Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that Tax Credits and subsequently Universal Credit were the worst thing to happen to the UK?

119 replies

BookkeeperBobby · 31/03/2022 20:09

I can see how it was well intentioned as a mechanism of redistributing money, maybe, in the short term. But 22 years down the line all it means is that employers pay less, productivity drops, UK workers are worth less. Add quantitative easing into the mix which means that anyone with any money buys up assets eg property, while at the same time wages stagnate due to the above, and the country has become a low wage economy with a high cost of living. Which in the face of energy price rises that have to be paid with real money, not just shuffling benefits around, is a disaster.

OP posts:
PastMyBestBeforeDate · 01/04/2022 00:22

They were introduced to try and close a gap and reduce poverty. Along with a reforming government and the NMW TC were a start.
Then the Conservatives came in. IDS introduced UC and the idea of closing the gap was lost. Businesses were able to use TC to avoid paying a decent wage. The gap increased. Unions were hobbled. Employment law was scalped.
And here we are.

Blossomtoes · 31/03/2022 23:42

@BookkeeperBobby

For those blaming Thatcher, obvs she was a horror but she left office 32 years ago. That's pretty much two generations and we had a labour government in power for thirteen years in the meantime. They achieved a landslide victory and had a huge majority. They could have done what they wanted in terms of addressing wealth inequality and no one would have been able to stop them. What they did was put in place a mechanism to subsidise low paying employers and create a rentier economy with guaranteed income for landlords. That's a Labour government.
Yes she left office 32 years ago after comprehensively destroying the fabric of this country. The damage she did was irreparable. It’s only with hindsight that I can see the extent of the devastation she left behind. Living through it, you were too close to see how appalling her legacy would be.

The Blair government for all its faults did the best it could. Money was poured into the NHS, Surestart, tax cuts for the poorest paid, minimum wage.

Of course there were things it should have done - abolishing right to buy and starting a massive social housing programme would have been great. The thing they had to bear in mind is that one term isn’t long enough for real achievement and they needed to get re-elected.

No government is perfect but, having been an adult under both Conservative and Labour governments, my perception is that Labour governments make society more equal and support the people at the bottom. Tory governments do a reverse Robin Hood.

Specter123 · 31/03/2022 23:24

@BookkeeperBobby

For those blaming Thatcher, obvs she was a horror but she left office 32 years ago. That's pretty much two generations and we had a labour government in power for thirteen years in the meantime. They achieved a landslide victory and had a huge majority. They could have done what they wanted in terms of addressing wealth inequality and no one would have been able to stop them. What they did was put in place a mechanism to subsidise low paying employers and create a rentier economy with guaranteed income for landlords. That's a Labour government.
It's a Labour government from the 90s.

Thinking has moved on from then (thankfully!) Furlough for example, would not have been considered by the Tories 30 years ago. Politics evolve especially during crisis events and I'd argue the cost of living currently is definitely a crisis.

BookkeeperBobby · 31/03/2022 23:20

For those blaming Thatcher, obvs she was a horror but she left office 32 years ago. That's pretty much two generations and we had a labour government in power for thirteen years in the meantime. They achieved a landslide victory and had a huge majority. They could have done what they wanted in terms of addressing wealth inequality and no one would have been able to stop them. What they did was put in place a mechanism to subsidise low paying employers and create a rentier economy with guaranteed income for landlords. That's a Labour government.

OP posts:
Bringonsummer19 · 31/03/2022 23:10

YANBU

Maverickess · 31/03/2022 23:07

Let's have a minimum wage that can actually be lived on at ft hours, without the need for in work benefits, and then when companies start bleating they can't afford it, tell them they can apply for the money instead of individuals to bolster their wages to a proper level, but they'll be means tested and if they're making a shit tonne of profit or overstretching themselves (not 'living within their means') then they get told no.

caringcarer · 31/03/2022 23:03

I think the minimum wage needs to go up and not by 20p or something stupid.

howtomoveforwards · 31/03/2022 22:59

It means employers do not need to pay the going rate because the tax payer will pick up the tab

That’ll be those same tax payers out working then, right?

I also think it pertinent to point out that more women than ever left abusive partners when tax credits were introduced. Thousands of children not having to watch their father beat their mother to a pulp is fucking priceless.

By contrast, women with more than 2 children are now stuck without that much needed financial support, and who knows how many are fearful of leaving because of not being able to manage financially.

lonelyapple · 31/03/2022 22:49

You're absolutely right OP! Tax credits and housing benefit massively subsidise low wages so that big business/rich landlords can make huge profits on the backs of taxpayers. Brown was an absolute idiot.

Kendodd · 31/03/2022 22:23

@Blossomtoes
Yes I think you're right.
All publicly owner stuff from the past is now owned by the rich, even social housing, much of it is owned by private landlords. The tenants living are the same people would would have been living in them when owned by the council, they would have a security and cheap rent. Instead they have insecure housing and high rent making someone else rich.

Kendodd · 31/03/2022 22:17

I think tax and benefits are all a bit of a red herring tbh. The issue is low pay and the rich hoarding profits that their workers made for them. I don't really know how you make them distribute profits better.
I don't believe taking away WTC would make bosses pay more.
I remember reading that one of Philip's Greens super yatchs cost the equivalent of the tax credits his workers were paid because they couldn't live on the wages he paid. If tax credits didn't exist I very much doubt Philip Green would have gone without his third super yatch and paid his staff more instead. His staff would have just been even poorer.

AnotherEmma · 31/03/2022 22:14

@Blossomtoes

The thing that destroyed the link between jobs and decent pay was Thatcher’s wholesale demolition of our heavy industry. Add to that selling off social housing and not replacing it and privatising everything in sight, in tandem with weakening unions and here we are.
Yup
Blossomtoes · 31/03/2022 22:12

The thing that destroyed the link between jobs and decent pay was Thatcher’s wholesale demolition of our heavy industry. Add to that selling off social housing and not replacing it and privatising everything in sight, in tandem with weakening unions and here we are.

planetme · 31/03/2022 22:01

Interesting thread

We used to really rely on tax credits up til a few years ago.
Haven't needed them or been eligible for years

It was awful if you got an overpayment though, a couple of times we had to pay back about 2k and it was inexplicable how they'd decided we owed it

PebbleMillAtOne · 31/03/2022 21:57

I’d be a skeleton if it wasn’t the UC I work gave bills just like so many others . Thank God for benefits

Swrigh1234 · 31/03/2022 21:52

[quote Villagewaspbyke]@BookkeeperBobby - what are you talking about? You think wages would rise if we cut off welfare? And then people have no other choice but to work for money? Then you think wages would fall? Emm not likely.

I have lived in places without welfare benefits. Wages are not high. It is not some sort of workers utopia. Quite the opposite.

If we cut off all welfare benefits wages would definitely fall. But there is a minimum wage. Do you think the poor should just starve?[/quote]
Supply and demand? It’s a very simple concept. As shown by in the last two years. Number of workers falls, wages go up.

mumda · 31/03/2022 21:50

Pre tax credits overtime existed.
Which means doorstep loans could be avoided by asking for overtime.

No one does overtime now. Certainly not for time and a half.

More part time working means more companies avoid national insurance payments too. And effectively tax credits subsidise companies allowing bigger profits.

Swrigh1234 · 31/03/2022 21:50

Spot on OP. Tax credits or any form of topping up low pay is a way to artificially suppress wages. It means employers do not need to pay the going rate because the tax payer will pick up the tab. It means that they do not need to work on productivity, invest in skills or technology because low paid workers are aplenty. It means lower productivity in the economy, making everyone poorer. All the while the skill gap grows and poverty perpetuates itself.
Tax credits were a way for nu Labour to throw crumbs and charity at people rather than to create an economy that pays well. Not surprising that all labour policies lead to deep rot in the economy. Unfortunately the Tories did not course correct and the low pay culture and worse standard of living is becoming a generational problem.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 31/03/2022 21:46

And you cannot just choose not to work and be on benefits. That's not what happens.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 31/03/2022 21:45

@Villagewaspbyke

In the uk we have so many luxuries. The low paid have a luxury that they can rely on benefits rather than having to work or to work more hours. Some of my relatives in other countries work crazy hours just to survive. There is no option not to work. You have no idea how hard life is for so many people.

We have many millions non working people on benefits in the uk. What do you think would happen to wages if they were forced to work?

Having to rely on benefits because your wages are so low is not a LUXURY.
Getoff · 31/03/2022 21:41

I would guess that benefits, if they have any impact on wages at all, it's by reducing the number of hours people to choose to work, forcing employers to offer higher wages to get the workers they need.

Can you link to any credible source about the effect of benefits on wages?

Why do you think benefits would cause wages to be lower? What's the mechanism/rationale?

Keepitonthedownlow · 31/03/2022 21:28

How do you know so many fit, healthy people aren't working? Channel 5 documentaries?

Angelswithflirtyfaces · 31/03/2022 21:27

Tax credits should be there for small businesses and public services to top up wages not mass profit companies such as supermarkets and companies that tax dodge. That money effectively goes to shareholders. Big companies should not be able to have tax credits to top up wages and pay a higher wage per hour.
Housing benefits should be capped as in rents capped. Landlords could then earn a profit but not an excessive one. We have our gas etc capped so why not rents?
If landlords sell up as a result councils can buy as stock.
More funding to upskill people. Instead of sending people to work for free at poundland in exchange for benefits, actually skill them to perform a public service job which we all pay for out of our taxes and national insurance anyway.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 31/03/2022 21:22

@Villagewaspbyke

In the uk we have so many luxuries. The low paid have a luxury that they can rely on benefits rather than having to work or to work more hours. Some of my relatives in other countries work crazy hours just to survive. There is no option not to work. You have no idea how hard life is for so many people.

We have many millions non working people on benefits in the uk. What do you think would happen to wages if they were forced to work?

How many millions of fit, healthy, working age people are not working and are on benefits in the UK?
dangermouseisace · 31/03/2022 21:14

I remember my dad having 2 jobs (full time and part time), my mum working full time and then some and us being sent to grandparents so they could continue to work. And still things were tight. At least things were better for my children in that respect.

Swipe left for the next trending thread