBuckette · 02/04/2022 09:33

Yes, it is not at all unlikely that the vaccines and treatments we currently have will not work on all future strains. There has already been a problem with Omicron- some of the treatments no longer work and vaccines are less effective. They will be able to tweak the vaccines and hopefully produce effective treatments against new variants but there would always be a delay.

It is less likely that new variants will attack younger people as much as older people but there are certainly no guarantees. I don't think they know that much about why older people are more susceptible at the moment but I think one of the reasons is because the virus attaches to particular receptors in the body which increase as people get older. That could change.

We know there are no guarantees and nobody thinks there are. It isn't about certainty. The question was whether people think a Covid 19 variant that's resistant to all of of our existing vaccines and treatments, not merely less effective but ineffective because that's what you said, and that also reverses the existing age profile for vulnerability, is as likely or more likely than a variant that doesn't do these things.

It seems you acknowledge that this is less likely, so it appears we do agree on that point. And because it's less likely, this is why people's responses are located in what we've already experienced and we know to be the most likely possibility, rather than something that is unlikely.

There's also the point that if for whatever reason we want to ask the what if things were completely different question, as well as the people whose low risk informs their views now, there are people whose high risk informs their views now. There are people who are in their 60s, 70s and 80s who take precautions and are/would be supportive of restrictions because they feel personally at risk from covid. If this were no longer the case, that raises the question of how their attitudes would change. It wouldn't be the case that everyone who complied with previous lockdowns and would comply with future ones because of their own fear would continue to hold this attitude if their risk profile suddenly dropped.

YouHaveYourFathersBreasts · 02/04/2022 09:18

I don’t think there will be another lockdown as there is a vaccine now. I do think winters for the NHS, which are hard enough as it is, will get worse. They need more funding chucked their way and better allocated at that, rather than national lockdowns.

SafelySoftly · 02/04/2022 09:10

Honestly of course there’s a risk. There could be a truly properly deadly variant. It could be much worse!

Not really too sure of point of this thread!

Belladonna12 · 02/04/2022 09:01

@Aishah231

I think governments realise even if the message is too unpalatable to say that lockdowns created more problems than they solved. The data from countries with no lockdown is roughly similar to those with lockdowns when you compare countries with similar demographics. We will live with the economic consequences of lockdown for at least a generation. If we have another lockdown it'll be for political not health reasons and I hope most refuse to comply this time.
What countries have had no lockdown and similar results to other countries with the same demographics/healthcare systems?
CounsellorTroi · 02/04/2022 08:58

UK Covid cases are at an all time high. Vaccines will lose their effectiveness. I don’t think it’s inconceivable we’ll return to masks and social distancing.

Belladonna12 · 02/04/2022 08:55

@HardyBuckette

To be clear, are you saying that a strain of the Covid 19 virus that doesn't respond to any of the quite effective treatments and vaccines we have now and that essentially reverses the pattern of all previous strains wrt who is most vulnerable is as likely as a new strain that does none of these things? I know it isn't impossible, but nobody thinks it is.
Yes, it is not at all unlikely that the vaccines and treatments we currently have will not work on all future strains. There has already been a problem with Omicron- some of the treatments no longer work and vaccines are less effective. They will be able to tweak the vaccines and hopefully produce effective treatments against new variants but there would always be a delay.

It is less likely that new variants will attack younger people as much as older people but there are certainly no guarantees. I don't think they know that much about why older people are more susceptible at the moment but I think one of the reasons is because the virus attaches to particular receptors in the body which increase as people get older. That could change.

Aishah231 · 02/04/2022 07:51

I think governments realise even if the message is too unpalatable to say that lockdowns created more problems than they solved. The data from countries with no lockdown is roughly similar to those with lockdowns when you compare countries with similar demographics. We will live with the economic consequences of lockdown for at least a generation. If we have another lockdown it'll be for political not health reasons and I hope most refuse to comply this time.

HardyBuckette · 02/04/2022 07:49

Sorry, was meant to say as likely or more likely there.

HardyBuckette · 02/04/2022 07:49

To be clear, are you saying that a strain of the Covid 19 virus that doesn't respond to any of the quite effective treatments and vaccines we have now and that essentially reverses the pattern of all previous strains wrt who is most vulnerable is as likely as a new strain that does none of these things? I know it isn't impossible, but nobody thinks it is.

UnmentionedElephantDildo · 02/04/2022 07:39

We know what's more likely to happen, and it isn't a more lethal strain that primarily affects children whilst also being vaccine and treatment resistant

We don't know what's likely.

We do know what's possible.

HardyBuckette · 02/04/2022 07:36

@Belladonna12

We're talking about Covid 19, that's the only disease being discussed. The OP didn't mention any other, probably for the very obvious reason that there's no way of knowing what future pandemics and responses might look like.

The virus mutates and the illness so far has been quite variable as a result. We don't know that the high risk groups now will be the same in the future.

Nobody said it was a certainty. We do however know exactly how the virus has progressed so far and who's been the most vulnerable. Additionally we know there has yet to be a strain that was vaccine resistant, and that we have a range of treatments now. We know what's more likely to happen, and it isn't a more lethal strain that primarily affects children whilst also being vaccine and treatment resistant.

So that still leaves us with the question of why the focus on a situation that's so very different from what we have so far encountered in just about every way, and why you continue to default to that when people point out why further lockdown in the Covid 19 pandemic is so unlikely.

Snazzyjazzpants · 02/04/2022 05:41

Lockdown are a policy choice. As long as the economy continues to deteriorate with high inflation and rolling product shortages no-one would dare consider it.
Lockdown compliance was contingent on massive wage replacement programs. How the heck would you run that now?
People could be dying in the streets and they'd just have to find another way to deal with it.

mjf981 · 02/04/2022 04:13

I highly doubt there will be another covid lockdown.
However, the inter connected world is a ticking time bomb. At some point another, much deadlier virus will emerge. Could be next week or in 50 years time. And at that point, yes, its likely that lockdown will happen. No-one can predict when or what this will be.

Dinoteeth · 02/04/2022 03:14

@fUNNYfACE36
I thought that's what they said too that they didn't really do anything. But it was sort of brushed under the carpet.

Back in March 2020 I remember one of the first press conferences BJ was trying to resist lockdown and said something i can't remember his exact words but he made me think we'll all get covid and to make sure we were stocked up on paracetamol.

Then the attitude changed a week or two later and keyworker lists were announced.

One thing that will never be allowed to happen again is banning visitors from Care Homes in Scotland. Thanks to Ann's Law and her brave family who pursued it through the courts residents will always be able to have at least one named visitor.

I also remember someone suggesting to me that the British Government were keen to keep kids in schools in an attempt to build up some resistance to covid in children and their parents.
Because if the vaccines that were being worked on didn't work then there had to be a Plan B.

fUNNYfACE36 · 01/04/2022 23:53

No,
It has been recognised that the lockdowns were a big mistake and did much more harm than good.Apart from those who the tories gave big contracts to

GettinPiggyWithIt · 01/04/2022 23:33

The government have completely blown any chances of people complying 🤷‍♀️

I know I wouldn’t be willing.

XenoBitch · 01/04/2022 23:26

I think if any restrictions/rules come back in, it will be things like masks and self isolation. Maybe Covid pass things too.
I do not believe that a lockdown will happen again. Especially not after the hypocrisy some MPs displayed over the rules. I honestly believe that the vast majority of people would not abide by lockdown rules again. When you look back on it, it was bonkers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread