Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU NO-ONE Can morally defend Will Smith

67 replies

TheRealKaren · 31/03/2022 20:38

If a physical assault happened in any other environment, it would lead to an arrest. So why are so many people defending Will Smith? While Chris Rock’s joke was at best ignorant and at worst spiteful, Will Smith was completely in the wrong. I’m amazed at the many people defending Smith, and I do think that there should be consequences for him. I partly believe that the academy is hesitant to react because they are worried they’re going to be seen as racist if they do.

I just don’t think violence is ever acceptable and no one should be slapped, over anything they say. I just don’t see how it would ever be justified in any other environment, especially a professional one which the Academy Awards are

YABU: Chris Rock deserves everything he got and it is OK to slap someone if they’ve offended you or someone you care about.
YANBU: Will Smith committed assault and should face the consequences.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
savedbyanalien · 01/04/2022 09:04

@Branleuse

Morally, i think it was a bit silly, but really, most people understand that if you insult a man or their wife in front of them, you risk a slap. I dont think its 'right' but I dont really care either. Noone was particularly harmed. I quite like all 3 of them

What the actual fuck? Confused

BowtieBling · 01/04/2022 08:53

Not read the full thread but if someone morally defends a slap they are defending a violent action and their moral compass looks off to me.

HumunaHey · 01/04/2022 08:51

@Porcupineintherough You can be ill with a disease but having a disease doesn't necessarily mean you are ill.

Porcupineintherough · 01/04/2022 08:24

@HumunaHey

Illness: a disease or period of sickness affecting the body or the mind

I guess we are using different dictionaries

HumunaHey · 01/04/2022 06:59

[quote Porcupineintherough]@HumunaHey of course its an illness,. What did you think it was, a lifestyle choice?

It was a display of male toxicity at its worst

It really wasnt. On the scale of male toxicity it barely moved the needle. Go look at the war in Ukraine if you want to see male toxicity at its worst.[/quote]
@Porcupineintherough It's not an illness by definition. It's a disease. You can have a disease and not be ill. I looked it up for confirmation and I was right.

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 31/03/2022 23:56

@Im2022

Don’t really care. But if you’re talking about consequences, then strip Weinstein, Spacey and Woody Allen off their awards and ban them and give James Franco and others like him a life time ban.

Loads of hypocrisy and shit.

This.
montysma1 · 31/03/2022 23:39

I am not defending him. But Rock is as much in the wrongas Smith yet I have heard very little condemnation of him. The woman had every right to go and sit in the award ceremony without being mocked and humiliated by a boorish oaf.

Justkeeppedaling · 31/03/2022 23:25

I partly believe that the academy is hesitant to react because they are worried they’re going to be seen as racist if they do

Imagine though if it was a white man who had hit either a black man or a woman.

Or come to that, if a black man had hit a white man.

In any of those scenarios the outcome would have been very different.

Sux2buthen · 31/03/2022 23:11

@Branleuse

Morally, i think it was a bit silly, but really, most people understand that if you insult a man or their wife in front of them, you risk a slap. I dont think its 'right' but I dont really care either. Noone was particularly harmed. I quite like all 3 of them
Agreed
Su9999 · 31/03/2022 23:10

There has been many threads on this issue now. Why start another one? FFS.

MangyInseam · 31/03/2022 23:08

@lljkk

and rape in 2017, that Chris Rock?

You can dislike WS's action without trying to say CR is a chronic victim. Real people are complicated.

Did Jada say she felt humiliated? There's almighty projection to assume any of us knows how she felt. If we're gossiping, I get impression she's the dominant character in that marriage, insisted on it being an open marriage, is boss of the family decisions, etc. She's nobody's inferior.

Yes, although that may not mean that she didn't "need" him to slap CR. Maybe the opposite - maybe that's what she wanted so that's why he did it. Whether that would be due to feeling humiliated or for some other reason I don't know.

Not everyone finds the idea of a partner standing up for them offensive.

Soontobe60 · 31/03/2022 23:00

@fUNNYfACE36

Mocking Will's wife's appearance as a result of her illness? He deserved all he got, and more!
Have a listen to Katherine Ryans podcast - The Slap.
GrandTheftWalrus · 31/03/2022 22:47

Ah I think I remember seeing something about that. Thanks.

Appalonia · 31/03/2022 22:47

@GrandTheftWalrus

Sorry for going off topic but what has James Franco done?
Alleged sexual assault

www.thethings.com

GrandTheftWalrus · 31/03/2022 22:37

Sorry for going off topic but what has James Franco done?

lemongreentea · 31/03/2022 22:28

@Im2022

Don’t really care. But if you’re talking about consequences, then strip Weinstein, Spacey and Woody Allen off their awards and ban them and give James Franco and others like him a life time ban.

Loads of hypocrisy and shit.

This
emmaliz · 31/03/2022 22:26

I think that there is no defence for Will Smith. Yes people have done worse, people can always do worse but that doesn't justify what he did either.
I don't know. Strip all of them of the Oscars, past offenders, Will Smith. In fact get rid of the Oscars its bollocks anyway, and celebrate people who really do something worthwhile.

NuffSaidSam · 31/03/2022 22:11

The "morality" of the episode is far from clear cut.

I'd say it was crystal clear.

You can't physically assault someone because you don't like what they say. It's that simple.

BlubFestival · 31/03/2022 22:08

I may not be able to defend his actions but I certainly wouldn't single them out either.

The "morality" of the episode is far from clear cut.

There are some interesting points to be explored about male violence (literal and verbal) and Hollywood's complicity in encouraging, normalising and condoning (sometimes by its inaction as well as actions).... But hoisting Will Smith up as the worst offender on this charge is... morally dubious.

empireemmy · 31/03/2022 22:07

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the request of the poster.

lljkk · 31/03/2022 22:02
and rape in 2017, that Chris Rock?

You can dislike WS's action without trying to say CR is a chronic victim. Real people are complicated.

Did Jada say she felt humiliated? There's almighty projection to assume any of us knows how she felt. If we're gossiping, I get impression she's the dominant character in that marriage, insisted on it being an open marriage, is boss of the family decisions, etc. She's nobody's inferior.

YouHaveYourFathersBreasts · 31/03/2022 21:55

@katicomps

The only thing I got from it was 'man gets aggressive with little to no provocation and then cries and whines how sorry he is .… in a completely non apologetic way' It's the same old story of men the world over.
Aside from yet another bloody thread about this incident, I think this is true. He’s behaved badly, got more backlash than he expected and offered up a crap non apology. You know the type: “sorry if I upset you…” Hmm
TheRealKaren · 31/03/2022 21:55

Sorry for starting this thread: I don’t visit MN that regularly and wasn’t aware how many there were 😳

I think that Will Smith could of expressed his disapproval in a more diplomatic way. Also as a feminist, I would be a bit annoyed if my husband stood up for me by punching someone (technically a former colleague) who made a slightly tasteless joke. I stand up for myself, thank you very much!

I think people were shocked when he started swearing as they realised it wasn’t a joke and he was really angry. It should also be noted that the f word is not allowed on Terrestrial television in the US even if it’s late in the evening. (hence why it was censored in their broadcast).

If Chris Rock doesn’t want to charge then that is his choice. Although I as an Pleb would, I can understand why he doesn’t want to however as he is already facing a lot of time in the media for the wrong reasons and likely doesn’t want to escalate and prolong the unwanted attention he is receiving. That being said, I believe the Academy can as it happened at their event, and it should be noted that the Los Angeles police are allowed to prosecuted themselves under Californian Law.

Agree that anyone convected of a crime against another when working professionally should be banned. I believe that James Franco has been banned.

OP posts:
LndnGrl · 31/03/2022 21:52

*sexual assault

LndnGrl · 31/03/2022 21:52

Yanbu. After reading about Chris Rock's history (bullying and serial assault) I'm disgusted that will smith isn't being 'cancelled'. I'm against cancel culture, but I can't believe the double standard here.