Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people keep dangerous dogs???

490 replies

Ori18 · 31/03/2022 10:23

Another little boy pronounced dead this morning on the news - the toddler who was mauled on Monday and subsequently suffered a cardiac arrest. The dogs in question are not thought to be banned under the Dangerous Dogs Act - but I'd be interested to know which breeds they were as it's quite evident that certain breeds are more dangerous to children than others - why aren't Rottweiler's on the banned list for example?

And even though Pitt Bull Terriers are banned, people still go out of their way to own them, and are then shocked when they attack small children, maul babies, tear limbs off people. It makes me so angry. Same goes for German Shepherds and Staffordshire Bull Terriers. The Bull Terrier dogs are/were specifically bred for fighting - why would you even consider having one of these types of dogs around a baby or a small child? What is going on there? Is it lack of intelligence? Lack of education? Lack of giving a fuck? Because I think there need to be more dogs on the banned list, and heavier penalties served to people who insist on breaking the law to keep these dogs.

Aggressive/dangerous dogs and babies/small children do not mix, should never be mixed and it shouldn't take more deaths for the law to change around this. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
SpringsSprung · 01/04/2022 10:35

Those of you saying "It's the idiots who don't train them" www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/crime/woman-killed-dutch-shepherd-k9-dog-b2048382.html

CounsellorTroi · 01/04/2022 10:25

Dogs are of no overall benefit to society. They don’t grow up and pay taxes like children do, they just use up the worlds resources and leave shit everywhere.

Tell that to veterans, the visually impaired, deaf people, people with mental health disorders or lonely Gladys down the road who only has a dog for company.

There are proven mental and physical health benefits to dog ownership

CounsellorTroi · 01/04/2022 10:22

I'm on a parenting group and every other week someone is asking how to STOP their little one from hurting/hitting/bothering the dog. It's maddening. It's pretty obvious separation is the only answer and the dog should never be hurt in the first place.

If you look at the Dogs Trust website a significant proportion of the dogs available will have “cannot live with children under 14” in their description. This is not because the dog is inherently dangerous, it’s because they have been mistreated intentionally or otherwise by children.

ThatDamnedDog · 01/04/2022 10:12

Dogs are of no overall benefit to society. They don’t grow up and pay taxes like children do, they just use up the worlds resources and leave shit everywhere.

Tell that to veterans, the visually impaired, deaf people, people with mental health disorders or lonely Gladys down the road who only has a dog for company.

I agree some dog owners shouldn’t be allowed to keep them, but tarring every dog owner with the same brush is ridiculous. I don’t particularly like other peoples children when they are acting in an unacceptable manner, does that mean all parents are arseholes who can’t control their offspring?

I have never taken my animals to the shops/a restaurant/the pub as I don’t believe it is beneficial to them or the other patrons. I spend a lot of my life training and exercising my dogs and they only go off lead in a secure paddock belonging to my friend. I would never leave any child with any animal without supervision as both are capable of unpredictable behaviour. Nor do I belittle people for not wanting to be near my animals as they don’t know them and the boys are big.

As a dog owner I am as fed up of judgemental pricks as people who dislike dogs are of me. If it wasn’t for my beautiful girl, who has since passed, I wouldn’t be here.

Hoppinggreen · 01/04/2022 09:10

We have a Goldie, have had them since I was around 8. They have a reputation as good family pets, which is probably why I have to regularly peel toddlers off him while the parent looks on fondly. He’s pretty good with people and does like children but he has teeth and claws and is a big boy, he could easily hurt a child without even meaning to.
We had a GR puppy when I was about 13 and a friends family got one from the same litter. Their dog accidentally knocked their toddler downstairs and he fractured his skull. I waited until my youngest child was 8 before we got our dog.
I love dogs and volunteer for a couple of rehoming charities but I do t think small children and dogs is a good combination

Hoppinggreen · 01/04/2022 09:04

@MangyInseam

It depends on what you mean by cock.

Oops. Crock, it should say.

I mean the “nanny dog” label NO dog should be viewed in that way and the term gets bandied around whenever people mention Staffies (which do tend to be dog reactive but usually ok with people). No dog should be left alone with small children
Wheniruletheworld · 01/04/2022 09:00

Dogs aren't inherently dangerous. Sadly, some idiots/wankers/arrogant sods (delete as appropriate) become dog owners and make them dangerous through goading, punishment or just general f-wittery

Nap1983 · 01/04/2022 08:59

I have a lab, my DD is 13 and I leave her alone with him with no concerns. My nephews are 5 and a baby and I would not leave them alone… it’s more how my dog might react to the kids unpredictability like running, shouting & screaming. Also he’s big so could knock over when excited.

Sathexperience · 01/04/2022 08:57

@MatildaTheCat

Aggressive/dangerous dogs and babies/small children do not mix, should never be mixed and it shouldn't take more deaths for the law to change around this. AIBU?

No dogs are completely safe around children let alone very young ones. There needs to be a concerted campaign to address this. I believe some breeds are very highly represented in domestic attacks but there isn’t one dog I would trust 100% including my own soppy mutt.

Couldn't agree more. Lots of people think they understand dog behaviour because they've had a few as pets, but are actually very very naive about the capabilities of any dog.
oblada · 01/04/2022 08:37

@Leonberger

Everyone saying that all dogs are the same and that no dog is more dangerous/prey driven than another needs to do some research.

There’s a massive difference genetically in the different breeds. Puppies are born with personalities much like people, they don’t come out blank Hmm

Absolutely. But owners have a much bigger responsibility than genetics. Some breed may be more prey driven but that makes them better at certain activities. And within those breeds every dog is different. Banning breed is stupid and misses the point which is about educating owners.
Leonberger · 01/04/2022 08:32

Everyone saying that all dogs are the same and that no dog is more dangerous/prey driven than another needs to do some research.

There’s a massive difference genetically in the different breeds. Puppies are born with personalities much like people, they don’t come out blank Hmm

oblada · 01/04/2022 08:30

People are dangerous. Not dogs.
I'm on a parenting group and every other week someone is asking how to STOP their little one from hurting/hitting/bothering the dog. It's maddening. It's pretty obvious separation is the only answer and the dog should never be hurt in the first place.
Dogs are animals. Not to be trusted regardless of breeeding. Not because they don't deserve it but because trust implies a level of thinking on the part of the other that that dogs do not possess. They are instinctive animals. They can be trained but they remain animals and need to be loved and cared for as such.

EerieSilence · 01/04/2022 08:25

I have a Dobermann and she loves small children. Gets agitated when she hears them cry because she thinks something bad is happening to them, gives sloppy kisses.
I would never leave her unattended around children though, because she's a big and powerful dog and could knock them down or nip them in a play.
There's no dangerous breeds, there's only dangerous owners. Sadly, many skanks love to hang around with bull-breeds because of the image (and relatively little activity and training demands).

blubberball · 01/04/2022 08:23

My son's secondary school has a rottweiler as a therapy dog. It's as sweet and soppy as anything

whatisthisinhere · 01/04/2022 08:04

@WiddlinDiddlin

There is another myth that really needs to die, unfortunately it isn't popular, dispelling this myth.

'There are no bad dogs/dogs are never born bad'.. etc.

Well.. yes, actually, many dogs are born 'bad', if by 'bad' we mean genetically predisposed to be fearful, to be anxious, to be more inclined to choose aggression when they feel threatened, to be more inclined to choose biting when they feel threatened...

There is a pervasive and horribly inaccurate idea that a puppy is a 'blank slate', and that being so, if you raise any puppy the right way, they will therefore turn out to be a wonderful, happy, well balanced dog.

That isn't true.

It cannot be true, because we now know that learned experience CAN be passed on genetically.

Fear (check out the mice and the cherry scent study, as its half 4 in the morning I can't be arsed to find it) learned by just ONE parent* can be passed to the offspring even when the offspring NEVER experiences the aversive stimuli.

So lets say Joe Toughs Pitbull learns to be terrified of the smell of baby powder - he's bred to Bob Arseholes pitbull who is genetically predisposed to want to use aggression first rather than last when scared.

The offspring all stand a chance of a/being scared of the smell of baby powder and b/being predisposed to use aggression first. But you wouldn't know which until much later on down the line.

No amount of training is going to alter that, you could raise that puppy with the absolute best of everything and still not ever guarantee that puppy won't react fearfully in that specific situation. If you're a sensible owner, the risks are minimal... but you could end up with a dog you have to manage super carefully it's entire life.

This is a wholly unpopular view with rescues of course because many of them raise puppies in less than ideal situations, from bitches and dogs who are unknown quantities and have (bitches at least) likely suffered some extreme stress during the pregnancy.

Its also typically a totally unknown thing as far as breeders of many dogs are concerned - neither old school showing breeders nor backyard arseholes tend to go to lectures on epigenetics.

So yes, unfortunately some dogs can even with the best intentions of breeder and buyer, and the best care and training - be born predisposed to be fearful.

If you combine that with poor training, use of aversives, bullshit like pack theory/rank reduction/dominance theory/poor housing, poor handling, lack of socialisation and enrichment... You easily end up with dogs who appear (the signs are generally there, but the people closest to the dog are neither looking for them nor likely to recognise them) to suddenly do something violent without warning.

We could seriously reduce the risks of this if no one bred from dogs with iffy temperaments, ensured bitches never experienced stress during pregnancy and raising a litter, ensured all dogs had the very best care... but I won't hold my breath for that!

(*study used males because theres a chance offspring can learn from the mother in the litter, but theres no reason to suggest they can't also get a fearful gene from the mother)

Yes, absolutely this. My puppy is from n excellent breeder, the dam was well cared for and from championship lines, and the sire comes from championship lines also. My puppy is biddable, responsive, and loves to please. I've had two rescues in the past, and while they were lovely, they were definitely not to be trusted at all around children or small animals. Breeding makes a huge difference
SamphiretheStickerist · 01/04/2022 06:44

@Thelnebriati

Am I the only dog owner on the entire thread that had third party insurance?
Nope! Cos that's what all of us sensible dog owners, who are being mainly ignored here, have.

Still, this is MN, where we are all idiots who can't make good decisions and daily threaten kids, and everyone else, without thought!

Fairisleflora · 01/04/2022 05:26

I do think some owners forget that having a dog is their lifestyle choice, and it is unacceptable for their dog to obstruct the lives of those who don’t want anything to do with your dog. So no, I don’t want your dog to be anywhere near me in a public place - if it comes anywhere near me I expect you to call it back. If the dog doesn’t respond to your calling it needs to be on a lead at all times. Dogs shouldn’t be allowed to ‘join in’ my kids football game in a public park. It’s not ‘cute’ it is 100% unacceptable.

Dogs are of no overall benefit to society. They don’t grow up and pay taxes like children do, they just use up the worlds resources and leave shit everywhere. If you want a dog, get one but get it out of my face.

DetMcNulty · 01/04/2022 05:10

And the training has always been positive reinforcement, absolutely nothing to do with pack theory or dominance.

You do need to have a licence here though, and we have rangers who can issue fines for dogs off lead where they shouldn't be, and get involved if there are disputes / dog attacks / dogs being neglected etc.

DetMcNulty · 01/04/2022 05:06

I have a big dog, he's 60kg part mastiff, got him as a rescue puppy and he's been through lots of training. I was conscious of the size of him, and did make sure we did specific training one on one, and the trainer was the lack of exercise is a huge part in aggression / poor behaviour in dogs. We run 8 to 10 km in the morning, then another walk at least another 5 km in the evening and he is super well behaved and chilled, but it takes a lot of work and vigilance which I think is underestimated. We're in Australia, so can take him off lead bush running, but I made sure his recall is 100% and he's been trained not to go near the wildlife, for his sake and theirs, particularly the kangaroos that bounce across the track and the snakes. Number of times I've met others with off lead dogs who's dogs have done a runner chasing a kangaroo is shocking.

I had him out for dinner at a pub, we were on a grassed section away from others, with some friends and their dogs, some idiot walked over with their baby, told me he loves dogs and plopped him on the grass in front of them. As soon as he started to crawl, my dog absolutely freaked out as he'd never seen a baby move like that. I had him secured, so there was never a chance he'd get close, but that shows you the mentality of some people, and lack of understanding of dog behaviour.

He's saved me from a pretty nasty situation though, out in bush a guy having a mental health breakdown jumped out at me, swinging a branch and screaming, my boy charged him, but even in that situation, he never went as far as biting or attacking, he stopped as soon as the guy backed off and just stayed between us.

WiddlinDiddlin · 01/04/2022 04:38

There is another myth that really needs to die, unfortunately it isn't popular, dispelling this myth.

'There are no bad dogs/dogs are never born bad'.. etc.

Well.. yes, actually, many dogs are born 'bad', if by 'bad' we mean genetically predisposed to be fearful, to be anxious, to be more inclined to choose aggression when they feel threatened, to be more inclined to choose biting when they feel threatened...

There is a pervasive and horribly inaccurate idea that a puppy is a 'blank slate', and that being so, if you raise any puppy the right way, they will therefore turn out to be a wonderful, happy, well balanced dog.

That isn't true.

It cannot be true, because we now know that learned experience CAN be passed on genetically.

Fear (check out the mice and the cherry scent study, as its half 4 in the morning I can't be arsed to find it) learned by just ONE parent* can be passed to the offspring even when the offspring NEVER experiences the aversive stimuli.

So lets say Joe Toughs Pitbull learns to be terrified of the smell of baby powder - he's bred to Bob Arseholes pitbull who is genetically predisposed to want to use aggression first rather than last when scared.

The offspring all stand a chance of a/being scared of the smell of baby powder and b/being predisposed to use aggression first. But you wouldn't know which until much later on down the line.

No amount of training is going to alter that, you could raise that puppy with the absolute best of everything and still not ever guarantee that puppy won't react fearfully in that specific situation. If you're a sensible owner, the risks are minimal... but you could end up with a dog you have to manage super carefully it's entire life.

This is a wholly unpopular view with rescues of course because many of them raise puppies in less than ideal situations, from bitches and dogs who are unknown quantities and have (bitches at least) likely suffered some extreme stress during the pregnancy.

Its also typically a totally unknown thing as far as breeders of many dogs are concerned - neither old school showing breeders nor backyard arseholes tend to go to lectures on epigenetics.

So yes, unfortunately some dogs can even with the best intentions of breeder and buyer, and the best care and training - be born predisposed to be fearful.

If you combine that with poor training, use of aversives, bullshit like pack theory/rank reduction/dominance theory/poor housing, poor handling, lack of socialisation and enrichment... You easily end up with dogs who appear (the signs are generally there, but the people closest to the dog are neither looking for them nor likely to recognise them) to suddenly do something violent without warning.

We could seriously reduce the risks of this if no one bred from dogs with iffy temperaments, ensured bitches never experienced stress during pregnancy and raising a litter, ensured all dogs had the very best care... but I won't hold my breath for that!

(*study used males because theres a chance offspring can learn from the mother in the litter, but theres no reason to suggest they can't also get a fearful gene from the mother)

BlackCountryWench2 · 01/04/2022 01:21

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

RobertaFirmino · 01/04/2022 00:50

@theton

Someone being killed by a cockerpoo isn’t newsworthy.

i think it would be, has anyone been killed by a cockerpoo?

I doubt it. Small jaws and easier to remove. That doesn't mean that they are less likely to attack though.
Natty13 · 01/04/2022 00:47

@Myee

There are far too many pet dogs now. Dogs should be working dogs only. They can be dangerous no matter how good the owner is, and I am sick of the mantra "it is not the dog it's the owner" well if the owner didn't have a dog no child or anyone else would be injured or killed. End of story, there is no excuse.

If people want a dog as a pet they should really live outside urban areas, there is no proper environment for dogs in suburbs, towns and cities, so they have to be walked twice a day outside in the streets somewhere, and the potential is always there for one of these dogs to go rogue on their walkies. Happens every single day.

Most owners are selfish. The dog this, the dog that, can I bring it into the pub/restaurant/supermarket/on holidays blah blah blah. I am indifferent to dogs and pets in general. I would not harm a hair on their heads ever, but would rather be miles away from any of them.

Not an acceptable view to many I am sure, but I am entitled to voice it just the same. I am not afraid to say it to people when out also. Sitting outside a restaurant the other day this woman had three furry things yapping and exploring (on a long lead). All around my feet and it drove me mad. I asked the owner if she would mind keeping the dogs over her side of the tables. Well the look I got! I was told that the dogs were her pets, were very well behaved and well trained and look....they really like you! Ugh, get away from me.. I've had it with them.

I have a serious back injury because a rogue dog was let off the leash in the local park and knocked me over. I won't say more because I will lose it. The owner marched off and didn't ask if I was OK. I was not.

Nah, people's choice to have kids and live in a city doesn't come above someone else's choice to have a dog a live in a city are you mental?
Unforgettablefire · 01/04/2022 00:16

@saltinesandcoffeecups

I like to tell this story when this subject comes up… don’t expect it to change minds, and it’s clearly an anecdote.

A guy I knew barely… basically we were people who went to the same neighborhood bar… had an American Bulldog. She was honestly the biggest dog I’ve ever seen, even 20 years later. Her head was bigger than mine as a full grown adult. She had be over 150lbs. She was never on a leash, she would sit by the door as ran in. One day I got to talking to him about her.

He told me somebody owed him money for a job he did (he was a painter by trade) while he was trying to collect the guy was bragging about his new pup, who apparently came from good fighting stock. He was excited to start training her so that one day she could fight her father. (In case you haven’t caught on yet she was a bred fighting dog intended to be used for illegal dog fighting). The guy I knew said, you know what you owe me a lot of money. Pay now or give me me the pup. The other couldn’t pay so grudgingly gave him the pup.

So he said he took the pup and one of the first things he did was drop her in a pile of little kids and proceeded to socialize her in every positive way he could. She was fully grown when I met her and was truly the best dog, warmest, happiest dog I had ever met.

I saw her give 1 warning over the years I knew her, and it was when she was under the table I was sitting at, and two men approached me. These two were known criminals in the neighborhood (they kind that ooze danger) and the minute she felt they were too close she gave a warning growl, and moved to get between me and them. They tried one more step and she bared teeth. They got the hint and backed off. Her owner was standing in the doorway watching what was going on and he said he would have stopped her before anything happened, but he knew who those two were and wanted them to know she was serious.

The minute they left she was laying her head in my lap drooling and giving me lovey eyes. And didn’t make a sound or acknowledge anyone else on the busy street that night or any other time after that.

If you’re still with me after that story… feel free to add this to any narrative you feel appropriate, but know that one dangerous breed dog who literally came from the dog fighting world who was the pup of active fighting dogs was not dangerous and was well behaved and well socialized and could give and receive love.

Lovely story thank you for sharing Smile that dog got lucky so did the owner she sounds like a cracking dog.
Myee · 01/04/2022 00:04

There are far too many pet dogs now. Dogs should be working dogs only. They can be dangerous no matter how good the owner is, and I am sick of the mantra "it is not the dog it's the owner" well if the owner didn't have a dog no child or anyone else would be injured or killed. End of story, there is no excuse.

If people want a dog as a pet they should really live outside urban areas, there is no proper environment for dogs in suburbs, towns and cities, so they have to be walked twice a day outside in the streets somewhere, and the potential is always there for one of these dogs to go rogue on their walkies. Happens every single day.

Most owners are selfish. The dog this, the dog that, can I bring it into the pub/restaurant/supermarket/on holidays blah blah blah. I am indifferent to dogs and pets in general. I would not harm a hair on their heads ever, but would rather be miles away from any of them.

Not an acceptable view to many I am sure, but I am entitled to voice it just the same. I am not afraid to say it to people when out also. Sitting outside a restaurant the other day this woman had three furry things yapping and exploring (on a long lead). All around my feet and it drove me mad. I asked the owner if she would mind keeping the dogs over her side of the tables. Well the look I got! I was told that the dogs were her pets, were very well behaved and well trained and look....they really like you! Ugh, get away from me.. I've had it with them.

I have a serious back injury because a rogue dog was let off the leash in the local park and knocked me over. I won't say more because I will lose it. The owner marched off and didn't ask if I was OK. I was not.

Swipe left for the next trending thread