Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be a bit pissed off about colleagues' lack of enthusiasm to return to the office?

111 replies

spuddy56 · 31/03/2022 20:31

About 6 months ago I joined a large organisation in a fairly large team (15 ish). Since covid the company have introduced flexible working. Whether or not you go in is down to individual people and their managers. Barely any of this team ever go into the office, particularly those who worked there pre covid, although there is a newer bunch tend to go in once a week and seem to be developing really positive working and social relationships out of it. My particular role doesn't overlap theirs at all but does overlap the with the more longstanding members who are refusing to go in. Although I get on well with everyone as far as I know (but who really knows from behind a screen!), I'm also aware that they are having social meet ups without me and it just feels so hard to get a grasp on the culture and the ins and outs of working with particular people. We currently have a high turnover too, and I wonder if people feel less loyalty because they are not forming face to face relationships? The managers want to encourage creativity and collaboration but this seems to difficult to me when there's no casual conversations and bouncing around of ideas outside of zoom and emails.

Am I being unreasonable to think that people should head in to the office occasionally or do we just need to get used to this?

P.s. I actually love working from home and the flexibility, I just think some face to face collaboration would be helpful too.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ButterfliesAndPancakes · 01/04/2022 16:46

YABU. Especially when you said you enjoy homeworking anyway 🤷‍♀️ Personally I love to WFH and think that office work is outdated. I recently turned down a higher paid job because it was fully office based. Once I factored in fuel costs I’d have lost money but more importantly, I value my work life balance and it would have meant up to two hours a day sat in traffic. Not for me anymore thanks. I’ve got two interviews next week at the same band which are fully home working which sounds right up my street 😆

GoldenOmber · 01/04/2022 16:41

In your position I’d probably look for another job. It doesn’t look like your colleagues particularly want to change the current setup.

There are definitely organisations that can make fully remote teams work really well, but they usually have people who self-select for that and put some effort into making it work on an organisational level.

In my workplace we have lost new starts due to full WFH when that was in place. Even with an effort to do decent induction and buddying and virtual shadowing programmes, remote work worked better for people with established histories and work relationships in the place than it did for new people. We are back in the office some of the time now and it’s so much easier to get new people up to speed.

MajorCarolDanvers · 01/04/2022 16:25

I agree with you that for new starters and staff retention, work from home is a disaster

For new starters iwfh is harder but not a disaster and I say that as someone who started a new role last year.

For retention it's excellent for those who prefer to wfh and the complete opposite of a disaster

Only a *disaster' for those who don't wish to do so and where there is no longer an office or a hybrid choice.

balalake · 01/04/2022 16:07

@EBearhug well put as to what is valuable time in an office and what is less valuable.

elephantmarchingin · 01/04/2022 15:36

@spuddy56

Wow *@elephantmarchingin* tips on meeting stakeholders and learning about systems make me over enthusiastic?! I want to do my job efficiently and effectively. My employers pay me well and I want to make sure I'm working as productively as possible for them. That might mean learning about the nuances of culture, senior stakeholders preferences and ways of working that I'm struggling to pick up effectively in a fully remote environment.

Of course, the issue here could be the lack of sharing in the team in general, and its been interesting to read answers from people whose teams are doing this well remotely. I do wonder though if this is exacerbated by strong pre covid work groups that had been formed face to face, making it harder for these older employees to consider new people as part of the team.

Frankly yes, you are probably that person who is always so very very helpful whilst winding others up. Just because you like the buzz of the office does not mean that everyone should have too, if you wanted an office environment you shouldn't have gone for a company with WFH
gannett · 01/04/2022 14:35

That might mean learning about the nuances of culture, senior stakeholders preferences and ways of working that I'm struggling to pick up effectively in a fully remote environment.

I just asked people about all of this. Depending how big or urgent it was I could drop a question in a group chat window; ask a colleague who'd been at the company longer than me but didn't manage me; ask my manager directly; email HR; etc etc etc. And getting a clear answer in writing is so much more useful than hanging around an office vaguely trying to "observe" things while also getting your own work done.

EmmaH2022 · 01/04/2022 14:06

@spuddy56

Wow *@elephantmarchingin* tips on meeting stakeholders and learning about systems make me over enthusiastic?! I want to do my job efficiently and effectively. My employers pay me well and I want to make sure I'm working as productively as possible for them. That might mean learning about the nuances of culture, senior stakeholders preferences and ways of working that I'm struggling to pick up effectively in a fully remote environment.

Of course, the issue here could be the lack of sharing in the team in general, and its been interesting to read answers from people whose teams are doing this well remotely. I do wonder though if this is exacerbated by strong pre covid work groups that had been formed face to face, making it harder for these older employees to consider new people as part of the team.

If you feel you're missing this info generally, talk to your manager.

I would be happy to meet remotely or face to face to help a new employee with systems or stakeholder handling chat.

I would be very unhappy at a blanket policy of being in the office, there's no need. I've been homeworking for years. In the office, I was very quiet because I was desperately trying to get work done amid noise.

I really think you need to consider an environment without home working, if you like office "buzz" generally.

EBearhug · 01/04/2022 13:44

I like most of my colleagues, but our team has always been split across different countries, so we've always had a lot of conference and video calls and messaging. I don't care if Petr is on a video from his home or the office in Amsterdam, because either way, we can be face-to-face.

We are now expected to be in once a week, and I'm considering days where I can avoid the colleagues I don't like so much. 😉 Although just now, I'm not allowed in till I'm testing negative for covid. Also, we've got buying works going on into May, so I'm not do keen on being there till that's over.

It works differently for different people. I like being in the office to see people, because I live alone. Another colleague likes coming in on the day the cleaner is due, and another to get away from his children. It also depends on whether you can have a dedicated workspace, or have to share the sitting room, or stay in your bedroom in a shared house - because we are all different.

I am expecting that as overseas travel is allowed again, we will be asked to be in on particular days when we have visitors (which I also expect to happen less often.) What I will miss is the unexpected visitors, who are over to see others and you catch up by accident.

There is value in having people together face-to-face, but it doesn't have to be daily. It also depends on the nature of the work - not all work can be done remotely. But a truly flexible workplace will take into account the needs of individuals and teams and the business and work something out that works for most people, new and old.

Totally agree that heavy periods are easier to deal with at home, though.

CoffeeWithCheese · 01/04/2022 13:27

A lot of the after school care provision around here has now folded because of the increase in working from home - so those who DO have to go into offices etc are now being massively fucked over in that regard too.

I'm currently doing a final clinical placement on healthcare - based at home but travelling to the community patients. I've lost so much informal learning from not being in an office - I've only spoken to one other member of the team in 3 months - we travel out separately, meet at a client, then travel home and log onto Teams to discuss it. It's soul destroying, and not to mention that no one now knows who has what resources as stuff that would be in the office cupboard is now scattered in car boots across the local area.

Hopefully we're all getting requested back to the office on a hybrid arrangement soon cos this is just a joyless slog. I literally would not know people who are colleagues if I passed them in the street - that's pretty awful.

spuddy56 · 01/04/2022 13:11

Wow @elephantmarchingin tips on meeting stakeholders and learning about systems make me over enthusiastic?! I want to do my job efficiently and effectively. My employers pay me well and I want to make sure I'm working as productively as possible for them. That might mean learning about the nuances of culture, senior stakeholders preferences and ways of working that I'm struggling to pick up effectively in a fully remote environment.

Of course, the issue here could be the lack of sharing in the team in general, and its been interesting to read answers from people whose teams are doing this well remotely. I do wonder though if this is exacerbated by strong pre covid work groups that had been formed face to face, making it harder for these older employees to consider new people as part of the team.

OP posts:
Minatrina · 01/04/2022 13:11

Just started a remote job in a creative industry where everyone is based in the same county and still barely anyone goes into the office at all. I love it. I'm in my mid twenties, I'm good with tech, and I am perfectly capable of connecting with others online.

It's the most efficient company I've ever worked for, everyone has great work-life balance so we have the headspace to come up with creative solutions etc.

I have plenty of friends and a family who are my priority, I have no interest in forced friendships with colleagues.

HardbackWriter · 01/04/2022 12:42

To go into an office to spend a day on zoom meetings to me seems pointless, the collaboration side is no different to me being at home and with global workforces now, this won't change. So there will never be the whole team in one room together

This makes perfect sense for teams that are global, but that's not the case for most UK employers. OP's colleagues all live close enough together that they still socialise together, so they obviously could all be in a room together. I'm not saying that means they should or must be.

WinniesHunny · 01/04/2022 12:32

@Dazedandconfused10

Personally for me I don't socialise with colleagues outside of work, they're my work colleagues not my friends.

To go into an office to spend a day on zoom meetings to me seems pointless, the collaboration side is no different to me being at home and with global workforces now, this won't change. So there will never be the whole team in one room together.

Indeed. I get on with them, some more than others, obviously. But I'm paid to talk to them, not going to waste my precious personal time on people I wouldn't ordinarily choose to spend time with. I already spend 5.5 days a week with them.
elephantmarchingin · 01/04/2022 12:30

@spuddy56

I don't even see it as being social...I would just love more in office time working together, talking about work, bouncing around problems, hearing informally about the best way to deal with certain situations etc. I don't care if I know what a colleague had for dinner or about their favourite hobby but I would like to know how they've worked effectively previously. I suppose things like small tips on meeting a particular senior stakeholder for the first time or shortcuts in the systems etc.
In fact YAB even more U here and sound like one of those far too over enthusiastic collegues that everyone rolls their eyes about.

You can 'bounce' ideas over chat/zoom calls. Not everyone needs to travel in, sit in an office then travel home to do exactly the same thing!

elephantmarchingin · 01/04/2022 12:28

YABU

HardbackWriter · 01/04/2022 12:26

@yellowsuninthesky

I also think that on the whole, WFH is better for women. You get people saying that if you are not visible in the office you won't get promoted. Well if promotion is important to you, you make yourself visible.

But it definitely helps with childcare issues, especially with older children who can entertain themselves but need an adult around, it is easier if you have elderly care responsibilities, and it also helps if you eg have horribly heavy periods and being close to a loo for 2-3 days a month is important. Also people with certain disabilities might find it easier to work from home, or close to home in a co-working space.

I think flexible and hybrid working is very good for diversity and inclusion.

I think an office going full WFH is good for those with caring responsibilities, but leaving how much/whether to work in the office to individuals is going to prove very bad for them. In that scenario the focus is likely to shift back to the office over time and groups who don't return or don't return much will gradually get overlooked.
maddening · 01/04/2022 11:28

I like hybrid, it is up to us to make it work as i can also see employers deciding enough is enough and dictating attendance, if people want the freedom they need to approach this in the spirit it is offered imo.

If people have moved further away then one day in is still doable, it is just one long commute as opposed to every day so still a winner imo.

PacificState · 01/04/2022 11:23

Was just thinking about the heavy periods point @yellowsuninthesky God what a nightmare that was, sitting in meetings feeling yourself leak through your second level of sanpro. Scurrying to the public loos in Waterloo (nasty as hell) to change everything before I dared embark on the second leg of my long commute. Having to take wet wipes everywhere. Never mentioned any of this to my boss or colleagues because I'd have looked like a weirdo.

Thankfully I'm an old gimmer now although I suspect menopause symptoms aren't always huge fun in an office either...

None of this is to say new starters/young people/employers' needs aren't important. Just that there are other groups of people whose needs have been routinely overlooked for decades.

Nicholethejewellery · 01/04/2022 11:17

YABU. People are employed to do a job, they should work wherever they are best able to do it as efficiently as possible.

ferretface · 01/04/2022 11:14

We have a designated day per week where attendance is strongly encouraged, it rotates through Monday to Friday so different working patterns can accommodate it - seems to be working pretty well.

MadameFantabulosa · 01/04/2022 11:06

We are insisting that everyone now comes into the office a minimum of three days a week. And that they work core hours, 9-12 and 2-4. Remote working (and returning to the office) has shown a lot of people shuffle in at 1100 or midday and a significant number have gone by 3. Failure to comply with this is a disciplinary matter.

There has been a lot of unhappiness about this, as some people sold up and moved to the country, assuming that remote working would continue. But a lot of what we do involves personal interaction and building relationships, and this suffered during lockdown, as it’s harder to do this on the phone or on Zoom.

yellowsuninthesky · 01/04/2022 10:45

I also think that on the whole, WFH is better for women. You get people saying that if you are not visible in the office you won't get promoted. Well if promotion is important to you, you make yourself visible.

But it definitely helps with childcare issues, especially with older children who can entertain themselves but need an adult around, it is easier if you have elderly care responsibilities, and it also helps if you eg have horribly heavy periods and being close to a loo for 2-3 days a month is important. Also people with certain disabilities might find it easier to work from home, or close to home in a co-working space.

I think flexible and hybrid working is very good for diversity and inclusion.

yellowsuninthesky · 01/04/2022 10:42

I agree with you that for new starters and staff retention, work from home is a disaster

Really? I left my last job (in 2018) because my then boss would not let me work from home as much as I wanted to (he then backtracked when I handed my notice in, but I'd already moved on mentally by then).

I think flexibility is crucial for staff retention. I have colleagues who are in the office every day, others who have no desire to go into the office at all or for except for important meetings (like me, I only want to go in twice a month) and everyone else inbetween. A good employer will aim to accommodate everyone as far as is reasonable. It obviously won't work for all roles and sectors, but for most office work it is completely do-able. Lots of companies have more than one office anyway, so you already had conference calls before covid - the difference is that they've moved to Teams.

BigSandyBalls2015 · 01/04/2022 10:36

I went into the office for a day recently and hated it. I loved the getting up and out the house, the exercise walking to the station, getting a coffee, reading on the train.

What I didn't miss is the noise in an open plan office, the constant interruptions about very minor things. The noisy eating, the smelly colleague .... I got far less done than at home.

I sound a miserable cow reading that back, I'm really not Grin.
I did enjoy the drinks after work with a couple of colleagues who are friends now.

HardyBuckette · 01/04/2022 10:34

@IceVolcanoes

Not working at the same time.

Thing is, business do have legitimate needs too. It’s not unreasonable to have daytime core hours that enable people to actually schedule meetings. Having people decide that they’d rather work 7pm to 3am or 5am to 8am then 7pm to 11pm (or whatever) isn’t necessarily useful to the business - even if it suits the individual employer.

It’s not unreasonable to decide that some face to face interaction is desirable - whether because it makes the direct work task easier or for less direct reasons, like their need to support new or junior staff.

There are a whole set of different needs to be balanced. People taking an ‘I’m alright jack’ attitude about home working (or office working) doesn’t help at all.

It just completely depends.

The things you've written above could all be applicable to an individual business, or they might not be necessary at all. It might be reasonable to want everyone in every day, it might be unreasonable to require any face to face interaction simply for the sake of having it. Additionally a particular business might well need to make compromises for the sake of ensuring they get the best staff- usually that's going to look like more flexibility but perhaps not always. There is so much variation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread