Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think elite sport isn't inclusive

117 replies

Dinosauria · 31/03/2022 15:33

And the main reason is financial.

Lots in the news about how people should/shouldn't be included in sport and the loudest voice is that sport must be inclusive.

But it isn't, elite sport cost a lot of money, amateur sport costs a lot of money, there must be a significantly greater number of people that are excluded from sport than those that are excluded based on their biological sex.

Where is the fury when it comes to children not being able to afford to participate?

Even football/rugby grassroots is run by volunteers but still around £80-100 a year and then boots/kit etc and then match fees, fuel to and from matches etc.
Swimming, £100 per month for county level plus race fees and fuel to travel
Cycling, triathlon all have large fees and kit requirements, whilst of course it is possible to manage on a shoe string when you compete for fun as soon as it becomes more serious it becomes expensive.

Travel, hotels all become a necessity when you start competing at a higher level.

Top Olympians in the UK are four times as likely to be privately educated than the population as a whole.

Sporting bodies should be looking into this rather than denying biology.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 31/03/2022 17:22

Perhaps someone could identify as being rich as Croesus and see if that helps.

Happy to 😆

ResisterRex · 31/03/2022 17:21

I agree with CapMarvel and the OP. There's not really much of a way round it though is there? To be good - elite - takes a lot of time. That means ferrying kids all over, or waiting around while they go to clubs etc. Even that costs in terms of not working or limiting work options.

TheKeatingFive · 31/03/2022 17:21

This is why I don't see an issue for transwomen competing in female categories, all it will do is raise the standard in the female game

By pushing them all out. Super 🙄

DrSbaitso · 31/03/2022 17:19

Perhaps someone could identify as being rich as Croesus and see if that helps.

Futuroute · 31/03/2022 17:17

Elite level sport is often more a competition as to how much money, free time and opportunities a person has.

Yes - and you might say this about many pursuits/careers that are desirable and highly competitive to get into - e.g. journalism, acting. They are out of the reach of the majority who have to spend most of their time doing a 'day job' and/or have no connections. Obviously there are exceptions based on luck or exceptional talent, but generally speaking, the wealthier you are, the more opportunities are open to you - in any field.

ChateauMargaux · 31/03/2022 17:16

@nicholethejewellery... really??? So you think female sport is not worthwhile and it would be better if it was only men.. go back to the 1950's and allow us to fight for our daughters so that they can have equal access to sport.

ChateauMargaux · 31/03/2022 17:14

@Dinosauria Don't get distracted by this. By all means campaign for greater access to sport for all. But the issue at hand is the erasure of female sport. We have spent the last 100 years fighting to get equal representation at the Olympics for women and we are still not there. Top male footballers receive salaries that equate to 1,627 of the world's greatest female players. Women and girls fight to have access to pitch time, coaches, kit behind hundreds of men and boys. If we have to share these already diluted resources with male bodied sports people, elite or otherwise, fewer women and girls will play sport. Why would anyone want that???

DrSbaitso · 31/03/2022 17:11

The reason why top-level male sport has traditionally been more lucrative than top-level female sport is because it's generally been the case that the male variant is at a higher level than the female one. This is why I don't see an issue for transwomen competing in female categories, all it will do is raise the standard in the female game.

Yes, to the point where no females can reach it.

donquixotedelamancha · 31/03/2022 17:07

This is why I don't see an issue for transwomen competing in female categories, all it will do is raise the standard in the female game. There will become a point when the division between male and female is no longer necessary, which is surely a good thing.

Absolutely. In cycling, for example, women just need to adjust their pelvis shape, produce more red blood cells and increase their proportion of muscle mass and the type of muscle cells so they can compete effectively with transwomen.

Those women complaining this isn't fair just need to try harder.

MidCenturyClegs · 31/03/2022 17:04

I agree that sports shouldn't be exclusive based on economic grounds.

However, sports itself at a competitive level (anything extra-curricular to schools) is exclusive, it is the nature of the sports. You are in it to yes, have fun, but to win.

Female sports have been set aside as a sex-based division in order to be inclusive to women and girls. If you let males play in the female division you will very soon end up with Male and Open categories.

If anyone wants to ignore biology, then it should be the Male categories. Female and Open would work well for everybody.

Brainwave89 · 31/03/2022 17:03

I would regard myself as quite sporty (I cycle, run and row). For all of these sports there is a real effort at inclusion IME. It does absolutely help if you can afford all the best kit, but locally we have had some good successions at outreach and I run a local girls and women's cycle class. It is totally different to the question of transgender athletes. I am keen for everyone to be involved in sport, but I was most concerned to see that we came close to allowing an elite cyclist competing as a man to compete as a woman within just over 12 months of male competition. This simply is not fair and does IMV have implications for the participation of women at grass roots level.

334bu · 31/03/2022 16:54

That said, I think we have totally gone the wrong direction in terms of funding sports in this country. We've completely gone down the route of funding the sports which we do best at, which creates a completely circular loop of pumping more and more money into fewer and fewer sports in a pointless chase for medals and trophys.

Might also be the reason why sports like British Cycling are so ready to throw their female members under the bus by including a male elite cyclist who identifies as as women in women's cycling competitions.

Ablababla · 31/03/2022 16:54

•This is why I don't see an issue for transwomen competing in female categories, all it will do is raise the standard in the female game. There will become a point when the division between male and female is no longer necessary, which is surely a good thing.*

I guess this is logical response if you genuinely believe ‘trans woman are women’ in every respect and that therefore biology isn’t why sport is segregated by male/female?

CapMarvel · 31/03/2022 16:41

Elite sport is not inclusive and will never be inclusive. It simply takes too much time and money to get someone up to the elite level for it to be any different. You can be the single most talented sportsperson on the planet but if you don't have the time and money to dedicate to training and competing it doesn't mean a thing.

That said, I think we have totally gone the wrong direction in terms of funding sports in this country. We've completely gone down the route of funding the sports which we do best at, which creates a completely circular loop of pumping more and more money into fewer and fewer sports in a pointless chase for medals and trophys.

The money should be going where it's actually needed and does the most good - at the grass roots level to encourage people to get into sports and keeping fit regardless of whether they will ever win wimbledon or not.

TheOrigRights · 31/03/2022 16:35

[quote monsterpup]@TheOrigRights yep! I personally spent close to £200 overall on membership fees this year alone [/quote]
As a university student?

I think that's a lot, and I'm a professional with a good income.

Jesus.

monsterpup · 31/03/2022 16:33

@TheOrigRights yep! I personally spent close to £200 overall on membership fees this year alone

BogRollBOGOF · 31/03/2022 16:33

I was never going to be elite in any sport. Not flexible enough for gymnastics and too small in other sports.
What I can have is a decent age grading. I can be average or better than average for a SW40-45 at parkrun/ running races. I could potentually aim for GFA qualification into events like the London Marathon. A transwoman with their physical advantages of height, muscle, hormones and pelvis that hasn't had to try passing two human heads through it is at a major advantage and their participation corrupts the statistics that I can use to measure myself against my peers.

Women have fought hard to even be able to participate in sport. Katherine Switzer entered the Boston Marathon as K Switzer in 1967. Women were not allowed to participate in marathons in case of damage to their reproductive organs Confused When a marshal realised that a woman had the audacity to participate, she was manhandled. She broke free and completed the race and was influential in women finally being allowed to professionally compete in marathons. The first women's olympic marathon was in 1984- less than 40 years ago!

Women's sport is still a long way behind mens in profile, recognition, funding and glory. There's been some recent progress but it's not something that can be taken for granted.

In amateur sport, girls need to see women participate and excel to encourage their participation. Without amateurs, you can't identify and train the elites. Single sex spaces can be important for safety and nurture (this also applies to male minority sport-my sons rapidly lost interest in gymnastics when they became the final boy in the local class)

If girls look at sports podia and see that the winners were never on an even footing with the other competitors that were born female, that dampens desire to particpate and compete. We already have campaigns like This Girl Can to empower girls and women to be active and overcome difficulties and inhibitions. Allowing people born with male physical advantage to participate as female undermines women's sport from the elites right through to grassroots, amateur level.

Sport is eliteist to some degree varying with the sport, but ignoring the biological differences of transwomen and women damages all levels of women's sport.

Note how there has not yet been any issues of transmen in professional male sport... there are few sports where they would be put at a major advantage.

TheOrigRights · 31/03/2022 16:32

By definition elite cannot be inclusive. Maybe you mean the road to being elite is not inclusive, and that I agree with.
I might have hidden elite skiing skills that my parents were unable to unleash. My son might have the skills to be an F1 driver. We'll never know.

For many sports though, someone with the skill WILL rise to the top - be spotted at school, or by a local amateur club.

Sporting bodies should be looking into this AND transgender issue, the two are not mutually exclusive.

TheOrigRights · 31/03/2022 16:26

@monsterpup

And you're 100% right OP, wealth is the biggest barrier to amateur sport and without amateur sport you will never know if you are capable of stepping up to elite sport.

My university requires you to buy a >£100 gym membership in one payment to join any of their sports clubs, whether you use the gym facilities or not. That's just not affordable for so many students and suddenly you're excluded from sports at university!

Wow, that's shocking! Is this on top of other fees a particular sport might have?
BoredZelda · 31/03/2022 16:26

Not sure why any of the trans stuff is being raised in this context, as all it will do is derail.

Doing anything at competitive level is expensive, whether it is dance, gymnastics, team sports. Heck, I was in a pipe band and it cost a fortune.

This is why organisations are consistently fund raising and why there is lottery funding available. I’m not sure what you think the alternative solution is, things need to be paid for. Most organisations will subsidise young people who are struggling. Who else do you think should pay for it?

monsterpup · 31/03/2022 16:21

And you're 100% right OP, wealth is the biggest barrier to amateur sport and without amateur sport you will never know if you are capable of stepping up to elite sport.

My university requires you to buy a >£100 gym membership in one payment to join any of their sports clubs, whether you use the gym facilities or not. That's just not affordable for so many students and suddenly you're excluded from sports at university!

monsterpup · 31/03/2022 16:13

@Nicholethejewellery There will become a point when the division between male and female is no longer necessary, which is surely a good thing.

I would genuinely love to hear your explanation for this.

ResisterRex · 31/03/2022 16:13

This is why I don't see an issue for transwomen competing in female categories, all it will do is raise the standard in the female game. There will become a point when the division between male and female is no longer necessary, which is surely a good thing.

Hmm

This approach will result in Male Team A and Male Team B. Yay equality!!! I don't think so.

We've worked very hard here and pumped a lot of money, thought, and time into improving our medals performances for the men's and the women's.

Obviously sports are exclusive. Otherwise we could all say "well I want a go" and people would have to watch random members of the public doing races, or a heavyweight boxer "being included" in a super middleweight match.

PS no one can consent on behalf of others eg to give away sex-based rights.

Goldrill · 31/03/2022 16:06

I generally agree, but on the point about Olympians and private education; i think there are plenty of private schools offering big bursaries to kids with sporting talent. So increasing accessibility rather than being rich kids to start with.

334bu · 31/03/2022 16:04

There will become a point when the division between male and female is no longer necessary, which is surely a good thing.

You mean there will be no difference because there will only be male competitors and how would that be a good thing for women?

Swipe left for the next trending thread