Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think it should be financially rewarding not to fly

105 replies

blameitonthecaffeine · 31/03/2022 17:28

I know there's probably no way round it but it annoys me that not flying is so much more expensive than flying.

After 2 years of not going abroad, I felt too guilty about the environmental impact to jet off again this summer so we've booked a holiday in Greece and are going there via trains and ferries.

Per adult, (children cheaper obviously) it has cost me around £350 for the train tickets and £140 for the ferry. So total £490.

I had a look at flights and a cheaper end (but direct) flight, with add ons of hold luggage and booking the seats would have been about £175 per person.

I'm very fortunate that I can afford this choice but really, it's hardly surprising that flying is so popular is it?!

Is there a way of making other transport options cheaper do you think or is it just the way it has to be?

I'm not even sure trains are that much better than planes after all this faff, time and money! It's 48 hours of travelling instead of around 4 for a start! Although we can see interesting places on the way (and build up more costs with additional nights accommodation!)

OP posts:
nonevernotever · 01/04/2022 07:32

I feel your pain having just spent £660 on two return train tickets (with a disabled Railcard that gets you a hefty discount) to travel from Edinburgh to Cornwall . Flights worked out as much the same price.

RachelAshleyWasGuilty · 01/04/2022 00:57

You've sent me down a rabbit hole, and got me all excited!

I used the 3 day interail pass many times in my youth, to get around France....I was delighted when I've just checked, it would be only £236 for the 5 of us to go all the way to Nice, maybe a day in Paris, maybe a side jaunt somewhere for a few days....

However, the cost of getting us all to France from Liverpool is at least twice that! Eurostar is only from St Pancreas, and it doesn't appear you can add in the domestic option any longer.

Any tips on getting to Paris cheaply?

Many years ago I used to get the overnight coach to London, and there was a really cheap train ferry combo, which unfortunately doesn't seem to exist anymore!

The alternative seems to be driving and catching the Dover/Calais ferry the parking up! HmmWhich I really wanted to avoid.

Any pearls of wisdom?

crackofdoom · 31/03/2022 23:14

(I wonder if the old Venice- Athens train, via Zagreb, Belgrade and Skopje still runs? Did that in 1990, before the war. Definitely one for the memoirs 😆).

crackofdoom · 31/03/2022 23:10

I get the impression that trains are better in Montenegro...I was reading the Balkan section of Seat 61 the other day. Does it have to be Bosnia?

(Digressing even further from the original topic, there's a new walking trail called Peaks of the Balkans that spans Albania, Kosovan and Montenegro. Two out of those three countries didn't even exist when I was growing up!)

DdraigGoch · 31/03/2022 22:36

I'm refusing to be defeated though. I might manage it by adding extra time at the start of the trip, so I'll get in touch with a colleague to see if I can swap rest days. She owes me a favour.

DdraigGoch · 31/03/2022 22:25

@crackofdoom

Is it Bosnia where you wanted to go- that did have a good train service but it's all gone? I remember rural Croatia being pretty impossible too. Shame they didn't keep the Communist era railways up.
Yes, as recently as 2014 they had a full timetable covering most of the country but in 2018 fell out with the Croatian Railways so trains stop short of each side of the border. That's only a 20 mile gap so bridgable by taxi. On top of that though, covid seems to have done away with most of what remained. Shame, they'd just got new airconditioned coaches for the cross-border journeys. Now there are just a handful of trains out of either Sarajevo or Banja Luka, with none connecting the two.

Getting to Croatia would be easy though, Zagreb has a sleeper from Zurich, and Split has a sleeper from Vienna. The Nightjet sleeper network (operated by the Austrian railways) is booming, with connections across Europe.

blameitonthecaffeine · 31/03/2022 21:53

Drag0nFru2t no, not P and O, it's a local Greek ferry from a town in the South of Italy to a town near Athens.

I take the point about it being better for the environment not to travel far at all but I was seeing Greece as a nearby option tbh. I only realise now, seeing the replies, how dense and privileged that sounds. I've seen more than my fair share of the world as has my husband so maybe it is time to stop. The children can make their own decisions when they are independent.

Travel is the one thing I have never regretted spending a penny on though and one of my biggest passions so it is sad. And, if time permits and long, crazy train and bus trips are better than flights to Mallorca, Paris or other nearby places, maybe it is still possible to travel and be environmentally aware. Just every few years instead of every year maybe. Or maybe not, I don't know.

OP posts:
RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 31/03/2022 21:22

Any bit of research shows air travel is worse for the environment. Part of the reason is that the emissions are released in the sky rather than on the ground.

If we care about the well being and future safety and survival of our children and their children we should all be doing what the OP is doing or forego holidays abroad.

ukborn · 31/03/2022 21:10

@Mybestyear try going to the Isle of Wight! I think it's the most expensive per mile ferry trip in the world.

Drag0nFru2t · 31/03/2022 21:02

I used to stay in a B&B which was 5 mins walk from the train station
It offered a discount for everyone arriving by train

Drag0nFru2t · 31/03/2022 21:00

If you have all the time in the world, it is easy to travel via train, ferry, coach

However, travelling long haul it is not so easy when you take into account time.

I assume that you are not going via P&O ferries?

lanthanum · 31/03/2022 21:00

A friend trying to get from East Anglia to Cornwall discovered that it was cheaper and quicker to fly via Spain than to take the train.

Myee · 31/03/2022 20:55

@crackofdoom

Thanks for the information.

Echobelly · 31/03/2022 20:23

I think we need to do more to motivate not flying - I reckon it would be useful for workplaces to have schemes whereby you get 2-4 extra days' holiday in return for travelling by train or boat (so you'd have to show proof of booking and then get the extra days). Because as well as the price there is the extra time that it may take that can be offputting, especially when holiday allowance is tight.

crackofdoom · 31/03/2022 20:19

Is it Bosnia where you wanted to go- that did have a good train service but it's all gone? I remember rural Croatia being pretty impossible too. Shame they didn't keep the Communist era railways up.

DdraigGoch · 31/03/2022 20:13

(as well as an impressively experienced train traveller!)

I've barely started (batflu interrupted things).

I'm getting very frustrated therefore that train travel to Bosnia is currently impossible. I hate being defeated.

Anywhere else in Europe though, train travel is the way to do it. It takes a little longer, sure, but you really experience the countries you pass through properly.

DdraigGoch · 31/03/2022 20:08

@NdefH81

Thing is travelling alone - sure just grab whatever But if you travel with a partner, friend, family, children…. On a 4 day travelling.. eating together and enjoying it and sharing food is part of the experience
I'm not sure that having a sit-down lunch in La Consigne in Gare de l'est is "just grab whatever". It wasn't expensive. I'm sure that most stations have family-friendly cafés within a short walk.
DdraigGoch · 31/03/2022 20:01

@3luckystars

Ships are very bad for the environment too. Cruises are far worse than planes. (I know you are not going on a cruise)
Cruise ships are bad, yes because they are a floating version of Butlins. If you did travel by cargo ship on the other hand, economies of scale reduce your emissions to naff all. Remember that a massive container ship is by far the most efficient way to transport goods, even compared with rail.

Being a foot passenger on a ferry isn't too bad either. Like with the cargo ship, your impact is minimal compared with the contents of the vehicle deck.

crackofdoom · 31/03/2022 19:55

You're a stronger and more patient person than I DdraigGoch, is all I can say 🤦‍♀️
(as well as an impressively experienced train traveller!)

Nde how do you know I have children? I don't think I mentioned it on this thread? 🤔

No, we will not always travel by train. This summer we will probably go camping in France, in my 1.5l engine van. Then next year we might all go Interrailing.

They, too, need to eat every day, so I'm still not getting your point about food. Do you think food everywhere is as expensive as it is in airports? 😆 You know major train stations mostly have little supermarkets in, where you can buy inexpensive food- and drink!! that you can then take on the train, right??

DdraigGoch · 31/03/2022 19:53

@Gowithme

Flight 368kg (per passenger) Efficient car 237kg (total) Large SUV 1,020kg (total) Train 64kg (per passenger)

Doesn't this suggest 4 people in an efficient car is better than them going on a train??

Trains are heavier because of how stringent the crash worthiness rules are. They also travel at higher speeds which reduces efficiency. So if you drive a Ford Mondeo as carefully as you can, with four passengers it will be marginally better per head.

That's for London-Glasgow though. Train travel in France for example uses electricity from a mostly-nuclear grid, unlike in the UK which depends heavily on gas turbines. Then there's the fact that most car journeys don't have a full car which gives the train the edge.

Simonjt · 31/03/2022 19:51

We’re going to Disney Paris in June, we decided to get the train was we thought it would be easier with the baby.

The eurostar is £482 return, flights and transport between home and the airport and our hotel and the airport is £232 all in.

We’re off to Sweden over easter two adults, one six year old and a baby (with seat) is £134 return. We can’t even get to manchester on the train that cheaply.

DdraigGoch · 31/03/2022 19:46

@crackofdoom

Oh well done DdraigGoch, for actually looking the figures up. I couldn't be arsed to, only to have more posters pop up downthread faux- innocently saying they've never seen any figures, but that they're sure flying isn't that much worse than driving or taking the train 🙄
The five minutes spent looking for my copy of "How Bad Are Bananas?" was well spent then.

(It was on the windowsill, where it must have been left after my last Mumsnet climate debate)

NdefH81 · 31/03/2022 19:41

You do have children though @crackofdoom

Are you always planning to travel by train with your children abroad?

DdraigGoch · 31/03/2022 19:41

@Bananabutter

Nothing wrong with flying. It’s quicker, easier, cheaper and a far better experience than any other mode of travel.
@Bananabutter "A far better experience"? I take it that you're wealthy enough that you've never had to suffer Ryanair?

Some low-cost airlines are now charging for bags carried in the overhead lockers, never mind the extortionate rates for hold luggage. By contrast on the train I am allowed to take two suitcases (as heavy as I can lift) plus an item of hand luggage at no extra charge.

Getting up at 3am to catch an early flight (because that's when the cheap ones can afford slots) is not my idea of fun. My last train journey to Europe on the other hand included salmon au penne in a brasserie in Paris Gare de l'est for a sit-down lunch. Very civilised.

NdefH81 · 31/03/2022 19:39

Thing is travelling alone - sure just grab whatever
But if you travel with a partner, friend, family, children…. On a 4 day travelling.. eating together and enjoying it and sharing food is part of the experience