Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unsafe to go to Kenya, Uganda and Rwanda as a queer woman?

237 replies

idiotwhoworries · 31/03/2022 19:51

I have a new job in the third sector. Very much in the future, there are opportunities for work (not permanently, but for short term projects) in several countries in Africa.

I'm married to a woman and feel so stupid because I can't safely go and work there at all, can I? Perhaps Rwanda but not the others?

I have obviously known for a long, long time why this would be problematic in theory, but it's never been relevant personally before and only now I actually have this job and the potential opportunity on the horizon am I thinking of the reality.

If any immigration officials either looked at my phone or questioned me ("are you married?" "what is your spouse's name?") they would know quick enough I am in a same sex marriage and while I imagine they can turn a blind eye and ignore - that seems like a big gamble?

OP posts:
BlueLaces · 02/04/2022 22:51

I've worked in/visited all of the countries you mention OP. I'm a straight woman, but I was never asked about my husband/marital status at immigration. I wasn't often asked about my husband in country either - people I met were more focussed on the fact that I didn't have kids. That was a big deal and something they struggled to understand.

My gay male colleague who also worked in one of those countries never mentioned his partner at all in conversation. If anyone assumed he was married (to a woman) he didn't correct them - he felt that it wasn't a risk worth taking.

bellinisurge · 02/04/2022 22:11

The Q word is as vile as the N word.

bellinisurge · 02/04/2022 21:47

Yawn.
Good luck in your new job.

Aichek · 02/04/2022 19:58

If she was 'discovered' nothing would happen though. Not as an aid worker from overseas in any of those countries. I live in a country where it is illegal to be gay. I know absolutely oodles of gay NGO workers here. There's a vibrant gay scene and LGBT+ local NGOs. It's not without difficulty for highly visible local activists at all, and they are sometimes arrested. It does not happen to overseas aid workers because the government knows full well they would have a diplomatic incident on their hands and they frankly couldn't be bothered.

Congratulations on your new job OP. If it helps, I used to pretend I was married (and wore a cheap ring) when travelling. I work in an Arab country now and while DP and I are not married people just assume we are and I let them. People will assume the norm- if you mention a partner people will think they are male. I really can't see why you would need to go into it.

I'm sorry people have been horrible to you- I'm an aid worker too and Mumsnet not only really hates us, it also assumes we have no critical faculties (instead of grappling with these questions daily). I work on Human Rights and so of course the work is where HR abuses are worse- I can't very well say I won't go to those places. Enjoy your new job, it sounds great

georama · 02/04/2022 19:29

@Grumpasaurusrex

Having lived in Uganda I definitely wouldn't go and be open about being a woman married to another woman. One girl I worked with was a lesbian and referred to her partner as 'my partner' and had no issue. So it depends how much you want the job i.e. enough to keep your private life private?
There's keeping your private life private and then there's having to hide and possibly lie about your spouse for months on end and live in fear that you might be discovered.
idiotwhoworries · 02/04/2022 19:09

@bellinisurge

You shouldn't be sent to/expected to go to a homophobic country. We should not be offering assistance or support to countries who can't support basic human rights.

Also

If you're not a lesbian you are bisexual. Please use the right words. Queer is a word used by violent homophobes.

Snorting with incredulity here.

Who do you actually think you are?

You can call yourself bisexual if that's your preferred choice, I don't care how anyone else refers to themselves. If it's right for you, it's right for you.

However, you don't get to dictate how I refer to myself. I am a queer woman.

I do not owe you, or anyone else, an explanation as to why queer is my preferred choice. My reasons are valid.

OP posts:
Sux2buthen · 02/04/2022 18:52

@bellinisurge

You shouldn't be sent to/expected to go to a homophobic country. We should not be offering assistance or support to countries who can't support basic human rights.

Also

If you're not a lesbian you are bisexual. Please use the right words. Queer is a word used by violent homophobes.

You cannot tell somebody what their sexuality is 😃 OP may be pansexual, asexual or a whole other bunch of things but she has made it clear that she doesn't call herself what you're saying. Anyway it's been done to death Good luck whatever you decide about work OP
bellinisurge · 02/04/2022 17:09

You shouldn't be sent to/expected to go to a homophobic country. We should not be offering assistance or support to countries who can't support basic human rights.

Also

If you're not a lesbian you are bisexual. Please use the right words. Queer is a word used by violent homophobes.

Grumpasaurusrex · 02/04/2022 17:09

I want to add that, having travelled the world extensively and lived as an expat in a number of countries (as I still do today) Uganda is my favourite country in the whole world and I'd definitely recommend going. You can politely decline to answer any questions about your personal life. That would be the professional thing to do anyway.

Grumpasaurusrex · 02/04/2022 17:04

Having lived in Uganda I definitely wouldn't go and be open about being a woman married to another woman. One girl I worked with was a lesbian and referred to her partner as 'my partner' and had no issue. So it depends how much you want the job i.e. enough to keep your private life private?

Kanaloa · 02/04/2022 16:03

@XmasElf10

I grew up in the times of “queer bashing” and I am definitely not normally woke but I completely understood the OP referring to herself as queer. She is fully entitled to use any descriptor about herself that she wants. I wouldn’t call a homosexual queer unless that was the descriptor they had claimed as I would not want to offend but in this case the OP has chosen queer so it would be rude not to use her chosen term.

OP I’d consider this a little like working in strict Arab countries with dubious womens rights. I think personally that I would find it very stressful to work in a place where I worried about getting into trouble just from being myself. I think it’s easy to say “it’ll be fine, particularly as you are a woman and not a gay man” but you only need to find a pocket of homophobia (and this thread shows how easy that is) and you could end up in a lot of trouble…. Particularly when the homophobia is backed by the law. I think I would not take the risk but I am a pretty risk averse person generally.

This is actually what I was trying to say re countries with dubious women’s rights. Sort of even if nothing happened the risk/worry that it might would just ruin the experience for me.
FirewomanSam · 02/04/2022 13:44

@idiotwhoworries threads like this remind me why I really, really need to get off Mumsnet. It’s such a toxic horrible place even though there are genuinely helpful people amongst all the crap.

I can’t believe that people aren’t content with questioning your identity and sexuality, they’ve now decided to attack your chosen profession and your hopes for your career too. Yes AIBU is notoriously nasty but threads like this are just horrible to read. Some people apparently really get a kick out of ripping apart an OP for no good reason.

I hope you’re ok and don’t let the bullshit get to you too much.

Crazykatie · 02/04/2022 11:33

[quote Porcupineintherough]@SlothyMoth yeah quite a lot of religion is about being saved - either that or propriating the Gods. Christian, Muslim, traditional - all works the same. And people in absolute poverty tend to be religious because it gives them the illusion of control over their lives. And religion, by it's very nature, tends to be conservative, not progressive.

Tell me, is any of the bollocks you are spouting based on experience? Because my neighbours would have thought you a patronising arse (no offence).[/quote]
For women in particular it is often the only social occasion that week and the joyous way that they worship is often quite uplifting.
In addition it is often the church that organizes food and medical aid so it is very beneficial to attend regularly, particularly rural areas, urban areas are much less religious, they have many more social opportunities.

Porcupineintherough · 02/04/2022 09:28

@SlothyMoth yeah quite a lot of religion is about being saved - either that or propriating the Gods. Christian, Muslim, traditional - all works the same. And people in absolute poverty tend to be religious because it gives them the illusion of control over their lives. And religion, by it's very nature, tends to be conservative, not progressive.

Tell me, is any of the bollocks you are spouting based on experience? Because my neighbours would have thought you a patronising arse (no offence).

Crazykatie · 02/04/2022 09:17

@Mahanii

Queer and NGO bashing aside...

In certain places I refuse to say I am divorced, I pretend I am married because as a woman it is safer to appear that you are 'owned'. Many people in varying circumstances lie for their safety, OP. It's up to you how you feel about that.

I would agree with that, you have to fit in with their culture, where a “married” woman has a higher status than a single woman, it’s the better option. I would caution the OP about any mention of single sex marriage in many countries, the gossip among the locals would spread like wildfire and could end up in a very difficult situation.
Mahanii · 02/04/2022 08:45

Queer and NGO bashing aside...

In certain places I refuse to say I am divorced, I pretend I am married because as a woman it is safer to appear that you are 'owned'. Many people in varying circumstances lie for their safety, OP. It's up to you how you feel about that.

SlothyMoth · 02/04/2022 07:40

[quote Porcupineintherough]@SlothyMoth do they aye? Which NGOs are these? And which Africans for that matter (it's a big place)? In the area I lived in Nigeria people would walk for days to bring their kids to the NGO clinics for vaccination or free medical treatment. When there was a special cataract clinic set up one year there were special services of thanksgiving .[/quote]
It's neocolonial. Richer economies facilitate economic and political interests through aid and interventions. China has been doing a powerful job of this but Americans and Europeans are still at it too.

Special services of thanksgiving
Comments like this are unprogressive and show the inherent saviour complex psychology at work.

Sux2buthen · 01/04/2022 22:56

@idiotwhoworries

Sounds like 'privileged persons' saviour complex, 'liberating' and 'rescuing' people in the poorest and least developed regions of the world, especially Sub-Saharan Africa.

Those that are supposedly being 'helped' are often seen as passive recipients of rich (often white) people's benevolence and sadly denied agency. Many people think NGOs parachuting people from the developed world into these situations perpetuates the disadvantages they face and many NGOs abuse their power as we have seen with Oxfam for example. According to some NGOs, Africans often find the this saviour attitude to help them "deeply patronising and offensive".

It's a deeply problematic set up.

Nope, no white saviour complex here. Our organisation is a social enterprise model and a major part of that is partnering with local medics to equip them with very specific clinical and technical skills (some of which are very, very new technology) needed to tackle several very specific illnesses that devastate people's lives and kill them if left untreated.

If you think there is no desperate need for doctors and clinics and training etc abroad, especially in rural areas, then you are simply broadcasting your own ignorance on this matter.

Shame on you for your misguided attempt to justify why children should suffer devastating disability and lose their lives before they even have a chance to get off the starting block - all for the want of medical care we access daily here in high income countries.

However @SlothyMoth. I see you exactly for what you are, and recognise that you are belligerently committed to misunderstanding the situation I'm writing about (because you didn't like the fact that I called myself a queer woman) while at the same time labouring under the illusion that your uninformed opinion is of any value.

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻excellent response. Also a virtual medal 🏅 being sent for putting up with a lot of the posts on here OP.
Porcupineintherough · 01/04/2022 22:45

@SlothyMoth do they aye? Which NGOs are these? And which Africans for that matter (it's a big place)? In the area I lived in Nigeria people would walk for days to bring their kids to the NGO clinics for vaccination or free medical treatment. When there was a special cataract clinic set up one year there were special services of thanksgiving .

SlothyMoth · 01/04/2022 20:34

Op, you clearly are an extremely confident and fervent helper of poor people in need. I hope it all works out for you and that you will find a way to fulfil your ambitions. It seems odd that you would choose MN AIBU to air out your concerns when you seem so knowledgeable, assertive and driven but maybe you did get something out of it. It's funny how authoritarian and devout some posters on this thread sound.

Sciurus83 · 01/04/2022 20:14

How utterly baffling that the OP is getting a hard time. Sorry OP, Mumsnet can be a very weird place sometimes. Good luck with your career, your work is important.

idiotwhoworries · 01/04/2022 20:02

Sounds like 'privileged persons' saviour complex, 'liberating' and 'rescuing' people in the poorest and least developed regions of the world, especially Sub-Saharan Africa.

Those that are supposedly being 'helped' are often seen as passive recipients of rich (often white) people's benevolence and sadly denied agency. Many people think NGOs parachuting people from the developed world into these situations perpetuates the disadvantages they face and many NGOs abuse their power as we have seen with Oxfam for example. According to some NGOs, Africans often find the this saviour attitude to help them "deeply patronising and offensive".

It's a deeply problematic set up.

Nope, no white saviour complex here. Our organisation is a social enterprise model and a major part of that is partnering with local medics to equip them with very specific clinical and technical skills (some of which are very, very new technology) needed to tackle several very specific illnesses that devastate people's lives and kill them if left untreated.

If you think there is no desperate need for doctors and clinics and training etc abroad, especially in rural areas, then you are simply broadcasting your own ignorance on this matter.

Shame on you for your misguided attempt to justify why children should suffer devastating disability and lose their lives before they even have a chance to get off the starting block - all for the want of medical care we access daily here in high income countries.

However @SlothyMoth. I see you exactly for what you are, and recognise that you are belligerently committed to misunderstanding the situation I'm writing about (because you didn't like the fact that I called myself a queer woman) while at the same time labouring under the illusion that your uninformed opinion is of any value.

OP posts:
SlothyMoth · 01/04/2022 19:29

@idiotwhoworries

In answer to OP's question, I would not chose to work in a country that has horrible and bigoted attitudes to gay and lesbian people, regardless of being queer or not

Lovely for you to have that neat way of looking at things.

What about the children and young adults there who are suffering from very treatable diseases who can't access doctors or medicines or medical equipment and training unless people - including big old queers like me - go out and make sure they can access it?

Not to go all Liam Neeson about this Grin but I have a very specific set of skills Grin that are extremely useful in my field.

Sounds like 'privileged persons' saviour complex, 'liberating' and 'rescuing' people in the poorest and least developed regions of the world, especially Sub-Saharan Africa.

Those that are supposedly being 'helped' are often seen as passive recipients of rich (often white) people's benevolence and sadly denied agency. Many people think NGOs parachuting people from the developed world into these situations perpetuates the disadvantages they face and many NGOs abuse their power as we have seen with Oxfam for example. According to some NGOs, Africans often find the this saviour attitude to help them "deeply patronising and offensive".

It's a deeply problematic set up.

Crazykatie · 01/04/2022 18:35

@Ijustreallywantacat

I'm not sure any of those countries would appeal to many for more than a couple of weeks anyway - straight or gay...

Kenya is a beautiful country and great to visit. The wildlife is spectacular.

I’ve travelled to quite a few African countries in general the people are lovely, white faces are welcomed often with enthusiasm. The problems women and children have are very similar to us, in rural areas they have to grow food to live, they have no money unless they can sell some or trade it for other essentials. Basic medical care is often lacking, treatments that would cost a few pence in the UK are not available, often due to incompetence and corruption.
AlisonDonut · 01/04/2022 17:10

@whumpthereitis

It’s ironic that those screaming about how they hate labels are the ones targeting OP because she’s refusing to use their preferred label. It’s not labels themselves you don’t like, just the ones you don’t personally approve of.

OP hasn’t made a post simply to share her labels and invite discussion as to terminology, she’s shared her label because it is entirely relevant to the particular issue she’s facing. Hardly a vanity exercise.

Anyway, there has been some useful information provided in amongst all the batshittery of this thread, and I do hope you’ve found it helpful OP. Best of luck to you!

I believe it is because many of us wouldn't dream of calling someone 'queer' due to the decades of it being used as a slur.

I mean, I've seen people get beaten up for being 'queer'. I'd never use it personally.

But then again I'm aware of the history of queer theory and all its connotations and still cannot get over someone using it about themselves, but that's their decision to make.