Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About snacks?

34 replies

SummerDays2020 · 31/03/2022 15:22

I always hear this idea that people nowadays can't go long without eating/eat too many snacks.

I find that a bit strange because growing up my mum always made 'elevenses' in the morning and 'tea' (as in sandwiches, cakes etc) in the afternoon alongside 3 meals a day. My grandparents had supper too.

None of us were/are overweight. I don't have snacks in the day, myself everyday but I do sometimes if I'm hungry in the afternoon.

In my opinion it is the quality of food that is important (it was all fresh home made food) and maybe the portion size too.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 04/04/2022 21:12

I grew up in the nineties and we definitely had snacks.

During the school day we had a tuck-shop open at morning break and most people bought something - crisps, sweets, chocolate. They sold fruit but I think it was there for decorative purposes Grin

I also went to holiday clubs and we had squash and biscuits around 10am and again around 3-4pm.

After school club ran until six and we were always given toast/biscuits to tide us over until we got home and had a proper meal.

I also have vivid memories of days out in the Lake District that were filled with soggy sandwiches, kendal mint cake, opal fruits and the odd pack of Sunmaid raisins!

My parents were big on healthy eating - wholemeal bread, fruit in lunchboxes, no sweets or crisps, but I still had regular snacks at school and at home on weekends.

EssexLioness · 04/04/2022 20:56

Should’ve said, we were really poor so we couldn’t afford anything (although my dad always bought tons of biscuits that only he was allowed). Meals weren’t large either and I remember being hungry a lot

EssexLioness · 04/04/2022 20:54

I am 44 and never had dessert or snacks, apart from Saturdays when I was allowed 10p for pick n mix

SummerDays2020 · 04/04/2022 20:52

@PinkSyCo

I’m 51 and don’t remember ever eating snacks at home. Always had a (usually hot) pudding after dinner though. My kids weren’t snackers either.
We always had pudding after dinner too. My DC usually have some fruit and/or yogurt if they want. But they probably only have it a few days a week. I make homemade desserts occasionally so they are a treat to my DC while they were the norm for me everyday.
OP posts:
SummerDays2020 · 04/04/2022 20:48

@incognitoforthisone

Weirdly, I was discussing this exact thing with my parents, who are both c.80 years old, at the weekend.

They both said that their families (working class Londoners) definitely considered it normal to have a mid-morning snack and a mid-afternoon one when they were younger. So when my nan was a housewife she stopped for a cuppa and maybe a couple of biscuits or an apple mid-morning, and then she'd have a slice of bread and jam or a rock cake or something with her children when they got in from school. My parents both say they used to be able to buy a bun or something during their morning break at school. And if you worked in an office or a factory, there'd usually be a tea lady who came round morning and afternoon with a tea urn and some basic snack items.

However, what both my parents say they never really did was a) snack while watching television or listening to the radio, b) buy a chocolate bar and eat it while walking down the street, c) have a stock of snacks just sitting there to be eaten at any time or d) snack on train/car/bus journeys. Also they basically just grew up drinking tea all the time instead of fruit juice, sugary drinks etc - things like lemonade or orange squash were a treat, not a daily thing. My mum also says that it baffles her that parents today carry snacks in their bags for babies and toddlers. She says that if you were out with a toddler all day, you'd take a packed lunch for it, but you wouldn't be delving into your bag for things for them to nibble on while you were out doing the shopping with them, apparently.

You've brought back memories for me mentioning rock cakes! My mum used to make them. We never had shop bought cakes beyond perhaps an iced bun from the bakery.

I had a job when young working in the civil service - this was late 90s - we used to have a tea trolley come round in the morning and afternoon - it was great! Grin

I agree with your points. We would sit at the kitchen table for our snacks. It was a sociable time. We didn't watch TV or anything. And yes to tea. Although we had a glass of squash usually after school with our tea when younger. My dad was quite surprised I encountered my young children to drink water rather than tea. When we had fruit juice sometimes at breakfast time it was in a very small glass. I must admit if my DC have a glass of juice it is much bigger. We only ever had fizzy drinks at a birthday party. My teen drinks far too many fizzy drinks!

OP posts:
SummerDays2020 · 04/04/2022 20:23

@Gonnagetgoing

I can't recall snacks as such at school, we just had breakfast, lunch, then dinner. I think we had something when we got home from school at about 3.30pm and then dinner wasn't until 7 or 8. So we'd have something like cake/biscuits etc. As a teenager probably similar but we'd get things like crisps, chocolate bar at breaks and also after school.

During holidays and at weekends we had sometimes biscuits or cake at 11 (elevenses) but not always. We also had something usually in the afternoon or before dinner but not always. Fruit/biscuits etc. If we saw a relative it'd be cake/snack etc.

We played out a lot and often didn't bother about snacks but that's not to say we didn't have any. I recall e.g. going to a big park that had an adventure playground, we had a picnic lunch, were allowed one or two ice creams and if we came out of the playground I'm sure we could eat whatever was left over (if anything) from the picnic. Thing is - though there were water fountains I don't recall us drinking more or eating more. We could quite easily go to e.g. a seaside town like Hastings and after having lunch could spend all afternoon playing and we had money for e.g. hot donuts or chocolate but i honestly don't recall buying loads! I mean we bought sweets from an old fashioned sweet shop but not to gorge on them!

I remember when I was quite small probably infant school age, my dad would take us to the sweet shop at the weekend. We would get a small amount of penny sweets and then we were allowed one each evening after dinner. I have to say when my DC get sweets they often come in very large packets and they might eat quite a lot in one go. They don't get sweets every week, though. It is a now and again thing.
OP posts:
SummerDays2020 · 04/04/2022 20:18

@Chely

The bad thing with grazing is you build insulin resistance increasing your risk of diabetes. The human body is great at fasting and feasting.
I completely agree with this. Our bodies need time to not be digesting and to repair. I think we had that as we never ate evening snacks.
OP posts:
Aroundtheworldin80moves · 31/03/2022 18:10

Something like a kit kat and a juice carton at midmorning break at Primary school was definitely normal in the 90s. I'm too young/old for school milk though (my brother got it though, two years older than me)

And a cup of tea and a little bun after school. (Homemade, a 3egg recipe made 20 and thin smear of water icing).

dipdye · 31/03/2022 18:04

It was Hobbit-levels of meal frequency

^
Grin
Anyone else hearing 'second breakfast' in Broad Scots

Grin
PinkSyCo · 31/03/2022 18:04

I’m 51 and don’t remember ever eating snacks at home. Always had a (usually hot) pudding after dinner though. My kids weren’t snackers either.

withiceplease · 31/03/2022 17:55

As a young child into teenager years, I cannot believe how much I ate.
Breakfast was 2 rounds of toast with beans or eggs at 7am. Crackers with cheese and apple at 11am. Lunch 1230 at school with pudding. Then got home from school and had 2 boiled eggs with bread and butter or bananas and custard. Evening meal about 6 with pudding then at 930pm all the family had cocoa and (supper) shredded wheat or weetabix with hot milk and sugar.
I was called 'sparrow legs' and definitely not overweight.
Changed somewhat with senior school but still 3 meals with 3 snacks and did sport 6-7 days a week

Sweets/chocolate once a week on Sunday

All food from scratch apart from the crackers

707smile · 31/03/2022 17:28

Yes, I agree. I grew up in the 90s and we definitely had small snacks (e.g. a piece of fruit, a biscuit) at 3pm and sometimes at 11am.

I don't think there's a problem with snacking as long as it's relatively healthy snacking, in fact 'hanger' is a real thing (apparently being hungry can raise your blood pressure) and I've noticed that for my nephews (I don't have kids yet) who I look after regularly, that they get a real dip in mood when they're hungry at 3ish and can behave quite manically until they've had a snack!

incognitoforthisone · 31/03/2022 17:23

Weirdly, I was discussing this exact thing with my parents, who are both c.80 years old, at the weekend.

They both said that their families (working class Londoners) definitely considered it normal to have a mid-morning snack and a mid-afternoon one when they were younger. So when my nan was a housewife she stopped for a cuppa and maybe a couple of biscuits or an apple mid-morning, and then she'd have a slice of bread and jam or a rock cake or something with her children when they got in from school. My parents both say they used to be able to buy a bun or something during their morning break at school. And if you worked in an office or a factory, there'd usually be a tea lady who came round morning and afternoon with a tea urn and some basic snack items.

However, what both my parents say they never really did was a) snack while watching television or listening to the radio, b) buy a chocolate bar and eat it while walking down the street, c) have a stock of snacks just sitting there to be eaten at any time or d) snack on train/car/bus journeys. Also they basically just grew up drinking tea all the time instead of fruit juice, sugary drinks etc - things like lemonade or orange squash were a treat, not a daily thing. My mum also says that it baffles her that parents today carry snacks in their bags for babies and toddlers. She says that if you were out with a toddler all day, you'd take a packed lunch for it, but you wouldn't be delving into your bag for things for them to nibble on while you were out doing the shopping with them, apparently.

OohRahhMaki123 · 31/03/2022 17:19

I've noticed this. I used to be a serial snacker... constantly thinking about the next thing. Trying to be healthy i.e. have porridge for breakfast, then a banana at 10ish, lunch followed by a yoghurt etc. I used to feel headachey, a bit shaky, my mood decreased etc whenever I'd stopped grazing for a while.

I've been cutting back and I stopped snacking and having a yoghurt / fruit / biscuit as "desert" after my lunch and dinner. I'm amazed at how different I feel. I don't get the weird headachey, shakey feeling that I used to. I can go for half a day and not think about snacking or food in general. Honestly, I think it was just a bad habit that I fell into and didn't realise until I'd started gaining weight.

Indicatrice · 31/03/2022 17:18

@nearlyspringyay

Elevenses 🤢 and afternoon tea are snacks. Not sure where your point is.
🤦🏽‍♀️
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 31/03/2022 17:14

@StrangeCondition

I find it a bit odd, I have 3 meals a day and manage just fine, there are people at work who are constantly eating all day and I just think why?
Exactly! I don’t like alcohol and see no point in drinking a bottle of wine of an evening but I understand some people enjoy it. Food is a quick, cheap and easy way to have a bit of pleasure in your day
ArcheryAnnie · 31/03/2022 17:14

In the 1970s when I (urban child) went on holiday to family (rural agricultural workers), I was always amazed at how many meals they had. It was Hobbit-levels of meal frequency - breakfast, second breakfast, elevenses, etc etc etc. But they simply had much more physical activity during the day, and the meals weren't overly large.

stuntbubbles · 31/03/2022 17:12

@StrangeCondition

I find it a bit odd, I have 3 meals a day and manage just fine, there are people at work who are constantly eating all day and I just think why?
Cos work is horrible and food is nice.
StrangeCondition · 31/03/2022 17:10

I find it a bit odd, I have 3 meals a day and manage just fine, there are people at work who are constantly eating all day and I just think why?

Crankley · 31/03/2022 17:07

We didn't have snacks in the late 1940s/50s which I guess is not surprising since rationing didn't end until 1954 and so I've never got into the habit of having snacks.

Gonnagetgoing · 31/03/2022 16:59

@Knittingnanny2

Yes those cupcakes! I used to make 12 fairy cakes when my boys were young and the icing on 12 was in total the same as on one cup cake Dare I also say we were more active back in the days of snacks? I’m talking 50’s 60’s for me when there was no family car and no indoor play except on wet days! It was only one biscuit though or as someone said, one tiny homemade jam tart. I get headachy if I don’t have something every 3 hours so try to have something small as I can still hear my mother saying “ you’ll spoil your appetite”
@Knittingnanny2

My DM used to make in 70s what she called Queen Cakes - so cakes which were fairy cakes but with currants/sultanas in them but no icing and made with brown sugar.

She did like Digestive Biscuits so we'd often have those if hungry. If we were at the bakery getting bread we'd often get an iced bun (with cherry etc).

There was no snacking as in crisps unless we went to the pub where we were allowed crisps and orange juice/coke/etc as long as we stayed in the pub garden/games room. And we had crisps with packed lunches/school journeys.

Gonnagetgoing · 31/03/2022 16:55

I can't recall snacks as such at school, we just had breakfast, lunch, then dinner. I think we had something when we got home from school at about 3.30pm and then dinner wasn't until 7 or 8. So we'd have something like cake/biscuits etc. As a teenager probably similar but we'd get things like crisps, chocolate bar at breaks and also after school.

During holidays and at weekends we had sometimes biscuits or cake at 11 (elevenses) but not always. We also had something usually in the afternoon or before dinner but not always. Fruit/biscuits etc. If we saw a relative it'd be cake/snack etc.

We played out a lot and often didn't bother about snacks but that's not to say we didn't have any. I recall e.g. going to a big park that had an adventure playground, we had a picnic lunch, were allowed one or two ice creams and if we came out of the playground I'm sure we could eat whatever was left over (if anything) from the picnic. Thing is - though there were water fountains I don't recall us drinking more or eating more. We could quite easily go to e.g. a seaside town like Hastings and after having lunch could spend all afternoon playing and we had money for e.g. hot donuts or chocolate but i honestly don't recall buying loads! I mean we bought sweets from an old fashioned sweet shop but not to gorge on them!

Chely · 31/03/2022 16:46

The bad thing with grazing is you build insulin resistance increasing your risk of diabetes. The human body is great at fasting and feasting.

junglejane66 · 31/03/2022 16:34

@Lovemusic33

We never had snacks (grew up in the 80’s), 3 meals a day and only pudding in the weekends. We had a fruit bowl but no other snacks. I never felt hungry, once I was a teenager I would buy a bar of chocolate from the shop or a packet of crisps with pocket money but parents only provided food at meal times. We were usually too busy to think about snacking. After school we would go straight out to play and wouldn’t eat until dinner time (5-6pm), never felt hungry before bed.

I remember going on a school residential trip and being offered super and no knowing what super was 🤣.

I'm not too sure what meal 'super' is either Grin
EV117 · 31/03/2022 16:20

I think many people aren’t having just one snack between meals though. I think it’s more ‘grazing’ rather than snacking, it’s also mindless snacking, as in gabbing crisps and chocolate bars or biscuits while doing something else like reading something on your phone or watching TV, even on a short drive. I think more people than we realise can literally not go an hour without eating something.