Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unsafe to go to Kenya, Uganda and Rwanda as a queer woman?

237 replies

idiotwhoworries · 31/03/2022 19:51

I have a new job in the third sector. Very much in the future, there are opportunities for work (not permanently, but for short term projects) in several countries in Africa.

I'm married to a woman and feel so stupid because I can't safely go and work there at all, can I? Perhaps Rwanda but not the others?

I have obviously known for a long, long time why this would be problematic in theory, but it's never been relevant personally before and only now I actually have this job and the potential opportunity on the horizon am I thinking of the reality.

If any immigration officials either looked at my phone or questioned me ("are you married?" "what is your spouse's name?") they would know quick enough I am in a same sex marriage and while I imagine they can turn a blind eye and ignore - that seems like a big gamble?

OP posts:
Ijustreallywantacat · 01/04/2022 17:04

I'm not sure any of those countries would appeal to many for more than a couple of weeks anyway - straight or gay...

Kenya is a beautiful country and great to visit. The wildlife is spectacular.

Chonfox · 01/04/2022 16:04

If you really wanted the opportunity to travel then take it and just lie. No big deal. If your wife wants to visit, say she's a friend. Not ideal but again no big deal in the grand scheme of things as it would be short term. If that sounds like too much hassle for you and you don't really want the travel well then you have a good excuse not to go. I'm not sure any of those countries would appeal to many for more than a couple of weeks anyway - straight or gay...

FairyLightPups · 01/04/2022 15:40

@whumpthereitis

It’s ironic that those screaming about how they hate labels are the ones targeting OP because she’s refusing to use their preferred label. It’s not labels themselves you don’t like, just the ones you don’t personally approve of.

OP hasn’t made a post simply to share her labels and invite discussion as to terminology, she’s shared her label because it is entirely relevant to the particular issue she’s facing. Hardly a vanity exercise.

Anyway, there has been some useful information provided in amongst all the batshittery of this thread, and I do hope you’ve found it helpful OP. Best of luck to you!

this
whumpthereitis · 01/04/2022 15:34

It’s ironic that those screaming about how they hate labels are the ones targeting OP because she’s refusing to use their preferred label. It’s not labels themselves you don’t like, just the ones you don’t personally approve of.

OP hasn’t made a post simply to share her labels and invite discussion as to terminology, she’s shared her label because it is entirely relevant to the particular issue she’s facing. Hardly a vanity exercise.

Anyway, there has been some useful information provided in amongst all the batshittery of this thread, and I do hope you’ve found it helpful OP. Best of luck to you!

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 01/04/2022 15:13

Well, I'm exclusively a female! Not exclusively homosexual.

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 01/04/2022 15:11

I'm mid 20s and it was used as a slur against me at school (I'm bisexual, fwiw). I don't like the word at all but it's clear what OP means here - that she is a woman in a female same sex relationship - and surely that's the relevant part here for her worries about work travel? Not why she doesn't call herself a lesbian - if I were in a same sex relationship I wouldn't call myself a lesbian because I'm not exclusively a female homosexual and I think it's important to leave that term to real lesbians.

nightwakingmoon · 01/04/2022 14:32

@GregBrawlsInDogJail

The reclamation of "queer" started well before Gen Z were born.
Yes it did, especially in America; but it was extremely divisive, and disliked by many of us for exactly the same reasons we still dislike it. So what’s your point?

It’s still in use as a slur or a derogatory term among quite a few demographics. If you’re under 25 you may never have heard it used as a derogatory term or insult, but that doesn’t mean it isn’t still used as such (some older people in the U.K. still use it as a slur).

lighterskies · 01/04/2022 14:06

I guess in terms of the work question it partly depends how easily you can shut off that part of your life for the months you are working in the country where it would be problematic.
Some people are naturally very private so could manage this easily and others would want to share more.
Older people in the LGBT community have a lot of experience of shielding parts of their lives from enquiry. But you may not think that the work opportunity is worth having to do this.

lighterskies · 01/04/2022 13:57

Gay family members in their 30's hate the term queer because it was used as a term of abuse for them for so long.
I think people should be sensitive to not forcing people to accept reclaimed meanings if they don't want to.

GregBrawlsInDogJail · 01/04/2022 13:24

The reclamation of "queer" started well before Gen Z were born.

BiscuitLover3678 · 01/04/2022 12:42

@Marvellousmadness

Gen Z really has f-ed up normalcy. Im so over the " I identify as this/that"
If you are a heterosexual person then I don’t think you can say that. Just like a man can’t say “oh I don’t get all this me too women’s rights stuff.”

You do realise that although lgbt+ rights were ok in the 00s they are actually better now. Respect what difference this has made to someone’s life, even if it is ‘annoying’ for you to have to understand.

Marvellousmadness · 01/04/2022 12:34

Gen Z really has f-ed up normalcy.
Im so over the " I identify as this/that"

nightwakingmoon · 01/04/2022 10:58

Well, I’m not confused about the word queer. I don’t like it - to me as a lesbian/bisexual woman it’s a nasty insult, and I don’t see why I personally should be made to accept it to describe me. Those who do want to, fine: I might find it strange to do so, but they can do what they like.

If you want to call yourself queer, do so! That’s your prerogative.

What isn’t acceptable is for ignorant people like the post by @SevenWaystoLeave (who has presumably never been called “queer” as an insult), to go about making nasty comments about “gender criticals” and throwing around accusations of transphobia, while dismissing others’ very real lived experience and what terms they choose to call themselves.

It’s always the proponents of so called “inclusive” language and gender identity who are the most vociferous in dismissing other people’s identity and lived experience, and policing what terms people may or may not use about themselves.

AlisonDonut · 01/04/2022 10:36

[quote FirewomanSam]**@Lilifer* and makes it difficult to call out the bullshitters without inadvertently upsetting those who seek to have asked in good faith! Again, sorry @lborgia*. Nuanced discussion is not easy on these boards![/quote]
You called me out for being sarcastic to the people who are so confused about the word queer.

Bookishandblondish · 01/04/2022 10:35

By the way, if it’s helpful, happy to discuss questions that you may want to ask your company.

I’ve travelled to the countries you mentioned but lived and worked in two other neighbouring sub Saharan countries for four years in total - as a lone woman who didn’t know a single person when they landed.

lborgia · 01/04/2022 10:24

@FirewomanSam - cheers, appreciate that. Yes, boards are hard work sometimes.

zingally · 01/04/2022 10:23

Your employer wouldn't send you somewhere unsafe for queer people.

I certainly wouldn't go to any of those countries as a lone woman. I might consider it as an organised tour/holiday. But with a view to independently living and working out there? Not in a million years.

FirewomanSam · 01/04/2022 10:21

@Lilifer and makes it difficult to call out the bullshitters without inadvertently upsetting those who seek to have asked in good faith! Again, sorry @lborgia. Nuanced discussion is not easy on these boards!

Bookishandblondish · 01/04/2022 10:19

Hi - I’ve actually been the manager in this position running a large healthcare project in a previous role.

The need was for short term - two weeks to six months business trips to a country that has been mentioned on this thread several times, also healthcare related ( country is notorious for its lack of human rights). It also was a project that offered opportunities to fast track promotion and was a really interesting project about improving access and quality of healthcare.

Firstly, due to the country, people were asked if they wanted to work on it so it was not compulsory. I offered informal conversations to anyone who was considering working on the project - and sexuality was raised by two people. Please note - unless someone raised it, I didn’t bring it up. I had informal and formal conversations with approximately 40-50 people over the year about working on the project. At any time, I had between 10-15 people working in country from UK, US and European offices.

In both cases, I talked through how we operated - our accommodation, how it worked, the reality of the social life, and the rules of the country - and what our company expectations were regarding the law. Everyone was expected to register with their relevant embassy. I’d also note this is a country where culturally, PDA just doesn’t happen.
We didn’t offer friends/ families visitation - the visa situation was far too costly and complex so that wasn’t a consideration.
One decided to work on the project, the other chose not to. We had no issues - and from my regular check ins with them, they were prepared and knew the expectation. In terms of letting people know, they did share with the immediate team that their partner was same sex ( they weren’t married) but not in a big announcement, more a “I’m going to stay with my partner X’s family” when asked what they were doing. For what it’s worth, if people came out and found they simply couldn’t hack it for whatever reason, they simply were moved off the project - it doesn’t suit everyone to travel for work and some people find it just doesn’t work for them.

Interestingly, I’ve worked abroad quite a bit and I think some posters on this thread underestimate the complexity of business travel and making sense of what is appropriate in places - including in so called liberal countries. There’s places that locals will know as being fine - and other areas where that isn’t the case. Also that locals may not say anything directly but find clothing/ behaviour distasteful- which may impact on the ability to do the work.

Lilifer · 01/04/2022 10:15

@FirewomanSam

It takes two minutes to draft a Mumsnet post and even busy and stressed people deserve a few minutes in their day to connect and chat about something on Mumsnet, sometimes it might be the only adult interaction they get in their day.

@Lilifer that wasn’t what I was saying, I was responding to the poster who keeps repeatedly stating that they don’t care, yet the fact that they’re on a thread nitpicking over the subject would suggest the opposite.

Fair enough. I agree that there are some posters who don't seem genuine in their wish to understand another perspective and that is frustrating and makes it all the more difficult for the likes of me to ask a genuine question because I'm afraid it will be seen as shit stirring. I really want to understand this tho because I don't want to offend people inadvertently 😣
FirewomanSam · 01/04/2022 10:05

@lborgia I’m genuinely sorry that I’ve caused you offence and in case my post wasn’t clear, it wasn’t aimed at you at all. There are people here asking genuine questions (like you) and as I said to another poster upthread, I think that’s great.

My sarcastic use of ‘terribly confused’ was aimed at the first couple of pages of this thread where there were some very disingenuous and faux-naive comments that set the tone for the whole thread and basically derailed it from the get go.

Again, I’m sorry that my post came across like it was taking a pop at those asking genuine questions and trying to understand better.

Butchyrestingface · 01/04/2022 10:03

I was interested in the definition of 'queer' in this scenario, and not because I give a shite whether the OP defines herself as 'queer' or 'lesbian'.

Yes, self-identifying as a woman in a relationship with another woman with another woman COULD mean that the poster is bi-sexual. But it could also mean that they are a male-to-female transgendered person.

And in that scenario, the advice on whether to go to any of the countries mentioned could surely vary for lesbians vs transgender people?

Nothing to suggest that the OP IS, but I do think a precise definition of how the term 'queer' is being used, could be relevant in terms of seeking advice on the safety of travelling to such-and-such a country. If not in THIS particular case, then certainly in others.

nightwakingmoon · 01/04/2022 09:59

@SevenWaystoLeave

What do you mean? I've had some good advice. Not sure what you mean

Sorry to say OP you've awoken the mumsnet "gender criticals", they hate the word "queer" because it's inclusive of trans people. Ignore them and hopefully they'll go away and not hijack your thread.

Nothing to do with trans - how ignorant of you to say that and how offensive to others’ lived experience and preferences about how they define themselves. You should know better than to decide to call a group of people a hugely offensive slur.

Many gay and lesbian people (me included) find the term “queer” very upsetting because it’s an unpleasant slur that also implies gay people are not normal in some way (“queer” meant strange or odd). It also historically meant gay men and erased lesbian existence. I’ve walked through cities at night as a young women with gay male friends and heard people shouting “queers” at them/us. How dare you assume it’s some kind of bigotry not to like the term!

I work with some older people who still use it as a slur and have no interest in reclaiming it - sure there are some young people who like the term, but a large proportion of gay people don’t, and it’s has nothing at all to do with trans. You really should educate yourself a little more.

AlisonDonut · 01/04/2022 09:57

@FirewomanSam

I think if any homophobic immigration / police start questioning you, just say you are queer not a lesbian and that should totally sort it out.

@Lilifer here’s a nice example of one of those disingenuous posts I was referring to Hmm

What is disingenuous about it?

Sarcastic yes.

Moppincraxy · 01/04/2022 09:56

@idiotwhoworries

I just googled meaning of queer and the first result was the Oxford dictionary definiiton:

My gut feeling is this is disingenuous.

You weren't "confused" by my chosen word of queer. You just don't like it, for whatever reason.

You knew exactly what I meant by my saying I am a queer woman. You felt the urge to go after the language I use, which is the language I am comfortable with.

Yes, I'm in a lesbian mariage. I am comfortable saying that. My wife is a lesbian or queer, she's comfortable with both.

However, I am queer. I'm not a lesbian.

Anyway, it really is inconsequential if you dislike me calling myself queer - but don't pretend you are "confused" by the word queer in the context I used it in. That's a little daft.

Your assumptions about me are wrong. I was genuinely confused about how you could be a woman in a lesbian marriage with a lesbian woman and not be a lesbian. I also don't understand what queer means as in real life I have only experienced it as a homophobic slur and on social media it seems to be such a broad term that I don't know what it means at all in terms of sexuality or identity. I was genuinely asking for clarification as I have a lot of experience in East Africa so thought I could be helpful but wanted to fully understand the situation before giving any advice.

However, you are making some pretty horrible and offensive assumptions about me and questioning my integrity. I'm not telling anyone how they should identify or policing language. I was trying to clarify what the situation that you were worried about was as I thought I might be able to help. I was genuinely confused and it is narrow minded and intolerant to assume that no one could be confused about the words you used when there is so much variance in what people understand queer to mean, and the fact that it is described as offensive in the dictionary.

The hostility, intolerance, casual ageism and sneering on this thread in response to a genuine question of clarification is kind of ironic in relation to the original question.