Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why so many people here feel like they have the right to deny/grant permission for their partners to do something?

137 replies

Bintymcbintface · 31/03/2022 21:18

Just this really. So many people here have posts like AIBU to not let DH to x or should I allow DP to do y. You're speaking about ADULTS here, people who are perfectly capable of making up their own minds and doing whatever they please and have been able to from the age of 18 when they became a full grown adult. If you want someone/something to lord over get a puppy and teach it to fetch you your slippers or something

OP posts:
Dinoteeth · 01/04/2022 04:50

Yes a SAHP has as much right to spare cash as the working parent. Verging on financially controlling / abusive to think otherwise.
If a couple have decided in their circumstances its better for one parent not to work outside the home that parent needs to be provided for by the working parent.

Bintymcbintface · 01/04/2022 04:49

@Dinoteeth

It's all relevant though someone working 5 days a week and spending a full day at the weekend hill climbing or golfing is hardly pulling there weight with the house and kids either.

If the other partner was to do the same them they'd be no family time what so ever.

Relationships have to be about give and take not just take.

I agree that family time and spending time together is important but if someone didn't want to spend time with me I wouldn't want to be in a relationship with them and wouldn't be. Either people work well together or they don't, if that's the dynamic of the relationship and someone isn't happy, don't be in that relationship, forcing someone to do something they don't want to do isn't a good ground for any sort of relationship anyway, people need to come to that decision themselves
OP posts:
Dinoteeth · 01/04/2022 04:45

It's all relevant though someone working 5 days a week and spending a full day at the weekend hill climbing or golfing is hardly pulling there weight with the house and kids either.

If the other partner was to do the same them they'd be no family time what so ever.

Relationships have to be about give and take not just take.

Bintymcbintface · 01/04/2022 04:40

@Dinoteeth

It's not always about who earned the money, a working parent who's being facilitated by a part-time / stay at home parent cannot hog all the spare cash.
So you think that someone who isn't working and therefore not contributing to the finances at all has as much right to have spare cash to do what they want with as the person who'd earned it all? Why? Why don't you find the idea of an adult being given "pocket money" demeaning?
OP posts:
Bintymcbintface · 01/04/2022 04:38

@alexdgr8

OP, you don't seem to have much of a concept of family life. you seem to see it as some kind of belligerent or combative house-sharing situation. rather than a chosen way of life, with a chosen other, and mutual support, respect, affection, shared goals and values; commitment.
Well then I think you're wrong. Perfectly well aware of how normal family life works but I am also aware that for a family to function and for everyone to be happy, there has to be a bit of freedom and for everyone to feel like an individual outside of that family unit and I feel like people don't get that.

How are you respecting someone if you feel like you have a right to control what they do? So many posts on mn are like wibu to say dh can't go out because last time he got so drunk he made a fool of himself and a mess in the kitchen. AIBU to say SO has to stop their hobbies as I don't think they're spending enough time with me etc etc it's gross

OP posts:
Dinoteeth · 01/04/2022 04:36

It's not always about who earned the money, a working parent who's being facilitated by a part-time / stay at home parent cannot hog all the spare cash.

Dinoteeth · 01/04/2022 04:32

Op However it's worded hey you / can I / do you mind if I, the question you are really asking is who honestly feels they can say No without a reason.

Neither DH or I would say no just because.
Although his lads sports week has been reduced to a shorter break because a couple of other wife's complaints about time away from home, holidays from work. Honestly I think it would have bugged me eventually especially when DC2 came along.

alexdgr8 · 01/04/2022 04:32

OP, you don't seem to have much of a concept of family life.
you seem to see it as some kind of belligerent or combative house-sharing situation.
rather than a chosen way of life, with a chosen other, and mutual support, respect, affection, shared goals and values; commitment.

Bintymcbintface · 01/04/2022 04:22

I hate the phrase "family money" are the bills paid and the kids clothed, fed and entertained? Did you go out to work and earn the money... If you've answered yes, guess what the money is yours

OP posts:
Bintymcbintface · 01/04/2022 04:20

I don't mean wording, I really do mean people thinking they have control over their SO and that they can forbid them from doing something. There's a difference between saying "hey do you have plans I'm going out with Steve for a pint" to "my partner wants to go out with Steve AIBU to say he can't go (for no reason other than I don't want him to)

OP posts:
Dinoteeth · 01/04/2022 04:20

@HelloViroids

If I say to OH “can I go out with Jane on Friday?” he knows I mean a) “were you expecting or hoping us to do something together that I may have forgotten/you have not yet raised, which we may both consider a better use of time and accordingly I will reschedule Jane”, and b) “are you available to watch DC, as this is not an important enough event to prevail on our relatives who sometimes babysit and we do not yet have a commercial babysitter sorted out who we are comfortable leaving DC with in the evening, so if you have prior plans I will reschedule Jane”? I do NOT mean “do I have permission to go out without you for you are in charge of my decisions?” But “can I” is quick short hand.
This most of the time "Can I go" is a polite way of saying I'm going unless it's interfering with other plans that are forgotten about. DH sent a text asking could he go to the pub that night, while my mum was in the car, she questioned why he asked too. Yet I thought it was a perfectly normal question.

I also imagine that in households with a tight budget its also about spending family money.

Bintymcbintface · 01/04/2022 04:15

@Obiwankenobe

100% agree with you Op. it’s complete bullshit People on here be like: My do wants to do something they want to do. They obviously are unable to weight up the pros and cons cause I’ve taken that role away from them for so long. As overlord of their universe - Natural title after we have decided we love each other and are committed to each other - should I allow it?

Why on earth would you choose to spend your life with someone that wouldn’t naturally put their partner and their family first? And then the worst part of the whole thing is they obviously don’t know whether they should unleash the shackles of control so instead, let’s ask a bunch of strangers on the internet. 😂 i suppose it’s good bedtime reading.

It's especially fun when the strangers on the Internet tell them that they're being unreasonable and rather than go away and think about their mindset or take any advice, they spend their time trying to detail why they're in the right
OP posts:
GreenWheat · 01/04/2022 04:03

I think you are overthinking the use of the wording as shorthand in most relationships to mean we are opening the line of communication. When I ask my DH if I can do X, we both know I am not literally asking for permission, but starting a discussion as to what else is on then and whether that time would work for our household. In a partnership, your actions affect others so yeah, you do need to check it's OK.

Obiwankenobe · 01/04/2022 03:52

100% agree with you Op. it’s complete bullshit
People on here be like:
My do wants to do something they want to do. They obviously are unable to weight up the pros and cons cause I’ve taken that role away from them for so long. As overlord of their universe - Natural title after we have decided we love each other and are committed to each other - should I allow it?

Why on earth would you choose to spend your life with someone that wouldn’t naturally put their partner and their family first? And then the worst part of the whole thing is they obviously don’t know whether they should unleash the shackles of control so instead, let’s ask a bunch of strangers on the internet. 😂 i suppose it’s good bedtime reading.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 01/04/2022 01:10

I think you're getting hung up on specific words and need to think about the overall meaning instead.

ClareBlue · 01/04/2022 01:02

I hate it when a third party says to you about your partner
'did you let them do that' or 'I wouldn't have let my partner do that'. I think that is more than the quick short hand for logistics. We all say 'is it OK if I'm out Friday' to confirm no conflicting plans etc and are not actually asking permission but the other example is a bit control freaky in my opinion.
But unfortunately there are people, mostly women, who genuinely have to get permission to do something.

stormswiftlysweetafton · 31/03/2022 23:01

Obviously adults can do as they please. Equally obviously, if they're in a partnership or marriage and they do things their partner or spouse doesn't agree they should be doing, that can create problems in the relationship, up to and including ending things.

If I have strong feelings about something, there's nothing wrong with me telling him so and asking him not to do it. He can make his choice, but if he wants us to stay together, there are things he "can't" do, just as there are things he wouldn't "let" me do, though of course I can go and do them anytime I please, if I decide it's more important than preserving our relationship.

Doesn't seem too difficult to understand.

timeisnotaline · 31/03/2022 23:00

This is just mucking around with words. I’m not ‘letting him’ go out, I’m agreeing to be home solo that evening looking after our newborn and older 2 dc. Etc etc

Fupoffyagrasshole · 31/03/2022 22:52

Lolz yea totally agree

See it daily on here.

I don’t ask permission from my husband to do anything nor does he ask me !!

We do let each other know that we have plans on whatever days and if we had a clash where we were both going out we would either get a babysitter or decide between us who reschedules.

But we are both adults and can’t tell the other one what they can and can’t do

EV117 · 31/03/2022 22:51

And I also quite like sending mine out on errands etc to balance the books a bit for all my wife work

I hear comments like this frequently from my SIL. She’s got the arse end of the unequal deal of balancing free time and housework - clearly my BIL has the upper hand in this, he’s the one doing what he actually likes most of the time. I’m sure he doesn’t care about the odd ‘errand’ he is ‘sent’ on. If he was busy or didn’t want to he wouldn’t do it. That doesn’t stop her talking the talk of ‘sending’ him there or ‘letting’ him do this. It’s all a smoke screen. She tries to seem more in control through this pretence of telling her DH what to do and acting like he’s a feckless child that she can command. It doesn’t stop him doing what he actually wants. If you have a balanced and equal relationship you wouldn’t need to talk such twaddle.

Isobelslider · 31/03/2022 22:42

Yeh, but you'd be pissed off with your SO if they spent £1k you don't really have on stag do without telling you, wouldn't you?

There's a difference.

MangyInseam · 31/03/2022 22:39

While I agree with the other posts in general, I do from time to time see ones, or people IRL, who seem to think they have a lot more control than is reasonable about a spouse. And they don't seem to realize it's not usual. I've always wondered if they came from families where one or both of the parents was similar.

MurmuratingStarling · 31/03/2022 22:34

@TinLeaf

After reading some of the OP’s previous posts I doubt the motives of *@Bintymcbintface*
What do you mean? Why?
Kite22 · 31/03/2022 22:31

You're talking absolute nonsense

You missed the bit where you meant to say "In my opinion". As that sentence is very subjective.

I think if you have to start getting into this mindset of ‘you’re not allowed’ you’re not really compatible. Or the person you are with is just an inconsiderate twat… or you are a too controlling… or a bit of both?

This ^

I think there is an element of the way people use language, but I agree with you OP in that I too often raise an eyebrow at all the threads where people talk about "letting" their partner do X, Y, or Z.
It is completely different from checking in with your partner about logistics (childcare, cashflow, etc)

TinLeaf · 31/03/2022 22:30

After reading some of the OP’s previous posts I doubt the motives of @Bintymcbintface

Swipe left for the next trending thread