Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unsafe to go to Kenya, Uganda and Rwanda as a queer woman?

237 replies

idiotwhoworries · 31/03/2022 19:51

I have a new job in the third sector. Very much in the future, there are opportunities for work (not permanently, but for short term projects) in several countries in Africa.

I'm married to a woman and feel so stupid because I can't safely go and work there at all, can I? Perhaps Rwanda but not the others?

I have obviously known for a long, long time why this would be problematic in theory, but it's never been relevant personally before and only now I actually have this job and the potential opportunity on the horizon am I thinking of the reality.

If any immigration officials either looked at my phone or questioned me ("are you married?" "what is your spouse's name?") they would know quick enough I am in a same sex marriage and while I imagine they can turn a blind eye and ignore - that seems like a big gamble?

OP posts:
Lilifer · 01/04/2022 09:19

@FirewomanSam thanks for your reply. Honestly I am not being disingenuous or trying to offend anyone here.

I absolutely accept and respect how anyone chooses to identify and if my assumptions are wrong and they correct me I'm cool with that.

I am a 52 year old woman, I have some seriously heavy shit going down in my life this last few years and I am not at all up to speed in this area because it's not something that I come across in my daily life. For eg the word queer was a slur when I was a teenager so I was unaware that this word was ok now, call that ignorance or being out of touch but I genuinely did not know that.

What I am struggling to understand on this thread is where people (I don't mean you because you replied in good faith and civilly) but the level of anger directed at people like me who are asking genuine questions and are being shot down as offensive or likened to "talking to my Nan" etc

Anyway thanks for your explanation and yes I agree that there's no need for me to have that knowledge of someone's sexual orientation and it makes no difference to my day but it's just something that I assume without giving it much thought, it's not even a conscious thought process just an underlying assumption. I don't honestly care what anyones preferences are that's not my business and I've far more important things to occupy my mind sadly 🙁

FirewomanSam · 01/04/2022 09:18

@SlothyMoth “We all identify as different things all the time Do we? I don't, nor do most people I know, they just are and get on with things”

Of course we do! If someone asks you where you’re from, do you say ‘oh I don’t know, I just am and just get on with things’? Or do you tell them where you grew up?

If someone asks if you’re married do you say ‘what a nonsense question, I just am’? Or do you tell them you’re married/single/widowed/divorced/cohabiting?

If someone asks what you do for a living do you say ‘I don’t need to label myself, I’m just here getting on with things?’ Or do you tell them your job title, your profession?

Those are all ways of identifying yourself just the same as calling yourself a man/woman/non-binary or straight/gay/queer/bisexual. Do you object to people ‘identifying’ in all of those scenarios? Or do you only object when the ‘identity’ is something a bit different to your ‘normal’?

SlothyMoth · 01/04/2022 09:18

Oh the irony of posting this on a thread where OP’s sexual orientation has been interrogated and scrutinised by people demanding to know exactly what she means and who she is/isn’t attracted to despite that having no relevance to the question she asked.

I think you misunderstand the meaning of irony but never mind.

AIBU is not exactly known as a supportive and gentle place to ask personal questions.

Queer doesn't mean much to many people, it seems the term itself is rapidly evolving. If this sort of thing is important to you that's fine, most of us are too busy trying to work out how to pay the next energy bill never mind and don't feel the need to advertise who we hop in bed with or what clothes we wear on any given day. (Warm wooly 'nan' style clothes today if anyone is interested).

Allaboutthatvase · 01/04/2022 09:17

@SlothyMoth
It was other people telling the op that she had her sexuality wrong and that decided rather than answering the question to focus on the labels

Just like you did. Your first response wasn't about the question at all it was to tell her you feel labels are self indulgent and your now asking why people can't just "get on with it"

Op has posted a very real specific question about specific travel.

People then started discussing her sexuality, telling her that term was wrong and trying to relabel her relationship.

Some people then popped up to tell her why was she making a big deal of it.

All this vastly overshadows the input of people that actually have experience of travel in that region.

It's what happens frequently on these threads. I've had it on previous threads under a different name, where any useful response gets drowned out under people telling me how exhausting it is, or why my question isn't a question despite no actual experience of it themselves.

Crazykatie · 01/04/2022 09:17

If you are discrete and do not display affection in public there will be no problem, if you are an activist and make a show of being gay there is a good chance you will be harassed.

In all countries there are single women that travel with friends, share rooms with them and don’t socialize with men, it’s wise to stick to the dress codes of that particular country too

lborgia · 01/04/2022 09:14

@JudyJ - thanks, it is really decent of you to explain your own pov. Each of these posts explains why the need for something that is so generalised.

No person is exactly like another, so “humans” is supposed to cover it (although some more human than others maybe?!).

Same here, that you have room to work out what you feel/think, and not be pinned down to a particular set of criteria.

FairyLightPups · 01/04/2022 09:14

@JudyJ

**Please don’t yell at me, but this seems a good moment for me to be able to ask.

If someone describes themselves as queer, is that, then, bisexual, or is it broader than that?**

I'm technically bi but these days much more likely to call myself queer, this is because I'm generally more attracted to women than men/have little interest in dating men but can't rule it out completely. I feel like using gay/lesbian wouldn't describe me accurately and could be offensive to some people who are exclusively attracted to women. But to call myself bisexual would imply to some that I'm equally attracted to/open to rrelationships with men, which I'm mostly not. It's obviously personal to everyone though. As an aside, "lesbian" has been used as a slur against me more than any other term.

Same, in high school I wasn't bullied with the word queer, it was lezza or dyke.
SlothyMoth · 01/04/2022 09:11

[quote Allaboutthatvase]@SlothyMoth

It can be important though. For example people here are insisting that the OP is a lesbian, even when she said she is not.

We all identify as different things all the time

For example how annoyed do people get about not using nick names, or being called a partner when they are infact married, being called the wrong job title or being called the wrong nationality/ area eg people from Essex calling themselves londoners, people from Scotland not wanting be called English or identifying as British because it fits their political views.

It wasn't the op that made this an issue, it was the people policing what she called her self[/quote]
We all identify as different things all the time Do we? I don't, nor do most people I know, they just are and get on with things

Anyone who gets overly annoyed about "using nick names, or being called a partner when they are infact married, being called the wrong job title or being called the wrong nationality/ area eg people from Essex calling themselves londoners" is rather a bit precious too. It sounds like the professionally offended. Hard work! I couldn't be bothered with it.

FirewomanSam · 01/04/2022 09:10

Many people don't really have the interest or time reflecting deeply on other people's ID or sexual orientations, it's not what features heavily for everyone.

Oh the irony of posting this on a thread where OP’s sexual orientation has been interrogated and scrutinised by people demanding to know exactly what she means and who she is/isn’t attracted to despite that having no relevance to the question she asked.

lborgia · 01/04/2022 09:09

Er, bit of a x-post there. I’m still fighting for women to be seen, it would seem!

JudyJ · 01/04/2022 09:08

**Please don’t yell at me, but this seems a good moment for me to be able to ask.

If someone describes themselves as queer, is that, then, bisexual, or is it broader than that?**

I'm technically bi but these days much more likely to call myself queer, this is because I'm generally more attracted to women than men/have little interest in dating men but can't rule it out completely. I feel like using gay/lesbian wouldn't describe me accurately and could be offensive to some people who are exclusively attracted to women. But to call myself bisexual would imply to some that I'm equally attracted to/open to rrelationships with men, which I'm mostly not. It's obviously personal to everyone though. As an aside, "lesbian" has been used as a slur against me more than any other term.

lborgia · 01/04/2022 09:07

@GregBrawlsInDogJail - don’t be so fucking rude!

“Talking to my nan” sounds like a cliche to barrel up all old women who haven’t understood the current language into one amorphous mass to be dismissed as irritating. Amazingly patronising for one so enlightened. How ironic.

All I did was ask for some guidance / advice. Not everyone lives in the middle of a diverse community. Even reading vaguely sensible news, these things are assumed, and at some point, some of us are going to ask questions!

I saw my opportunity and fortunately @FairyLightPups was gracious enough to explain.

SlothyMoth · 01/04/2022 09:07

oh ffs. It's fine to take that as a rule of thumb assumption, most people do but if you find out that's not how the people involved see themselves, you need to respect that.This really is like talking to my nan.
What's up with you nan? Are you being ageist? Funny how it's ok to be ageist yet you want others to show respect you, doesn't it cut with ways? @Lilifer asked a genuine question, no need to be so rude @GregBrawlsInDogJail. Many people don't really have the interest or time reflecting deeply on other people's ID or sexual orientations, it's not what features heavily for everyone.

It really is all self absorbed, why the need to label yourself, just live and let live whether you like women or men and whether you feel male or female whatever that is anyway. Most of us just are and get on with things.

To OP's question, I think it depends if you are someone who just blends in it should surely not be a problem but on the other hand what would you want to work in a country that doesn't respect and protect people who are gay?

FairyLightPups · 01/04/2022 09:07

@SlothyMoth

All this ;I identify as this and that', I find it very self absorbed. I wonder what, once all this identity stuff is out of fashion, as it eventually will, is going to be the next BIG THING.
Ah yes what a fun time it will be when all the silly gay people stop being gay and everyone goes back to being straight.

Get a grip!

FirewomanSam · 01/04/2022 09:05

@Lilifer

I feel out of the loop here. 🤔

Is it now wrong to assume for the most part that someone in a same sex marriage is gay and someone married to someone of opposite sex is straight (by and large, and accepting there are exceptions to this)?

I guess the question is why do you need to assume anything? How often does a need for that knowledge actually present itself?

If someone is talking about their husband/wife/boyfriend/girlfriend then that usually tells you whether they’re in a same-sex or opposite-sex relationship, but why do you need to know what their preferences are beyond that? What difference does having or not having that information make to your day?

For the purposes of this thread, OP said she is a woman married to another woman and that she is happy for her relationship to be called a ‘lesbian relationship’ but that she herself does not identity as ‘a lesbian’ and prefers to refer to herself as queer. I can’t believe the number of people who are apparently losing their minds over that very simple statement.

OP has given us all the information we need to be able to advise on her question, which was about how she would get on in those counties as a woman married to another woman. Thankfully some people have given great sensible and practical advice, but my goodness some of the disingenuous ‘confused’ responses wanting to pull apart OP’s identity (for reasons that make no difference to her actual question) are disgusting.

Allaboutthatvase · 01/04/2022 09:00

@SlothyMoth

It can be important though. For example people here are insisting that the OP is a lesbian, even when she said she is not.

We all identify as different things all the time

For example how annoyed do people get about not using nick names, or being called a partner when they are infact married, being called the wrong job title or being called the wrong nationality/ area eg people from Essex calling themselves londoners, people from Scotland not wanting be called English or identifying as British because it fits their political views.

It wasn't the op that made this an issue, it was the people policing what she called her self

GregBrawlsInDogJail · 01/04/2022 09:00

@Lilifer

I feel out of the loop here. 🤔

Is it now wrong to assume for the most part that someone in a same sex marriage is gay and someone married to someone of opposite sex is straight (by and large, and accepting there are exceptions to this)?

Hmm oh ffs.

It's fine to take that as a rule of thumb assumption, most people do but if you find out that's not how the people involved see themselves, you need to respect that.

This really is like talking to my nan.

Clymene · 01/04/2022 08:59

@Allaboutthatvase - I absolutely agree with you in permanent job positions. In short term contracts/projects, it's very easy. I just don't ever talk about it.

Ironically, the only person who's asked me in 10 years of contracting is a woman I don't know very well who's married to another woman.

Brainwave89 · 01/04/2022 08:59

My son is gay and has worked recently on projects in Rwanda and Tanzania. These were perhaps for a period of 3-4 weeks and he experienced no difficulty at all. However, there would clearly be a big difference between 2-3 weeks as a foreign health worker and permanent residence. In some African countries there is a move to more stringent anti-gay measures including discussion of a death penalty.

Lilifer · 01/04/2022 08:57

I feel out of the loop here. 🤔

Is it now wrong to assume for the most part that someone in a same sex marriage is gay and someone married to someone of opposite sex is straight (by and large, and accepting there are exceptions to this)?

SlothyMoth · 01/04/2022 08:56

All this ;I identify as this and that', I find it very self absorbed. I wonder what, once all this identity stuff is out of fashion, as it eventually will, is going to be the next BIG THING.

Allaboutthatvase · 01/04/2022 08:55

@lborgia

Please don’t yell at me, but this seems a good moment for me to be able to ask.

If someone describes themselves as queer, is that, then, bisexual, or is it broader than that?

I have no frame of reference, and hate feeling like the out-of-touch - I know that I am now seen as a white cis-gendered privileged person, which I hate because in my head I’m still a closest anarchist. Clearly not.

I’m really bothered by the idea that I would go a fair way NOT to call someone queer (as per other pps who have equal memories of earlier decades), but now people identify as that, and I cannot seem to find a proper definition (the one googled above just says homosexual, right, which isn’t correct either?!). In my head it’s the same as some POC saying the “n” word. If they wish to say it to each other, that’s up to them, but no way would I (or should I) use it. I feel the same about queer at the moment.

If anyone feels like helping with this, I would be grateful. I’m not a troll, I’m not antagonising, I’m just wanting to know.

I think that I would wait to see how a person describes themselves first

It's fairly common now for younger lesbians to describe themselves as gay. I do, but some of the older generation of lesbians I've met are horrified by that.

I use queer as a bit of a catch all term. I'd describe my friendship group as a queer group as it has a range of sexualities other than straight.

People tend to be much more fluid in describing sexuality and queer tends to be used to cover everything that's not hetro, and can be used as a vague term when people don't feel one label fits well eg don't feel bisexual or lesbian fits.

lborgia · 01/04/2022 08:53

@FairyLightPups - thank you! That really did help.

FairyLightPups · 01/04/2022 08:45

This is like having a conversation with my Nan

Grin
FrecklesMalone · 01/04/2022 08:45

@alexdgr8

i don't understand. you are a woman married to a woman. yet you say you are not a lesbian ? how come ?
I'm a woman married to a man but I'm not straight. Fuck me maybe non-straight people get married to the person they love but it doesn't define their sexuality. This is like having a conversation with my Nan.