Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why so many people here feel like they have the right to deny/grant permission for their partners to do something?

137 replies

Bintymcbintface · 31/03/2022 21:18

Just this really. So many people here have posts like AIBU to not let DH to x or should I allow DP to do y. You're speaking about ADULTS here, people who are perfectly capable of making up their own minds and doing whatever they please and have been able to from the age of 18 when they became a full grown adult. If you want someone/something to lord over get a puppy and teach it to fetch you your slippers or something

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WalkingOnTheCracks · 05/04/2022 09:34

The voting's close.

I voted 'YANBU' because that's what I believe and my OH said I could.

Suprima · 05/04/2022 07:52

God this thread was a wild ride.

All that to come to the conclusion that OP just has it out for SAHMs with husbands who are considerate about their wives’ feelings and their family schedule.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 05/04/2022 07:24

I think the idea of freedom, isn't freedom from responsibilities, it's not permission per se but consideration. Consideration for the other and the goals of the relationship.
Couples tend to have complex logistical arrangements especially when children arrive or employment isn't standard 9-5. Another common problem is presenting the other with a request that is quite blatantly unreasonable and puts the relationship goals on the back burner for selfish reasons. What's unreasonable varies from person to person.
Relationships are a series of negotiations some requests are obviously not appropriate. I certainly think friends and careers always bring dilemmas into relationships.

Going out drinking, bar hopping, or variations on this theme for either party is a popular contentious issue that arises in all relationships. Many, many marriages have and will continue to be destroyed by this one simple seemingly simple request.

Cirelle · 05/04/2022 06:00

I’m 50% responsible for two kids so I can’t just swan off and do whatever I like. I have to ask my DH because he has to take the kids. In fact I’m likely to phrase it as “I want to go to X, will you look after the kids?” That’s not asking permission, it’s organising childcare. And if it costs a significant amount of money I’d tell him how much and give him the chance to object, because the money I’m spending is half his. If he says no it’s not because he’s controlling, it’s because there’s a good reason why he can’t take the kids or we need the money for something else.

Myrighteyeball · 05/04/2022 05:43

OP, you seem very aerated about one part of a couple not being in paid work because they are taking care of children.

AIBU to wonder why you feel like one partner has the right to deny/grant permission for the other to be a SAHP? Grin

Valeriekat · 03/04/2022 15:33

@blacksax

Goady McGoadyface is alive and well I see...
Ahh yes!
Valeriekat · 03/04/2022 15:29

@Dinoteeth

Yes a SAHP has as much right to spare cash as the working parent. Verging on financially controlling / abusive to think otherwise. If a couple have decided in their circumstances its better for one parent not to work outside the home that parent needs to be provided for by the working parent.
Exactly
FrangipaniBlue · 02/04/2022 07:49

Never in a million years would the words "can I......" leave my mouth when talking to DH. Nor would I expect him to ask me permission either.

The conversation would go like this.....

Me "do you have any plans on Saturday?"
DH "no why?"
Me "Kate has asked me to do X so if you've no plans I'll go"

Somanyquestions1984 · 01/04/2022 23:05

Bintymcbintface??

Seriously?? Confused

JudgeJ · 01/04/2022 22:46

@ReadyToMoveIt

Yes, my husband has to ask my permission to go away for a weekend as, in the absence of any other childcare (SEN child), I will be the one doing it solo. Ditto I ask him if he’s happy to take on all the childcare while I go away.
Interesting choice of words there. He has to ask permission but you ask if he's happy to take on all the child care. Do you not seek his permission to go?
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 01/04/2022 17:33

@Bintymcbintface

I'm not trying to be inflammatory, nor am I naive. I think it's naive of women to think they're just fine not earning for themselves and depending on SO to finance everything, what about job losses, relationship breakdowns, where will you stand then? Is it not the case that men who are at home all day expecting their OH to pay for everything are known as cock lodgers?
If one person is staying at home to do the childcare and the other is earning the money, and this was decided together, they are not really 'depending on SO to finance everything'. That's a but of a simplistic way to put it. No, dads who do all the childcare whilst partners earn are non generally considered cock lodger as cock lodgers don't contribute at all.
ldontWanna · 01/04/2022 17:20

@Bintymcbintface

I'm not trying to be inflammatory, nor am I naive. I think it's naive of women to think they're just fine not earning for themselves and depending on SO to finance everything, what about job losses, relationship breakdowns, where will you stand then? Is it not the case that men who are at home all day expecting their OH to pay for everything are known as cock lodgers?
No , if they are home doing child care,house work etc they are called SAHDs. Just like the women are SAHMS ,not freeloaders.
blacksax · 01/04/2022 17:05

Goady McGoadyface is alive and well I see...

ReadyToMoveIt · 01/04/2022 16:39

@Bintymcbintface

I'm not trying to be inflammatory, nor am I naive. I think it's naive of women to think they're just fine not earning for themselves and depending on SO to finance everything, what about job losses, relationship breakdowns, where will you stand then? Is it not the case that men who are at home all day expecting their OH to pay for everything are known as cock lodgers?
Not if they’re doing all the childcare, which would otherwise have to be paid for if he was going out to work.
Bintymcbintface · 01/04/2022 16:09

I'm not trying to be inflammatory, nor am I naive. I think it's naive of women to think they're just fine not earning for themselves and depending on SO to finance everything, what about job losses, relationship breakdowns, where will you stand then? Is it not the case that men who are at home all day expecting their OH to pay for everything are known as cock lodgers?

OP posts:
Vapeyvapevape · 01/04/2022 13:53

Now you’re just being a wind-up merchant

I agree .

Blackbird2020 · 01/04/2022 13:36

…so no more from me…

Blackbird2020 · 01/04/2022 13:35

sitting on your arse waiting on your partner to hand you a chunk of money they earned for your pocket money

🙄

Now you’re just being a wind-up merchant.

I’m unable to take people who make such flippant and unintelligent comments seriously, so more from me on this thread! And here I was giving you the benefit of the doubt that you were being merely naive….

HardbackWriter · 01/04/2022 12:31

@Bintymcbintface

Someone making a twat out of themselves only has bearing on them so in that case it is treating your partner more like a child than an actual partner. Why can't it be a case of haha you looked like a bit of a dick didn't you, by the way you made a mess in the kitchen that needs sorted. Easy

It does piss me off, it's quite grabby along the lines of people being annoyed their retired parents are living it up and eating into whatever inheritance they feel they're entitled to. Most folk in that instance are of the mind they earned it and should do what they want with it. Why that isn't the case for partners is beyond me

Gosh, you've got a lot of hobby horses that you want to rant about in this one thread, don't you? People banning their partners going out for no reason (which I have never seen anyone advise on MN, ever), stay at home mothers, now people who resent their elderly parents spending money (again, not a mainstream or widely supported view...). You're spending a lot of time judging other people, aren't you? Would you say you're a happy person yourself?
Happiestdogs · 01/04/2022 12:30

Anyway I'm supposed to be studying now during naptime instead of debating this but I've got drawn in by my annoyance

Happiestdogs · 01/04/2022 12:28

I don't sit on my arse all day, I look after two small children all day and then study several hours a night. My DH does want to be a parent to them but would prefer not to work all day and then have sole childcare every evening if we don't have to, and although I'd actually prefer to work more in the evenings than we've agreed to I do understand that (and like to see him too) so for this short period of our lives we have decided this is what works best for us as a team. If anyone misses out financially it's actually me and yes I'd rather he took on more childcare so I could work more but I wouldn't say he doesn't want to parent them at all.

Before kids, when he earned more we split it equally and then when I earned more we split it equally, why wouldn't we?

Bintymcbintface · 01/04/2022 12:26

@Momicrone

Looking after the kids meant all money coming in to the house was jointly mine
OK so if you get paid for looking after your kids, how much do you pay your SO when you go out and they have the kids by themselves?
OP posts:
Momicrone · 01/04/2022 12:25

Looking after the kids meant all money coming in to the house was jointly mine

AryaStarkWolf · 01/04/2022 12:24

@Bintymcbintface stay at home parenting suits a lot of couples, it makes life ruin smoother in a lot of cases and you don't end up like ships passing in the night working days/nights between you. If it works for both people in the relationship, why on Earth does it bother you? (and you do seem really bothered by the whole idea of it!)

As a side note, both me and my DH currently work full time as our kids are grown up now but we've changed according to what suited us at a particular time over the years when the kids were younger, we've both worked part time to accommodate their care at one point or another. "Partner" means exactly that, you're both working together for what benefits your family most

Bintymcbintface · 01/04/2022 12:22

Why did you have kids with someone that doesn't want to be a parent to them? Joint savings you have both contributed to is different from sitting on your arse waiting on your partner to hand you a chunk of money they earned for your pocket money

OP posts: