Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unsafe to go to Kenya, Uganda and Rwanda as a queer woman?

237 replies

idiotwhoworries · 31/03/2022 19:51

I have a new job in the third sector. Very much in the future, there are opportunities for work (not permanently, but for short term projects) in several countries in Africa.

I'm married to a woman and feel so stupid because I can't safely go and work there at all, can I? Perhaps Rwanda but not the others?

I have obviously known for a long, long time why this would be problematic in theory, but it's never been relevant personally before and only now I actually have this job and the potential opportunity on the horizon am I thinking of the reality.

If any immigration officials either looked at my phone or questioned me ("are you married?" "what is your spouse's name?") they would know quick enough I am in a same sex marriage and while I imagine they can turn a blind eye and ignore - that seems like a big gamble?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
intwrferingma · 03/04/2022 22:25

You g friend of mine is gay and has worked and studied in Uganda. He is white British. He wants to go back. His mum is worried for the reasons you are OP bit he loves the country and is determined. I imagine he would go alone tho, leaving his partner here in the UK at least initially. So yes... worrying but it doesn't stop people. And I guess you g friend has a certain amount of white privilege which may protect him? I dunno...

whumpthereitis · 03/04/2022 21:45

@bellinisurge

"I'm going to Eastern Europe/Deep south of America. Do you think that's safe as a [n-word]". Would you say that? No. Because it's offensive. However much it has allegedly been "reclaimed".
Here’s a better analogy:

If you heard a black person say that word, would you go up to them and demand they stop? I doubt it. You don’t get to dictate what anyone else refers to themselves at. You may find it offensive, but that’s entirely your issue to deal with. It’s not OP’s problem.

I’m sure you’ll cope.

Ozanj · 03/04/2022 21:45

It’s totally safe in Kenya. Even if you held hands people would think you were sisters / friends & there just isn’t the same animosity towards gay women as there is to gay men. However you would be expected to keep your relationship under wraps & your spouse may not be welcomed in the same way as others would.

Thelnebriati · 03/04/2022 21:30

Have you asked your employer how they manage these situations and what support they have put in place?

WalltoWallBtards · 03/04/2022 21:18

@bellinisurge in the words of Elsa, Let it Go!
Plenty of gay men and women use the word queer.
Your hang ups about the word are not relevant to this thread!

Kanaloa · 03/04/2022 21:09

@bellinisurge

"If someone is using the word about themselves they’re hardly going to offend themselves." Are you going to use the N word?
Obviously not you dipstick. I would not presume to tell a Black person that they cannot use it though, because I’m not a complete idiot as you obviously are.
idiotwhoworries · 03/04/2022 20:53

@BlueLaces

I've worked in/visited all of the countries you mention OP. I'm a straight woman, but I was never asked about my husband/marital status at immigration. I wasn't often asked about my husband in country either - people I met were more focussed on the fact that I didn't have kids. That was a big deal and something they struggled to understand.

My gay male colleague who also worked in one of those countries never mentioned his partner at all in conversation. If anyone assumed he was married (to a woman) he didn't correct them - he felt that it wasn't a risk worth taking.

Thank you, this is helpful to know you were never asked at immigration. Interesting to hear that people focused on you not having kids.
OP posts:
idiotwhoworries · 03/04/2022 20:50

@Aichek

If she was 'discovered' nothing would happen though. Not as an aid worker from overseas in any of those countries. I live in a country where it is illegal to be gay. I know absolutely oodles of gay NGO workers here. There's a vibrant gay scene and LGBT+ local NGOs. It's not without difficulty for highly visible local activists at all, and they are sometimes arrested. It does not happen to overseas aid workers because the government knows full well they would have a diplomatic incident on their hands and they frankly couldn't be bothered.

Congratulations on your new job OP. If it helps, I used to pretend I was married (and wore a cheap ring) when travelling. I work in an Arab country now and while DP and I are not married people just assume we are and I let them. People will assume the norm- if you mention a partner people will think they are male. I really can't see why you would need to go into it.

I'm sorry people have been horrible to you- I'm an aid worker too and Mumsnet not only really hates us, it also assumes we have no critical faculties (instead of grappling with these questions daily). I work on Human Rights and so of course the work is where HR abuses are worse- I can't very well say I won't go to those places. Enjoy your new job, it sounds great

Thank you! It's interesting that you mention the thriving gay scene, despite it being illegal where you work. That mirrors what some friends have said about other countries they visited.

I mean, obviously if I do go I won't be going to any gay events myself, but it's heartening to hear of lgbt culture persisting and people going about their business, even in the most adverse of circumstances.

OP posts:
bellinisurge · 03/04/2022 18:14

"I'm going to Eastern Europe/Deep south of America. Do you think that's safe as a [n-word]". Would you say that? No. Because it's offensive. However much it has allegedly been "reclaimed".

babbez · 03/04/2022 17:38

That should be different standards (I agree with post above!)

babbez · 03/04/2022 17:37

@Crazykatie

My experience after travelling in 6 African countries is that “westerners” are treated with more respect than locals but if you were to get involved in any kind of controversial activity you would be going home quickly.

As for safety in general, don’t go out unaccompanied at night, otherwise it’s OK. As an example in Zambia I met 2 French women, mid 20s, cycling from Addis Ababa to Capetown, no problem they arrive at a village enroute, asked where they could camp, they were always offered every hospitality including food. Where in Europe would you get that welcome.

Westerners are held to the same standards as an African woman would be. Yes, people will still disapprove, but I genuinely don't think your safety would be compromised. It's just how it is: they won't care that much because it's known that it's the norm over here, same as if you said you had pre-marital sex or whatever

Tigertigertigertiger · 03/04/2022 17:23

Don’t go.
It’s not safe

Crazykatie · 03/04/2022 17:21

My experience after travelling in 6 African countries is that “westerners” are treated with more respect than locals but if you were to get involved in any kind of controversial activity you would be going home quickly.

As for safety in general, don’t go out unaccompanied at night, otherwise it’s OK. As an example in Zambia I met 2 French women, mid 20s, cycling from Addis Ababa to Capetown, no problem they arrive at a village enroute, asked where they could camp, they were always offered every hospitality including food. Where in Europe would you get that welcome.

bellinisurge · 03/04/2022 17:17

"If someone is using the word about themselves they’re hardly going to offend themselves."
Are you going to use the N word?

Curioushorse · 03/04/2022 17:06

God, OP, this thread is batshit. Thanks for the good work you're doing. Yeah, you absolutely should get out in the field. It's important and you'll love it- but I think when you're working in aid you're working in areas where you're not always going to be mixing socially with the locals anyway. And I also feel like you're there with slightly different goals and attitudes from most people too. Not sure that your personal life will even be considered that relevant.

Curioushorse · 03/04/2022 16:59

I worked for a few years in another African country (not on your list). My organisation did let two married women go to live there- one in aid, the second as 'trailing spouse'. They were advised not to say anything. I think they both understood the cultural aspects of the job enough to feel ok with that- and, actually, in my relationship we had had enough of a problem in that I was the one working and my husband the 'trailing spouse'. Cultural issues were something we all had to deal with.

To be honest I think they just never mentioned it, and it was outside the experience of the majority of the people in the country enough that I just don't think it would have been an issue. It would have just been considered another weird foreign thing. Possibly it would would have been considered hilarious.

Pretty sure they wouldn't have been in danger because of their relationship.

BigGreen · 03/04/2022 16:51

I am so sorry that such homophobia still exists that you have to think about this.

I think it depends hugely on where you go, you'd need to risk assess properly. If you'd be alone, not 'out' or actively seeking a relationship then it would be a lot easier to fly under the radar.

WalltoWallBtards · 03/04/2022 16:47

I've not read on all the comments on the word 'queer' but I can tell you that I know many, MANY lesbian women who use that word and are comfortable with it - considering it reclaimed ( back in the 80s/90s) from the homophobes. I'm also aware of what I would consider 'annoying' straight people claiming some kind of 'queerness' because they don't like dresses or do like dresses or whatever but don't that let you for defining you. EVER!!!!

DaisyWaldron · 03/04/2022 16:46

If you are talking about/to an individual, you use the word they ask you to use. If you want an umbrella term to cover a wider range of people you can use LGBTQ+ or LGBTQIA.

timeisnotaline · 03/04/2022 16:37

I would have said why would you go to work there if that’s the approach in that country, whether or not you could keep your relationship and sexuality secret. Similarly to others I have not chased opportunities in eg Saudi Arabia as I don’t want to work there with their attitude towards women, and to a large number of other groups (gays, lesbians, also migrant workers who aren’t well paid ‘expats’). But I see your medical field and I do understand why you might want to. It’s probably not a good idea though.

I really only ended up commenting to say that while I’m sorry your thread has been derailed, it has also actually been really useful- I haven’t tracked usernames but the original question on using queer is one ive wanted to ask, and there were very helpful answers.
I’m still stuck on another version of the question where eg at work making a general statement - can I use queer as it’s been reclaimed, or should I avoid it because clearly it offends some people? I do feel like the latter is the right approach, that I can’t use an umbrella term that will offside members of the community being described, but I’m keen to hear what others think. (Probably obvious by now that I’m straight)

WalltoWallBtards · 03/04/2022 16:26

And as for anyone saying that you'll be safe in Uganda or Kenya - Sexual violence and rape, and murder, against LGBTQ+ women, and men, is absolutely rife in those countries. But you can go and look at HumanRights Watch and others reports on that and decide for yourself. Being an Aid worker is unlikely to give you any more protection, in fact it's more likely to make you a target.
Those governments with their ANTI - LGBTQ+ laws give free reign to the homophobes and bigots who feel that they have the right to punish gay people for existing.

WalltoWallBtards · 03/04/2022 16:18

You already know the answer - NO - because your life would be at risk in 2, probably 3 of those countries if word got out about your sexuality. It's okay until it's not.

I'm a lesbian and I cannot imagine taking a role like this which would mean hiding, and I mean HIDING, who you really are. It would be exhausting, you would only be able to trust a handful of people with the fact you have a wife which might sound okay bit on a day to day basis NEVER talking about your partner is very tricky. Never making reference to them, lying about why you're 'single' or lying about your 'husband'. Exhausting.

As a queer woman I turned down 6 months in Dubai for work - in theory a lot safer - but as soon as my HR dept were talking about having my wife coming over as the 'nanny' to our kids for visa purposes, and the issue of ours kids having both our names on the birth certificates, and advising me about how we might have to be very, VERY DIScreet etc I decided that no amount of money or job prospects or even experiences was going to throw me back into the closet.

Kanaloa · 03/04/2022 16:00

Having seen that you’ll only be there for a couple of months I suppose you could just lie. But I wouldn’t want to, it would just feel a very stressful experience and I would feel repressed.

Kanaloa · 03/04/2022 15:58

@bellinisurge

The Q word is as vile as the N word.
Plenty of black people use the N word. It’s almost as if the group it refers to are allowed to decide whether or not they themselves find it offensive. It’s ever so patronising to sit down a group and say ‘okay, now you must not refer to yourself as x! We wouldn’t want to offend your group.’

If someone is using the word about themselves they’re hardly going to offend themselves.

Crazykatie · 03/04/2022 09:20

The recent trend in development aid is for the work to be done by local staff so many less expat workers are being allowed, that is also the trend with church organizations. Developing countries have plenty of educated people capable, in fact the main restriction is the inability of the governments to pay salaries to those local staff, or deliver the materials needed to achieve the intended benefits.

One example recently is the government of one small African nation needed more food produced so fertilizer was obtained but delivery to villages was not arranged, when it did happen it was too late tohelp much.

I really do not expect much change in developing countries the political will is not there, they will accept whatever aid or investment is offered but a large part ends up with the elite not the population.