Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the Covid situation will ever deteriorate again so badly that we need another lockdown?

215 replies

goaskmum · 01/04/2022 07:15

Posting here for traffic.

I’m in no way suggesting the situation will ever deteriorate and I’m in no way advocating another lockdown.

I’m genuinely curious though, do you think the situation will get worse again, perhaps in the winter, were the hospitals can’t cope and we end up back in lockdown again?

Or do you think because most people are immune to covid either through having it or being vaccinated that it will keep on getting better from here on and there will never ever be a single restriction imposed again?

YABU - there will never ever be anymore restrictions. It’s over
YANBU - there could very well be another lockdown in the future if it gets out of hand

OP posts:
BurnDownTheDiscoHangTheDJ · 03/04/2022 08:00

I can see next winter being chaos if people get complacent/ don’t get a booster etc. My friends who work in the NHS say they’re worried about it and already planning.

HardyBuckette · 03/04/2022 07:45

What do you mean by back at square one LarGoo, in the context of lockdowns? Because I can see how circumstances might arise where at least some people outside the crank wing are calling for it again, but a perceived or arguable need is only one of the factors that need to be in place for a lockdown to be feasible.

There also needs to be a government who'll implement one led by a PM who can survive doing it, substantial public buy in and some mechanism to pay enough people to stay at home for there to be a sufficient drop in contacts. There's also the schools issue. It's very clear that any attempt at another national closure would be politically toxic, so the government aren't going to want to go anywhere near it, and would additionally be accompanied by even greater numbers of parents quite understandably desperate to get key worker places. But it's not a lockdown in any meaningful sense if the schools are open.

LarGoo · 02/04/2022 21:38

Good point. I agree, my words were poorly chosen and the word ‘slow’ and “the vast majority” are more appropriate, but I don’t believe that changes the underlying message. We should be doing whatever we reasonably can to slow the spread. Every time a virus moves from one host to another there is a chance that it will mutate, and with C19 it’s likely that the next mutation (that becomes dominant) will be will be more severe.

As someone with a CEV dh, I’m probably more cautious than many others, but I can’t see how opening windows, adding ventilation to workplaces and testing/ wearing masks when seeing the most vulnerable in society is a hardship.

GoldenOmber · 02/04/2022 21:20

We all want it to be over, but the best way to actually stop this virus from mutating is stopping its spread.

But we cannot actually do this. It is not within the power of humanity to do. We can potentially slow the spread temporarily, at great cost, to buy time for vaccines. But all the measures in the world, from whatever ‘sensible measures’ you personally prefer to whatever hellish authoritarian response China is trying at the moment, are not able to stop it.

I also wouldn’t be so sure that ‘nobody wants’ another lockdown, personally. Most people don’t, but…

LarGoo · 02/04/2022 21:11

Much as I know no one wants another lockdown and the harm on some people, all it takes is another more serious variant and then we’re back at square one.

People seem to be lulled into a false sense of security by the fact that Omicron is less severe that other variants, but that is pure chance. Viruses always try to mutate to be more infectious (as Omicron is) but their severity is pure chance. All a virus wants to do is replicate - it doesn’t care if it kills you or just gives you a runny nose.

Obviously I hope Omicron is the worst we will get from now on, but realistically in the next few months we’ll get another variant that will more severe. Given that the government and people seem to have given up on any restrictions, no one seems fussed about boosters or masks, there is little surveillance, and we haven’t bothered to take the sensible steps (increase ventilation in schools, hospitals, etc) I do worry that we’ll be back to severe restrictions in Autumn.

We all want it to be over, but the best way to actually stop this virus from mutating is stopping its spread.

HardyBuckette · 02/04/2022 20:10

@Belladonna12

The things the elderly might do to not observe a lockdown in such a situation are the same things that many of us, including the elderly, did when not observing the last lockdown. For the over 80s in my family that included having whoever they liked in their house, visiting the homes of other family members, meeting outside, having haircuts from hairdressers and barbers who continued operating on the quiet and in one case going to a party. I'm not aware of any octagenarian who rioted whilst ignoring the last lockdown, but tbf I also don't know anyone under 80 whose lockdown breaches looked like that either.

I disagree that they would be doing the same thing as they were in the last lockdown if it was their children or grandchildren whose lives were they were risking rather than their own. It's a bit different risking your own life if you're near the end of life anyway compared with risking the lives of your children or grandchildren. How would they get a haircut if hairdressers didn't want to work because they were younger and at higher risk?

Again though, the elderly are not a monolithic bloc. It's horribly patronising to assume they'd all think the same way and just plain daft to assume they've all got children and grandchildren. There would be variation, just as there is in other age groups, just as some people in their 20s were actively calling for lockdown and others ignored it. Because people over 80 don't share a hive mind or hive life.

Also, since when were all hairdressers and barbers young? My gran's is in her 60s. The retirement age is closer to 60 than 70 and, as we know, people fall through the financial cracks in lockdown.

caringcarer · 02/04/2022 19:54

Don't even whisper it. Few could cope with another lockdown.

Belladonna12 · 02/04/2022 19:49

The things the elderly might do to not observe a lockdown in such a situation are the same things that many of us, including the elderly, did when not observing the last lockdown. For the over 80s in my family that included having whoever they liked in their house, visiting the homes of other family members, meeting outside, having haircuts from hairdressers and barbers who continued operating on the quiet and in one case going to a party. I'm not aware of any octagenarian who rioted whilst ignoring the last lockdown, but tbf I also don't know anyone under 80 whose lockdown breaches looked like that either.

I disagree that they would be doing the same thing as they were in the last lockdown if it was their children or grandchildren whose lives were they were risking rather than their own. It's a bit different risking your own life if you're near the end of life anyway compared with risking the lives of your children or grandchildren. How would they get a haircut if hairdressers didn't want to work because they were younger and at higher risk?

HardyBuckette · 02/04/2022 19:32

I don't think that there is a large gap, particularly as as the majority don't work. They are not going to be rioting because pubs and restaurants are shut. They wouldn't want to mix with their younger family members and potentially give them a life-threatening disease. What do you think they would they be doing in order to not observe lockdown?

Of course there's a large gap. Because there's a huge amount of activity limitation that can be done that's way short of lockdown. Being willing to limit activities and being willing to observe lockdown are not remotely the same thing. A person who is willing to take an LFT before going to a large event and not go if they're covid positive is a person who's willing to limit their activities, but it doesn't follow that they'll then support or observe a lockdown. This is before considering whether a majority and a sufficient number to make lockdown viable are the same thing.

The things the elderly might do to not observe a lockdown in such a situation are the same things that many of us, including the elderly, did when not observing the last lockdown. For the over 80s in my family that included having whoever they liked in their house, visiting the homes of other family members, meeting outside, having haircuts from hairdressers and barbers who continued operating on the quiet and in one case going to a party. I'm not aware of any octagenarian who rioted whilst ignoring the last lockdown, but tbf I also don't know anyone under 80 whose lockdown breaches looked like that either.

And you just cannot say that a whole cohort of people will definitely all have the same attitudes just because they're the same age, because of course they won't. Any more than all twentysomethings do.

FabFitFifties · 02/04/2022 19:22

There would have to be no hospital beds. We won't find out how many deaths there are, but we will be told if hospitals are in crisis. Even then, I imagine restrictions, but no lockdown.

ddl1 · 02/04/2022 19:06

Very unlikely, though less drastic restrictions may be imposed from time to time. Vaccinations make death much less likely, even if you get it - and most of us probably will, sooner or later. But there may be other pandemics!

Belladonna12 · 02/04/2022 18:57

@HardyBuckette

Ok. There's a large gap between the majority limiting their activities and the elderly as a cohort advocating for and observing a lockdown despite being low risk themselves. Remember that you need the population to do both in order for lockdowns to do what they're aimed at doing, and the state needs to be pretty confident that this will happen before being willing to instigate one.
I don't think that there is a large gap, particularly as as the majority don't work. They are not going to be rioting because pubs and restaurants are shut. They wouldn't want to mix with their younger family members and potentially give them a life-threatening disease. What do you think they would they be doing in order to not observe lockdown?
PurpleDaisies · 02/04/2022 18:48

Remove free tests = reduced testing = number of positive test falls = Tories claim success

Except ONS survey. 1 I’m 13 in England with covid at the moment.

notanothertakeaway · 02/04/2022 18:43

@Lougle

There's no routine testing now except NHS etc. So there won't be an accurate number of infections to work from. See no evil....

How would they decide to lockdown without any numbers?

Agree with @Lougle

Remove free tests = reduced testing = number of positive test falls = Tories claim success

HardyBuckette · 02/04/2022 18:39

Ok. There's a large gap between the majority limiting their activities and the elderly as a cohort advocating for and observing a lockdown despite being low risk themselves. Remember that you need the population to do both in order for lockdowns to do what they're aimed at doing, and the state needs to be pretty confident that this will happen before being willing to instigate one.

Belladonna12 · 02/04/2022 18:05

There doesn't have to be, but you mentioned plenty of contagious diseases hitting the young more than the elderly when the point that the elderly would likely still be at the highest risk of a new Covid 19 strain was made. So that's what we were discussing.

Ok, I believe that the majority of older people would limit their activities for the benefit of younger people if they were at highest risk from covid.

HardyBuckette · 02/04/2022 17:33

@Belladonna12

It's interesting that you water down what you were asking about again. You mention a deadlier variant that isn't responsive to vaccines and treatments, omitting reversal of the age risk profile you mentioned previously. Meaning that in this scenario, the elderly would still continue to be the ones most likely to die.

There doesn't have to be a reversal of the age risk profile. Even if elderly people were still at high risk, the risk could also increase quite a lot in younger people.

There doesn't have to be, but you mentioned plenty of contagious diseases hitting the young more than the elderly when the point that the elderly would likely still be at the highest risk of a new Covid 19 strain was made. So that's what we were discussing.
Belladonna12 · 02/04/2022 17:29

It's interesting that you water down what you were asking about again. You mention a deadlier variant that isn't responsive to vaccines and treatments, omitting reversal of the age risk profile you mentioned previously. Meaning that in this scenario, the elderly would still continue to be the ones most likely to die.

There doesn't have to be a reversal of the age risk profile. Even if elderly people were still at high risk, the risk could also increase quite a lot in younger people.

HardyBuckette · 02/04/2022 16:22

@TheKeatingFive

A more severe strain would change the situation in many ways, but what people don't factor into this scenario is the role of essential workers.

Would people obediently pop out to stack shelves/deliver Amazon orders/drive ambulances/keep your electricity and wifi going if they're exposing themselves to a virus with a much higher death rate? I doubt it.

The comfy lockdown conditions that certain people experienced in the first phases of the pandemic wouldn't be happening if we had a much more severe strain. It would be grim as fuck.

I don't believe the conditions that enabled the lockdown of March 2020 are replicable again.

This is also true. In order to construct even hypothetical scenarios where they can argue that lockdowns are plausible in the near future, people not only have to engage in very strangulated reasoning, they also need to ignore various structural factors.

Basically, if we were to get to the stage where a lockdown might at least arguably be considered necessary (arguing from a pro lockdown perspective for a moment) then the building blocks from the last two probably aren't going to be in place.

HardyBuckette · 02/04/2022 16:15

@Belladonna12

Once again, nobody thinks it's impossible. The question is why the focus on this rather less likely scenario when people respond based on what is most likely.

It's not unlikely that a more deadly variant will emerge and it's not particularly unlikely that vaccines and treatments will not initially be effective.

And also why, even in your focus on that point as you argue that further lockdowns could happen during this pandemic, you don't address the impact of lower risk on the behaviour of many who are higher risk now

I'm not sure what your question is? Are you saying that older people will refuse to comply with lockdowns if they are at low risk even if younger people are being hospitalized and dying? I doubt it. 80-year olds don't party much anyway and are unlikely to want their children or grandchildren to die.

It's interesting that you water down what you were asking about again. You mention a deadlier variant that isn't responsive to vaccines and treatments, omitting reversal of the age risk profile you mentioned previously. Meaning that in this scenario, the elderly would still continue to be the ones most likely to die. You're kidding yourself if you think there would be willingness to weather all the damages of lockdown yet again so that people who have already had long lives could live longer. The political and economic factors making lockdown so unlikely would still be in place, and there wouldn't be the general buy in from the population.

And yes, I'm stating that if you want to talk about a total flipping of the age risk profile, that means considering the impact it would have on everyone's behaviour, not just that of people whose risks would increase. You've alluded yourself to some people's attitudes being linked to their own risk: that's true in some cases and everyone knows it. With that in mind, you can't simply assume that all these people will be willing to voluntarily limit their own activities (presumably you understand that it doesn't need to be a party to transmit covid...) for someone else's benefit. Some will. They won't all. Much as I think this isn't a very useful way to view people's takes on the likelihood of a lockdown, if you're going to do it then do it properly.

Belladonna12 · 02/04/2022 15:13

Once again, nobody thinks it's impossible. The question is why the focus on this rather less likely scenario when people respond based on what is most likely.

It's not unlikely that a more deadly variant will emerge and it's not particularly unlikely that vaccines and treatments will not initially be effective.

And also why, even in your focus on that point as you argue that further lockdowns could happen during this pandemic, you don't address the impact of lower risk on the behaviour of many who are higher risk now

I'm not sure what your question is? Are you saying that older people will refuse to comply with lockdowns if they are at low risk even if younger people are being hospitalized and dying? I doubt it. 80-year olds don't party much anyway and are unlikely to want their children or grandchildren to die.

Belladonna12 · 02/04/2022 14:54

Sweden had restrictions in 2021. They are more like Norway and Denmark than Scotland and their covid death rate has been much higher than those countries.

TeacupDrama · 02/04/2022 12:17

I don't think lockdowns work Sweden never locked down in 2021 their death rate was exactly the same as 2015-2019 5 year average ie no excess deaths ( they did have excess deaths in 2020 but much lower than UK and Scotland) Sweden is very much like Scotland rather than England with similar and lower population density but most people living in urban areas the equivalent of Scottish central belt ,
in this country deaths have been below the pre covid 5 year average since January, yes people are still dying from covid but perhaps these are the same people that might have died from flu pneumonia and other respiratory diseases in a different year as flu deaths are tiny tiny now
Scotland still has masks some restrictions and a much lower population density than England but it's case rate is much higher, doesn't really suggest that these precautions help at all if they did it should be the other way about,

nordica · 02/04/2022 11:50

The recent variants have been so transmissible that it's hard to see how a lockdown would help as lots of people still need to go to work, food shops stay open, there would be support and childcare bubbles again and generally lots of mixing.

However I don't think covid will be the last pandemic in our lifetimes and I hope governments around the world are doing some serious planning for the next one to avoid the delays when things start looking serious.

TheKeatingFive · 02/04/2022 11:44

A more severe strain would change the situation in many ways, but what people don't factor into this scenario is the role of essential workers.

Would people obediently pop out to stack shelves/deliver Amazon orders/drive ambulances/keep your electricity and wifi going if they're exposing themselves to a virus with a much higher death rate? I doubt it.

The comfy lockdown conditions that certain people experienced in the first phases of the pandemic wouldn't be happening if we had a much more severe strain. It would be grim as fuck.

I don't believe the conditions that enabled the lockdown of March 2020 are replicable again.