Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Weekly Shop Cheaper in Aldi?

65 replies

PancakePenelope · 31/03/2022 12:22

Just looking for some tips really!
I currently get most of our grocery/ household shopping from Asda and I am pretty careful with spending. There are some things that I like / are cheaper from Aldi and I go there to stock up on these once a month.
I am always hearing people say that they do all their shopping at Aldi to save money, but when I have done a weekly shop in Adi I perceive that the total is more expensive. Granted - I usually do this online and click and collect, so I might not be seeing all of the deals?
We are a household of three adults (fairly strong appetite) and a toddler. We eat very cheap lunches during the week (at work) but like nice food in the evenings. Vegetarian dinners are absolutely not an option - we are very meat and fish heavy (and I don't really want to hear about the impact this has on the planet / health etc. Plus I do understand that meat costs significantly more than vegetables).
Please give me your tips for shopping cheaply at Aldi!

OP posts:
Mrsmch123 · 31/03/2022 14:30

I'm a bit mehhh at Aldi. For us we didn't save that much and had to go to tesco to get stuff Aldi didn't sell. I didn't like the double shopping so just stick with Tesco now.

PancakePenelope · 31/03/2022 14:29

@Mirrorball2022
Thank you - on the occasions that I bought fresh produce from Aldi tit didn't go off any quicker than things I had bought elsewhere. Not sure if it is a problem with some stores.
Our branch of Aldi has some of their normal stock on shelves above the specials in the middle aisle. This is really annoying when shopping with a toddler - I am trying to pick up some gravy granules so venture down the middle aisle and directly underneath them there are loads of toys etc. I definitely do not buy him everything he asks for, but it does make shopping stressful when you are constantly saying no!

OP posts:
Foxyloxy1plus1 · 31/03/2022 14:28

Maybe it depends where your Aldi is and how new the store is. Ours is six months old and the next nearest one, a couple of years old. I’ve found that their range of stuff is increasing, although there are still a few things we need to go elsewhere for. During lockdown, the Sainsbury’s delivery was regularly between £80 and £100. Aldi is usually between £50 and £60 and that’s allowing for the increase in food prices.

Mirrorball2022 · 31/03/2022 14:26

@PancakePenelope

Thanks everyone! I will certainly do a bit more analysis between the two! It's not that I am desparate to shop in Aldi or in Asda particularly. I kind of feel like a lot of people are saying that they have cut back on expediture by switching to Aldi so maybe I am missing something! Recent conversations about cost of living (in RL and on MN) always seem to involve someone saying "well I shop at Aldi to save money" which implies that by not switching to Aldi for the majority of our shopping I am spending more than I should? But on the face of it I cannot see much of a saving. Maybe those people have also changed what they buy / their eating habits when they switched supermarket...
I think everyone shops differently. I notice a difference of easily £5-£10 on a similar shop between Aldi and Asda, but I can get what I need from aldi. Some people can’t and have to shop around. It’s all subjective to your needs and wants. Not everyone needs to save £5-10 on their weekly shop or can’t always get everything in one store and that’s Ultimately their own choice.
hangrylady · 31/03/2022 14:26

I love Aldi and can get most things from there, unless it's a specific spice or random ingredient for a recipe, in which case I'd go to Sainsburys for that one thing. The things I don't like are the shampoo and conditioner and marmite dupe but I pick up these in other places. Fruit and veg, meat, cheese, alcoholic drinks etc all great. On the occasion I go to Sainsburys I'm outraged at the total at the checkout for a few items!

chisanunian · 31/03/2022 14:25

I tend to buy food for 3-4 days at a time rather than a whole week, and what I usually do is have a rough idea of meals and then go and see what they've got and what looks good/cheap that day. Then I meal plan on the hoof.

Mirrorball2022 · 31/03/2022 14:23

I do all my weekly shop at aldi. My local one has fresh fruit and veg which is fine and it doesn’t go off any quicker than elsewhere. This is mentioned a lot when talking about aldi but I’ve never had problems. But there’s just two of us and no kids so maybe it’s just easier to shop. I don’t shop in the middle aisle unless things I see are needed.

I got used to the non branded thing years ago and it’s fine. We have a coop locally for top ups of bread etc if needed. I buy some of my cleaning stuff from smol subscription anyway but the others I get all at aldi. The money we save on food shopping comes in handy for meals out/takeaway treats.

PancakePenelope · 31/03/2022 14:20

Thanks everyone!
I will certainly do a bit more analysis between the two!
It's not that I am desparate to shop in Aldi or in Asda particularly. I kind of feel like a lot of people are saying that they have cut back on expediture by switching to Aldi so maybe I am missing something! Recent conversations about cost of living (in RL and on MN) always seem to involve someone saying "well I shop at Aldi to save money" which implies that by not switching to Aldi for the majority of our shopping I am spending more than I should? But on the face of it I cannot see much of a saving. Maybe those people have also changed what they buy / their eating habits when they switched supermarket...

OP posts:
DelphiniumBlue · 31/03/2022 14:16

I don't understand, I reckon our shop is £30-40 pw cheaper at Aldi than Sainsbury's Morrison's or even Asda. Better quality than Asda, too.
Meat is where we make the biggest saving.

BlooberryBiskits · 31/03/2022 14:13

[quote PancakePenelope]@BlooberryBiskits
I am definitely prepared to shop around, but maybe not visiting multiple shops every week. Plus the more shopping trips we go on, the more 3YO will want treats and the less resolve I have to say no...[/quote]
I agree: fewer trips saves a lot!

I’d suggest you try to do a full shop at ALDI, make note of what you like/dislike and keep receipt to compare vs ASDA

Then rotate stores (if you can make the time)

PancakePenelope · 31/03/2022 14:06

@BlooberryBiskits
I am definitely prepared to shop around, but maybe not visiting multiple shops every week. Plus the more shopping trips we go on, the more 3YO will want treats and the less resolve I have to say no...

OP posts:
BIWI · 31/03/2022 14:03

@PancakePenelope

How much money does everyone actually save by going to Aldi? Is it a few £s a week or more?
Some time ago, when Aldi first opened near us, I did a very geeky thing and compared the price of everything I had bought at Sainsbury with the nearest equivalent at Aldi. (If there wasn't an equivalent, then I left that product out of my calculations.). Overall it was about 30% cheaper at Aldi.

The only thing I've had from there that hasn't gone down well, is their catfood. Our ungrateful little buggers wouldn't countenance it.

As our Aldi is just round the corner from Sainsbury's it's not a hassle to go to both. I do Aldi first and then anything I can't get there (catfood!) I pick up at Sainsbury's.

Aldi wine and gin is amazing - both in terms of quality and value.

usernotfound0000 · 31/03/2022 14:03

I buy everything that I can in Aldi, there is some stuff that I can't get there and I go to either Morrisons or Asda for those bits, but it's usually 1 or 2 things a week. We are a fanily of 2 adults and 2 children. Weekly spend is usually £60-70. This week, due to logisitics, I had to do the weekly shop in Asda, I didn't buy anything different, in fact I didn't buy for a full week as we are away next week and spent over £90! My tip is definitely meal plan. I don't have issues with the produce, strawberries are the only thing I can't get to last so we eat those first.

BlooberryBiskits · 31/03/2022 13:57

@PancakePenelope

How much money does everyone actually save by going to Aldi? Is it a few £s a week or more?
I save a LOT, but that is partly because I also do some of my shop at Sainsburys and Waitrose, both of which are much pricier vs Aldi/Lidl and also ASDA.

I'm planning to do Aldi & Lidl every couple of weeks (alternating them), so I can really limit what I need to buy in my Sainsburys top ups. It works for me as I have all of these close to home/work

TBH - to work out what saves you money keep your receipts & compare stores. You can then plan your meals based on what is best in each shop

Christmas1988 · 31/03/2022 13:54

I usually shop in Sainsbury’s but they have had missing items for ages so when we drive past Aldi I pick up what I’m missing, I don’t think it’s much cheaper at all especially their kitchen rolls! If you buy brand names it’s cheap but supermarket own brands vs Aldi own brands are pretty similar.

Doubleraspberry · 31/03/2022 13:51

I find both Aldi and Lidl offer better quality at a lower price. Eg Torchon ham is a similar price to other supermarkets’ far more budget ham offer. So you sometimes need to dig a bit deeper on what is being compared. I can buy the posh ranges in Aldi and Lidl and still not pay a lot.

BlooberryBiskits · 31/03/2022 13:47

OP - shopping at several stores is a better way to maximise your budget than sticking to 1 store, as different shops charge higher/lower for different things

They all tend to benchmark a certain 'basket' (usually milk/cheddar/beans/chicken/bananas - 10-12 items) which tend to be v similar prices everywhere

IME Aldi is great for cleaning/laundry products, yogurts, store cupboard foods. I also like their pies (higgidy dupes), chocolate

If you are prepared to shop in a few different stores (rotating 3-4) you are likely to make good savings: however understandably many people just don't think its worth their time

SilverHairedCat · 31/03/2022 13:43

I go to Lidl as its closest but we went to Asda at Xmas thinking we'd do the big Xmas shop there. I walked out with nothing after seeing the prices - you'll save a fortune at Lidl or Aldi, but it does vary depending on what you're cooking.

PancakePenelope · 31/03/2022 13:43

How much money does everyone actually save by going to Aldi? Is it a few £s a week or more?

OP posts:
PancakePenelope · 31/03/2022 13:42

@Covetthee
Interesting example - I pay 40p for spring onions from Asda, every week.
It's funny because I find it difficult not to be tempted by extras from Aldi - so we are total opposites!

@Lyricallie

Good tips thank you - do you meal plan before you go, or do you go into the shop, find the offers and plan from there? I am a strict meal planner, but can only seem to manage it when I am online shopping! In store I find that I will blunder and when I get home I have missed key ingredients somewhere along the way. I should mention that I have a very vocal 3YO with me when I shop (hence the preference for click and collect!)

OP posts:
TonkaTruckduck · 31/03/2022 13:42

I genuinely don't find Aldi cheaper by the time you've factored in going to other shops, either a bigger supermarket or faffing about in B and M etc.
Yes Aldi is cheap, but I can only get about 70% of what I want, so I end up in other shops buying stuff I don't need. Plus I work my time out to be my hourly rate at work and if I factor that in, Aldi is definitely a loser.
The individual goods are cheap at Aldi, but if you can't complete your shop there it's a false economy.

Chely · 31/03/2022 13:41

Asda is better imo, Morrisons occassionally. I can't get a descent shop at Aldi and it's not close to us either.

I get toilet roll, bin bags, dishwasher tablets, laundry stuff and a few other bits in bulk from Costco every couple of months rather than using supermarket. Well worth the membership fee.

nearlyspringyay · 31/03/2022 13:38

I can't do a full shop there, end up in Sainsbury's anyway so it's not cost or time effective.

HelebethH · 31/03/2022 13:36

Their yoghurts are good especially the Greek style
Extra Mature cheddar cheese
Marmite dupe
Swiss style muesli. Both the nutty and Berries and cherries. Used to buy Dorset until I tried these
Frozen Haddock/Cod in Breadcrumbs
Pork mince
Pork loin chops
Chilled sourdough pizzas

BarbaraofSeville · 31/03/2022 13:35

only issue i have with aldi is their fresh produce doesnt last long

People always say things like this and it's never been my experience and I've shopped regularly in Aldi for decades, long before it was socially acceptable to do so.

Aldi nappies are supposed to be very good, so possibly another thing to stock up on monthly. I'm sure cheese and cooked meats are cheaper in Aldi and the dates will often mean you can buy for the month, or at least alternate one week Aldi, the next Asda - that might be another way to do it?