Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think elite sport isn't inclusive

117 replies

Dinosauria · 31/03/2022 15:33

And the main reason is financial.

Lots in the news about how people should/shouldn't be included in sport and the loudest voice is that sport must be inclusive.

But it isn't, elite sport cost a lot of money, amateur sport costs a lot of money, there must be a significantly greater number of people that are excluded from sport than those that are excluded based on their biological sex.

Where is the fury when it comes to children not being able to afford to participate?

Even football/rugby grassroots is run by volunteers but still around £80-100 a year and then boots/kit etc and then match fees, fuel to and from matches etc.
Swimming, £100 per month for county level plus race fees and fuel to travel
Cycling, triathlon all have large fees and kit requirements, whilst of course it is possible to manage on a shoe string when you compete for fun as soon as it becomes more serious it becomes expensive.

Travel, hotels all become a necessity when you start competing at a higher level.

Top Olympians in the UK are four times as likely to be privately educated than the population as a whole.

Sporting bodies should be looking into this rather than denying biology.

OP posts:
Simonjt · 31/03/2022 19:33

It depends on the sport, in some sports (rugby for example), if you have the talent then the path to becoming elite isn’t expensive. You’re looking at around £80-120 a year, if you can’t afford it kit etc is provided.

When I think about the other lads who were in the academy with me no one was wealthy, no one was really even middle class.

As someone who grew up in poverty and had to be financially independent from 17, my lack of money never held me back in rugby. In fact my earnings and the flexibility of rugby are the only reason I could attend university.

monsterpup · 31/03/2022 19:32

@NeverDropYourMooncup my point is that most gyms, while more expensive over a year, don't require you to pay hundreds of pounds upfront and most club sports don't make you pay for a gym you won't use before you get the honour to pay for their club

Fizbosshoes · 31/03/2022 19:18

Lots of things, at the very top level, are elitist, by being prohibitively expensive for a certain percentage of people, regardless of their ability (private education, university, any extra curricular activities like dance, drama or music, being an MP )
I'm not saying that makes it OK but it's not just sport that is like that.
But I also don't think the fact it's financially elitist should mean transwomen should be allowed to compete with biological women (I would say trans people but a trans man would be at a disadvantage against biological men so I can't imagine many of them are in elite competitions)

NeverDropYourMooncup · 31/03/2022 19:16

@monsterpup

And you're 100% right OP, wealth is the biggest barrier to amateur sport and without amateur sport you will never know if you are capable of stepping up to elite sport.

My university requires you to buy a >£100 gym membership in one payment to join any of their sports clubs, whether you use the gym facilities or not. That's just not affordable for so many students and suddenly you're excluded from sports at university!

You want to see the cost of an entire year for somebody who isn't a student.
CapMarvel · 31/03/2022 19:13

But it's the same for almost literally everything.

If you want to be good at music you need the money for an instrument and lessons and to drive up and down the country for recitals.

If you want to be good at art you need money for materials.

Etc. Yeah, it's not necessarily fair but what can be done about it, realistically?

Dinosauria · 31/03/2022 19:11

No that's not what I'm saying at all. I'm saying only those with financially stable backgrounds become elite, not the top performers, Hornetfarmer (although why the fuck you'd want to farm Hornets) has a more succinct reply.

Shopbought you actually prove my point. Many children do not get the chance to learn to swim as it is expensive. Those that get scouted for scholarships are club swimmers. The local club takes on children from 2, by 7 they are competing and swimming a lot. Whilst these may not be very wealthy backgrounds they are still financially stable to be able to commit to swimming in the first place

OP posts:
CapMarvel · 31/03/2022 19:08

@Hornetfarmer

Those saying Elite sport is only for the best of the best and that is why it is not inclusive are wrong. Elite sportspeople are not the best of the best. They are the best of the ones who can afford it.
Totally this.

But short of massively increasing funding of sport at all levels, what can be done about it?

Shopboughtmeatballs · 31/03/2022 18:35

No, it isn't, that's what elite means. Also, the schools thing isn't a great indicator in this instance OP, as (some) private schools offer extraordinary scholarships and facilities for kids competing at the top end. My DD was briefly at a school in the South West which had 2 olympians in the queue for lunch at the canteen.. The swim team boarded, were in the pool at 5 a.m and were allowed to sleep through lessons. None of them came from wealthy backgrounds and all were on huge scholarships. They were basically recruited at a VERY junior age as part of the schools branding.

lifelast · 31/03/2022 18:28

Of course elite sport is not inclusive - it wouldn't be called elite support if it were. The clue is somewhat in the title.

The olympics, aren't meant to be inclusive. They are some of the most exclusive events in the world. Only the best in the world get to enter.

I think what you mean is accessible. Sports should strive to be accessible to those who want to partake. But elite sports are not inclusive - only the top performers get to participate.

Hornetfarmer · 31/03/2022 18:24

Those saying Elite sport is only for the best of the best and that is why it is not inclusive are wrong.
Elite sportspeople are not the best of the best. They are the best of the ones who can afford it.

Dinosauria · 31/03/2022 18:24

[quote inventinglouise]@Nicholethejewellery - ah, you're one of the "women don't try hard enough" brigade, or as I prefer to call them, "morons".[/quote]
Grin

OP posts:
Dinosauria · 31/03/2022 18:24

@DogsAndGin

It’s a competition OP. The very opposite of ‘inclusive’. Hmm
That I know, but inclusivity is the buzz word.

I do know these are different points, but I know talented children who are not able to compete due to their parents financial situation (even ones that have got scholarships but very few of these cover every extra cost)

Monty I don't understand your post, any of it but especially this

Because the most genetically gifted sports women on earth will be beaten pretty effortlessly by fairly mediocre men (in elite sport terms).

OP posts:
inventinglouise · 31/03/2022 18:21

@Nicholethejewellery - ah, you're one of the "women don't try hard enough" brigade, or as I prefer to call them, "morons".

NurseBernard · 31/03/2022 18:17

There will become a point when the division between male and female is no longer necessary, which is surely a good thing.

I think a few of us are not understanding why this would be a good thing.

Can you please explain @Nicholethejewellery?

ClafoutisSurprise · 31/03/2022 18:15

There will become a point when the division between male and female is no longer necessary, which is surely a good thing.

Because they’re actually all males? Great idea! Just think of all the things we can level up for ‘women’ by simply reclassifying male people. Pay gap, sex-based violence, visibility... Just jettison the inferior female women in favour of the male women who out-class them on all these fronts and we can achieve equality for women at a stroke!

DogsAndGin · 31/03/2022 18:14

It’s a competition OP. The very opposite of ‘inclusive’. Hmm

Gerriden · 31/03/2022 18:09

YANBU.

Like a PP states it's called Elite Sport sometimes because it is only the financially elite can fund it. There will be many that miss out because they cannot afford to fund it.

For those that are unaware, even novice Equestrian sport is not a level playing field. It is not just based on the horse, the skill of the rider is about part of the success but there will many incredibly talented riders out there that will never, ever get the opportunity to shine because they or their parents can't afford the top class horses and facilities that other parents can.

That's life but I'll never be fooled by the "They're at the top purely because of talent and hard work", particularly in Equestrian sport.

montysma1 · 31/03/2022 18:01

Utterly ludicrous point.
Of course top sorts people are genetically gifted.
The same as top musicians, top, top scientists and top everything else.

That is not at all the same as biological men being "discriminated" against by not being allowed to compete against women.

Because the most genetically gifted sports women on earth will be beaten pretty effortlessly by fairly mediocre men (in elite sport terms).

Dinosauria · 31/03/2022 17:58

@donquixotedelamancha

This is why I don't see an issue for transwomen competing in female categories, all it will do is raise the standard in the female game. There will become a point when the division between male and female is no longer necessary, which is surely a good thing.

Absolutely. In cycling, for example, women just need to adjust their pelvis shape, produce more red blood cells and increase their proportion of muscle mass and the type of muscle cells so they can compete effectively with transwomen.

Those women complaining this isn't fair just need to try harder.

Agree, the lazy sods just haven't been trying.
OP posts:
Dinosauria · 31/03/2022 17:55

@ResisterRex

This is why I don't see an issue for transwomen competing in female categories, all it will do is raise the standard in the female game. There will become a point when the division between male and female is no longer necessary, which is surely a good thing. Hmm

This approach will result in Male Team A and Male Team B. Yay equality!!! I don't think so.

We've worked very hard here and pumped a lot of money, thought, and time into improving our medals performances for the men's and the women's.

Obviously sports are exclusive. Otherwise we could all say "well I want a go" and people would have to watch random members of the public doing races, or a heavyweight boxer "being included" in a super middleweight match.

PS no one can consent on behalf of others eg to give away sex-based rights.

Thanks to you and pp, I also have no words to reply, I hope it was a joke.

BoredZelda because it is linked, I've been reading about the need to be inclusive yet I've first hand experience of very talented youngster having to give up their sport because their parents can no longer afford it (or more usually not be able to afford the step up to county/ regional) so its already not inclusive.

monsterpup that is awful, not surprising, but awful.

OP posts:
FrippEnos · 31/03/2022 17:42

This is why I don't see an issue for transwomen competing in female categories,

Yet in most cases the "elite" transwomen were only ever mediocre men.

Bridges seems to be an anomaly in that they are still competing at the top level of male sports. How you can't see that this person shouldn't be competing with women is beyond me.
Thomas was ranked 472 in the male rankings yet is number 1 in the female rankings.
Hubbard wasn't even very good as a male yet still qualified as an over aged unfit transwoman.

underneaththeash · 31/03/2022 17:32

@TheKeatingFive

This is why I don't see an issue for transwomen competing in female categories, all it will do is raise the standard in the female game

By pushing them all out. Super 🙄

Exactly.
TheKeatingFive · 31/03/2022 17:32

Whatever one feels about gender, we have to stop pretending that it's possible to change sex or that ones sex is somehow immaterial.

DrSbaitso · 31/03/2022 17:30

I've seen this loony "allow transwomen to compete in women's events because that'll make women better" argument a few times now. Is it the latest absurdity now they finally seem to have realised that humans aren't clownfish, or is it a troll? It's impossible to say who's taking the piss these days.

Franklin12 · 31/03/2022 17:23

I am heartily sick of all of this. Trans rights dont trump all other rights.

Have a seperate section for trans but dont degrade sport like this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread