Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why so many people here feel like they have the right to deny/grant permission for their partners to do something?

137 replies

Bintymcbintface · 31/03/2022 21:18

Just this really. So many people here have posts like AIBU to not let DH to x or should I allow DP to do y. You're speaking about ADULTS here, people who are perfectly capable of making up their own minds and doing whatever they please and have been able to from the age of 18 when they became a full grown adult. If you want someone/something to lord over get a puppy and teach it to fetch you your slippers or something

OP posts:
Bintymcbintface · 01/04/2022 12:16

@IncompleteSenten

When you want to do something that seriously impacts on another person, is it not basic manners and consideration to discuss it with them and see how they feel? And if what you wanted to do would so badly affect the other person that they really did not want you to do it then no they can't deny you permission but they can make their own decisions about how to proceed and you can't control that either.

I wouldn't dump stuff on a colleague, friend or neighbour that would increase their load / responsibilities / impact their finances without their agreement so why would I treat the person I'm supposed to love with less courtesy?

Again, I am talking about people who feel like they literally have the right to tell their SO's what they can and can't do, not people having a discussion about individual plans and how to work around childcare etc
OP posts:
Bintymcbintface · 01/04/2022 12:13

Someone making a twat out of themselves only has bearing on them so in that case it is treating your partner more like a child than an actual partner. Why can't it be a case of haha you looked like a bit of a dick didn't you, by the way you made a mess in the kitchen that needs sorted. Easy

It does piss me off, it's quite grabby along the lines of people being annoyed their retired parents are living it up and eating into whatever inheritance they feel they're entitled to. Most folk in that instance are of the mind they earned it and should do what they want with it. Why that isn't the case for partners is beyond me

OP posts:
IncompleteSenten · 01/04/2022 12:10

When you want to do something that seriously impacts on another person, is it not basic manners and consideration to discuss it with them and see how they feel? And if what you wanted to do would so badly affect the other person that they really did not want you to do it then no they can't deny you permission but they can make their own decisions about how to proceed and you can't control that either.

I wouldn't dump stuff on a colleague, friend or neighbour that would increase their load / responsibilities / impact their finances without their agreement so why would I treat the person I'm supposed to love with less courtesy?

Happiestdogs · 01/04/2022 12:08

Well, OP, perhaps you should speak to my DH. I'm a SAHM to 2 very young DC albeit doing a uni course and I would love to work in the evenings, (especially when I finish study, which I currently do at night) but he'd really prefer me not to as he would rather not have sole childcare responsibilities every night after work. He isn't "not letting" me exactly but I understand what he means so we are compromising and I will work a couple soon and then more in September when we wouldn't be paying out twice for childcare which we otherwise can't afford

He was very relieved I didn't go back to my previous high responsibility and long commute role, and I am grateful to be with the DC, but equally if we split I will currently have no career to go back to whereas his has gone to strength to strength and he never needs to worry about missing meetings etc for unwell children, pick up or drop off times or anything like that because I'm at home to do it. In return he gets to relax in evenings whereas that's when I start my assignments every night once kids are asleep. Would it be fair then that I also had to ask if I were to spend any money? The money for the course incidentally comes from savings which I also paid into pre kids

ReadyToMoveIt · 01/04/2022 12:06

Oh come on there have been posts here saying that partner went out and made a bit of a twat of himself and came home making a mess and questions as to whether or not they should be allowed out again. That's the same as saying I don't want them to

But that is a reason though isn’t it, even though many wouldn’t think it valid. The reason being he made a twat of himself and made a mess.

People who are entirely funded by their partners, what happens if the relationship breaks down? You have no money to go anywhere, no job to pay for the house you're in or another elsewhere...

Well if they’re married they generally are entitled to half of everything their partner has (house, savings, pension etc), which I imagine really, really pisses you off.

Momicrone · 01/04/2022 12:04

Or you stay in said house

Bintymcbintface · 01/04/2022 12:01

Oh come on there have been posts here saying that partner went out and made a bit of a twat of himself and came home making a mess and questions as to whether or not they should be allowed out again. That's the same as saying I don't want them to.

People who are entirely funded by their partners, what happens if the relationship breaks down? You have no money to go anywhere, no job to pay for the house you're in or another elsewhere...

OP posts:
bluebird3 · 01/04/2022 11:19

@Myrighteyeball

I typed a response then read all OP's posts and realised they're a fool.

But I'm posting anyway, not for OP's benefit but for those on here whose partners think it's reasonable to selfishly spend all the money and do all the things.

Firstly, money. Until recently I earned more than my DH and for a period he was a SAHD to facilitate my career. Did I keep all of the money I earned except what was needed to provide basics for the family? Did I fuck. He was not working so I could work full time. Had he not been there, I could not have worked in the same way (very full on job averaging about 60 hours a week). I wasn't just 'supporting' him - he was supporting my ability to work and earn more. And I didn't give him 'pocket money' - we just spent from a joint account with joint cards.

Secondly, OP, I don't think I can just prohibit my DH from doing whatever he pleases or that he needs to ask permission to do things.

However, one of your early posts suggests that on should just 'expect' or 'wait' for one's partner to do the right thing - you say "I'd trust them to respect the relationship". For some people this is just never going to happen either because their partner is neurodivergent or for another reason.

For example, my DH's behaviour when we had a newborn was atrocious. He had absolutely no qualms about telling me that he would be out several nights a week with friends, telling me that his mother would be staying for weeks at a time , and telling me that he would be attending cricket matches for hours each weekend.

Of course I didn't tell him he couldn't do these things - he's not a child. But it would not have been reasonable for me to just leave it and expect that he would change his mind - because he wouldn't have. There were many many conversations where I told him what he was doing was unfair. At the start, I couldn't trust him to respect reasonable boundaries at all. This was partly because of the parenting he received and partly because he has ADHD - and partly because he couldn't see why his life had to change completely so a fair whack of ingrained sexist thinking too.

It's great if you can always expect your partner to respect reasonable boundaries - but not everyone can all the time and for some people saying to their partner 'that's not reasonable and I don't agree to facilitating it' is the only way to achieve a fair outcome for themselves.

This is spot on.
SartresSoul · 01/04/2022 09:14

I think when you have children things change because you both have equal responsibility for them so it isn’t fair for one parent to often go galavanting leaving the other parent to constantly pick up the slack.

AuntieMorag · 01/04/2022 09:12

When my husband says "Is it OK if I go to x on y" it's not asking for permission he is asking whether we have anything else on, whether I have anything planned, whether there is anything else that should be done at that point. It's not permission like a child would ask, it's called being a partnership.

ReadyToMoveIt · 01/04/2022 09:08

Ah OK. That seems very rare though tbh

Yeah. Not something I’ve ever encountered. Even on here there’s generally a reason (parent being left with the child is ill, finances etc), even if other people don’t see the reason as valid.
I don’t know anyone who says ‘no you can’t do that because I don’t want you to’. Do you, OP?

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 01/04/2022 09:05

@Bintymcbintface

I don't mean wording, I really do mean people thinking they have control over their SO and that they can forbid them from doing something. There's a difference between saying "hey do you have plans I'm going out with Steve for a pint" to "my partner wants to go out with Steve AIBU to say he can't go (for no reason other than I don't want him to)
Ah OK. That seems very rare though tbh.
Blackbird2020 · 01/04/2022 09:04

No one is saying that 1 parent should carry the total financial burden. Some families are set up this way, others not, depending on their circumstances, personal preferences etc…

For what it’s worth, I don’t think you’re being goady. I think you have a very idealistic view of family life though. Do you have children with a partner? A lot of people (including me pre-kids) have very idealistic views, which go out of the window when the reality of family life hits….

Vapeyvapevape · 01/04/2022 08:58

If my partner went out with his mates every weekend without asking if I minded ie came home every Friday and told me he's off out regardless of my plans , I would be questioning the whole relationship tbh as it would show how little he thought of me .

ReadyToMoveIt · 01/04/2022 08:52

Why should one parent carry the whole financial burden? How is that fair

Because the other one is carrying the childcare burden?
Why does bother you how other families organise their finances? I couldn’t give a shit who pays for things in other peoples relationships, it doesn’t affect me 🤷🏻‍♀️

Bintymcbintface · 01/04/2022 08:50

@LizzoBennett

Your thinking is very black and white OP. I've never said that my DH couldn't do something but he always 'asks' because it's a way of saying that he respects my time and needs.

I also think you're very unfair on SAHPs. Why should both parents work like passing ships in the night to the point of exhaustion when they don't need to? I'm sure the parent that is taking care of the children all day (especially infants) and then doing a night shift wouldn't have the energy to go out or socialise.

My guess is that you're a goady troll...

I literally meant that some people think that they can forbid their partner from doing something and gave examples of things I've seen in other threads, not having a discussion about things.

Why should one parent carry the whole financial burden? How is that fair

OP posts:
CheshireChat · 01/04/2022 08:47

Yeah, it doesn't sound like the OP values women that much really.

Side note, but I've only heard of one man ever to have the kid(s) during the day and then go to work evenings/ nights, otherwise it was only ever women Hmm.

CrunchyCarrot · 01/04/2022 08:46

I have 2 cats. I have to ask their permission before I can have my own dinner (their lordships must be fed first and any other needs attended to), engage in any activities I'd like to do, or relax of an evening. I must be up at 6 a.m. as they have decreed it, make sure their litter tray is spotless at all time, clean up after any critters brought in, etc. So the thought of lording it over my DP - well that would be a luxury, really... oh dear must shoot off as the cat is climbing all oagre teh keysbeord...agghhhrrr

Vapeyvapevape · 01/04/2022 08:45

Many couples ask permission without actually asking for 'permission' . It's just a normal thing to do. Granted you shouldn't need permission to cut your hair short, but if anything affects or involves the other members of the family I would say most people would discuss it and ask if it's ok . It just isn't as black and white as doing whatever you want and fuck everyone else.

Minatrina · 01/04/2022 08:27

Boring and very obviously bitter viewpoint tbh OP

maddening · 01/04/2022 08:24

Doing childcare all day and working all night? Bloody hell! 😳

Momicrone · 01/04/2022 08:15

How will that work if he's working away? That's a completely different scenario

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 01/04/2022 08:12

Next time DH is deployed to a war zone i must remember to tell him to come home each night so I can get an evening job so I can feed and clothe myself...

ButterfliesAndPancakes · 01/04/2022 08:12

YABU. DH and I always discuss things like going out with friends. I’ve mentioned things in the past and he’s looked shifty and said ‘no’. One time it was because it was a surprise weekend away and he was going to propose 🤷‍♀️

SamphiretheStickerist · 01/04/2022 08:09

@Bintymcbintface

Why can't one partner work days and the other evenings so there are no childcare issues? That way both parents are contributing to "family money" and no childcare to pay out. Why wouldn't you want to be financially independent rather than having to ask SO for money to get your hair done/buy clothes? If you go for a night out with your friends do you pay SO to stay home with the kids or would that be unheard of because who the hell pays someone to look after their own children?
And I missed this one entirely! Blech!
Swipe left for the next trending thread