Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people keep dangerous dogs???

490 replies

Ori18 · 31/03/2022 10:23

Another little boy pronounced dead this morning on the news - the toddler who was mauled on Monday and subsequently suffered a cardiac arrest. The dogs in question are not thought to be banned under the Dangerous Dogs Act - but I'd be interested to know which breeds they were as it's quite evident that certain breeds are more dangerous to children than others - why aren't Rottweiler's on the banned list for example?

And even though Pitt Bull Terriers are banned, people still go out of their way to own them, and are then shocked when they attack small children, maul babies, tear limbs off people. It makes me so angry. Same goes for German Shepherds and Staffordshire Bull Terriers. The Bull Terrier dogs are/were specifically bred for fighting - why would you even consider having one of these types of dogs around a baby or a small child? What is going on there? Is it lack of intelligence? Lack of education? Lack of giving a fuck? Because I think there need to be more dogs on the banned list, and heavier penalties served to people who insist on breaking the law to keep these dogs.

Aggressive/dangerous dogs and babies/small children do not mix, should never be mixed and it shouldn't take more deaths for the law to change around this. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
yellowsuninthesky · 31/03/2022 11:54

@Nincomepoop

More children are run over than killed by dogs. Due in car accidents than killed by dogs. Should we ban automobiles?

Worse yet, more children are killed by their parents each year than by dogs. Why do we allow parents to keep their kids?

The world can turn without pets. We kind of need transport and for humans to continue (to some extent). It's unfortunate that some people are feckless parents (understatement) but short of sterilising them, there isn't much you can do.

I would be in favour of expensive dog licences but (a) how do you enforce it; and (b) it would make dog owners even more entitled because they can afford the licences - SUV driver syndrome.

MissEDashwood19 · 31/03/2022 11:53

@AHungryCaterpillar

Here we go with the “all dogs can be dangerous” nonsense well I know I would fancy my chances more with a jack Russell/poodle/chihuahua than a staff, pit or Rottweiler... some dogs have far more ability to seriously injure or kill than others so no they aren’t all as “dangerous”
This. Whilst heavily pregnant, I was savagely attacked in an unprovoked attack by a Collie-German Shepherd mix. The attack was terrifying and only stopped when my DH, having heard my screams, came running up the road and pulled the dog off.

Children don't stand a chance if a big dog (think Rottweiler, Pitbull, Bull Terrier, German Shepherd) attacks.

I question why families choose to have these breeds with small children.

Although, they are invariably the ones that come out with nonsense like "Pitties/Staffies were nanny dogs" and "Chihuahuas are more aggressive than my Pittie". It only takes one minute for your beloved "Pittie" to snap and something catastrophic to happen. Surely even the most deluded can see that a Pitbull or German Shepherd is more dangerous than a Toy Poodle.

Even small dogs should never be unsupervised with children. My small dog, from a breed known to be very good with cats and children, is NEVER left alone with my small DC.

Shortname · 31/03/2022 11:53

@WiddlinDiddlin That's really interesting, I didn't know the context of the banned breeds ruling and it really makes the whole thing an absolute joke, banning breeds clearly not the answer. Wish I'd read your post before posting mine!

Femalewoman · 31/03/2022 11:52

@DrDinosaur

Loads of people protesting there are no 'dangerous breeds'. Link to list of fatal dog attacks in uk including the breed. Complete lack of poodles, labradors, and chihuahuas on list. Multiple rottweilers, pitbulls etc on list. Still loads of people insisting its nothing to do with the breeds.
Yep. Every time there is a dog attack the same old same old comments. However, looking at recorded deaths by dog attack it's a certain small number of breed of dog that come up and up again. Obviously, it doesn't mean all of that breed are a problem but there some of them do kill and many of those have the very strong bite/jaw/muscle mass that mean they grip and don't let go.

There also appears to be a complete denial by some dog owners that their dog would never do that because x y and z. Why take the chance. Supervise the dog and don't leave with very young children , don't be complacent.

HesterShaw1 · 31/03/2022 11:52

Excellent post @WiddlinDiddlin

The problem is much deeper than the dog breed. It's like everything.

yellowsuninthesky · 31/03/2022 11:52

People don’t really understand dog behaviour and think they can control their dogs but many of them are clueless and shouldn’t be in charge of a chihuahua let alone a large powerful dog with the potential to kill

Exactly this.

Nincomepoop · 31/03/2022 11:51

More children are run over than killed by dogs. Due in car accidents than killed by dogs. Should we ban automobiles?

Worse yet, more children are killed by their parents each year than by dogs. Why do we allow parents to keep their kids?

TiddleyWink · 31/03/2022 11:51

Completely unrealistic of course, and would be wildly unpopular - but I would support compulsory vetting by RSPCA/social services of any living situation involving children and dogs. SS get involved when kids are known to be living with dangerous adults yet dogs are just ignored until it’s too late.

It’s beyond scandalous that every few days there is another child killed by a domestically kept dog and more isn’t being done to address it.

I know someone with a very large and barely trained lab who has physically injured their child at least once - not serious enough to involve authorities by why the fuck should any child be subjected to living with an animal that can hurt it?

If only dogs were restricted to adult only households where everyone had the capacity to consent to the situation.

As I say, I know quite how unrealistic this is, but I can dream.

MrOllivander · 31/03/2022 11:48

The only dog I've ever been bitten by (and badly) was a collie
I don't like Akitas but that's because I can't read them - I dog sat for one that was nasty, food guarding, aggressive, the lot. Mum would let the dog hold the childs arm in its mouth BlushAngry
Ended up doing long long walks with it daily, twice a day and dog turned very quickly into a much better behaved dog as it wasn't bored and cooped up. Did loads of activities, sniffing walks, some fast paced ones and she was so brain/body tired that she didn't have the energy to think about food guarding!

SirChenjins · 31/03/2022 11:47

All dogs can be dangerous - apart from the fact it’s specific breeds which, time and time again, are the ones killing people.

Shortname · 31/03/2022 11:46

I do sort of agree with you, despite having known several of the most gentle, soppy staffies and German shepherds ever, all wonderful family pets, its clear that their size/strength/jaws could do far more damage than eg a spaniel. I know that would be down to mistreatment by owners, but how can we effectively legislate against people mistreating their dogs and making them vicious, we can't, so sadly more breeds should probably be banned.

MarrymeTomHardy · 31/03/2022 11:44

I think the breed specific legislation is part of the problem...All dogs can be dangerous...not just those on the list...
& yes I do have a staffie who is soft as anything & I trust 100% BUT never left him alone with babies/young children because you don't know what they may do to the dog & the dogs reaction...this goes for ALL dogs though.
And don't be fooled by handbag/companion breeds, little dogs are good at jumping & you can get some really poorly though-out cross breeds with really bad temperament as with a dog of any size!

WiddlinDiddlin · 31/03/2022 11:44

Why aren't such breeds banned?

Well in 1990/1, the government wanted to look like it was 'doing something' in response to a number of high profile attacks by dogs on children.

At that point, pitbull type terriers were very popular, although the breed that triggered it all was in fact a Rottie, pitbulls had also been in the press.

The Kennel Club, the breed clubs all went to town protecting their breeds, because they're all registered breeds...

Except pitbull terriers, which are not. Funnily enough, nor are the other three breeds banned at the time, nor were there any examples of those three breeds in the country.

So four breeds were banned, one which was hugely popular but had no official representation and 3 that didn't exist here.

Hey presto, governments done something, all the little children will be safe, everyone will live happily ever after.

Only they didn't - because this didn't address WHY people were keeping bull & terrier type dogs that were a risk around small people and strangers, it didn't look at WHY these compact, economical to keep, robust, easy to train animals were popular with a disenfranchised youth in deprived areas, with drug dealers who wanted protection where having a dog is legal and a knife is not.. and so on..

It also didn't factor in that labelling these breeds dangerous, devil dogs, illegal... gave them a desirability they'd really not previously had!

And it really didn't help that you can create an illegal 'type' dog out of two perfectly legal breeds, or that a litter of puppies could contain legal and illegal animals, with no way of telling til around 9 months old.

So the numbers didn't go down. They went up. As did the numbers of people wanting them.

If you're asking why do people want them - loads of reasons!

Most of the bull breeds I have worked with are eager to please, exuberantly friendly, easy to train, easy to feed and keep, typically very healthy animals that rarely need the vets, whelp easily etc etc.

They have a stupidly high pain threshold and no understanding of anyone's (dog or human) personal space, they're still playing when everyone else is in pain and begging for mercy... so when they ARE eventually hurt - it has to be pretty bad. This tends to mean that trainers using aversives like prong collars, shock collars, yanking and kicking etc need to go very far to get a response...

In combination with that they're also remarkably fast learners AND sensitive little flowers mentally - they don't forget, and being terrier types under the bull breed macho appearance, the answer is 'get in there first, don't ask questions, just muller it'.

Another HUGE HUGE factor is the number of people who persist in teaching dogs NOT to growl - a growl is a warning, its a communication, it says 'give me more space/stop doing this' - but SO many dogs are taught via punishment NOT to give that warning..

When you combine all these elements, it is easy to end up with a dog who can do a lot of damage when they finally say 'fuck this' and are pushed over the edge.

Banning is not the answer though - we've done that since 1991 - it has not worked, by any metric you care to measure, it hasn't worked. Surely adding more breeds to a list, to try to improve on something that does not work... will also NOT WORK.

It isn't as simple as saying 'its not about the breed' because it is.. AND.. it isn't.

If we got rid of every bull breed in existance, someone would produce labradors with higher and higher pain thresholds (they're already half way there!) and a ready willingness to use aggression and bite (again.. ive met some seriously dangerous labradors as a result of horrific breeding and training).

Some people have a desire to own a dog that intimidates others.
Some people have a desire to own a dog that can do and is trained to do physical damage (look at the rise in popularity of bite sports, look at the number of celebs who have bought pre-trained protection dogs they're not remotely capable of handling or working safely).

Some of us just love the fatheaded lummoxes they are if raised properly - I won't live with em, they're too exuberant for me as I really can't be knocked around and trampled, but I bloody love training with them, they're hilarious fun, super fast to learn, do so with humour and a joy at simply working with a human.

VampireMoney · 31/03/2022 11:44

And you’re mental thinking a toy companion breed is a friendly family dog. Some of the nastiest dogs I’ve met have been “toy dogs” sure they’ll do less damage but they usually have an attitude problem. I’d take a Rottie over toy dog anyday.

Absolutely this. The only dogs I've ever been attacked by were toy breeds. Is the fact they do less damage ok then??

Tell that to 4 year old me who had her lip ripped open by a chihuahua and needed several stitches and now has a scar. But it's ok because it didn't kill me eh. Or my DD when she was 2 as we walked past a Jack Russell minding our own business the dog turned on the lead and bit the back of her leg. She needed a couple of stitches. But that's ok because it's not too much damage eh.

Ozanj · 31/03/2022 11:42

Big dogs need big houses. They need an owner willing to walk them miles everyday. They need stimulation and proper nutrition. It sounds really offensive and terrible but bluntly they need owners with money. Too many owners coop them up in tiny terraces & are too lazy to walk them / can’t afford puppy training and then get surprised when they get aggressive.

PrtScn · 31/03/2022 11:40

@XelaM

OP - I agree with every word and people who claim Rottweilers are "big softies" are just mental. I have a dog, but he's tiny and I purposely chose a toy companion breed because I want a friendly family dog!
And you’re mental thinking a toy companion breed is a friendly family dog. Some of the nastiest dogs I’ve met have been “toy dogs” sure they’ll do less damage but they usually have an attitude problem. I’d take a Rottie over toy dog anyday.
DrDinosaur · 31/03/2022 11:40

Loads of people protesting there are no 'dangerous breeds'.
Link to list of fatal dog attacks in uk including the breed.
Complete lack of poodles, labradors, and chihuahuas on list. Multiple rottweilers, pitbulls etc on list.
Still loads of people insisting its nothing to do with the breeds.

VampireMoney · 31/03/2022 11:39

Any dog can be a risk around children if it's not properly trained. I own large dogs and I have children. I'm neither unintelligent or uneducated. I care very much about the safety of my children and others, and that's why my dogs are well trained. I'm sick to death of people thinking big dog equals vicious dog.

There are no bad dogs, only bad owners.

Also children need to be taught how to respect animals. People shouldn't be letting their small child pull on the ears of ANY sized dog.

Almostwelsh · 31/03/2022 11:39

I'm sick of hearing "it's not the breed it's the owner". The breed does matter when it comes to damage inflicted. Even if you never leave your child alone with a dog, a large dog is very difficult to stop if it does attack.

I would never have an animal in my home that I couldn't overpower singlehandedly if necessary. And many, many dogs do fall into that category, including Staffordshire bull terrier, GSD Rottweiler and even Labs.

Even the best trained dog can attack if it's ill or injured, especially things like brain injury and if the worse happens I need to be able to fight it off.

MrsSkylerWhite · 31/03/2022 11:39

Because they’re not very bright.

PepperamiPrincess · 31/03/2022 11:38

I don’t trust my Maltese around my 8 year old DC.

It’s utterly heartbreaking the number of children killed in the UK because their idiot parents put them in dangerous situations with dogs

Prinnny · 31/03/2022 11:37

Any dog has the potential to harm a child; I have one of the most placid breeds a british bulldog (Churchill dog) he’s so chill and the most perfect family dog but I would still never leave him unsupervised with a child. It’s just a risk I’m not willing to take, he’s an animal at the end of the day.

Infinitemoon · 31/03/2022 11:37

The fact you've said 'she never will hurt anyone' means you are complacent and its that sort of attitude that leads to these incidents happening.

Exactly. Going by this thread if I had any power, I would ban all dog of a certain weight, size and bite force from houses with children. Some people are just never going to get it?!

Meadowbreeze · 31/03/2022 11:37

It's almost never the dog itself though. Almost always the owner. Millions of dogs were bought in the last 2 years by very inexperienced owners without any idea of dedication and time it takes to make a dog safe. I am sadly not suprised this is happening a lot now.
Ive seen labradoodles jump at kids in our local park, a cockapoo bit me on the hand last week when I was sitting on the park bench eating a sandwich. It was off lead and owner didn't seem to care. They didn't even see it happen.
I hate that dogs are getting a bad rep for this.

Greedy7 · 31/03/2022 11:36

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Swipe left for the next trending thread